Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 20:55

hamsterchump · 24/08/2022 20:42

This thread just shows you how much so many people really value and love having someone to look down on. People will literally forego a pay rise if it means other people won't get to have one. Gross.

Amen.

hamsterchump · 24/08/2022 20:42

This thread just shows you how much so many people really value and love having someone to look down on. People will literally forego a pay rise if it means other people won't get to have one. Gross.

Carpy88999 · 24/08/2022 20:09

NewPapaGuinea · 24/08/2022 19:57

I think a better way would be to guarantee a percentage of profits as a bonus for staff. Why do the execs get to not only have better salaries, but bank all the bonuses.

Pay nurses footballers wages

NewPapaGuinea · 24/08/2022 19:57

I think a better way would be to guarantee a percentage of profits as a bonus for staff. Why do the execs get to not only have better salaries, but bank all the bonuses.

Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 19:55

Erictheavocado · 24/08/2022 17:21

@Cyclemarine

I don't think you need to worry about the pay difference between teachers and TAs in the unlikely event of a £15p/h mw. Mainly because schools won't be able to afford it, because like the recent teacher payrise it will fall to schools to fund it from there existing, already stretched, budgets. The situation in most schools is already at breaking point - I am a TA and a governor in my school, so have a pretty good idea of the state of our finances and I know that there is every likelihood that with the unfunded payrises, increase in fuel costs and increase in cost of resources such as books etc, many of our support staff will end up being made redundant next year. Including me. I imagine that the same pattern will be repeated across lower paid jobs throughout the public sector and many of those people will end up on benefits since there simply won't be jobs available if the NMW increases to £15ph. Many of those former employees will end up on benefits , so the economy will not gain as instead of paying a small amount of benefit to enable people to take lower paid jobs, we will be paying out more benefits to those who can't work as their jobs have disappeared.

I am old enough to remember when John Smith was shadow chancellor and put forward what seemed to me, a well thought out plan to improve funding for public services in general. Unlike most politicians, he was honest and stated that in order to fund the services the public claim to want, there would have to be a small rise in tax. Labour lost the election. Unfortunately, it seems we only want these services if somebody else is paying for them. It's all very well saying that companies who can't afford £15ph, don't deserve to exist, but it's not just companies that can't afford it. The public sector can't either.

That's a good point about lower paid public sector jobs getting cut and the thought is quite grim...I know TA's and other support staff do such great work and make a complete difference in the lives of some of the more vulnerable children. And nation is in such a dismal state it doesn't need to add high unemployment rates to everything that's wrong with it.

I think one problem with this current government, is that taxpayers don't trust them, especially after the recent shambles with so much money wasted during Covid.

I'd like to think if people trusted politicians to actually improve services with a rise in taxes they would support it but then I don't know. Clearly there are some people don't mind public services being in a mess if they can hold onto a bit more of their salary.

RunningSME · 24/08/2022 19:52

Have any if you actually ever met a person who is a CEO for even a modestly sized company ? One of my ex boyfriends runs a private bank, that’s his job.
I have witnessed his mother in their £900,000 house at the time in 2000 so Lord knows what it’s worth now, order a new kitchen because hers was 10 years old and that’s what you do kitchens only last 10 years dont they 😳
throwaway joints of beef and whole chickens because they’ll be out of date tomorrow and there’s nobody here to eat them.
when emergency guests have landed on them phone actual restaurants and order £400 worth of food to be delivered to the house because what they have in their freezer couldn’t be cooked in time and we can’t keep people waiting.

these people are on a different planet to most of you posting.

They aren’t bad people but they would literally find it impossible to comprehend that you couldn’t spend £145 on a bottle of wine it’s just completely beyond anything that they’ve ever experienced.

My ex’s school fees are the same as what I am pretax. His parents had three children in private education.

Different planet.

Flutterbybudget · 24/08/2022 19:51

A wage of £15/hr would pay around £31,200 for a 40hr week, 52 weeks a year. Remember that many minimum wage earners do not have set hours contracted, and are actually unlikely to get paid holiday/ sick leave on those hours, so would be lower than that. Now consider a wage of £31,200 (before tax) that’s £25,000 take home, and service bills in excess of £6,000, not counting housing costs, water, council tax, childcare costs, etc, etc

Currently, many are earning low wages, topped up by the taxpayer, through Universal credit and housing benefits. The question is, who should pay the “real” wage of a worker? The taxpayer, or the employer? My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs?

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 19:47

Another £5.10 an hour.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 19:46

Florenz · 24/08/2022 19:42

The minimum wage should pay enough to live a decent life, buy a modest house, go on holiday once a year, run a car, raise a child etc. Those with higher education, special skills etc should earn more but not THAT much more.

How much more do you suggest?

Florenz · 24/08/2022 19:42

The minimum wage should pay enough to live a decent life, buy a modest house, go on holiday once a year, run a car, raise a child etc. Those with higher education, special skills etc should earn more but not THAT much more.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 19:34

Well rn there's fuck all incentive not to.

Right now they're staring actual physical harm in the face by keeping things as they are.

At what point do you think this will tip? Because I think it's quite close.

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 18:47

If the entire workforce of Tesco walked out tomorrow then it might happen

but in the real world what is the chance of that happening

it depends really on what the union for Tesco decides to ballot and whether the members vote to strike?

In reality it could happen, but Id be doubtful that enough would vote to strike on a payrise

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 18:44

then the workers need to stop doing his work and making him money, there is no profit without the workers
Laughable suggestion

who do you think makes the CEO his or her money then?

It seems most on here want ceo to have money and workers to go without and suffer, any mention of a raise for workers at the bottom and their are objections, but no-one seems to object to CEOs getting paid over 200x the wages of a worker

PestorPeston · 24/08/2022 18:35

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 13:27

Did you learn maths at school?

How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?

Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage.

Can you do the sums? In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million. Add up the zeros. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each.

This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing.

Did you learn maths at school?
How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?
Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage.
Can you do the sums? (obviously not) In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million BILLION Add up the zeros Good idea 10,000 x 300,000 = 3,000,000,000. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each.
Actually they would get £3,000
This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing.

This thread has so many examples of poor maths, I feel that there may be some Government ministers present.

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 18:35

If the entire workforce of Tesco walked out tomorrow then it might happen

but in the real world what is the chance of that happening

I’m not sure but the chances are increasing every day. In truth none of us know how people are going to react or the extent of the economic crisis. I wouldn’t knock it off the table just yet.

we need practical solutions not idealistic ideas that will never happen

Well, we’ve needed practical solutions, at governmental level, for over a decade and that’s not happened. Any practical solution is going to take time, cost money (debt) and real leadership. Idealistic ideas are as real a possibility as practicalities currently.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 18:28

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 17:55

Is it though? People are being priced out of simply existing, if your badly paying job doesn’t even keep you vaguely above water then why bother with it?

I'd like to see the CEO of Tesco's reaction if that happened.

He wouldn't be laughing.

He'd be scared.

holidaynightmare · 24/08/2022 18:13

I think the whole system needs reviewing to be honest

  • minimum wage isn't enough for people to live on alone but a good number of these people will get top-ups from UC or tax credits
  • there are people working very few hours or only 1 person working in a couple receiving more than 2 people working - work should pay people shouldn't think "it's not worth it I'd be worse off" that's ridiculous
  • there is mention of nurses and midwives on this but the whole NHS paybands system need reviewing, £1400 a year extra for lower paybands is quite frankly an insult and they've been on about it for ages it's now August and nobody has seen a penny extra of this insulting gesture.
  • minimum wage only gets to the higher amount once someone is 25 and there should be at a rate for 16 year olds, then again at 18 - 16 year olds to get experience then a rise at 18 but it's unfair to pay those age 25 or over a lot more and it would also sort out employers putting people on zero hour contracts (especially in retail and hospitality!) and giving all the hours to the younger "cheaper" staff which seems common
  • however as a side note zero hour contracts need closely regulating fo ensure nobody is penalised

The issue is some small businesses would struggle to pay their staff say £15 but the current rates are simply not enough to live on

rwalker · 24/08/2022 18:08

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 17:55

Is it though? People are being priced out of simply existing, if your badly paying job doesn’t even keep you vaguely above water then why bother with it?

The theory is no one works for a company that pays massive wage to ceo
so no one works for them they pay ceo a normal high wage and the spare cash bumps everyone’s wages up
If the entire workforce of Tesco walked out tomorrow then it might happen
but in the real world what is the chance of that happening
we need practical solutions not idealistic ideas that will never happen

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 17:55

rwalker · 24/08/2022 17:43

Laughable suggestion

Is it though? People are being priced out of simply existing, if your badly paying job doesn’t even keep you vaguely above water then why bother with it?

rwalker · 24/08/2022 17:43

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 17:15

You really think the CEO pay cut could fund £15 min wage for the entire uk work force is beyond unrealistic

then the workers need to stop doing his work and making him money, there is no profit without the workers

Laughable suggestion

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 17:39

@JustALittleHelpPlease I agree with you. We shouldn't be talking like this is a temporary situation that has come from nowhere. People have not been paid properly for a long time.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 17:36

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 17:15

You really think the CEO pay cut could fund £15 min wage for the entire uk work force is beyond unrealistic

then the workers need to stop doing his work and making him money, there is no profit without the workers

Yes.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 17:28

bringonthesunshinefinally · 24/08/2022 17:10

I think if you're on minimum wage and potentially also struggling to make ends meet, then inflation is not your biggest immediate concern. Feeding your family is.

Possibly true but the people who do have the time/energy/resources (and who are paid to do the job of running the country to benefit all of its citizens) do know that inflation is making it harder to put food on the table. I wouldn't expect someone on minimum wage struggling to feed their family to fix this. I would expect the people who are paid to fix it to get their sleeves rolled up though.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 17:21

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 16:59

"Cost of living" is distraction talk. Even prior to energy hikes we were already in the situation where millions of full time working employees are claiming benefits. Wages in the lower four deciles have barely risen for fifteen years. That's a generation worth of years. Energy prices have brought it to our attention but it's been going on for a long time.

This isn't a cost of living crisis. It's a wage crisis. We've been printing money and subsidising employers paying poverty wages via benefits for a decade and a half.

You can't run a country like that, long term. As we are finding.

Cost of living is cost of living, it's not temporary, its always there.

We have propped up wages for a very long time. It isn't working now and it wasn't working before. That is not a distraction, that is the nub of the issue.

The current crisis has thrown it into sharp relief but the fact is the cost of living has out stripped wages for far too long. It can't be solved by simply chucking money around - that's a good portion of the reason why we're in this mess.

Erictheavocado · 24/08/2022 17:21

Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 15:24

You were veering off topic by insinuating things that were patently false - suggesting I do not care for the plight of service workers or I think their job isn't tough.

Teaching and nursing are physically demanding too btw and you may not have to ask for permission as such but teachers can't just swan off to the toilet anytime too.

That is not my argument, nor is my arguments teachers are the only special people. The fact is - you cannot compare teaching with all the training it involves (see time and costs required for this) and all the emotional burdens they carry and all the planning/marking they have to do outside of work hours ...and going on residential or day trips etc...with working an entry level/check-out job at a supermarket where you clock in and out and leave your work there.

I assume under this proposal that some TAs would see their wage rise to 15 pounds an hour? While TAs are underpaid, I think teachers would really have to question why they have these significant additional responsibilities and tasks for little more pay than the assistants in their classroom on £15/hour, so you really would have to raise teachers wages too by a significant amount .

Many teachers already work in supermarket jobs actually but my main
point is- NMW workers getting as much as £15 will impact not only teachers but many others who earn a similar amount, unless their wages are increased by a similar amount. The reason for that is landlords will hike up housing costs which is one of the biggest causes of a high standard of living.

So at the end of the day everyone, including NMW workers will still have the same struggle we are facing now.

I think a much more sensible approach would tackle extortionate housing and energy costs.

@Cyclemarine

I don't think you need to worry about the pay difference between teachers and TAs in the unlikely event of a £15p/h mw. Mainly because schools won't be able to afford it, because like the recent teacher payrise it will fall to schools to fund it from there existing, already stretched, budgets. The situation in most schools is already at breaking point - I am a TA and a governor in my school, so have a pretty good idea of the state of our finances and I know that there is every likelihood that with the unfunded payrises, increase in fuel costs and increase in cost of resources such as books etc, many of our support staff will end up being made redundant next year. Including me. I imagine that the same pattern will be repeated across lower paid jobs throughout the public sector and many of those people will end up on benefits since there simply won't be jobs available if the NMW increases to £15ph. Many of those former employees will end up on benefits , so the economy will not gain as instead of paying a small amount of benefit to enable people to take lower paid jobs, we will be paying out more benefits to those who can't work as their jobs have disappeared.

I am old enough to remember when John Smith was shadow chancellor and put forward what seemed to me, a well thought out plan to improve funding for public services in general. Unlike most politicians, he was honest and stated that in order to fund the services the public claim to want, there would have to be a small rise in tax. Labour lost the election. Unfortunately, it seems we only want these services if somebody else is paying for them. It's all very well saying that companies who can't afford £15ph, don't deserve to exist, but it's not just companies that can't afford it. The public sector can't either.