Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ExpectMore · 15/10/2022 19:25

Higher wage economy*

ExpectMore · 15/10/2022 19:24

antelopevalley · 15/10/2022 12:52

We need a higher wage economy. To achieve that we need manufacturing back. We need to be investing.

I agree with the fact we need a higher wage evident.

A manufacturing economy isn't going to do it. Manufacturing is low skills and low wages, we'd be outcompeted but China and the like.

Advanced manufacturing might help, but it doesn't have the scale.

If you look around the globe, high wage economies are knowledge economies. That's what we need to target

antelopevalley · 15/10/2022 12:52

We need a higher wage economy. To achieve that we need manufacturing back. We need to be investing.

ExpectMore · 15/10/2022 12:46

SchoolQuestionnaire · 15/10/2022 10:44

I think the minimum wage should be increased albeit gradually. A sudden increase would make some businesses untenable and it’s not unreasonable to allow them some time to adjust their business model to accommodate further expenses. It’s also naive to think that larger companies will allow their profits to dwindle to pay for these increases. It’s far more likely that there will be redundancies and staff will be expected to do more for the increased wage. But hopefully the payoff would be people working for a living wage rather than the current low salaries.

How do you think the in parallel required increase in productivity would be achieved to offset the increased staffing costs? Ie if the staffing costs are higher, the output is going to have to be higher to generate the additional income to fund the additional costs.

I'm not certain many businesses will be able to make it work nor individuals willing to accept changes to increase productivity (for example we've all seen the ludicrous revolt by the railway workers when modernisation has been suggested) for the blanket increase to be viable.

It's just put up the cost of doing business here and inevitably make us less competitive on the global stage.

Thoughts?

SchoolQuestionnaire · 15/10/2022 10:44

I think the minimum wage should be increased albeit gradually. A sudden increase would make some businesses untenable and it’s not unreasonable to allow them some time to adjust their business model to accommodate further expenses. It’s also naive to think that larger companies will allow their profits to dwindle to pay for these increases. It’s far more likely that there will be redundancies and staff will be expected to do more for the increased wage. But hopefully the payoff would be people working for a living wage rather than the current low salaries.

LoisLane66 · 15/10/2022 07:06

@SwanBuster
Far too many variables for it to be considered.

dianthus101 · 27/08/2022 21:10

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 27/08/2022 14:00

Back in my parents day, you could have a single earner in a family doing my job, there was enough income to have a good standard of living with a decent house, car, food and holidays. These days we need to be a joint income family just to afford the basics.
This is what needs fixing. Not how much we earn but what percentage of that income has to go in housing, energy and food costs. When we have government officials stating that people on 45k are going to need support to live there is something very wrong.

I'm not sure how old your parents are but when I was a child in the 70s, few people had more than one car and many didn't drive at all. Hardly anyone went on foreign holidays either. Food was very basic too. It wasn't really what people today would call a decent standard of living.

panelf · 27/08/2022 15:10

Namedifferentorquestion · 26/08/2022 18:25

Ah, the middle earner on £40K doesn't believe in raising the income of the poorest earning individuals in society..... nice

This

antelopevalley · 27/08/2022 15:04

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 27/08/2022 14:00

Back in my parents day, you could have a single earner in a family doing my job, there was enough income to have a good standard of living with a decent house, car, food and holidays. These days we need to be a joint income family just to afford the basics.
This is what needs fixing. Not how much we earn but what percentage of that income has to go in housing, energy and food costs. When we have government officials stating that people on 45k are going to need support to live there is something very wrong.

People on £45k are going to need help to live if they have high rents/mortgages, childcare or a number of children. Plenty will still manage to pay for the basics.
£45k is more than the average family income.

panelf · 27/08/2022 15:04

This

sjxoxo · 27/08/2022 14:51

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 27/08/2022 14:00

Back in my parents day, you could have a single earner in a family doing my job, there was enough income to have a good standard of living with a decent house, car, food and holidays. These days we need to be a joint income family just to afford the basics.
This is what needs fixing. Not how much we earn but what percentage of that income has to go in housing, energy and food costs. When we have government officials stating that people on 45k are going to need support to live there is something very wrong.

This ^ is a really important point & often overlooked. This is what has skewed family life as it was known and the problem with the tories is ‘maximum employment’ to say how great business is doing but the reality is many of the jobs are phony and they’d rather have a higher rate of employment but less pay per post.

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 27/08/2022 14:00

Back in my parents day, you could have a single earner in a family doing my job, there was enough income to have a good standard of living with a decent house, car, food and holidays. These days we need to be a joint income family just to afford the basics.
This is what needs fixing. Not how much we earn but what percentage of that income has to go in housing, energy and food costs. When we have government officials stating that people on 45k are going to need support to live there is something very wrong.

Alexandra2001 · 27/08/2022 13:49

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 11:33

Why do you think being a AHP is a vocation but training as an accountant or a lawyer etc isn't?

where did I write that those were my thoughts? That’s an assumption you made

so your mum as a nurse thinks her job is now done by others without qualifications- so lower pay

this has deliberately been manoeuvred so that those on lower pay are doing the job of a nurse - it’s a con

what would have happened to your mate in the road if no ambulance turned up?

You made that clear distinction, not me.

HCA's do have qualifications....

Its not just in nursing, band 4 physio and OT assistants doing complex home release assessments, with significant come back if that patient has a preventable fall etc and is back in.

Death, which is what happened, by your argument, we might as well call 222222 and ask for the nearest taxi.

its ridiculous to even being having this argument, the UK is a supposed to be a wealthy first world country and should have a first world, well funded, effective and fully trained workforce, commensurate with the medical equipment and knowledge available.

Other European countries mange to do so, why can't we? and more importantly, why do we put up with such shite.

Believeitornot · 27/08/2022 13:46

Dadaya · 27/08/2022 12:38

To add to this though we are stuffed for going for the scandi system because of the obsession of house owning over last 40 years
To be fair, the obsession with home ownership is because of poor UK legislation in relation to tenancies. In other countries the market is rent controlled so landlords can’t put prices up. Tenancies are more secure, notice periods are longer, eviction is harder, and the tenant has first refusal if the property is put up for sale.

My uncle has rented the same property for 54 years, he has been able to decorate and put down carpets as he saw fit. Even installed his own fitted kitchen, secure in the knowledge that he would be living there long enough to have full use of it. Never been inspected or had anyone looking over his shoulder. That would never have happened in the UK.

That sounds amazing! I would have rented for longer if I wasn’t so nervous about putting up so much as a picture for fear of losing a deposit.
Renting could be a very secure yet flexible option for people, but nope, you’re made to feel like you should be grateful for a landlord letting you use “their” home, when you’re actually paying through the nose for it.

The more I think about it, the more I think private landlords should be outlawed. Or massively regulated.

MarshaBradyo · 27/08/2022 12:41

It’s tricky though as when a city goes through change prices can rocket. Berlin has seen change recently and the price of ownership has become more an issue and some may feel left behind once that happens.

I prefer ownership without a doubt, it gives us options later

Dadaya · 27/08/2022 12:38

To add to this though we are stuffed for going for the scandi system because of the obsession of house owning over last 40 years
To be fair, the obsession with home ownership is because of poor UK legislation in relation to tenancies. In other countries the market is rent controlled so landlords can’t put prices up. Tenancies are more secure, notice periods are longer, eviction is harder, and the tenant has first refusal if the property is put up for sale.

My uncle has rented the same property for 54 years, he has been able to decorate and put down carpets as he saw fit. Even installed his own fitted kitchen, secure in the knowledge that he would be living there long enough to have full use of it. Never been inspected or had anyone looking over his shoulder. That would never have happened in the UK.

justasking111 · 27/08/2022 12:20

DS had a Belgian girlfriend through university she thought it mad to own a property. Her parents both professional working rented their lovely home. Their standard of living was very high

Crikeyalmighty · 27/08/2022 11:25

To add to this though we are stuffed for going for the scandi system because of the obsession of house owning over last 40 years and the fact that the UK mentality is as it is with regards to a fair society.

There are people there who are way better off than others but it's far less noticeable
And yes it's expensive- but the main expense is eating out and drinking out and things like haircuts- but they aren't 'essentials' unlike housing and often childcare or public transport(also quite cheap and very good)

Crikeyalmighty · 27/08/2022 11:16

As I've explained before the difference when we lived in Denmark was that people had much higher wages but much higher tax, so essentially ended up with similar monthly pay to here-- the big difference though was masses of good quality social housing ( even me as a bit of a snob would have lived in it) - childcare at a quarter of UK rates and no NI or council tax. So a couple with a take home of around £3500 would often have£600 housing, £300 childcare plus their utilities and that was it. Hence very few totally stay at home mums , but a lot of security. The people who lost out were single people and to some extent older people (high pensions though) and those with no kids- but it was accepted as part of a well functioning society

Quincythequince · 27/08/2022 10:15

Honeyroar · 24/08/2022 11:22

Too many people have degrees. So they shouldn’t be paid much higher. When my 80 year old dad went to uni 1% of the population went. Nowadays it’s a massive percentage. You don’t have to be clever or particularly intelligent to go (I’m proof of that myself).

Agreed. Way too many degreesC and way too many shitty degrees too.

Those poor kids who were sold a line that this was better when all they get is tens of thousands worth of debt and a job in a call centre.

Quincythequince · 27/08/2022 09:47

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

Your moral view on why peoples choose to do things are neither here nor there.

They are not obliged to train for the best part of the decade, Incur huge debt, work very antisocial hours in a very stressful job and then be expected to be paid the same as a road sweeper.

Don’t be so ridiculous. A shelf stacking job should not be paid the same as a surgeon or a trained engineer making decisions which could if made badly, kill thousands.

And your raising eyebrows at this notion of their apparently questionable motives doesn’t make it wrong.

animaginativeusername · 27/08/2022 09:37

YABU.
You're not on minimum wage

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 27/08/2022 08:50

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

Have you shared your brilliant economic theory with No 11? It is incredible that this amazing idea hasn't already been thought of, piloted, evaluated and written into policy by now. You work in the civil service, so already have an advantage of the other 5 million or so other people who have ideas how to drive the economy. Don't waste time getting opinions here, because clearly you feel they do not understand your point.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 27/08/2022 08:49

Yes, as a small business owner I don’t draw from the business anything more than a lot of my staff are paid. If minimum wage goes up I have two choices, raise my prices or slim down my workforce. With VAT, Coro tax, my own tax, pension, NI, etc. you could run a small
country on the tax that my company and staff pay!

The OP nailed it, increasing pay to increase peoples affordability because costs are increasing is just a way to line government pockets further in the long run and actually benefits nobody because it just excuses the increase in cost of living…

Some smaller companies will become unsustainable.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 20:02

Namedifferentorquestion · 26/08/2022 18:25

Ah, the middle earner on £40K doesn't believe in raising the income of the poorest earning individuals in society..... nice

It's possible to want to raise the income of the poorest in society without believing that raising the minimum wage is the best way of doing this.

Of course, I understand the principle behind giving people the dignity of earning a wage that enables them to pay for a decent standard of living, and in theory, I'm all for that. In practice, though, I just think that a £15 nmw would force lots of employers out of business, leading to mass unemployment.

So I wouldn't support a minimum wage of £15 but that doesn't mean I want the poorest to go without - I would quite happily pay more tax on order to ensure that everyone has access to a decent standard of living, whether that is done through tax credits or similar, or through some kind of subsidy to reduce the cost of housing and other essentials. I don't begrudge anyone a decent life, I just don't see how putting loads of employers out of business and loads of people out of work is going to help anyone.