Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else absolutely shocked of three innocent people in Liverpool all drug related!!

386 replies

Toosadtocomprehend · 23/08/2022 23:11

If anyone reading this that takes recreational drugs should be absolutely ashamed of the carnage that their habit is causing…an innocent 9 year old ,20 year old and 22 year old have lost their lives because of other people shitty pastimes …think think think before you snort or smoke that poison!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 20:35

I would hate there to be a death penalty in the UK, and would absolutely work against it. To me that is truly the appalling vista.

Nonetheless, as we learned six and a bit years ago, people can get very determined to have The Will of The People brought into law and then everyone has to live with the reality.

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 20:31

OneTC · 30/08/2022 18:09

And re: American thing it's interesting, America holds drug producing countries to ransom with aid, if countries don't engage in long protracted wars with cartels that have almost unlimited funds then America (and other signatories) withhold aid money. Loads of people die so that drug production is hopefully interrupted and yet everywhere is still awash with drugs. So it's completely ineffective policies in America, the UK and Europe that cause all the shit way back to the point of production.

I wonder if we asked the question, imagining we are talking about cynical Tories - “For whom has the war on drug been sufficiently profitable to make it worth continuing?”

OneTC · 30/08/2022 18:09

And re: American thing it's interesting, America holds drug producing countries to ransom with aid, if countries don't engage in long protracted wars with cartels that have almost unlimited funds then America (and other signatories) withhold aid money. Loads of people die so that drug production is hopefully interrupted and yet everywhere is still awash with drugs. So it's completely ineffective policies in America, the UK and Europe that cause all the shit way back to the point of production.

OneTC · 30/08/2022 17:58

I think the Tories are most likely to do it, b for the wrong reasons unfortunately, but they'll see it for the potential cash cow it is. Labour already failed to deliver what it promised.

Lib Dems have stated it previously as a policy but yeah, lib Dems they can say anything they like knowing they'll never have to do it.

Out of interest does your support for the death penalty in democracies cover any future changes in the law here? Do you allow yourself an opinion on countries like the USA? Anywhere? I mean what is opposing the death sentence in a country that doesn't have it? Definitely the most interesting concept thing coming out of this thread for me!

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/08/2022 17:27

Which party do you think would be the most likely to legalize drugs in the UK. Because it is so obvious to me that it would be the tories, in the same cynical way they selling off the NHS whilst creaming off for themselves personally.

None of them. Well maybe the LibDems if they could find their arse with both hands.

And you're right that if the Tories were involved it would be a shit show. It does need to be done properly, with good intent, and none of the major parties are capable of pulling that off right now!

araiwa · 30/08/2022 17:19

I'd imagine the Tories would fight anything about legalisation of drugs.

I believe it is mainly blue states that have legalised weed in the usa

araiwa · 30/08/2022 17:16

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 15:10

Well obviously when you legalize something it no longer counts in the crime figures, and you therefore ‘reduce crime.’

Some people are trying to reduce harms, or even actually reduce usage.

Drug related crimes

The murder, gang warfare etc

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 16:52

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/08/2022 15:22

You think me and @OneTC are drug dealers? That's... interesting. Au contraire, I've worked in treatment. Unless that was a cover.

No, I don’t think you are, and have been here long enough to know that you have helped pick up the pieces.

I mean in terms of lobby groups (apparently Amazon make donations to drug legalization campaigns, meaning my Tesco comment was not hyperbole) and if we go back to the US, those who lobby against legalization - the prison industrial complex, are not people I would voluntarily socialise with.

Which party do you think would be the most likely to legalize drugs in the UK. Because it is so obvious to me that it would be the tories, in the same cynical way they selling off the NHS whilst creaming off for themselves personally.

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/08/2022 15:22

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 15:11

And you say 'you just don't care' about deaths. Why do you think people advocate for legalisation if they don't care about deaths or addiction?

Because they have drugs they want to sell?

You think me and @OneTC are drug dealers? That's... interesting. Au contraire, I've worked in treatment. Unless that was a cover.

OneTC · 30/08/2022 15:19

Some people are trying to reduce harms, or even actually reduce usage.

And others still are wishy washily advocating the death penalty because who are they to have an opinion

SleeplessInEngland · 30/08/2022 15:14

Legalising and regulating drugs seems a much more realistic way of comabting the problem than keeping the situation as it is and just magically hoping everyone stops taking drugs overnight.

OneTC · 30/08/2022 15:12

lol

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 15:11

And you say 'you just don't care' about deaths. Why do you think people advocate for legalisation if they don't care about deaths or addiction?

Because they have drugs they want to sell?

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 15:10

araiwa · 30/08/2022 14:53

Yes all drug related crime would reduce if drugs were legalised. In all countries

Well obviously when you legalize something it no longer counts in the crime figures, and you therefore ‘reduce crime.’

Some people are trying to reduce harms, or even actually reduce usage.

OneTC · 30/08/2022 15:03

And you say 'you just don't care' about deaths. Why do you think people advocate for legalisation if they don't care about deaths or addiction?

We just care wrong

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/08/2022 15:01

Do you think the murders in Mexico will stop if they just decriminalized everything.? No you don’t- you just do not care.

Not stop but reduce, yes. And Mexico is an interesting case because of the American market. It's so linked that it would be difficult to see the effects as people would still have to operate illegally for the US market. Decriminalise in the States and you would see a massive fall in drug-related murders.

The big one for me is drug-related deaths generally, ODs and similar. They fall dramatically after more sensible solutions are found.

And you say 'you just don't care' about deaths. Why do you think people advocate for legalisation if they don't care about deaths or addiction?

OneTC · 30/08/2022 14:55

Yes I reject anyone's right to think that executing people is fair or right.

That's pretty standard in opposing the death penalty I am surprised you haven't come across it before.

Also interesting seeing Voltaire (incorrectly) invoked in support of repressive justice. That's an unusual thing to take away from that quote of Halls

araiwa · 30/08/2022 14:53

Yes all drug related crime would reduce if drugs were legalised. In all countries

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 14:42

The reason that I and many others I reckon would struggle with the idea of an opponent of the death penalty being in support of the death penalty in certain instances is because it's nonsense.

Do you want to think that through?
The principle is very simple, it’s from Voltaire “I may not agree with what you have to say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” (Although I can admit to being less principled than Voltaire and would give up my own right to free speech, never mind yours, long before it was defending to the death).

what you’re saying is you reject other countries rights (just talking about the democratic ones here) to have systems of government you disagree with? Or is it that you accept their right to the death penalty whilst retaining your own right to make a cat’s bum face on the internet because you’re better than the unlettered.

Do you think the murders in Mexico will stop if they just decriminalized everything.? No you don’t- you just do not care.

araiwa · 30/08/2022 12:55

FreudayNight · 29/08/2022 21:06

At least be accurate. I didn’t say I was in favour, (I am against the death penalty in all cases) I said it was popular in countries that have it.

And I think in democratic societies that’s actually OK. It’s their country, their vote, and they need neither my permission nor yours to execute dealers. As horrific as that might sound.

When you opine that countries ravaged by drugs (even more than the UK has been) should be soft of those profiting the most from it, you just sound like an absolute twat.

That's because I wasn't responding directly to you. If I was I would have quoted you or tagged you @FreudayNight like this

But to be honest I can't make head nor tail of your unlettered posts anyway

OneTC · 30/08/2022 12:09

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 11:53

This might be tricky for you but I am against the death penalty. I am for democratic processes, which are undermined by drugs.
I support other peoples right to be pro death-penalty even though I disagree with them on it.

I would never use someone’s having a different value to me on whether democratically legal death penalty is good, to assume that they are homophobic and want to throw gay people off buildings.

And if you want to go dabbling in cultural differences you might ask yourself why the Sacklers (Pharma drug peddlers as per your preferred model, are Republicans, who are the biggest supporters of the death penalty.)

It seems to me that your failing is assuming that there is an easy solution, or even worse, assuming that the moral superiority you’ve awarded yourself has some basis is reality.

If people can’t even decide what “An effective drug policy” would look like, how can we possibly even think about how to get there.

Is an effective drug policy one in which choosing whether to get off your face on alcohol or coke is just a matter of which is your preferred tipple?

The reason that I and many others I reckon would struggle with the idea of an opponent of the death penalty being in support of the death penalty in certain instances is because it's nonsense.

I don't think there's an easy solution but I'm capable of looking to countries that have done quite alot of the work on this already, rather than harking towards countries with more repressive policies and ongoing problems.

And still you don't actually say anything.

Agrudge · 30/08/2022 11:57

Guns and knives are the cause of this

guns and knives dont kill people ,people kill people

FreudayNight · 30/08/2022 11:53

This might be tricky for you but I am against the death penalty. I am for democratic processes, which are undermined by drugs.
I support other peoples right to be pro death-penalty even though I disagree with them on it.

I would never use someone’s having a different value to me on whether democratically legal death penalty is good, to assume that they are homophobic and want to throw gay people off buildings.

And if you want to go dabbling in cultural differences you might ask yourself why the Sacklers (Pharma drug peddlers as per your preferred model, are Republicans, who are the biggest supporters of the death penalty.)

It seems to me that your failing is assuming that there is an easy solution, or even worse, assuming that the moral superiority you’ve awarded yourself has some basis is reality.

If people can’t even decide what “An effective drug policy” would look like, how can we possibly even think about how to get there.

Is an effective drug policy one in which choosing whether to get off your face on alcohol or coke is just a matter of which is your preferred tipple?

OneTC · 30/08/2022 09:54

FreudayNight · 29/08/2022 21:06

At least be accurate. I didn’t say I was in favour, (I am against the death penalty in all cases) I said it was popular in countries that have it.

And I think in democratic societies that’s actually OK. It’s their country, their vote, and they need neither my permission nor yours to execute dealers. As horrific as that might sound.

When you opine that countries ravaged by drugs (even more than the UK has been) should be soft of those profiting the most from it, you just sound like an absolute twat.

Are you against it or not?

SleeplessInEngland · 30/08/2022 09:29

The war on drugs is a huge failure and shaming people into not wanting to get off their heads has never worked. Any public policy has to start with those two realities.