Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to move in with MIL!

260 replies

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 21:59

hi all I need so ideas on what to do -

situation is we’ve sold our home and are exchanging in 10 days. We will have 3 weeks exactly from date of exchange to moving into our new home.

I stupidly left it to husband to deal with and he kept assuring me it’s all being dealt with but now I find out he hasn’t found anything! His plan is to move with his mum as he doesn’t want to “waste” the money. I do not get along with her and 3 weeks feels like hell.

what are my options? He is saying 3 weeks but could well be longer as date has only been discussed and nothing signed. DH keeps reminding me that it’s his money and as I’m a SAHM at present it’s his decision.

I looked at air bnb but it’s ridiculous prices. Estate agents require minimum 6 months.

please give me some ideas!

OP posts:
Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 12:28

You may want men to keep all the benefits of their spouse's labour and childcare but the courts and the law don't (entirely) agree with you.

I certainly don’t want that. But I can’t change the law. Assets are shared. Earnings are not classed like this. They simoly are not. As individuals we are entitled to any money we earn or that’s held in our names. We are not legally entitled to our spouses wage. Savings are considered an asset, income and future income is not.

how can people have such limited understanding. If you were legally entitled to your spouses wage everyone would have joint accounts etc. it would be easy to access it. The whole reason women end up like the op is they don’t know their rights and listen to shite being posted on the internet.

there js no such concept or legal right to classing your spouses salary as yours. Irrelevant of gender. Men who don’t work are not legally entitled to their wife’s wage and vice versa.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/08/2022 12:17

Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 12:07

This is completely misrepresenting it. In the whole of the uk you are not legally entitled to your spouses wage. It is not yours. There is no point folks pretending they are, they are not. It is not anyones money other than the person who earned it,,

On divorce assets are split, the point of the marriage contract is that goods and work are shared.

You may want men to keep all the benefits of their spouse's labour and childcare but the courts and the law don't (entirely) agree with you.

If you don't want to pool your assets when you raise a family - don't get married. A choice made by many men who use exactly that lack of a contract to benefit from women's labour and then fuck off.

Triffid1 · 24/08/2022 12:17

Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 12:07

This is completely misrepresenting it. In the whole of the uk you are not legally entitled to your spouses wage. It is not yours. There is no point folks pretending they are, they are not. It is not anyones money other than the person who earned it,,

Well, IN marriage I'm not sure of the LEGAL issues but certainly, if he has 3 dependents, he is morally and ethically obliged to support them. And I think most people would agree that if she's not working and doing childcare then she is WORKING and does deserve compensation in some way - albeit that is unlikely to be in the form of a salary (on threads like these though, I often think it SHOULD be in the form of salary - the work might be better appreciated then).

And certainly, on divorce, she absolutely WOULD be entitled to a share of his assets and/or income.

Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 12:14

I’d also add the people writing this erroneous stuff are not helping the op at all.

Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 12:07

C8H10N4O2 · 24/08/2022 11:38

Nope, marriage (in England, Wales and I think Scotland) is a contract wherein income and worldly goods are shared as a unit, traditionally on the assumption of raising a family.

Much as if you entered into any business contract on a 50/50 basis. The financial benefits of the arrangement do not all accrue to one partner.

This is completely misrepresenting it. In the whole of the uk you are not legally entitled to your spouses wage. It is not yours. There is no point folks pretending they are, they are not. It is not anyones money other than the person who earned it,,

YankeeDad · 24/08/2022 11:59

@ChangeNane1
If you have not exchanged on the sale of your current house, and if your name is on the deeds, then I think you should contact the solicitor representing you in the sale and tell them that you withdraw your permission to sell your current house. Follow that up in writing, especially if the solicitor was chosen by your husband.

If your name is on the deeds, then you have negotiating leverage that goes away the day the exchange to sell your house is sold.

It sounds as though your husband and his MIL want to use you and this leverage may help you to prevent that, or to escape it in case leaving the relationship is the only way not to be treated like a slave.

Maytodecember · 24/08/2022 11:50

Exchange is the binding contract to sell and buy.
Completion can be the same day, the next week or 3 weeks later or whenever — it’s mutually agreed.


  1. Are you on the house deeds/ mortgage of the house you’re selling? If so you can either delay exchange, or agree a completion date that suits you. You DON’T vacate a property at exchange.

  2. Are you on deeds/ mortgage of new property? Are you 100% sure there is a new property?

  3. Your MIL, DH or anyone else cannot refuse to allow you to leave— that is imprisonment. If this happens you call the police.

id suggest you speak to Women’s Aid about taking your children to a refuge. Divorce your husband.

Triffid1 · 24/08/2022 11:45

If it's "his money" perhaps it's time to start charging him for childcare. You can use that money to rent a hotel room or stay in an air bnb

Meraas · 24/08/2022 11:42

@Floweryflora

I just don’t get posts like this. There is no legal basis for this at all. It is not family money, it’s his money, it’s his choice how to spend it, even on divorce there would just be child maintenance. Family money is a myth made up by non earning folks who want their spouses money. It is their choice on whether to pay for you or not. Pretending they can take a stance and it’s some mythical thing called family money is a joke. It’s not. If she wants money and he doesn’t wish to give her it then she needs to get a job. As unpalatable as it is, that’s it.

No, on divorce the judge assesses the asset pot and divides it based on a number of factors (earnings, children, etc)

The fact that you don't know that basic detail makes the rest of your post unreadable.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/08/2022 11:42

Baoing · 24/08/2022 11:30

A few weeks with your MiL is the very least of your problems. Suck it up

Why do people keep saying this? The OP has said that she's prevented from leaving the house and is treated like a servant. She describes how it took years to extract herself before from MiL's control. It's an abusive, controlling situation, and possibly the H is part of it.

Wtaf?

If OP had stated this upfront in her OP instead of dripfeeding it later, PP would have picked up on it.

And of course the H is part of the control & abuse.
He allowed his mother to keep OP locked up for ... however long it was before she managed to escape to their own home by threatening divorce.

This marriage is not going to improve.
I would not be surprised if other family members are going to be named on the deeds, but not OP. She is seen as a chattel. It's time for her to escape for good this time.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/08/2022 11:38

Floweryflora · 24/08/2022 10:03

I just don’t get posts like this. There is no legal basis for this at all. It is not family money, it’s his money, it’s his choice how to spend it, even on divorce there would just be child maintenance. Family money is a myth made up by non earning folks who want their spouses money. It is their choice on whether to pay for you or not. Pretending they can take a stance and it’s some mythical thing called family money is a joke. It’s not. If she wants money and he doesn’t wish to give her it then she needs to get a job. As unpalatable as it is, that’s it.

Nope, marriage (in England, Wales and I think Scotland) is a contract wherein income and worldly goods are shared as a unit, traditionally on the assumption of raising a family.

Much as if you entered into any business contract on a 50/50 basis. The financial benefits of the arrangement do not all accrue to one partner.

Baoing · 24/08/2022 11:30

A few weeks with your MiL is the very least of your problems. Suck it up

Why do people keep saying this? The OP has said that she's prevented from leaving the house and is treated like a servant. She describes how it took years to extract herself before from MiL's control. It's an abusive, controlling situation, and possibly the H is part of it.

Wtaf?

KettrickenSmiled · 24/08/2022 11:27

issue is MIL is very controlling.
Hmmm. So is your husband from t he tiny snapshot you've shown.

She’s not being nice in “letting” us stay there. She never wanted us to move out in first place as according to her culture the son stays with parents and the wife is a servant to MIL, obeying every command and spending all day cleaning n cooking. I wouldn’t be allowed to leave the house if I stayed with them. It’s taken me years to get out from under her control and I don’t want to get back there again.
Again - HOW did you allow yourself to be so passive that you are now at risk of being back in her clutches?

We were “allowed” to move out in the beginning as I was ready to get divorced. This was pre-kids and now she knows I’m stuck so if I get back there it will be hell
Call Womens Aid.
Get a solicitor.
Get back to work.
Get away from your arse of a husband.
You know how he was raised. Why do you think he will be inclined to treat you any better than his mother does?

KettrickenSmiled · 24/08/2022 11:24

DH keeps reminding me that it’s his money and as I’m a SAHM at present it’s his decision.

A few weeks with your MiL is the very least of your problems.
Suck it up, & start planning your route back into full time work, because with a stinking attitude like that from your husband I doubt your marriage is going to last.

Don't allow yourself to sleepwalk into financial abuse.
Leaving all the big decisions & money choices up to your H while allowing him to imagine that only he counts because it's "his money" while you act as unpaid nursemaid & housekeeper is a recipe for disaster.

You need to wake up & start taking responsibility for yourself.
For example - how did you allow yourself to drift into not knowing where or how to house your DC when you knew your house was sold?

He is saying 3 weeks but could well be longer as date has only been discussed and nothing signed.
Frankly, after the 'it's my money' comment, I'd be wary of signing up to a mortgage with your H. I'd be using the short time you have now to assess how much money & assets are held within the marriage, & talk to a solicitor about what proportion of that asset I could take with me if I divorced.

Mariposista · 24/08/2022 10:48

RayneDance · 24/08/2022 10:45

I would also be announcing going back to work

Absolutely this. Get some financial independence and security!

Baoing · 24/08/2022 10:48

She never wanted us to move out in first place as according to her culture the son stays with parents and the wife is a servant to MIL, obeying every command and spending all day cleaning n cooking. I wouldn’t be allowed to leave the house if I stayed with them. It’s taken me years to get out from under her control and I don’t want to get back there again

Why tf are posters recommending that the OP 'sucks it up'?

Would YOU live like this? ^^ The OP has said that she's prevented from leaving the house and is treated like a servant. Why is anyone suggesting that she returns?

OP, forget the house for now. You need to follow the advice of DarkDay and others on this thread. Please - you have the chance of a better life for you and your DC. It's so hard, but please try to steel yourself. Good luck.

Dragmedown · 24/08/2022 10:48

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 22:21

issue is MIL is very controlling. She’s not being nice in “letting” us stay there. She never wanted us to move out in first place as according to her culture the son stays with parents and the wife is a servant to MIL, obeying every command and spending all day cleaning n cooking. I wouldn’t be allowed to leave the house if I stayed with them. It’s taken me years to get out from under her control and I don’t want to get back there again. We were “allowed” to move out in the beginning as I was ready to get divorced. This was pre-kids and now she knows I’m stuck so if I get back there it will be hell

But you will be allowed to leave as presumably you’ll be out doing school runs etc? Leave in the morning and then have plans. Go shopping, see friends….what do you normally do? Gym, classes…anything else you do outside the home?

Tbh having read your update I just can’t understand why you left it to your husband to sort and only at the last minute are panicking that he did nothing about alternative accommodation. Surely staying with MIL was always a high possibility? You have been a bit foolish in leaving this to him given the track record.

RayneDance · 24/08/2022 10:45

I would also be announcing going back to work

RayneDance · 24/08/2022 10:44

Wow it's his money so he gets to call all the shots with no care to how you feel?

Are you on the mortgage/deeds of a new house?.

Did you work before?

I wouldn't allow it on principal..

Dragmedown · 24/08/2022 10:42

DH keeps reminding me that it’s his money and as I’m a SAHM at present it’s his decision.

Nevermind your MIL, this ^^ is your biggest problem.

However, you’ve asked for advice on the move, so I’m with the posters who say ‘suck it up’. I would save the money and make plans to spend time out of the house/with friends etc. Is there family or anyone else you could stay for a night with at the weekends to break it up? Moving is so expensive, the cost of living is rising etc etc…throwing money at a hotel when you can stay somewhere for free is madness.

DarkDayforMN · 24/08/2022 10:38

You absolutely should NOT move in with MIL and husband. Under no circumstances.

Have you seen all the legal documentation re the new house? I'm getting the impression that you haven't! That's really scary.

Have you got a joint bank account and access to it? Get your hands on as much money as you can as soon as possible, you are probably going to need a solicitor. Take the kids and go to your mother's house if you can, or contact Women's Aid and explain that you are being expected to go back to an an abusive situation, or both.

Get money (and passports etc), get away and then get advice.

Hesleepswiththefishes · 24/08/2022 10:32

What a horrible way to speak to you, you’re a partnership

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 10:32

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 22:26

@GinIronic that’s exactly what my own mum said!

I don’t have family here unfortunately and I can’t ask others to expect others to let us stay.

So you don't even know if you have DEFINITELY got a house to move into and certainly don't trust him?!

Wow. Your relationship is completely fucked.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 24/08/2022 10:31

"DH keeps reminding me that it’s his money and as I’m a SAHM at present it’s his decision"

F that. You're a family unit. And he failed to let you know he hadn't sorted anything out.

I think MIL is the least of your problems. You have a major DH problem!

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 10:29

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 22:21

issue is MIL is very controlling. She’s not being nice in “letting” us stay there. She never wanted us to move out in first place as according to her culture the son stays with parents and the wife is a servant to MIL, obeying every command and spending all day cleaning n cooking. I wouldn’t be allowed to leave the house if I stayed with them. It’s taken me years to get out from under her control and I don’t want to get back there again. We were “allowed” to move out in the beginning as I was ready to get divorced. This was pre-kids and now she knows I’m stuck so if I get back there it will be hell

You seriously are blaming your MIL for controlling behaviour?!

Is your DH innocent in this department?! Really?!

He probably wants to move home precisely to put you in your place. He holds the same views. Wake up.

Your MIL isn't the problem. Its your marriage.