Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any EV owners about who can reassure me about charging costs?

36 replies

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 19:32

I have a e-Mokka on order and now I’m wondering if I should be worried about charging costs.

I will only be able to trickle charge at home. So will rely on charging stations.

Are charging station costs going up as sharply as domestic fuel prices?

(For anyone who recognises my NN, Yes I have too much time to think this week and yes, I am preoccupied with living costs.)

YABU = it’s quite affordable
YANBU = yes it’s expensive and increasing - panic.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HairyKitty · 23/08/2022 21:11

If you check your vehicle spec for the charger type and then download Zap-Map you will be able to check what’s available near you?
Also is there any way to run an ordinary plugin cable at home and run it to the car?

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 21:08

littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 21:04

We went south of Tours - we broke our journey each way in Normandy to ease any charging worries. We'd have been fine IF Eurotunnel hadn't had a massive delay - so we weren't able to fully charge up before our train at the Eurotunnel terminal (but we were able to change up a bit). We then arrived later than planned in France, a lot more frazzled and had some serious charging stress the first 24 hours as we had missed the first Ionity charger...and were rushing to make our accommodation booking...we also limited air conditioning use in the heatwave which made the journey really hard and difficult. The battery drain to use air con was not worth losing miles at that points....

We were saved by McDonalds of all places in Normandy. The local charging points were mostly not very user friendly (we had read up and had Chargemap card) or were out of order. But we finally got sorted with Ionity near Le Mans and after that all was well for the rest of the trip. We used Ionity for reliable - if expensive - charging. But it was a nice surprise to find local chargers which worked and were easy to use.

We would do it all again. BUT a Tesla would be a dream abroad - at the Baie de Somme Ionity station we finally found on the way back there were about 15 Tesla chargers - very underused - and about 6 non-Tesla charges which were in very high demand...sharp elbows were needed to ensure you weren't queue jumped.

I'd love to use the Lidl chargers abroad but we tried several that were not working; some that used very different connectors; and some that just made no sense at all...all fine if you know the lie of the land but travelling I want something easy, reliable and assured. At least Ionity mostly provided that (even if we did have to wait for 45 mins at one stop as all the chargers had 'just' started charging when we arrived).

I love our electric car for local journeys (up to about 100 miles away - we can very comfortably do over 00 miles without charging, with air con in summer with our battery). Anything over that and it becomes a bit more of a planning situation. But we've travelled a fair bit in the electric car and always managed to charge it...sometimes with more stress admittedly!

Thank you this is all good detailed info. I do love a good ferry jaunt.

OP posts:
littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 21:05
  • we can very comfortably do over 200 miles! Not sure where my '2' went....
littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 21:04

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 20:01

How far did you travel across France? Was it stressful thinking about charging?

We went south of Tours - we broke our journey each way in Normandy to ease any charging worries. We'd have been fine IF Eurotunnel hadn't had a massive delay - so we weren't able to fully charge up before our train at the Eurotunnel terminal (but we were able to change up a bit). We then arrived later than planned in France, a lot more frazzled and had some serious charging stress the first 24 hours as we had missed the first Ionity charger...and were rushing to make our accommodation booking...we also limited air conditioning use in the heatwave which made the journey really hard and difficult. The battery drain to use air con was not worth losing miles at that points....

We were saved by McDonalds of all places in Normandy. The local charging points were mostly not very user friendly (we had read up and had Chargemap card) or were out of order. But we finally got sorted with Ionity near Le Mans and after that all was well for the rest of the trip. We used Ionity for reliable - if expensive - charging. But it was a nice surprise to find local chargers which worked and were easy to use.

We would do it all again. BUT a Tesla would be a dream abroad - at the Baie de Somme Ionity station we finally found on the way back there were about 15 Tesla chargers - very underused - and about 6 non-Tesla charges which were in very high demand...sharp elbows were needed to ensure you weren't queue jumped.

I'd love to use the Lidl chargers abroad but we tried several that were not working; some that used very different connectors; and some that just made no sense at all...all fine if you know the lie of the land but travelling I want something easy, reliable and assured. At least Ionity mostly provided that (even if we did have to wait for 45 mins at one stop as all the chargers had 'just' started charging when we arrived).

I love our electric car for local journeys (up to about 100 miles away - we can very comfortably do over 00 miles without charging, with air con in summer with our battery). Anything over that and it becomes a bit more of a planning situation. But we've travelled a fair bit in the electric car and always managed to charge it...sometimes with more stress admittedly!

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 20:47

I did work out before I ordered that even if I had to hire a vehicle for holidays and exceptional circs I would still be better off, and I want to minimise my environmental guilt.

These RL anecdotes are much more confidence inspiring than what the motor industry have to say.

OP posts:
OwBist · 23/08/2022 20:47

Have a look at Zap-map. It will show you all the chargers around and the operators, so you can look at their sites and find the costs per kWh. The Shell network (much bigger than just Shell garages) is showing 66p per kWh on a 50kw charge. Prices have gone up a lot recently, but it's still cheaper than petrol.

lemonsorbetinthesun · 23/08/2022 20:42

I have an EV. I charge overnight. Slow charge and it’s not very expensive. Cheaper than fuel.

the only issue you may have is that you can’t have charging cables across the roads and paths. I know pod point won’t install a charger unless it meets those requirements

Frazzled2207 · 23/08/2022 20:38

Trickle charging at home will be fine as long as you don’t do high mileage. Mine takes 12 hours from empty to full but it’s never empty. I very rarely do more than 20 miles so it doesn’t need more than 3-4 hours to get it back up to full.

yes you will be exposed to rising energy costs but you’ll save a fortune compared with petrol/diesel long term

HelloDoris · 23/08/2022 20:37

I should say we trickle charge her overnight...

HelloDoris · 23/08/2022 20:36

We have a Zoe, charge her up overnight (we are looking at changing our electric to Octopus and taking their EV rate)
octopusev.com/charging/tariff

Lots of charging points round us, download the zap map app and you can start looking at charging points and their costs. Out local Lidl has free charging points and chargeable rapid points.. not looked at what Tesco offers.

HereLiesBetelgeuse · 23/08/2022 20:32

I don't have a charger at home so I only use public points. My council rates are 25p per kWh whether it's a slow 7kw charger or a rapid 50kw. You will be able to find the local council tariffs online somewhere. I use the Chargeplace Scotland app and I have a card from them to pay and pay a direct debit to them every month. Beware that some places have overstay charges and here those depend what type of charger you are using ie the 50 you can only stay an hour or else you get a £5 overstay charge.
The next council area to me have all free charging so I try to use that if I'm out in that area. My car has a 33w battery so I can fill up for £8/9 and that does me around. 150/160 miles. I tend to stick it on a fast charge x 2 a week while I walk the dog nearby.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 20:31

At least 90% of my journeys now are just me around town.

OP posts:
SpotOnMyBot · 23/08/2022 20:19

I have one through work. We charge it overnight. It is fantastic for pottering around town and short journeys but I must admit, we are starting to get frustrated with longer trips as so many chargers are out of order on the motorways or the cities near them.

The charging costs now are fine but they are going up fairly quickly. What you will find though is that your usage will depend how you drive. If you are mainly doing city driving (ie slow!) you won't use much at all. Even motorway driving, if you stick around 60mph, it is enormously efficient!

Bunnyfuller · 23/08/2022 20:12

I have the Corsa-e and a home pod poin. Program it to charge 2am-7am, it’s more or less full in that time.

I don’t commute any longer and kids bus, so is definitely cheaper

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 20:04

I’m sure it will be fine, really.

It was just uncharacteristic for me to make a sudden emotional decision and tear up all my sensible thought processes.

You’ve all helped. Thanks.

OP posts:
HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 20:01

littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 20:00

Lastly - we also took our car to France this summer - we planned to use the Ionity network which is ££ but still significantly less than fossil fuels. We attempted using the Lidl chargers but none worked for us so we ended up sticking to Ionity - although Monet's gardens had a super network which was cheap as chips - I think 1€ 20 for 2 hours....you seemed to pay for the time you used rather than the energy taken...

How far did you travel across France? Was it stressful thinking about charging?

OP posts:
littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 20:00

Lastly - we also took our car to France this summer - we planned to use the Ionity network which is ££ but still significantly less than fossil fuels. We attempted using the Lidl chargers but none worked for us so we ended up sticking to Ionity - although Monet's gardens had a super network which was cheap as chips - I think 1€ 20 for 2 hours....you seemed to pay for the time you used rather than the energy taken...

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 19:59

SavoirFlair · 23/08/2022 19:59

can I ask why you chose the e-mokka (?!) and not the Corsa electric?

Motability. Limited choice.

OP posts:
SavoirFlair · 23/08/2022 19:59

can I ask why you chose the e-mokka (?!) and not the Corsa electric?

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 19:58

littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 19:53

Depends where you are - locally we have a fast charger in a council run car park that is free to charge (£1.50 to park for 1 hour and I can get over 80% charge on that - we have a 64KW battery Hyundai Kona). However we were elsewhere in the country (Somerset) and for a similar set-up it was about £30 to charge AND 80p to park for the hour!
We have a PodPoint (7KW) at home and didn't notice a major cost - we've had our electric car since May 2021 - but with electricity prices rising we are trying to make the most of our local council's amazing provision. Not just the fast charger - there are many regular chargers which are 'free' but you pay for parking. It does mean an adjustment - e.g. I will park in the swimming pool car park and intend to spend a few hours in town ticking off errands purposefully to maximise charging time. We still use our home Pod Point but much, much less than we used to. Provision elsewhere is much more hit and miss but it's all expanding....locally, here, it's great.
Enjoy your car when you get it...!

Thanks. This is all really helpful.

OP posts:
littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 19:57

And yes - many Tescos have PodPoints - usually limited to 3 hours or whatever the parking restrictions are. I've found when using it for the 3 hours (I was having to get out the house to study last year) that in that time with a 64KW battery I'd get maybe 40 miles added in that time maximum. For an more usual 30 mins - 1 hour I'd get maybe 15 miles...so enough to more than replenish the journey to get to the store but not really adding significant mileage. I'm still grateful for it. One observation is how popular in Somerset the PodPoint at Tescos was - no wonder when the Council or their contractor was fleecing the population with the fast charger costs elsewhere....

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 23/08/2022 19:56

FirewomanSam · 23/08/2022 19:53

It’s going up but it’s still much cheaper than petrol. If you’re reliant on public chargers then rapid chargers will be much more expensive than the slower ones, and you can even charge for free at Tesco and a few other places. Some public chargers will even be cheaper than your home electricity tariff. I live in a block of flats with a communal charger that’s currently 20p/kWh, cheaper than my electricity rate in my flat!

Is there any scope at all for you getting a proper charger at home? I think you will find using the ‘granny’ charger alone very tedious and it’s not really recommended to use it all the time, although plenty of people do.

I was hoping to mainly use public chargers and trickle charge when a top up is needed.

I was wavering about how sensible that was but the heatwave pushed me over into eco-fervour.

I nearly always have something work related I can do on the tablet. So I don’t mind taking a coffee and waiting for a charge at a charging point once or twice a week.

OP posts:
fruitpastille · 23/08/2022 19:54

We trickle charge our zoe a couple of nights a week. Our local aldi has medium fast chargers to use for free while shopping so we use those sometimes (sometimes they have been out of order though).

littlebauxpeep · 23/08/2022 19:53

Depends where you are - locally we have a fast charger in a council run car park that is free to charge (£1.50 to park for 1 hour and I can get over 80% charge on that - we have a 64KW battery Hyundai Kona). However we were elsewhere in the country (Somerset) and for a similar set-up it was about £30 to charge AND 80p to park for the hour!
We have a PodPoint (7KW) at home and didn't notice a major cost - we've had our electric car since May 2021 - but with electricity prices rising we are trying to make the most of our local council's amazing provision. Not just the fast charger - there are many regular chargers which are 'free' but you pay for parking. It does mean an adjustment - e.g. I will park in the swimming pool car park and intend to spend a few hours in town ticking off errands purposefully to maximise charging time. We still use our home Pod Point but much, much less than we used to. Provision elsewhere is much more hit and miss but it's all expanding....locally, here, it's great.
Enjoy your car when you get it...!

FirewomanSam · 23/08/2022 19:53

It’s going up but it’s still much cheaper than petrol. If you’re reliant on public chargers then rapid chargers will be much more expensive than the slower ones, and you can even charge for free at Tesco and a few other places. Some public chargers will even be cheaper than your home electricity tariff. I live in a block of flats with a communal charger that’s currently 20p/kWh, cheaper than my electricity rate in my flat!

Is there any scope at all for you getting a proper charger at home? I think you will find using the ‘granny’ charger alone very tedious and it’s not really recommended to use it all the time, although plenty of people do.