Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just had an offer from Octopus

382 replies

quicklybeendrivenmad · 23/08/2022 16:01

Octopus energy
Log out
Your current tariff
Flexible Octopus
Unit rates
Electricity: 27.35p per kWh
Gas: 7.28p per kWh
Standing charges
Electricity: 48.26p per day
Gas: 27.22p per day
Your new tariff options
Octopus 12M Fixed
£989.12
monthly estimate
Loyal Octopus 12M Fixed
Most popular
£945.53
monthly estimate
This tariff features 100% renewable electricity and fixes your unit rates and standing charge for 12 months. There are no exit fees, so if you change your mind, you're in control.
Your new quote
£11,869.50

God knows where these figures have come from, last months gas was £19 and Electric £180!! Who the hell would sign up to £989 per month at nearly £12k a year. Love how they say Loyal Octopus "Most popular" popular to who? Think they mean them.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Sporty2022 · 24/08/2022 20:10

Energy companies don’t make big profits?.. well maybe some don’t but British Gas did !

Mumtofourandnomore · 24/08/2022 20:08

@1dayatatime , the thing is, most wind farms are really expensive to set up, and so to get financing, wind farms will have hedged their sales prices to guarantee their revenue streams. This is true of other generators too.

This means that it isn’t the generator making the money, it’s the banks. It’s entirely dependent on whether generators hedge 100% of their output. Profit sits all over the place - making it hard to legislate for.

I definitely agree with you on Russia.

Sporty2022 · 24/08/2022 20:08

Part of me thinks that the government will intervene and take up the slack. But then another part of me says , if the government was going to do anything they’d have announced it by now.
Its not as if they don’t know what’s coming.

Boris Johnson said that while the war in Ukraine is on, the rest of Europe will
have to endure higher energy costs.

But not all of Europe is, it’s is Britain’s that’s getting hammered.

And Truss doesn’t believe in hand outs apparently.

1dayatatime · 24/08/2022 19:30

@EtnaVesuvius

just find it hard to hear people coming out in defence of energy companies

++++

The thing is the energy suppliers are really not making much profit on customers (if any profit at all).

The energy producers (oil and gas companies) and the energy generators ( including and especially wind farm owners as they have no fuel input costs) are the ones making massive profits.

If consumers either refuse or are unable to pay for these higher prices then the energy supply companies will simply go bust and this time there really will be no other supply companies willing to take on these stranded customers.

Ironically the cause of the price hikes on electricity and gas is largely due to reduced supplies from Russia. But because of the higher prices the Russians are making the same amount of money on selling their gas but just on lower volumes. It's completely insane.

Redqueenheart · 24/08/2022 18:24

Unless they are pumping liquid gold into your home, this is simply ludicrous.

Cancel your DD, insist they bill you based on your actual usage every month and pay what you can afford.

I think we all need to call their bluff and do the same thing.

This nonsense is simply going to crash the entire economy...

The government needs to re-nationalise the whole lot and be done with it.

LakieLady · 24/08/2022 17:51

NoMichaelNo · 23/08/2022 17:36

£4,503.13
Based on the latest industry estimate of your energy use. Regular readings make this more accurate.
Tariff cost breakdown
âš¡ Electricity
Daily standing charge Question mark icon 37.65p /day
Unit rate Question mark icon 72.87p /kWh
Early exit fee £0
🔥 Gas
Daily standing charge Question mark icon 27.22p /day
Unit rate Question mark icon 19.56p /kWh
Early exit fee £0

For a one bedroom property, currently using less than £100 combined electricity and gas.

That's massive.

A friend was offered a deal that was a massive increase in monthly payments. When we crunched the numbers, their "estimate" was based on her using 60% more energy than she did over the last 12 months.

When we worked out what she would pay on those rates but at her actual level of usage, it was nowhere near as much.

I think some of these companies are trying it on.

gonutkin · 24/08/2022 17:36

coldcaff · 24/08/2022 17:14

Our fixed deal with octopus ends this month, I've no idea what they're asking us to pay going forward. Currently pay about £100 for both gas and electric.

I've been foolish and buried my head in the sand over all this. My anxiety can't face it.

I feel the exact same, we pay £100 a month at the moment, but if this happens again and again we physically won't be able to pay it. I don't know how this can happen, a lot of the country is going to be feeling the same. How bills can treble or more over night is crazy to me! I've never seen anything like it

gonutkin · 24/08/2022 17:34

@EtnaVesuvius

just find it hard to hear people coming out in defence of energy companies

I totally agree. The people who work for the energy companies are innocent in this, but is this really necessary with the price rises, i wonder sometimes if these types of prices are really needed for energy companies to make a profit. Just like the fuel companies, biggest profits seen but we were paying out of our nose for it so would make sense. The whole thing is hugely worrying for anyone without loads of disposable cash laying around, I honestly don't know how we will be able to afford it when it goes up again.

coldcaff · 24/08/2022 17:14

Our fixed deal with octopus ends this month, I've no idea what they're asking us to pay going forward. Currently pay about £100 for both gas and electric.

I've been foolish and buried my head in the sand over all this. My anxiety can't face it.

PuzzledObserver · 24/08/2022 16:49

Colleague and I were chatting today and she asked me to have a look at the offer she’d just had from EonNext for when her fixed tariff ends in October. The default was that she would roll over onto the variable rate, and although that was a massive increase, it was much lower than the fix they were offering, so she was just going to let that happen. But she invited me to have a look and advise her.

The fix she was offered was 60p for electricity and 15.5p for gas. So obviously the variable rate at 28p for electricity and 7.5p for gas looked much better.

So I told her that by the time she was actually on the variable tariff, electricity would be something like 52p, and gas 14.7p. And then could be going up by another third in January, and then another 25% in April. Whereas the fixed tariff was for 12 months.

She wondered about waiting till the new PM is announced as there is supposedly more help coming. However, we checked whether the fixed tariff is guaranteed for any length of time. It isn’t - it could be pulled at any moment. It was also without exit penalty.

So the decision was to accept the fix. It comes into effect from when her current fix ends in early October. It is more expensive than variable from October - December, but from January onwards will be cheaper. And if the Government actually gets off its arse and does freeze the price cap from October onwards, as has been mooted, then she can switch back to variable rate with no penalty.

Needless to say, she will be trying to cut usage as well.

Mumtofourandnomore · 24/08/2022 15:00

EtnaVesuvius · 24/08/2022 13:58

I just find it hard to hear people coming out in defence of energy companies when they are pressuring people to increase their DDs way, way beyond what people use.

Mine changed my DD without my consent to nearly double what I pay (and four times what I was using at the time). I have a smart meter so I know what I use. I told them to put it back down but if I’d been elderly I might have thought I couldn’t afford to put the heating on and sat there in the cold.

That’s immoral.

Normally direct debits are reassessed either once or twice a year. So your supplier looks at your usage, looks at the forecast prices, considers any outstanding balance on your meter and works out what your expected bill will be for the next 12 months and spreads it evenly over the year. The goal is to make your bill zero, a year from now.

Wholesale prices are astronomical - hence the rises - it isn’t because your energy company is trying to rip you off. Traditionally most customers preferred to have a set amount to pay each month to help budget. I agree some customers prefer to pay on receipt - I do understand that. Also, it is sensible not to have a huge credit built up - this is protected if your supplier goes bust but it’s a hassle to transfer over. It’s also better to be in your account than theirs.

Ultimately customers pay for energy they use so if you lower your DD manually, be careful that you aren’t getting into too much debt - be prepared to pay more as the year goes on.

MinervaTerrathorn · 24/08/2022 14:22

FourTeaFallOut · 24/08/2022 14:13

But who would have been cold since April? And surely building the hefty credit required to mitigate the winter fuel bills ahead was better achieved sooner, rather than later?

An elderly person? My grandmother usually turns the heating on for the last time in May, it's often on in April.

FourTeaFallOut · 24/08/2022 14:13

But who would have been cold since April? And surely building the hefty credit required to mitigate the winter fuel bills ahead was better achieved sooner, rather than later?

EtnaVesuvius · 24/08/2022 13:58

Mumtofourandnomore · 23/08/2022 23:29

Yes, I do. Somebody has to lol. Is it because I defend them in all my posts. The energy market is really interesting but really complicated. Work has been crazy. We do actually try our best for customers.

I‘m not a fat cat - honest.

I just find it hard to hear people coming out in defence of energy companies when they are pressuring people to increase their DDs way, way beyond what people use.

Mine changed my DD without my consent to nearly double what I pay (and four times what I was using at the time). I have a smart meter so I know what I use. I told them to put it back down but if I’d been elderly I might have thought I couldn’t afford to put the heating on and sat there in the cold.

That’s immoral.

Mumtofourandnomore · 24/08/2022 08:15

NoWordForFluffy · 24/08/2022 05:27

This annoys me. That should be for the industry to pay for, not the consumer.

It’s the government’s fault for allowing little suppliers to set up with no regulation. These little suppliers took cash from customers, and when prices went up they all went bust as they hadn’t hedged forward volumes.

There needs to be rules to make sure that suppliers have a certain amount of capital and that if customer pay in advance, that cash is protected. I agree it’s not the fault of consumers, but it’s not the fault of properly run suppliers either - it’s an Ofgem fault for awarding supply licences to cowboys.

Headshothelp · 24/08/2022 07:37

Lemonyfuckit · 23/08/2022 17:20

Another thing - my mum is on Octopus, and I understand all their energy comes from renewable sources. Now I understood that the current horrendous prices that are coming with the removal of the price cap is because the wholesale price of gas has gone through the roof due to global supply/demand issues, so I'd like Octopus to explain why their prices have increased so much if it all comes from renewables (unless it's simply a knock on supply/demand effect with so many people switching to suppliers from renewable sources?)

Neither gas or electric is actually completely renewable from Octopus, or anywhere.

The gas flows in the same pipes and electricity down the same wires as everyone else's.

But say there is 10,000 cubic metres of renewable gas in the network every day and Octopus use 5000. They have basically paid to say that that renewable gas is "theirs". Despite the fact it may not go to their customer's homes.

It's a concept called GOO (guarantees of origin) and the idea is to make more investment in renewable energy more likely by turning it into a viable investment opportunity.

ClaryFairchild · 24/08/2022 07:26

Slightly off topic, but those who are panicking about heating costs, if you Google DIY solar heating you can find some instructions on building a small solar heating system which might help. I've been saving vegetable cans and want to build one as a project with DSs, which is why I've been looking at it. It apparently even works on cloudy days, although clearly not as efficiently.

Hopefully something like this would keep the edge off the cold for people.

quicklybeendrivenmad · 24/08/2022 07:15

I know my usage is high, but part of our business is run from home, scariest thing is I actually have quite a large credit on my account. And don't even get me started on how much our business electric has increased on our business premises as there is no cap on that.

OP posts:
EverydayIsPJday · 24/08/2022 07:06

@AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair no I know we havent secured a DD fee but presumably we've fixed at those rates enegy rates which is based on our annual consumption. I appreciate that doesn't mean I crank the heating on full blast and have a rave with loud speakers. Just that we are trying to grab a lower rate now before it rockets again. I have no idea if it's the right thing to do but I can bail out at no exit fee and I know I can't afford some of the figures suggested on here. It's also referred to as a very good deal but he MSA. Scaremongering working by the energy companies/media? Absolutely. But I have small children so what else can I do?

Swedecabbagelime · 24/08/2022 06:43

The government need to offer help to small businesses. Where I work the energy bill is about to treble. I’m worried about redundancy and that will be the same across the country. Not all workplaces are huge multinational companies who can absorb this cost. There are many many small businesses who will struggle to pay this and their staff.
I’d rather be cold at home knowing my job was safe tbh.

NoWordForFluffy · 24/08/2022 05:27

Mumtofourandnomore · 23/08/2022 22:50

Apologies I realise my post didn’t read well.

To be more concise, the increase in standing charges is primarily driven by the cost of failed suppliers (more expensive energy bought be the new supplier plus cash customers had paid in advance that the bust supplier had taken).

These costs have been calculated on the whole, so were included from April and there haven’t been new suppliers going out of business, so should broadly be stable (I think).

This annoys me. That should be for the industry to pay for, not the consumer.

OakTreex · 24/08/2022 03:02

@BarbaraofSeville it's not disingenuous, I simply do. I'm careful of my useage, like all of us right now I imagine, but I don't sit in the dark all evening or light candles or anything.

Others I know on prepayment are similar and I can see another poster agreeing.

On the face of it, it seems they should be more expensive. They just aren't in my opinion and anecdotally from people I know right now.

Perhaps it's simply the fact the energy company can't decide on an arbitrary direct debit figure that doesn't reflect useage Confused

hownowpurplecow · 23/08/2022 23:47

I can’t believe the size of some of these quotes. I need to ring Octopus tomorrow as we’re currently on a fixed rate, we pay £230 a month and our highest predicted month is Jan 23 when they’ve estimated we’ll use £320, which we’ll have enough credit to cover. Except we’re due to move house next month and now I’m worried they won’t let us take our current fix with us and who knows what they’ll try and charge us. We’ve a baby due in October, plus a two year old at home, which means I’ll be dropping to half pay from January on mat leave and we need to keep the house relatively warm for the kids. What an absolute nightmare! Luckily we’re downsizing from our current house so at least our mortgage will be considerably less than our rent is now. Fingers crossed we can take our current tariff with us when we move, but it doesn’t feel all that hopeful. I keep thinking someone has to do something, but I have zero faith in either Liz Truss or Rishi Sunak to give a shit.

Friars23 · 23/08/2022 23:45

TopKnotch · 23/08/2022 22:52

@Friars23 I've reported your post as it includes names and addresses etc

Thanks. Yes, I realised my mistake and reported it too.

Mumtofourandnomore · 23/08/2022 23:29

EtnaVesuvius · 23/08/2022 23:04

Hmmm, @Mumtofourandnomore , methinks you work for an energy supplier…

Yes, I do. Somebody has to lol. Is it because I defend them in all my posts. The energy market is really interesting but really complicated. Work has been crazy. We do actually try our best for customers.

I‘m not a fat cat - honest.