Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who was BU/rude - teenager or grandparent

215 replies

Seriou · 23/08/2022 15:04

I was out today for a few hours and asked my mum to look in on late teenage DP if she was in area (regularly in my area).

I’ve come home to rant on WhatsApp about how rude dd is - GP came in with a friend and spent time in house/garden drinking tea together. GP asked dd to come downstairs but she wouldn’t.

Relevant facts - DD wasn’t actually expecting GP to visit, Dd is extremely shy and has some SEN, dd was still in her pyjamas, dd hasn’t seen friend for years.

Was GP rude for bringing friend in and then demanding DD come down, and then BU in saying I’m raising a rude teenager ?

Or was Dd actually rude and should have made an appearance?

OP posts:
Seriou · 23/08/2022 17:18

I never told DD about the visit because GP had indicated she wouldn’t be able to.

The request to pop in would not be unusual in itself - DD is still getting use to spending time home alone, so if I know I’ll be a while and GP is in the area, I would ask her to call in.

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 23/08/2022 17:18

It’s your DD’s home too, and I think it is a bit much that your Mum waltzes in, friend in tow, when your Dd is not expecting her. And disrespectful of you to make an arrangement for her to be ‘checked on’ without telling her.

So why is everyone else in this scenario deserving of respect and manners but not your Dd?

Plus you, and presumably your Mum know she is extremely shy. Yes, ideally she would have said hello. She was probably upset.

I think you should apologise to her for putting her in that situation. You set her up to fail and I think it is OTT for your mum to be ranting about her.

KosherDill · 23/08/2022 17:11

My sympathies lie entirely with the teen.

Octomore · 23/08/2022 17:10

OP is being strangely quiet about her view.

OP - how would you feel if your daughter invited someone round without asking or telling you, and then expected you to host them when all you wanted was to chill out with a book?

Aprilx · 23/08/2022 17:10

Neither of them are really at fault. I think you are most unreasonable by arranging this visit but not telling DD about it and presumably also not telling GP that she would be a surprise visitor.

TheLion · 23/08/2022 17:09

Weird all round. If GP pops in a lot then she should be used to DD's behaviour and likewise DD should be used to her gran coming over. I'm surprised this hasn't come up before tbh. Is it the first time GP brought a friend over?

I would think better communication from everyone would help the situation eg GP should have said "yes, I'll stop in this afternoon with Sharon from Pilates. We'll have a cup of tea in the garden" then you should have text DD "just to let you know, granny is popping round with Sharon later. Please say hello to them but then you can go off to your room if you prefer" and then replied to your mum "lovely, please don't expect too much from DD btw as she's not feeling great at the moment". That way everyone knows what is going to happen and both sides can manage expectations.

user29 · 23/08/2022 17:09

I don't think ts the GPs fault.She had probably made plans for te day with this friend before your request came in.Then you asked her to call in ,and even though she had made plans, did her best to comply with this request,
Was your dd rude? Undoubtedly..But the person most to blame is you for asking the GM to do this and then not evening telling your dd

Octomore · 23/08/2022 17:09

Good point. Someone who lets themselves in should not expect to be hosted.

Triffid1 · 23/08/2022 17:07

I think you or your mother bringing a random friend round and expecting a teenage DD to entertain them is weird and rude. In addition, if your mother is round so often that she has a key and her popping in and out is normal, then she should be treated like anyone who lives there and that means that no, your DD is not obliged to make a big fuss of her arrival every time (ie she doesn't need to be treated as a guest).

BabyDreamers · 23/08/2022 17:06

I can't bare people visiting unannounced. I'd have had the door locked and pretended I was out. I'd have had to have got dressed, brushed my hair and put make up on to be able to go downstairs and face people. I'm introverted but not necessarily shy so if your daughters shy that must have been anxiety overload. GP is in the wrong and rude.

takealettermsjones · 23/08/2022 17:05

What treatment has your DD had for her shyness?

Oh, come on. Shyness in itself doesn't need 'treatment'. I know many happy introverts.

876starlight · 23/08/2022 17:03

Nagado · 23/08/2022 15:09

I don’t think any of you covered yourselves in glory here. It was pretty rude for your DD to refuse to come down to say hello. It was pretty rude for your DM to turn up with a random stranger and expect to have a tea party and it was pretty rude of you not to have warned your DD that her grandmother might be popping in to see her.

Literally this in a nutshell

Octopuscrazy · 23/08/2022 17:03

Your dd was incredibly rude.
A quick hello is not difficult or onerous even if your DM had brought a friend (a bit unusual but I couldn't get too het up about it)

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 17:02

You should have told her GP and a friend were coming round!!! You're rude!

Heartrate · 23/08/2022 17:02

I think DD was rude but GP was inconsiderate because the response was entirely predictable and why would GP out DD in a position that would make her so uncomfortable?

Octomore · 23/08/2022 17:00

I can understand why your DD is painfully shy if she has he boundaries stomped on like that by you and grandma.

Not just her grandma, but her mother. They both see the DD's wishes/opinion as irrelevant.

Octomore · 23/08/2022 16:59

You and GP were unreasonable.

Did you ask your dd if she wanted her GP to pop round? Did she get a say?

And then the GP waltzed into your DD's home with no warning, expecting DD to play the host to her and her friend.

Your DD was at home, minding her own business. She had the right to be consulted on whether she wanted to entertain visitors, or whether she'd prefer to chill on her own.

chinesefortea · 23/08/2022 16:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 23/08/2022 16:53

GP should have told you she was with a friend and would it be ok for said friend to pop by with her, then you could have at least informed your DD.
GP could also have just popped up to see DD, have a chat and explain that she is with so and so and they’ll be downstairs for a bit if she fancies joining them.

diddl · 23/08/2022 16:41

Seriou · 23/08/2022 15:22

GP pops in a lot - not every day but at least twice a week and has a key, but the door was unlocked so she came straight in as usual.
The friend hasn’t been here for a few years, and it was her appearance that kept dd from coming downstairs, not the GP herself.

Presumably you're OK with that but what about others who live there?

How do you feel about your mum bringing a friend in & sitting drinking tea?

She was supposed to check on your daughter not force her to socialise with her & a friend!

madasawethen · 23/08/2022 16:40

All very odd behaviour. You and your DM have zero boundaries.

Take the key back and tell your DM to stop popping in your house uninvited. It really is not normal behaviour for her to bring a friend and raid your kitchen and sit around in your garden like that.

Your late teen DD doesn't need a babysitter or checking in on, unless there is some massive thing you haven't mentioned. That isn't normal behaviour nor is the sneakiness of it.

I can understand why your DD is painfully shy if she has he boundaries stomped on like that by you and grandma.

What treatment has your DD had for her shyness?

howdidigethere · 23/08/2022 16:37

Presuming your DD isn't ill why does she need popping in on? You've obviously got a relaxed arrangement with your DM seeing as she has a key and lets herself in unannounced but bringing the friend and them having a cuppa is a bit strange to me. Not sure I'd want to be commanded to come downstairs and say hello to a virtual stranger either.

amusedbush · 23/08/2022 16:34

Your DD was rude by "normal" standards but I don't particularly subscribe to those (I'm autistic). I would be annoyed enough if someone turned up unexpectedly, but bringing along someone I didn't know well would tip me over the edge.

I'm on your DD's side here - why should she have to get dressed, go downstairs and make small talk when she doesn't want to? I think it's a bit rich that the DGM is ranting about rudeness while being bloody rude and making her DGD feel uncomfortable in her own home!

I've spent a lifetime plastering on a smile and being a people pleaser for the sake of politeness and it's thankless.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 23/08/2022 16:21

This is a genuine question to all of the PP's who have said that the OP's 17/18 or 19 year old DD must pop in and say hello, why must she?

IMO she is either an adult now, or soon to be one, and whether or not she has SEN she is her own person, and allowed her to make her own judgements. Just because you or I don't know the DD's reasons for making her decisions, it is none of our business - as it was the OP, DD's mum who has asked us, not her DD herself.

So I really would like to know please, where this well hidden rule book is, that says an adult living in her own home, has to acknowledge anyone who comes into her home without her requesting them to?

SunshineLaughter · 23/08/2022 16:20

I'm on your daughters side actually. Why should she have to go downstairs and entertain her Grandmother and a person she doesn't know in her own home? You should have given her a heads up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread