Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who was BU/rude - teenager or grandparent

215 replies

Seriou · 23/08/2022 15:04

I was out today for a few hours and asked my mum to look in on late teenage DP if she was in area (regularly in my area).

I’ve come home to rant on WhatsApp about how rude dd is - GP came in with a friend and spent time in house/garden drinking tea together. GP asked dd to come downstairs but she wouldn’t.

Relevant facts - DD wasn’t actually expecting GP to visit, Dd is extremely shy and has some SEN, dd was still in her pyjamas, dd hasn’t seen friend for years.

Was GP rude for bringing friend in and then demanding DD come down, and then BU in saying I’m raising a rude teenager ?

Or was Dd actually rude and should have made an appearance?

OP posts:
MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 24/08/2022 21:45

And we wonder why young women have such poor boundaries.

Marotte · 24/08/2022 21:33

Grandparent had no right to bring a friend into your almost-adult daughter's home without permission - why did grandparent think s/he had the right to this? And preferably, this permission would come from your daughter given freely in advance and not just as an "I hope you don't mind, we're outside" type of thing, and not just from you, it was rather an invasion of privacy at the age she is, although it's your house, and she's a minor, so it's up to you how to run things. You should definitely have let her know that you had asked her grandparent to pop round so she could have been mentally prepared and dressed if she wanted to be, but that still wouldn't have included the friend. (Sitting in and enjoying your garden while having a cuppa with a friend doesn't really sound as though she actually did what was asked, which was to check in on the house and your daughter.) I'd personally say that the grandparent is a CF, but other Mumsnetters may disagree.

Delatron · 24/08/2022 21:27

You’re the unreasonably one. At 17 you should have some privacy in your own home and not have your grandma and friend popping in unannounced at any moment.

A 17 year old doesn’t need checking up on and why does the grandma pop in the whole time? Poor kid.

Hotandbothereds · 24/08/2022 21:27

stressease · 24/08/2022 20:28

In my family it would be normal to say hi grandma, would you like a cup of tea. Along with grandmas. friend . Normal social skills.

Plus, your Mam was doing a favour to you popping in (you asked her) so I could see why it might have upset her.

GP wasn’t doing DD a favour though, since she didn’t even know about it.

Very poor communication from the OP was the issue here.

Vivi0 · 24/08/2022 21:21

No, your DD was not rude.

She is entitled to say no. I think it’s a great thing actually, that at her age, she felt comfortable and confident enough to say no, and mean it.

Looking back, I would have complied and went downstairs and said hello, even though I wouldn’t have wanted to, because I internalised that being nice and polite was more important than how I felt and what I wanted.

The problem with that though, is that it trickles through into other relationships and situations, which isn’t great. It took me longer than it should have to find the confidence to say no, and to mean it.

I’m raising my children to have boundaries and to feel comfortable saying no to things they don’t want to do, and I couldn’t give a fuck who finds it rude.

It’s a real shame your DD’s grandmother wasn't respectful of her granddaughter’s no, but, as another poster put it, they won't see it that way as their generation is very different, especially when it comes to consent and boundaries.

tigger1001 · 24/08/2022 20:57

"My mother had a key and could come and go as she pleased and I wouldn’t have had it any other way both children adored her. I really don’t understand this. No wonder the young are so entitled."

No one would come into my house without knocking and being invited in. Same goes for their grandparents houses. Yet my kids also adore their grandparents. The two are not linked.

For me, it's far more entitled to just walk into someone's home without asking. Boundaries and privacy are important and should be respected.

sumayyah · 24/08/2022 20:53

I have a 17 year old with autism and selective mutism, not a chance would she go say hello with a stranger there.

Honestly it was mismanaged all around.
You should have told your teen that her grandmother may pop in while your out so that she knew to be dressed and could prepare herself
Your mum should have said she was out with a friend so you could tell her thanks but it's best she doesn't visit your teen with friend in teen

I have lower expectations of your teen if they find change and strangers difficult as I know with my daughter that unexpected changes can cause meltdowns and strangers trying to speak to her or even look at her causes her to hurt herself, she picks at her skin causing injuries

Kite22 · 24/08/2022 20:29

My mother had a key and could come and go as she pleased and I wouldn’t have had it any other way both children adored her. I really don’t understand this. No wonder the young are so entitled.

Not sure about "the young" Hmm
I'm grey haired and counting down to retirement. Nobody has every just walked into any home I have ever lived in, including back when I was a child.

My Mum always had a key to all the homes I have earned, but she would never presume to just walk in. I have a key to my sister's home and to my niece's home, but again, I would never walk in - it is for emergencies. I like it when people 'pop round' if they are in the area and don't need an appointment like so many MNers but if I go to anyone's home, or if they come to mine, everyone would knock / ring the bell and wait to be let in.
In the case of me asking someone to let themselves in, that would only happen if nobody were there. If you were - for whatever reason - asking them to go in when someone was there, then you would obviously tell the person in the house that X is coming round this afternoon.

stressease · 24/08/2022 20:28

In my family it would be normal to say hi grandma, would you like a cup of tea. Along with grandmas. friend . Normal social skills.

Plus, your Mam was doing a favour to you popping in (you asked her) so I could see why it might have upset her.

MiniMeMama · 24/08/2022 20:26

GP was being unreasonable. They won't see it that way as their generation is very different, especially when it comes to consent and boundaries

Hotandbothereds · 24/08/2022 20:08

If I was your DD I’d have felt the same!

If I was chilling at home in my pjs and some let themselves in unannounced with a stranger and expected me to be sociable I’d be livid! I hate unannounced guests.

Your Dd is allowed to have time in her own home undisrupted, I think the GP was in the wrong for bringing a friend & you were wrong for not asking your Dd if she minded GP dropping in.

Missingpop · 24/08/2022 19:59

GP was in the wrong for bringing a friend to your home & expecting you Dd to be all jolly hockey sticks about it; personally if I was in my pjs & someone came into my home with what amounts to a stranger I’d be pretty fucked off about it !!
You asked GP to look I’m not have a coffee morning stand up to the old bird tell her your dd wasn’t being rude but she wasn’t in suitable clothing & wanted to shower etc before meeting people!! If the old dear doesn’t like it tough next time don’t ask her to look in I guess although you child has Sen needs she’s capable of being alone & sensible enough not to burn the house down?

Romeiswheretheheartis · 24/08/2022 19:57

Elsiebear90 · 23/08/2022 18:12

Your GM was rude to bring a guest to someone’s house without at least warning them in advance, it’s not her house, she sounds extremely entitled. I’m not surprised your daughter didn’t come downstairs, I wouldn’t appreciate someone I barely knew coming into my house unannounced either and then being expected to socialise with them when I’m not even properly dressed.

Agreed. My dd would have done exactly the same, she really struggles with anything unexpected that she's not prepared for, and with meeting strangers. Her anxiety would have been sky high just knowing they were downstairs.

GP could have popped upstairs and knocked on dd's door to say hi, with no expectation for dd to go down and socialise with the friend.

Madamum18 · 24/08/2022 19:40

GP and DD need to sit down and chat giving each other their perspectives, so that they understand and each can try to work out a compromise that works for both of them

Bleachmycloths · 24/08/2022 19:35

All of you sound unreasonable and slightly ridiculous - EXCEPT your teenage daughter.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 24/08/2022 19:30

BusyMum47 · 24/08/2022 10:09

@Seriou I don't think your daughter was rude at all - she's shy, with SEN tendencies & wasn't expecting her gran to visit at all, let alone be called down to face a relative stranger while in her PJs! Her Gran should have known how this may make her feel. A simple pop upstairs & quick chat to check on her should have done the job. Her priority should have been more about making sure her granddaughter was ok & less about losing face in front of her friend!

This. DD was probably embarrassed to be seen in her PJs and have to explain it to a stranger, especially if she had no warning they were in her home.

Also was this a private WhatsApp where she ranted at you or a public one? if public, its not nice of her to run down her GD.
Your DD clearly said she was OK with GM visiting but no one else when you'd asked her previously.
Did GP know this?

threatmatrix · 24/08/2022 19:18

Mardyface · 23/08/2022 15:06

Well... I think you were a bit rude asking DM to drop in and not telling DD tbh. I can see both your DM (doing you a favour) and DD's (not expecting the visit, not feeling sociable) perspectives.

My mother had a key and could come and go as she pleased and I wouldn’t have had it any other way both children adored her. I really don’t understand this. No wonder the young are so entitled.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 24/08/2022 19:18

My dd sounds similar to your dd op and there's no way I'd ask my mum to pop in without warning her.

She would be mortified and would behave exactly as your dd did.

Your dd was rude but that's because you ambushed her.

SharingTheLove · 24/08/2022 19:17

I don’t understand the comments that family can’t just call in, why not? I never need to arrange to visit my dad. Family and friends knock and open the door themselves. If it’s locked, it means we aren’t in or be patient and wait! You’re all very precious about your privacy!!

I’ll no doubt get a hammering for my opinion. Ah well.

LaDamaDeElche · 24/08/2022 19:12

You said DD has SEN, as she's only just getting used to spending time alone, I'd imagine these affect her a lot and she isn't your typical 17 year old. Difficult to say without knowing what SEN are. Is she very into routine? You said she is very shy around strangers, which I know this friend isn't, but if your DD hasn't seen her for a long time, then it may almost feel that way to her. I think the unreasonable one was your mum here, but it's hard to say really without knowing what how her SEN affect her every day life.

surreygirl1987 · 24/08/2022 18:58

I think you are the unreasonable one to have told your mother to drop by without telling your daughter! I'd have hated that as a teenager (and would hate it even more now actually). I would have probably come down to be polite but would have been really annoyed.

pilates · 24/08/2022 18:54

Your mum shouldn’t invite random people to your house. I can understand why your DD didn’t want to come down tbh. If your DD is fine with grandma popping round fair enough but I would double check that it is still the case and it’s not becoming annoying.

Blueink · 24/08/2022 18:31

Not clear how we are supposed to vote? Agree it wasn’t well thought through and feel sympathetic to DD. She’s made her boundaries clear, she’s happy to spend time with GM randomly popping in being welcome, but not an unannounced visit from someone she hasn’t seen for years. You might need to smooth it over for DD, since you asked DM to visit.

Cazareeto1 · 24/08/2022 18:27

What kind of SEN issues does DD have? GP surly knows of this? Depending on how severe SEN is, DD should have been prepared that GP may pop in and to say hello. (My youngest has high SEN issues and my middle mild SEN issues. Both need prepared in different ways for visits) (middle child doesn’t feel comfortable and finds it mentally exhausting being expected to be social when he isn’t prepared)

mussymummy · 24/08/2022 17:53

Nagado · 23/08/2022 15:09

I don’t think any of you covered yourselves in glory here. It was pretty rude for your DD to refuse to come down to say hello. It was pretty rude for your DM to turn up with a random stranger and expect to have a tea party and it was pretty rude of you not to have warned your DD that her grandmother might be popping in to see her.

This