Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman trying to pull a fast one! Advice pls

110 replies

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 12:48

I sold a shoe cabinet in face book market place. Very reduced. She picked it up yesterday and looked at it carefully and then decided to buy. I have her a further £5 off as she kept saying there’s a scratch.

my husband and her husband loaded it in the car and this morning I get a message from her saying can she have the other shelves as they are missing! I was confused as it was obviously there. There’s 4 shelves and she opened it infront of us and I saw too. I replied back that’s it’s impossible 3 of the 4 shelves have dissapeared. She keeps messaging me. Where do I stand? Husband not home and I’m home alone with my little kids. Say if she turns up?

OP posts:
Jobear2797 · 24/08/2022 18:44

Legally as she picked it up you don’t have to do a thing, found this out to my cost when I arranged for a delivery company to pick up a brand new mattress for me, it was supposed to be a specific one I needed for my back, seller confirmed on numerous messages that it was but when it was delivered and we unwrapped it it wasn’t the correct one, spoke to PayPal who said as I had arranged collection it then from the moment it was collected I had officially accepted the goods, even though it wasn’t as described there was not a damn thing I could do about it.

This lady is actually worse off as she collected it and paid cash, so legally she accepted the cabinet the moment she gave you the money, sold as seen, her problem.

To be honest it does sound like she’s trying to pull a fast one and sadly these days there are plenty like her that will try to complain about anything they can to get a freebie, you’d already given her a £5 reduction, she’s chancing her arm, block her and forget about it. If she turns up, which I very much doubt as you know the shelves where all in there, so know she is pulling a fast one, call the police.

I suspect you’ll find your cabinet for sale for £100 on eBay within a week, all shelves intact!!!!!

cherish123 · 24/08/2022 18:41

Tell her this again. It's up to her to make sure she takes all the parts. If she's still claiming the shelves aren't there, ask her to return it and give her the money back. I'd clock it up as experience and bin it. You have not lost any money. Personally, I don't sell to strangers. Just give it to charities in future.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 24/08/2022 18:29

she messaged me last week asking if she could have for half the price asked

She's a scammer and a CF.

Sorry she stressed you out so much. Moving is stressful anyway.

Hope your move goes well and enjoy your new home!

GrasssInPocket · 24/08/2022 18:13

My money's on the shelves being on the floor of the unit. You can't fix stupid...I once sold a high bed to a couple and handed them the assembly instructions as there were quite a lot of parts, including the exact number of different-sized dowels to connect the pieces. Man waved them away, "don't need those, I do this kind of thing all the time at work". A couple of hours later there's a phone call with them claiming to be missing four small dowels but inexplicably had four larger ones left over that didn't fit the holes ... 🙄😂

gamerchick · 24/08/2022 18:09

Keep her blocked. If she posts online people will only say what's been said on this thread. She isn't going to turn up.

Grumpybird · 24/08/2022 18:08

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 12:59

It’s really making me uncomfortable. For the sake of £30 why would someone do this? She was there with the loading stage how could we secretly take out 3 shelves! Plus why would we want to have 3 shelves without a cabinet.

Because she’s a CF and people like her will argue over the smallest amount of money and hope you give in. Bought as seen, block and ignore her

Maryminx · 24/08/2022 18:01

Block her!
for your safety have nothing to do with her. This is a scam,don’t be afraid or intimidated,

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 19:46

She didn’t turn up. My anxiety was just hitting the roof today. I’m so annoyed I let her get to me and spoil the last week in my home.

Thank you so much everyone, you have no idea how much you all helped me. Apologies for all the typos I made in earlier posts, I was just panicking so was quickly typing into phone.

OP posts:
VerifiedBot2351 · 23/08/2022 17:44

Is there a chance that the shelves have become dislodged in the journey and are actually at the bottom of the unit? IKEA Billy bookcase shelves do that.

Justsaynonow · 23/08/2022 17:40

Do you have a local Buy Nothing group? I've just given away a huge amount of stuff, picked up from our front yard, no interaction required. Might be easier and save you some time.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 23/08/2022 16:49

Shocking to read this, next time if you ever sell anything take a photo so you have time / date when they arrived to pick it up and get them to sign a receipt that they have all the items as they sound mad. Why would you want to keep something that has no value to you. Good luck with the move as know is stressful.

WiddlinDiddlin · 23/08/2022 16:32

Some people are determined that they should get anything they want for free or as near as possible.

Some of those people are just arseholes and some of them are running businesses reselling stock they've bullied, conned and tricked out of people, or have tried to.

There are groups/forums that share these tricks 'claim theres a scratch, claim somethings missing'... 'pretend you misheard the price and hand over a tenner less and if questioned say 'oh, im sure you said 30, not 40...' '

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 23/08/2022 16:21

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 23/08/2022 13:29

Sold as seen.

This is why I also don't like giving away items on Freecycle - last woman whinged a bit about a brand new work table (from my work) in a box. Yet I'd put pics etc of it up.

She complained about a brand new table you gave her free of charge? What did she want, you should pay her to take it away?

BangaloreLulu · 23/08/2022 15:59

Giving her the benefit of the doubt and just assuming she is a complete moron rather than driven by bargain-hunting frenzy, the shelves have probably tumbled off their pegs whilst in the car and are all now sitting neatly stacked on the floor of the cabinet, and just need sliding out and balancing back on their pegs again.

IAmAWomanNotACis · 23/08/2022 15:42

There was something a little odd but I just thought it was eagerness at the time - she messaged me last week asking if she could have for half the price asked. I messaged her right back explaining someone is supposed to see but if they dont turn up I will let her have it as a reduced price. She was really eager and said she's on her way! I hadn't at this time given my address so i politely explained I will contact her if the other person doesnt show up. She messaged me everyday and I told her last night she can have it.
I dont know if its red flag or just eagnerness but I've not had this before.

Yeah, definitely red flag territory. She is a "bargain hunter". Probably argues about 10p items at car boot sales.

All is done now, please try to put her out of your mind.

Darkstar4855 · 23/08/2022 15:41

She’s just trying it on OP, block her and she’ll give up.

I sold a wardrobe online once for £100, buyer turned up and said sorry, I only have £80, is that ok? I said no, £100 or you don’t have it. She magically found another £20 in her pocket! It’s amazing how cheeky people will be if they think they can wring some extra cash out of you.

Johnnysgirl · 23/08/2022 15:39

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 15:34

There was something a little odd but I just thought it was eagerness at the time - she messaged me last week asking if she could have for half the price asked. I messaged her right back explaining someone is supposed to see but if they dont turn up I will let her have it as a reduced price. She was really eager and said she's on her way! I hadnt at this time given my address so i politely explained I will contact her if the other person doesnt show up. She messaged me everyday and I told her last night she can have it.

I dont know if its red flag or just eagnerness but I've not had this before. Most people just dont turn up. I've only listed for past 2 weeks not used. But i think I need to listen to my gut now

Just don't deal with anyone acting weirdly like that from the off. How was she "on her way" when she didn't even have your address at that point? Confused
Dealing with this nonsense can't be worth thirty quid.

eldora · 23/08/2022 15:37

Does that mean it was supposed to be £60 and she got it for £30?

It sounds like she’s decided she should have it for free and is whittling it down.

In her deluded she probably thinks she did you a favour taking it away so it should have been free.

Does she know you are moving?

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 15:34

There was something a little odd but I just thought it was eagerness at the time - she messaged me last week asking if she could have for half the price asked. I messaged her right back explaining someone is supposed to see but if they dont turn up I will let her have it as a reduced price. She was really eager and said she's on her way! I hadnt at this time given my address so i politely explained I will contact her if the other person doesnt show up. She messaged me everyday and I told her last night she can have it.

I dont know if its red flag or just eagnerness but I've not had this before. Most people just dont turn up. I've only listed for past 2 weeks not used. But i think I need to listen to my gut now

OP posts:
ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 15:29

Yeah she inspected it for a good 5 minutes and opened it. She managed to see a tiny scratch but missed 3 shelves missing! As i have anxiety i keep replaying it and I definitely saw the shelves in and when her husband lifted up I remember the shelves there and he took straight to the car on my driveway and nothing fell out.

OP posts:
Branleuse · 23/08/2022 15:27

Tell her it was sold as seen, she inspected it in front of you and you graciously already gave her a discount, so you are afraid you cant do any more for her

WisteriaLodge · 23/08/2022 15:26

Did she inspect it by the front door? Do you have a Ring camera? Stupid woman trying it on.

madasawethen · 23/08/2022 15:21

I've had a few try things like this. I either block them if they are complaining online or if it's in person, I show them the door and just say, well I guess this isn't the one for you, good bye.

I find certain demographics are the worst. I don't even stress anymore with it. I just show them the door or block.

PinballWizard18 · 23/08/2022 14:48

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 12:53

Legally where do I stand?

No legal recourse what so ever

She's a cf

LookItsMeAgain · 23/08/2022 14:47

ChangeNane1 · 23/08/2022 13:57

I’m giving what I can to charity now and just taking the rest to the tip. It’s too much stress. I sold a lawn mower this morning too and made sure the guy tested it out to show it works. Hopefully won’t hear from him later!

Even if you do, the item worked when he bought it. What he does after that is not your concern.

If he comes back with some issue, block him too.