Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unreasonable to say no to charities?

63 replies

PurpleWisteria · 23/08/2022 11:31

DH and I are very lucky and will be able to cope with the increase in the cost of living. We have good pensions and savings. No holidays since pre Covid and no debts to service.

We had a look at our finances and have decided to give a monthly amount to our 2 DS's (and partners) to help them out for a while as both have hefty mortgages. Neither DS has asked for this but we know they are worried. We have often helped both out financially thinking better now than when we are dead. Morbid, perhaps.

We will not have to cut back on the money we give to our charities.

However, this morning I had an email from a local charity that we support asking us to increase our donation (quite substantially). I appreciate that a lot of people will be struggling and we have no intention of stopping donations but don't feel able to increase the amount and support the DS's. Especially as I think we will be hearing from other charities along the same lines.

However, I feel guilty. AIBU to say no?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Malie · 24/08/2022 19:30

It’s great you give to charity. But we can’t support everyone. But if everyone did a little it would add up

RancidOldHag · 24/08/2022 19:23

YANBU

With the proviso that as we're about to face higher inflation, you increase the amount periodically, say once a year, so that its value isn't eroded

Redqueenheart · 24/08/2022 19:19

''@Cheeselog
^Assuming you live in the U.K. YABU to support a local charity when you could change or even save someone’s life in a developing country with that money www.givewell.org/giving101''^

I think your logic is bizarre.

It is perfectly fine to support local, UK-based projects and they save lives too.

There are many UK health and disability charities that do fantastic work to improve the lives of adults and children in this country and fund medical research that saves people's lives.

Not to mention UK charities that save lives by providing drug and alcohol rehab or supporting victims of domestic violence or by providing mental health support to those who are self-harming and/or thinking of ending their lives.

Or by working to prevent the refugees who risk their lives crossing the Channel from drowning.

Are you suggesting only charities that work overseas/in the developing world save lives? I am sorry but that's nonsense...

People should choose whatever cause they feel close too and inspired by.

NovaDeltas · 24/08/2022 19:07

You do realise it was just a generic spam email and they don't know your finances or your plans with your sons, right? You realise it's not specifically tailored to you...

Redqueenheart · 24/08/2022 19:05

''@OlderParents ·
as an ex professional charity fundraiser, I have thoughts on the sector. I support charities still, but boy do I look at their published accounts to check who is actually using the money I donate wisely. The final straw for me leaving the sector was a charity that funded 100% of it's charitable work from interest on a huge pot of wealth, but fundraised in order to pay for.... the wages of office staff like me. I was a fundraiser: I was literally asking people to pay for my salary. No thanks.''

Yes, I worked as a Fundraising Manager. I remember asking a small health charity to list the projects/work they wanted me to fundraise for. I was shocked to see that most of the money they wanted me to find would go to pay the CEO and Finance director salaries. Needless to say I did not stay long in that role. Of course staff needs to be paid but surely the majority of the money needs to be spent on actual services/support/campaigns.

As a Comms Director for another charity I was asked to authorise spending over a £1500 for a vanity video that would be used only once at the charity's AGM so that the CEO could show-off what he had achieved in front of the board of trustees. Same charity also bought each of the trustees an I-pad. All of that from money that was donated to actually help support vulnerable people...

I lost a lot of respect for the sector in my years of working for various organisations.

It is a good suggestions to look at their account and also support charities that have visible, tangible services: animal shelters, homeless shelters, soup kitchens, food banks rather than those who only do campaigning/lobbying or just run trendy, vanity projects that very few people actually benefit from.

DoAllMyOwnStunts · 24/08/2022 18:38

entropynow · 23/08/2022 23:36

The difficulty with this approach is that saving lives is not the only measure of effectiveness.
Improving lives through e.g. development and education is at least as important.

Oh absolutely.

One of their most-recommended charities is one that prevents blindness. Another does repair operations following childbirth injuries.
You can filter by "save a life" or "improve health" or whatever you want to do or donate to their "top 10" charities and they share it out.

Cheeselog · 23/08/2022 23:54

entropynow · 23/08/2022 23:36

The difficulty with this approach is that saving lives is not the only measure of effectiveness.
Improving lives through e.g. development and education is at least as important.

Er, pretty hard to improve someone’s life if they’re dead is it not?

But the measure they use is QALY - quality adjusted life years - rather than just additional life years, anyway.

Cheeselog · 23/08/2022 23:52

Assuming you live in the U.K. YABU to support a local charity when you could change or even save someone’s life in a developing country with that money www.givewell.org/giving101
But YANBU to refuse to increase your donation beyond what you are comfortable with, of course.

OlderParents · 23/08/2022 23:46

as an ex professional charity fundraiser, I have thoughts on the sector. I support charities still, but boy do I look at their published accounts to check who is actually using the money I donate wisely. The final straw for me leaving the sector was a charity that funded 100% of it's charitable work from interest on a huge pot of wealth, but fundraised in order to pay for.... the wages of office staff like me. I was a fundraiser: I was literally asking people to pay for my salary. No thanks.

Ziggyisthebestdogintheworld · 23/08/2022 23:46

My dad is one of those people who isn’t bothered about presents for either his birthday or Christmas
anyway,I spotted an advert for oxfam-you could pick something for a 3rd world country to make lives a bit better for the people living there
we bought him a toilet,a goat,a few mango trees and a supply of condoms-with the idea we’d buy other bits the following year
well that idea went to pot when oxfam rang him at least 5/6 times a week,(sometimes 2/3 times a day) wrote to him-2/3 letters a day and really laid it on thick and tried to guilt him into spending more money than he has
my mother had to go to the top to get them to stop-it took some doing,and they where really snotty with her for daring ‘not to care’
weve all vowed never to A-do it again (we would have done this twice a year for the rest of his life) and B-we never shop in their shops/online
shame really-though their own greed,they lost out

Daisywithastory · 23/08/2022 23:36

On the flip side to what a lot of people are saying here, I’m on a charity fundraisers’ Facebook group and someone posted the other day about sending an email saying the opposite, looking for advice on wording I think or to see if other charities were doing the same. But it was to email supporters in the context of the cost of living going up so much to see if anyone wanted to adjust their monthly donation downwards.

entropynow · 23/08/2022 23:36

DoAllMyOwnStunts · 23/08/2022 20:35

Someone on here very usefully told me about this book/website/movement which tells you which charities are legit and cost-effective:

www.thelifeyoucansave.org/about/the-life-you-can-save-uk/

The difficulty with this approach is that saving lives is not the only measure of effectiveness.
Improving lives through e.g. development and education is at least as important.

Bumply · 23/08/2022 23:16

I give to several charities.
When asked to increase a donation or donate to a new charity I ask them which charity they think I should cut to allow that.
It usually shuts them up.

Redqueenheart · 23/08/2022 22:12

I have worked for charities for 20 years and many do brilliant work.

But there are a lot of issues for fundraising too.

I worked for charities where a lot of the money raised went into paying the CEO and a couple of directors a fat salary rather than supporting the people they were supposed to help.

I hate ''chuggers'' and the way some charities try to guilt-trip people into donating. Sometimes charities also use third parties rather than in-house staff to fundraise and these external agencies can be quite bad when dealing with people. Really pushy and rude.

I think there is more pressure than ever on charities though as they pick up a lot of the slack when it comes to supporting vulnerable and disadvantaged people at the moment as government keeps cutting services and does nothing to help the poorest. So some are worth supporting but you should never be pressured in giving.

Also charities can raise money from other sources: Trusts and Foundations, corporate partners and so on. it is not only the public that can support them.

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/08/2022 21:31

Lots of ignorant posts about charities.

The vast majority of charities are doing amazing work. They do it on a shoe string. They do it with staff who are paid 10% than they would be if working in the public or private sector.

Charities save lives every day, they protect children from harm, they help women escaping domestic abuse, they are trying to prevent horrible diseases and supporting those who have them. They enrich our lives by running sports clubs, Scouts, museums. They are trying to save the planet and protect it from future generations. They run food banks, they give free legal advice, they run shelters for homeless people.

This country, and others would be well and truly fecked without charities.

Of course OP if you do not need to donate any more and its perfectly reasonable to decline the request.

Wonnle · 23/08/2022 21:23

That's Cancer Research UK not BHF by the way , my mistake .

Wonnle · 23/08/2022 21:22

Danielle9891 · 23/08/2022 18:43

Sorry but I would just stop the donations if they ask again. It always seems to be these big charities that constantly ask for money while their CEOs or that get millions. I don't mind donating to local small charities where I know where the money is going but I wouldn't donate if the asked for it.

Same here , the CEO of BHF get's nearly 250k salary per annum by the way !

Grumpusaurus · 23/08/2022 21:11

Personally, I think that is quite outrageous by the charity and I would cancel any further donations.

DoAllMyOwnStunts · 23/08/2022 20:35

Someone on here very usefully told me about this book/website/movement which tells you which charities are legit and cost-effective:

www.thelifeyoucansave.org/about/the-life-you-can-save-uk/

myusernamewastakenbyme · 23/08/2022 19:07

My 23 year old son who has only just graduated and got a job was staying with me a few weeks ago....I was at work and he answered a knock at the door...he was persuaded to give his bank details and sign up to a direct debit...I'm annoyed as hes only just started working and has student debts and an overdraft to pay off...I know its his own fault but I also know my son and I knpw he would have struggled to say no at the door.

Irridescantshimmmer · 23/08/2022 18:50

You are right to put the needs of your family first.

Don't go feeling guilty, you already give to charity anyway I think your conscience should be chrystal clear.

Danielle9891 · 23/08/2022 18:43

Sorry but I would just stop the donations if they ask again. It always seems to be these big charities that constantly ask for money while their CEOs or that get millions. I don't mind donating to local small charities where I know where the money is going but I wouldn't donate if the asked for it.

PlanetNormal · 23/08/2022 18:41

YANBU.

If a charity I was supporting tried that with me, I would cancel my payments completely and write to the head person at the charity explaining exactly why I was no longer prepared to support the cheeky fuckers.

trèschaud · 23/08/2022 18:37

itsnotdeep · 23/08/2022 14:47

The law has changed quite a bit since Olive Cooke fyi.

OP, it's not unreasonable to say no to charities.

To the other PP, charities depend on donations to survive and to carry out their (mostly) really good work. They aren't money grabbing. Many are doing the work that the govt or the NHS or other public services should be doing. If they don't ask for money, no one donates to them. You can just ignore any asks or opt out of future contact. If they continue to contact you then, you can contact the ICO.

There are too many of them though, all with directors on very good salaries.

Do we really need as many cancer charities as we have, for example? Why not have fewer and bring down the admin costs?

I had to threaten to call the police last week because two doorstep chuggers were pressurising my neighbour who has dementia.

NanaNelly · 23/08/2022 18:28

54321abcd · 23/08/2022 12:01

Anyone remember this story about 92 year old Olive?
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3083859/Shame-charities-drove-Olive-death-Organisations-exploited-pensioner-s-kind-heart-admit-sending-begging-letters.html

When I wound up my father's estate I found he had been 'guilted' into multiple charitable donations and was in receipt of copious begging letters from them every month ....and then there are the manipulative adverts on the tv as well.
The charity sector has lost its way.

Yes. My sister in law is terminally I’ll and told us recently that a charity had offered to help her write her will. We had to explain that although they said she didn’t have to leave them anything she’d probably find it very difficult not to. The whole thing makes me feel quite sick.