Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!

332 replies

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 11:22

My late DF was a history buff and after he died we gave a lot of his books to charity but kept a few.

Among them was an English translation of Mein Kampf. It’s a first edition from 1939.

I held on to it as a historic artefact but would now like to move it on.

I can’t sell it on Amazon or eBay as it’s banned.

So the question is: do I bin it? (YABU)
Do I donate it to a library or something? (YANBU) Where?!

OP posts:
CPL593H · 23/08/2022 14:41

scatterolight · 23/08/2022 13:43

Not had time to read the thread but just Google and you'll find lots of professional auctions sell these. And they fetch a big price. It could be worth 10s of thousands. One example: www.google.com/amp/s/www.thelondoneconomic.com/must-reads/rarest-ever-signed-copy-of-adolf-hitlers-autobiography-mein-kampf-is-up-at-auction-119000/amp/

DO NOT BIN IT OR DONATE. Your dad would have wanted you to have that money.

I'm not an expert and I'm not saying the OPs copy won't have monetary value, but it won't be anything like the same as a very early autograph copy such as that.

My university library certainly had copies in both English and German, many years ago. I would see if you can donate, because as others have said some people buying an early edition may well see it as a "trophy" to go with other Nazi artefacts, because the actual text is very easily obtainable.

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 14:39

iwishihadaname · 23/08/2022 14:37

try the Bodleian in Oxford

Wouldn't they already have a copy?

iwishihadaname · 23/08/2022 14:37

try the Bodleian in Oxford

SparklyLeprechaun · 23/08/2022 14:36

I doubt a museum would be interested, even the first edition print was in the tens of thousands of copies, there will be loads more floating around. A second hand book dealer might take it off your hands.

mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 14:35

balalake · 23/08/2022 14:30

I suggest binning it. Burning without an audience would be preferable but I understand with the lack of rain would not want a possible fire risk.

Amazon has got something right by refusing to sell it.

Why would you want to bin an important piece of history?

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 14:34

BloodAndFire · 23/08/2022 13:48

'And if he was?'

It just slightly blows my mind (as someone whose entire extended family were murdered by the Nazis) that people can be so unashamedly proud of that history.

"And if he was" is hardly me saying I am unashamedly proud of my DP's family two generations ago possibly being Nazi party members Shock . If they were, they were hardly unique. People really need to try and understand the prevailing conditions in interwar Germany, and what motivated those living there to do what they did, to join in with what they joined in with.

(As an aside, British people have always seemed rather proud that we have never had a dictator here in modern times, that we didn't have the climate of terror which drove people to betray their neighbours and join in with things they shouldn't have joined in with. I'd say that the past couple of years have shown that this potential has always been bubbling away under the surface, actually)

People these days surely can acknowledge what their ancestors did without feeling they need to apologise for it all the time. Confronting their history of the first half of the 20th century is something Germany has done much better than Japan, for example.

Mein Kampf is an important book, just the same as Das Kapital is an important book, which can also be implicated in the deaths of millions of people.

balalake · 23/08/2022 14:30

I suggest binning it. Burning without an audience would be preferable but I understand with the lack of rain would not want a possible fire risk.

Amazon has got something right by refusing to sell it.

DownNative · 23/08/2022 14:30

Interesting.

"But on Amazon’s subsidiary AbeBooks, which operates largely independently, hundreds of new and used copies of “Mein Kampf” are available."

www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/technology/amazon-hitler-mein-kampf.html#amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&aoh=16612610170817&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&ampshare=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2F2020%2F03%2F17%2Ftechnology%2Famazon-hitler-mein-kampf.html

Abebooks does sell a leather book (cover?) for Mein Kampf.

www.abebooks.co.uk/Kampe-1812-Leather-Bound-Hitler-Adolf/30592991903/bd

It appears Amazon is inconsistent there.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!
Flubber88 · 23/08/2022 14:24

thirstyformore · 23/08/2022 11:32

My family has a huge swazstika flag which my late grandad took off a church in cologne in WW2. I think it's in my mum's loft at the moment. I don't think these sorts of things should be destroyed. I'd donate the book to a museum.

Agree with above

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 14:22

mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 14:20

Exactly.

It's ironic that so many people support destroying a book written by a man who supported destroying books.

I kind of thought the world had enough copies but yes see the argument for keeping it a bit more now

DownNative · 23/08/2022 14:22

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 14:17

@DownNative I note that in that last listing, the title has been misspelled, presumably to get round the rules.

Good spot! Didn't notice that though I would assume Ebay have accounted for misspellings. I know when I helped run a forum years ago that's what we did. You just pop them in the algorithm and it'll automatically deal with it for you.

SwedeCarrotLime · 23/08/2022 14:21

You'd think that if eBay and Amazon were serious about stopping the sale of the text on their platforms they might think to incorporate the key words 'Adolf' and 'Hitler' in their automatic screening of listings.

mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 14:20

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/08/2022 14:12

The World needs original hard copies - because what happens when the official originals get burned and the digital ones get edited otherwise?

You'd get people falsifying excerpts and without a large number of first editions knocking round, there's no way of showing 'no, the writer didn't say that, he said...'

It's preserving evidence. Evidence of a great evil, so that it cannot be misrepresented, falsified or erased in the event of similar threats to humanity.

Exactly.

It's ironic that so many people support destroying a book written by a man who supported destroying books.

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 14:19

DownNative · 23/08/2022 14:18

Odd because I don't think this one is critically annotated. It's brand new in original shrink wrap though.

It's Hitler's own words in that one.

Yes they've not used the title of the book to get round it. Sneaky.

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 14:18

I'd report those ebay listings. They've tried to be sneaky and use phrases other than the actual title.

Anyway. This has been a really interesting discussion, I had just thought of getting rid of it not being an issue but I am slowly seeing the arguement to physical copies needing to be kept.

DownNative · 23/08/2022 14:18

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 14:13

This was the email I got from Ebay when I tried to list it:
"You listed the book Mein Kampf, but it is not a critically annotated edition. eBay only allows critically annotated versions of Mein Kampf to be listed on the site. While we appreciate that you chose to utilize our site, we must ask that you please not relist in this case."

And this from Amazon:
"After reviewing your title again, we confirmed that it is in violation of our content guidelines and we will not be offering this title for sale on Amazon.
We reserve the right to determine whether content provides a poor customer experience and remove that content from sale.
Thanks for your understanding.
Best regards,
Amazon"

Odd because I don't think this one is critically annotated. It's brand new in original shrink wrap though.

It's Hitler's own words in that one.

Elmore · 23/08/2022 14:18

BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 13:19

Bin it. People who want to read it from a historian POV can do so by going through the right channels. You sell it or give it away it will most likely fall into a Neo-Nazi’s hands for the purpose of idolatry - Nazism is not in the past. It is not just ‘history’.
Presumably if Osama Bin Laden had written a memoir with his ‘profound’ ideas on women’s rights and what to do about people who don’t follow Islam we wouldn’t be selling that willy nilly. It’s irresponsible.

People should only be allowed to access information through “the right channels”? The spirit of fascism is alive and well in the modern liberal

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 14:17

@DownNative I note that in that last listing, the title has been misspelled, presumably to get round the rules.

OP posts:
SwedeCarrotLime · 23/08/2022 14:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

She doesn't even say she was sad, @BloodAndFire! She says she wishes she could have talked to him about his history.

DownNative · 23/08/2022 14:15

Further examples being sold on eBay. Some are translations of Hitler's original German language edition. One has an introduction by a British writer and is quite thick.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!
What to do with Mein Kampf?!
What to do with Mein Kampf?!
BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 14:15

Awww, it's sweet that you're all reuniting on this thread to reminisce about charming gifts of Mein Kampf to newborn babies, and heartwarming stories of family history. I really am hiding this thread now, it's a bit fucking much tbh. It's amazing how quickly people stopped even pretending to give a shit. It's not even out of living memory yet

There was another Hitler thread not that long ago which also went in a weird direction and had what I think were quite dodgy comments. Not sinister - I don’t think there are many neo-nazi mumsnetters lurking around - but there does seem to be a lot of genuine ignorance and naïvety around Nazism and it’s affects even today, and the influence Hitler’s rhetoric has even today. People seem to feel very distanced from it, or try and look at it from a ‘historical’ and purely objective point of view, as with other historical events, but it’s not really the past the same way as for example the English Civil War. This is why especially people who are German or with German heritage get very uncomfortable when people discuss ‘understanding Hitler’s motives’ or categorising a first edition of dangerous rhetoric as a ‘historical artefact’. It’s still raw and still feels risky - the way you discuss Hitler and the Nazis needs to be done responsibly and thoughtfully. You can’t talk about Hitler and the Nazis in the same way you discuss Henry VIII beheading his wives 500 years ago, like it’s history dead and buried. It isn’t.

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 14:13

This was the email I got from Ebay when I tried to list it:
"You listed the book Mein Kampf, but it is not a critically annotated edition. eBay only allows critically annotated versions of Mein Kampf to be listed on the site. While we appreciate that you chose to utilize our site, we must ask that you please not relist in this case."

And this from Amazon:
"After reviewing your title again, we confirmed that it is in violation of our content guidelines and we will not be offering this title for sale on Amazon.
We reserve the right to determine whether content provides a poor customer experience and remove that content from sale.
Thanks for your understanding.
Best regards,
Amazon"

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 14:13

DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 12:53

because there are massive numbers of creepy nazi fetishing collectors out there? Plus just actual fascists. The far right never went away

I mean, I know that - but OP will sell it and the money can go to an anti-Nazi cause somewhere. People who want to get hold of this can just buy it online - they don't need to go out of their way to search out a first edition.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 23/08/2022 14:13

TheBikiniExpert · 23/08/2022 14:07

It's a bit fucking sick of you to say how sad it was that your grandfather died early, in this context, tbh. I think I need to leave this thread.
😮Wow. That's really nasty.

I've reported it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/08/2022 14:12

BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 13:38

I am astonished by the people saying destroy it / burn it, do they really not realise the irony of taking a position that is identical to that of the Nazis on writings they disapproved of?

Its not comparable. Destroying or binning a book that is freely available to read because there are plenty of copies preserved already, along with being digitally immortalised, is not censorship. No one here has said all copies should be burned in a big Nazi style book bonfire.
But if you happen to find one now, in your attic, there really is no reasonable reason to keep it, or give it away or sell it when it has its risks. These books already exist in relevant museums, and are available in libraries.They are not that rare or remotely in danger of being erased from history.
I think surely we can agree that the world only needs a certain amount of actual hard copies of ‘Mein Kampf’.

The World needs original hard copies - because what happens when the official originals get burned and the digital ones get edited otherwise?

You'd get people falsifying excerpts and without a large number of first editions knocking round, there's no way of showing 'no, the writer didn't say that, he said...'

It's preserving evidence. Evidence of a great evil, so that it cannot be misrepresented, falsified or erased in the event of similar threats to humanity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread