Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!

332 replies

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 11:22

My late DF was a history buff and after he died we gave a lot of his books to charity but kept a few.

Among them was an English translation of Mein Kampf. It’s a first edition from 1939.

I held on to it as a historic artefact but would now like to move it on.

I can’t sell it on Amazon or eBay as it’s banned.

So the question is: do I bin it? (YABU)
Do I donate it to a library or something? (YANBU) Where?!

OP posts:
DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 15:29

BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 15:25

Well I’m glad you just contributed @DrowsyDragon @carefullycourageous @IAmAWomanNotACis I was beginning to think I was going a bit loopy there, reading all these bizarre comments recommending ways to sell and profit off a core Nazi text and acting as though every old copy of Mein Kampf was a sacred artefact and to throw it in the bin like an old Anne Rice novel would be some kind of sacrilege or crime against historical enquiry 😂

I'm going to guess we might be the few people who actually currently work in Uni Libraries/Antiquarian Books/ Museums/Archives. Not everything is an artefact and can or should be preserved and as for making money off Nazi memorabilia, blech. I am instinctively suspicious of private collectors of Nazi stuff. Plenty is in museums for the historical record, and it certainly doesn't stop deniers and, as I have said, unless there is a unique feature, this is just a copy of an old bad book. And as a UK book, there's almost certainly already the legal deposit copy in the BL or one of the other five legal deposit/copyright libraries.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 23/08/2022 15:26

It's interesting the concept that because the OP has ended up with a physical copy of a highly controversial book they don't want, they are unable to dispose of it in case they are then compared to Nazis.
I liked the compost bin idea - at the end of the day your copy is just paper and glue. Let it go. The book is out there, you're not personally erasing history by disposing of something you don't want, nor wish to pass on.
Incidentally for most of my life, I believed I my unknown grandfather was a Nazi.
It certainly puts an interesting slant on discussions around immigration, British values and heritage.
(As it turns out I have Irish heritage on my DF's side, which still puts an interesting slant)

BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 15:25

Well I’m glad you just contributed @DrowsyDragon @carefullycourageous @IAmAWomanNotACis I was beginning to think I was going a bit loopy there, reading all these bizarre comments recommending ways to sell and profit off a core Nazi text and acting as though every old copy of Mein Kampf was a sacred artefact and to throw it in the bin like an old Anne Rice novel would be some kind of sacrilege or crime against historical enquiry 😂

pinheadlarry · 23/08/2022 15:21

Sell it, make some money

DisforDarkChocolate · 23/08/2022 15:21

Skatewing · 23/08/2022 11:40

I will buy it from you.
I'm a collector of controversial books

Sorry for being nosey but what books do you own?

CulturePigeon · 23/08/2022 15:16

Donate to Imperial War Museum or a university history department.

I wouldn't advise selling to a personal collector...I suspect there are some very dodgy individuals out there who collect this stuff.

I worked at the IWM and we were very, very careful about who had access to this kind of thing - only bona fide students and researchers. While they need to be in museums and archives, I would be very worried about anyone who wanted to own such a thing. I always think: these things have been in the presence of evil...and wouldn't want it in my home.

Hawkins001 · 23/08/2022 15:15

It's puzzling, we ban books that advocate violence ect, yet freely sell various other e.g. Music album's that showcase or glamourise violence ect.

Hawkins001 · 23/08/2022 15:14

NewspaperTaxis · 23/08/2022 12:07

Can't believe Hitler's been cancelled.

It could be argued that this could contribute to the repeat of history, though rewriting and forgetting the past.

LaFemmeNicola · 23/08/2022 15:11

BloodAndFire · 23/08/2022 13:50

Then read one of the many, many books written by actual historians and scholars not the incoherent manic ramblings of a racist cunt.

You don’t seem to understand that you don’t get to tell other people what to read.

Have you actually read the book? If not, you should. It’s appallingly written, but it tells you much about the mindset that caused so many millions of deaths.

There is nothing noble about what you are trying to do here.

carefullycourageous · 23/08/2022 15:11

Northernparent68 · 23/08/2022 15:03

Offer it to a university

They will have loads of copies already!

DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 15:10

Freedomfighters · 23/08/2022 14:43

Hitler liked destroying books he didn't agree with as well.

How about you just choose not to read it rather than advocate destroying historical records that other people may well be interested in learning more about.

It's not the historical record for godsake. It's a copy of a book that a quick search shows over a hundred unis in this country alone have copies of in English and German. No one is going to forget the existence of Medin Kampf if the OP doesn't find somewhere to donate it to and quite rightly decides not to make money by selling a fascist item to an unknown buyer.

carefullycourageous · 23/08/2022 15:10

Comefromaway · 23/08/2022 11:31

It's banned???? Really?

Presumably selling it is banned because selling Nazi memorabilia is extremely problematic - and consequently banned in some otherwise liberal countries - because some people are collectors/traders because they genuinely celebrate Nazism.

IAmAWomanNotACis · 23/08/2022 15:07

It's not a rare book. Relevant museums will all have copies already, I honestly wouldn't bother IWM or anybody else with the offer. They likely get 100s of offers a year of it.

I understand the history of book and ideas destruction associated with him and his ideas, but objections don't quite track IMO. He wanted there to be no way other than his; destroying an old book which advocates ideas that are unilaterally considered bad, knowing that there are copies in the relevant places for study doesn't have the same energy and impact.

The fact is that millions of books get pulped and go to landfill because they're just not wanted any more. You don't have to give this one any more headspace than that; it's an old book, it's not rare, nobody wants this particular copy, so out for recycling it goes.

DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 15:07

You guys realise destroying one copy of a book doesn't 'erase it'. There are literally thousands of that book floating around. It's not Hitler's original manuscript or annotated by Goebbels. The fact that is old doesn't make it 'an historical artefact'. I binned a paperback Anne Rice the other day because I couldn't repair it, have I destroyed Anne RICE?! Mein Kampf is widely available, unless this copy has something more unique than being old, annotations by a fascist, signed, whatever, you can probably happily dispose of it and thus not run the risk of profitting off people with a hard on for Hitler.- The Uni will likely have it's own copy and in unlikely to want this unless it specialises in the area.

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 15:05

Grissii · 23/08/2022 15:02

If you’re willing to sell it, I’ll buy it

Why? Just curious what you would do with it.

Northernparent68 · 23/08/2022 15:03

Offer it to a university

Grissii · 23/08/2022 15:02

If you’re willing to sell it, I’ll buy it

SwedeCarrotLime · 23/08/2022 15:00

entropynow · 23/08/2022 14:57

Incidentally OP and everyone talking about how this is a first edition: Mein Kampf was first published in 1925 so whatever edition this is may not be particularly rare.

The 1939 edition is the first unexpurgated translation in English.

SparklyLeprechaun · 23/08/2022 14:59

entropynow · 23/08/2022 14:57

Incidentally OP and everyone talking about how this is a first edition: Mein Kampf was first published in 1925 so whatever edition this is may not be particularly rare.

It's a first UK edition, obviously. There are earlier US editions in English.

entropynow · 23/08/2022 14:57

Incidentally OP and everyone talking about how this is a first edition: Mein Kampf was first published in 1925 so whatever edition this is may not be particularly rare.

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 23/08/2022 14:52

This seems like a grim question but is it signed? A first ed in English is likely worth around £200-£1000 depending on the condition, a signed copy is worth £20k+ and there's tons of them floating about although none in english I don't think. I can well understand not wanting to make a profit from it, that wouldn't sit right with me either.

Personally, I would take it to your local antique shop as a first port of call who will be able to put you in touch either with a rare book dealer or an auction house. Personally (because I can afford to), I would then donate the proceeds to either a veterans charity, and LGBT hostel, a charity that help asylum seekers, a charity that helps the disabled or of course, a Jewish charitable organisation. However, Hitler would have been just as appalled to think of the proceeds from his book going to help you and your family given I'm assuming you're British - so if you do need to keep the money, you shouldn't be made to feel guilty about that by strangers on the internet.

We've got to be more grown up about awful historical objects as your sensibilities evolve. It's a brilliant, brilliant thing that the world is becoming more tolerant and inclusive, but that inclusivity came at a very high price. That price was the lives and experiences of those who came before us and whos suffering opened our eyes to how wrong our thinking was. Erasing that history then suggests that the victims shouldnt be remembered either.

Objects like this one should be treated as curiosities - so alien to our thinking and way of life now that they're traded and bought and sold with a value gleened from how juxtaposed they are to our way of life now. For example, at our local garden centre there's an antique shop that has a man catcher which was used in 17th century Louisiana to punish slaves who tried to escape plantations.. it's a huge wooden pole with a metal collar on the end. This is in rural staffordshire. There's a confederate flag and a painting of 'happy' slaves working in fields in the same part of the shop and the owner will happily come and tell you all about how he bought the collection from a local historian who'd had them from a bristolian colleague who'd specialised in the history of enslaved people and the British empire. He also used to use it to give talks on the history of Bristol and its links to slavery.

I'd like to think Hitler would be spitting feathers if he knew his books were so rare and forgotten that we're finding them in attics and it's opening discussions on what a bloody nutcase he was. It's very unlikely to fall into the hands of someone who wants to use it as inspiration - those people have access to it online already. Much more likely it's going to go to someone like me with a ridiculous collection of banned/ controversial/ naughty books and it will rarely be opened again. I have a 1955 copy of Lolita, it doesnt mean I'm in to 12 year olds..

entropynow · 23/08/2022 14:49

Sellorkeep · 23/08/2022 12:07

Interesting hobby!

Indeed. @Skatewing
Care to share your list?

entropynow · 23/08/2022 14:44

LickYouLikeACrispPacket · 23/08/2022 11:24

Burn it.

You don't do irony, do you?

Freedomfighters · 23/08/2022 14:43

balalake · 23/08/2022 14:30

I suggest binning it. Burning without an audience would be preferable but I understand with the lack of rain would not want a possible fire risk.

Amazon has got something right by refusing to sell it.

Hitler liked destroying books he didn't agree with as well.

How about you just choose not to read it rather than advocate destroying historical records that other people may well be interested in learning more about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread