Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!

332 replies

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 11:22

My late DF was a history buff and after he died we gave a lot of his books to charity but kept a few.

Among them was an English translation of Mein Kampf. It’s a first edition from 1939.

I held on to it as a historic artefact but would now like to move it on.

I can’t sell it on Amazon or eBay as it’s banned.

So the question is: do I bin it? (YABU)
Do I donate it to a library or something? (YANBU) Where?!

OP posts:
IKillHousePlants · 23/08/2022 16:34

A quick Google shows 1939 1st ed English translations sell at auction for about £150 if that helps you decide

carefullycourageous · 23/08/2022 16:30

People don't like burning/pulping/shredding/recycling books, but I think it is fine, there is burning books because you want to stop people accessing books and the words in them, and there is burning books because it is a convenient way to dispose of a surplus/unwanted book.

Although recycling is probably what I would do.

BeanieTeen · 23/08/2022 16:20

Well, that's another point isn't it, not selling this book isn't saving someone from being exposed to it. It is already freely available. No point then in destroying it.

Or, by that same argument, no point in keeping it either.

It’s not about exposure to the actual text. You could say the same about selling an original Nazi flag - everyone knows what a swastika looks like, and a Neo-Nazi may well already have stitched their own so what harm is there in selling one of those? What difference does it make?
A great deal of difference. I wouldn’t underestimate the pride and satisfaction a Nazi-Sympathiser can get from owning these sorts of things. Reading Mein Kampf on your kindle and having a generic copy on the shelf is not as powerful as having a first edition copy in pride of place, especially if it adds to your already extensive memorabilia collection. Things like these help to further internalise and cement and spread dangerous ideals.
It’s not dissimilar to religions having sacred objects. Crosses and crucifixes have sincere meanings to people, they cling on to them when they are dying. You could even compare to some super fan listening to their favourite band on iTunes then buying a signed vinyl record. It might actually be broken - but it’s precious to them nonetheless. And holding it and looking at it may actually bring out more obsessive emotions than listening to the songs.
Symbolism is powerful. Objects can be very emotive. To think that owning a first edition copy of Mein Kampf makes no difference when it’s freely available to read anyway is I think dangerously naive. The OP really should not try and sell it. It’s irresponsible.

AMindNeedsBooks · 23/08/2022 16:11

Sorry, replied too quickly.

*Or didn't start a world war.

HIS mindset is important to study because look what he managed to 'achieve' with it? Historians look at events they weren't involved in, you will always see it clearer from the primary source. I don't get why that is hard to understand.

SammyScrounge · 23/08/2022 16:04

CulturePigeon · 23/08/2022 15:16

Donate to Imperial War Museum or a university history department.

I wouldn't advise selling to a personal collector...I suspect there are some very dodgy individuals out there who collect this stuff.

I worked at the IWM and we were very, very careful about who had access to this kind of thing - only bona fide students and researchers. While they need to be in museums and archives, I would be very worried about anyone who wanted to own such a thing. I always think: these things have been in the presence of evil...and wouldn't want it in my home.

Sorry, but that is a silly response, especially from someone who worked at the IWM. All things Nazi should be freely studied to stymie the Holocaust deniers. Mein Kampf is turgid but you can see the direction Hitler's mind was taking among the daft rants and diatribes.
Hiding the book away gives it the status of a forbidden treasure, something to be savoured at secret meetings.
On public display, this book would be seen for what it is - boring and mad and nothing but drivel.

AMindNeedsBooks · 23/08/2022 16:04

BloodAndFire · 23/08/2022 13:50

Then read one of the many, many books written by actual historians and scholars not the incoherent manic ramblings of a racist cunt.

The whole point is reading what Hitler wrote though, his mindset. Not historians who didn't write the book.

Fingeronthebutton · 23/08/2022 16:01

It is only banned in Germany.

Ragwort · 23/08/2022 15:59

I can't imagine which university or museum would actually want it? If they want a copy for historical reasons there are more than likely to have one already.

I work in a charity shop and it is very clearly listed as something we are not allowed to sell.

Latenightreader · 23/08/2022 15:58

Museum person here. Museums (properly accredited ones) have strict acquisition policies which list what they are and aren’t allowed to collect. They aren’t usually allowed to duplicate items in the collection (there are exceptions), the condition and care needed are taken into account, and they also have to fit the museum’s remit which may be geographical, linked to a particular period etc. Most museums need to put new acquisitions to a board of trustees or a committee of some sort, which can take some time, and yes, we regularly need to reject things for various reasons. If a museum can’t take something, they may be able to suggest somewhere else that can, and the Museums Association has a page where items are offered to other museums.

Blueblell · 23/08/2022 15:57

Keep it! Definitely don’t burn it as some suggested.

SenoritaNaturista · 23/08/2022 15:52

Book auctioneers -
www.dominicwinter.co.uk/

carefullycourageous · 23/08/2022 15:44

I think I would burn it or recycle it just because I wouldn't know what to do with it and it is not a rare book, it is a well-known and widely available book, that I wouldn't want to keep and I wouldn't feel comfortable advertising to sell.

Raquelos · 23/08/2022 15:44

Joystir59 · 23/08/2022 15:37

I'd like to read it. I'm didn't realise it was banned.

It isn't banned, you can buy it on AMazon!!

If you want to read it you should, there is nothing more likely to make you realise the mediocrity of Hitler as a thinker. It is just a badly written rant.

earsup · 23/08/2022 15:44

probably many of those copies around...if valuable...sell it...donate some money and spend rest on a night out....we found some interesting nazi stamps and coins and a hitler youth vest while clearing out late gm house...she used to run a hotel and had many american and polish and czech soldiers stay....they gave the bits to her....we sold the lot on ebay as allowed then....donated some money to IWM and had a good night out.

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 15:41

The burn-it crowd is just virtue signaling their disapproval of the Nazis as though that isn't the default position of everyone on this thread. Good grief someone up thread is calling people who disagree Nazi sympathisers ffs. Really the lack of nuance in that kind of thinking is apparent to everyone except them.

This is exactly it! Thank you for articulating what I couldn't @Raquelos

mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 15:40

Joystir59 · 23/08/2022 15:37

I'd like to read it. I'm didn't realise it was banned.

It's not banned.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/08/2022 15:39

DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 15:07

You guys realise destroying one copy of a book doesn't 'erase it'. There are literally thousands of that book floating around. It's not Hitler's original manuscript or annotated by Goebbels. The fact that is old doesn't make it 'an historical artefact'. I binned a paperback Anne Rice the other day because I couldn't repair it, have I destroyed Anne RICE?! Mein Kampf is widely available, unless this copy has something more unique than being old, annotations by a fascist, signed, whatever, you can probably happily dispose of it and thus not run the risk of profitting off people with a hard on for Hitler.- The Uni will likely have it's own copy and in unlikely to want this unless it specialises in the area.

What if there's an order from the wrong sort of government that all universities and museums must destroy their copies?
What reference is there then if they then start misrepresenting the text?

It's not unheard in history for texts to be 'standardised' so that they represent what discourse those in power wish to set. And for that to lead to human rights abuses and persecution. The Bible is one of those texts, not just in the books included, but the wording and translations. People both in favour of Christianity in its various forms and against it all have misused it throughout history in that way; it's absolutely possible for a malevolent authority to come into power and seek to restrict access and then rewrite the thing to suit their purposes, along the lines of 'he said he wanted a homeland for those that didn't share the same values, there's no way that meant systematic murder of millions, as extermination isn't mentioned anywhere in our official copy'.

All you need is a populist candidate in difficult times where, for example, their father's involvement with some sort of Klan is glossed over and their actual membership of or sympathy with even more vile organisations is kept quiet.

Outlyingtrout · 23/08/2022 15:38

I would try and donate to a museum or educational facility. An organisation that will be responsible in owning it and passing it on if the need arises. I wouldn’t donate or sell to a private collector in case I inadvertently gave it to an actual Nazi who collects memorabilia, rather than a history buff. I suspect they tend to disguise their real reasons for wanting this stuff when buying it.

Failing that, I’d probably compost it.

Joystir59 · 23/08/2022 15:37

I'd like to read it. I'm didn't realise it was banned.

Raquelos · 23/08/2022 15:35

chillipenguin · 23/08/2022 13:54

If people want to read it they can read it. It doesn't have to be this edition. It's already preserved for history.

Well, that's another point isn't it, not selling this book isn't saving someone from being exposed to it. It is already freely available. No point then in destroying it.

The burn-it crowd is just virtue signaling their disapproval of the Nazis as though that isn't the default position of everyone on this thread. Good grief someone up thread is calling people who disagree Nazi sympathisers ffs. Really the lack of nuance in that kind of thinking is apparent to everyone except them.

DrowsyDragon · 23/08/2022 15:33

Ok, I am not saying don't engage. I am saying there are plenty of copies in Universities for people to engage with, there is no need to preserve this one. Offer to your local uni, a war museum and if they say no, dispose with a clean conscience. Nothign is being cancelled.

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 15:33

And I do share the total distaste for Nazi memorabilia collecting.

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 15:31

It seems like nowadays many people think that if you engage with something and give it headspace, you approve of it and agree with it, or its author.

So you get those idiots who now won't contemplate Harry Potter books because they're scared that people will think they're transphobes.

And no, I'm not directly comparing Harry Potter to Nazism.

barms90 · 23/08/2022 15:30

Some of the comments on here... wow. Its historically an important book we shouldn't just cancel it because its uncomfortable..for history students its actually one of the best primary sources we have access to and gives and understanding into what happened and why.
I had to read extracts for history and my only take away was that it was really boring and a bit of a slog.
I think u shud see if any museum would be interested in it.

Nomorefuckstogive · 23/08/2022 15:29

Surely a university would love this? We had to study it at Uni (languages, history and politics degree.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread