Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do with Mein Kampf?!

332 replies

Bannedcontent · 23/08/2022 11:22

My late DF was a history buff and after he died we gave a lot of his books to charity but kept a few.

Among them was an English translation of Mein Kampf. It’s a first edition from 1939.

I held on to it as a historic artefact but would now like to move it on.

I can’t sell it on Amazon or eBay as it’s banned.

So the question is: do I bin it? (YABU)
Do I donate it to a library or something? (YANBU) Where?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Againstmachine · 02/09/2022 09:59

Is the person above involved in counter extremism which I don't think they would talk so openly about, or are they just a member of UAF/Anita.

CPL593H · 02/09/2022 09:35

I'm against the sale of Nazi memorabilia (which this book might be categorised as because of its age) because it does end up as trophies for the far Right.

However, I have doubts that anyone actually involved in counter terror/extremism would talk excitably about that on a public forum, even an anonymous one. At least I'd hope they wouldn't.

Hoppinggreen · 02/09/2022 09:02

Tinytinseltown · 02/09/2022 01:04

Oh do tell me what qualifies you to make that judgment. Oh go oooon, please, I’d be genuinely thrilled to hear you had some experience in the field that you can adjudicate who is and isn’t qualified to work in counter extremism. I’ve worked on counter Daesh, counter far right, counter Kremlin, and counter Iran ops. Now you go!

I think some of these people you have worked with might have rubbed off on you a bit

Freedomfighters · 02/09/2022 08:44

Tinytinseltown · 02/09/2022 01:04

Oh do tell me what qualifies you to make that judgment. Oh go oooon, please, I’d be genuinely thrilled to hear you had some experience in the field that you can adjudicate who is and isn’t qualified to work in counter extremism. I’ve worked on counter Daesh, counter far right, counter Kremlin, and counter Iran ops. Now you go!

You're starting to sound a bit unhinged.

Tinytinseltown · 02/09/2022 01:04

Freedomfighters · 01/09/2022 09:15

You don't seem equipped with the skills to work in any high level post in counter extremism. Full of false assumptions and personal opinions. No substance behind it.

Oh do tell me what qualifies you to make that judgment. Oh go oooon, please, I’d be genuinely thrilled to hear you had some experience in the field that you can adjudicate who is and isn’t qualified to work in counter extremism. I’ve worked on counter Daesh, counter far right, counter Kremlin, and counter Iran ops. Now you go!

Tinytinseltown · 02/09/2022 01:01

Elmore · 01/09/2022 10:10

So you fabricate terrorism threats to drum up support for removing freedoms.Not buying it

🤣🤣🤣

Your post makes total sense. No really, it does! Oh wait, no, no it doesn’t. Where on earth have I advocated for removing freedoms? I just said you’d be a shitty person if you made money out of selling the incoherent ramblings of a mass murderer. I’m not sure that’s an overly controversial statement in the real world, but by god it has stirred the ire of a whole three people on mumsnet who seem to think ‘freedom’ means ‘alright with extremism’.

I am very glad I do my job and you don’t, put it that way. Honestly if you saw a fraction of the shit we deal with (protecting the public from physical harm from these people, by the way), you wouldn’t be so blasé about something as fundamental to the far right extremist cause as this fcking stupid book.

Elmore · 01/09/2022 10:10

Tinytinseltown · 01/09/2022 03:06

Currently work in it. Far right extremism is by far the biggest threat the country and the West more generally faces in terrorism terms atm. Not suggesting no one should read it. I have, it’s dross, and with proper context historically useful to see how easily people can be manipulated by far-right firebrands with confused (not confusing, confused) and incoherent messaging. There’s much more coherent, pernicious and scary manifestos out there, all freely available online.

My problem is with OP trying to make money off it, and the incredible nativity of many people on this thread - y‘know, the kind of person whose tag on MN is ‘freedomfighters’, who probably thinks they’re edgy because they didn’t wear a mask during lockdown.

So you fabricate terrorism threats to drum up support for removing freedoms.Not buying it

Freedomfighters · 01/09/2022 09:15

Tinytinseltown · 01/09/2022 03:06

Currently work in it. Far right extremism is by far the biggest threat the country and the West more generally faces in terrorism terms atm. Not suggesting no one should read it. I have, it’s dross, and with proper context historically useful to see how easily people can be manipulated by far-right firebrands with confused (not confusing, confused) and incoherent messaging. There’s much more coherent, pernicious and scary manifestos out there, all freely available online.

My problem is with OP trying to make money off it, and the incredible nativity of many people on this thread - y‘know, the kind of person whose tag on MN is ‘freedomfighters’, who probably thinks they’re edgy because they didn’t wear a mask during lockdown.

You don't seem equipped with the skills to work in any high level post in counter extremism. Full of false assumptions and personal opinions. No substance behind it.

Tinytinseltown · 01/09/2022 03:06

Freedomfighters · 24/08/2022 09:25

Why does you having worked in counter extremism mean that the op should bin or burn the book? Clearly other people also own a copy of the book who are not neo nazi fanboys. Did you think adding a job you once worked in would add more legitimacy to what is essentially just your personal opinion about what people should or should not be allowed to read?

Currently work in it. Far right extremism is by far the biggest threat the country and the West more generally faces in terrorism terms atm. Not suggesting no one should read it. I have, it’s dross, and with proper context historically useful to see how easily people can be manipulated by far-right firebrands with confused (not confusing, confused) and incoherent messaging. There’s much more coherent, pernicious and scary manifestos out there, all freely available online.

My problem is with OP trying to make money off it, and the incredible nativity of many people on this thread - y‘know, the kind of person whose tag on MN is ‘freedomfighters’, who probably thinks they’re edgy because they didn’t wear a mask during lockdown.

Freedomfighters · 24/08/2022 17:28

Well seeing as it's easy to pick up a copy off the shelf anyway, then the advice to bin or burn it isn't the best advice as absolutely anyone can get themselves a copy if they wish. Nice to see that there is still some freedom to read what we want, despite the authoritarians trying to dictate otherwise. I think I'll get myself one. I would sell it and get the money for it op.

TheBikiniExpert · 24/08/2022 16:56

BeanieTeen · 24/08/2022 16:13

Owning a vintage copy of Mein Kampf is not going to make them any more Nazi. With any luck, they might even read it and find out how unimpressive their hero was. Either way, no actual extra harm happens to anyone by selling the book, so chucking it is quite a sacrifice to make for a very uncertain benefit.

Sacrifice 😂
Lord almighty…
Love how many people on here really think Neo-Nazis may actually be put off Hitler by owning or reading Mein Kampf. Are people really so clueless about extremism? Naivety at its most embarrassing finest.
This thread is really disconcerting. The ignorance and naivety around the reach, extent and influence of Neo-Nazism and it’s dangers is staggering.

It's a book that is easily and cheaply available! Don't you think if someone really wanted to read it they would? No point in OP throwing cash away.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 24/08/2022 16:38

BeanieTeen · 24/08/2022 16:13

Owning a vintage copy of Mein Kampf is not going to make them any more Nazi. With any luck, they might even read it and find out how unimpressive their hero was. Either way, no actual extra harm happens to anyone by selling the book, so chucking it is quite a sacrifice to make for a very uncertain benefit.

Sacrifice 😂
Lord almighty…
Love how many people on here really think Neo-Nazis may actually be put off Hitler by owning or reading Mein Kampf. Are people really so clueless about extremism? Naivety at its most embarrassing finest.
This thread is really disconcerting. The ignorance and naivety around the reach, extent and influence of Neo-Nazism and it’s dangers is staggering.

Yes, throwing £150 (or whatever it turns out to be worth) in the recycling bin is quite a sacrifice for many people. Perhaps you're wealthy enough that that's nothing to you. But even if you're not, it's easy enough to throw other people's money at your principles, more difficult when it's your own.

Lots of us would think twice, or even several times, about giving up that kind of money on the reasoning that there's a small chance that the person who buys it might be a neo-Nazi, and that a neo-Nazi owning such a thing might do some kind of tangible harm. (Like what?)

The bit about Mein Kampf's crapness maybe changing a neo-Nazi's mind was an obvious joke at the expense of Hitler 🙄 Though I suppose joking isn't allowed any more, even if you're mocking Hitler (something of which there's a tradition going back to the war).

At the end of the day, it's a slightly valuable old book. OP is not responsible if someone who buys it does something weird with it.

BeanieTeen · 24/08/2022 16:13

Owning a vintage copy of Mein Kampf is not going to make them any more Nazi. With any luck, they might even read it and find out how unimpressive their hero was. Either way, no actual extra harm happens to anyone by selling the book, so chucking it is quite a sacrifice to make for a very uncertain benefit.

Sacrifice 😂
Lord almighty…
Love how many people on here really think Neo-Nazis may actually be put off Hitler by owning or reading Mein Kampf. Are people really so clueless about extremism? Naivety at its most embarrassing finest.
This thread is really disconcerting. The ignorance and naivety around the reach, extent and influence of Neo-Nazism and it’s dangers is staggering.

LurkingBookseller · 24/08/2022 15:28

I work in a bookshop, and we usually have a copy of Mein Kampf on the shelves. As would most branches of Blackwells, Waterstones, the odd Smiths and independents. We don’t sell it very often, but it’s almost always people with a reading list (I.e. students) buying it.

We also sell translations of the bible, the koran, The Satanic Verses, The God Delusion, Blair’s autobiography (which at one time was regularly moved to the ‘True Crime’ section by persistent visitors!), Charles Bronson’s book …

And … and … the most controversial book of recent memory - ‘Trans’ by Helen Joyce 😲 Shock, horror, bookshops sell controversial books, hurrah for free speech, long may it last!

[awaits cancellation]

DrowsyDragon · 24/08/2022 10:25

It's not out of print. This particular edition will be but it is available, usually with critical analysis and framing which is a preferably way for students to engage with the text for a variety of reasons

Dotjones · 24/08/2022 10:07

Ragwort · 24/08/2022 07:48

Donate it to a museum Hmm honestly, don't you think any museum that actually wanted a copy for it's archives would already have one. I work for a charity shop are - we forbidden from selling copies or even 'recycling' (you wouldn't know where it ends up), so we would destroy.

And what ridiculous comments about never 'destroying' any book ... how many copies of '50 Shades of Grey' (for example) does the world need?

Most museums are not large, well-funded operations, most largely rely on donations so it's perfectly possible that a museum doesn't have a first edition copy of this book. Equally the OP's copy might be in a better condition than their current one. The point is, offer it to a museum and see what the response is. Let them decide whether they want it. It's not like donating a double decker bus to a transport museum, a single copy of a book can easily have room found for it in the archive if it's not going on display.

Comparing "50 Shades of Grey" to "Mein Kampf" isn't really relevant. If it turns out that the author of "50 Shades of Grey" is one of the most evil people in history and tries to wipe an entire race off the face of the planet, then perhaps in 80 years first edition copies might be worth a museum getting hold of. But you're comparing a widely available, in print piece of of trash, to a historically significant, out of print one. The only similarity is that they are both awful.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 24/08/2022 09:51

OP you might be interested in Mein Kampf's translation history, it's a pretty interesting story. At least one version (though not your 1939 one[ was commissioned as anti-Nazi propaganda.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mein_Kampf_in_English

Freedomfighters · 24/08/2022 09:25

Tinytinseltown · 24/08/2022 08:01

Worked in counterextremism for a long time. Bin it, burn it, or turn it over to a museum (if it’s a first edition, otherwise see options 1 and 2). If you sell it the most likely collector in the market is going to be - guess what - a neonazi fanboy. Trust me, they absolutely love this shite.

It’s honestly abhorrent you would consider trying to make money off this book.

Why does you having worked in counter extremism mean that the op should bin or burn the book? Clearly other people also own a copy of the book who are not neo nazi fanboys. Did you think adding a job you once worked in would add more legitimacy to what is essentially just your personal opinion about what people should or should not be allowed to read?

HesterShaw1 · 24/08/2022 09:25

NicolaSixSix · 23/08/2022 23:09

@Eightiesfan ehm why do you have several copies in your school?

I expect it's a Nazi school where neo Nazis can send their kids.

Or maybe European Fascism is on the curriculum?

chillipenguin · 24/08/2022 09:17

Purplestorm83 · 24/08/2022 08:52

Jewish charities will likely not want the proceeds from its sale amp.theguardian.com/uk/2001/jun/18/books.humanities

Seems fair enough.

Elmore · 24/08/2022 09:08

There’s so many people enjoying a good screech without engaging their brains

Livpool · 24/08/2022 08:58

Why should IP destroy, or even have to donate the money? I am assuming OP isn't a Nazi!

Purplestorm83 · 24/08/2022 08:52

Jewish charities will likely not want the proceeds from its sale amp.theguardian.com/uk/2001/jun/18/books.humanities

MotherWol · 24/08/2022 08:37

Contact the Wiener Holocaust Library and ask if they would accept it; if not I’d seriously consider disposing of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread