Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter's step mum

366 replies

BonnieBobbet · 23/08/2022 07:56

I don't know where to start with this and may well be being unreasonable but it's really hard for me to see my child upset and I'm after some advice about this.

Basically me and ex-p share one 9 year old DD. He now has a child with his wife too, a 3 year old.

My daughter loves her brother but she's really struggling with how things have changed so much with her stepmum and her family since he came along.

She used to be very invested in my daughter's life, they spent time together going places, she'd help out in the school holidays and things, and yes admittedly she's helped me out on a few occasions too. I've always been very grateful and it was never expected but she's offered in the past and we get on well enough.

Since her son was born is like she never really has time for DD. Never takes her anywhere anymore, doesn't help out ex-p making some logistics difficult.

Her family were really good with her too and she enjoyed their company. They weren't grandparents to her but she really liked them. Now it's the same, she feels they are only interested in her brother, she doesn't really understand why he can go for sleepovers and SMs mum and dad's house but she can't for example.

She no longer bothers buying her things to give him on father's Day or his birthday saying she could buy him something herself with her pocket money. She could of course and she then does but it's just another example of how things have just abruptly stopped for her since SM had her real baby iyswim.

Ex-p has never taken our DD abroad saying they prefer UK holidays anyway and I've never been bothered by this obviously as UK holidays are still great and it's not my business. DD has made comments in the past but I've told her not to be ungrateful. I take her away abroad every year anyway. Except now SM is off what seems like every 6 months on holidays with her son, one of which was Disneyland just before the school hols. They can afford all of this but never prioritise a family holiday including DD.

She's a SAHM and according to DD has just stopped doing anything like helping tidy her room or change or sheets and things leaving them to either her or her dad when he remembers all the while ensuring her son's room is spotless every day.

I know he's her dad and it's his responsibility not hers. But the change is just so obvious and hurtful to DD. She says her brother is all SM cares about now and I don't know what to say or do.

Do I say something or stay out of it? Obviously it's technically none of my business what her family do or where she goes or what she does with or for her child but it's affecting DD and she prefers staying with me now.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 23/08/2022 13:01

There're 3 crowds here on MN in response to this: no obligation crowd (they talk about extremely crass things like being an unpaid childminder, making me want to vomit, these are the people who on the sm board, complain about the sc eating too much) and there's basic decency crowd (yeah, she's OK, I'll tolerate her but not my child, who really cares) , and there's being a real, loving family (accepting that this an innocent child and loving her). I'm hoping the last is the silent majority.

There's another position, too. That is one of complete sympathy with OP's predicament, a recognition that it's the child's feelings that come first, but a realistic conclusion that there's nothing to be gained by raising this. It it can only cause a large amount of angst that nobody in this situation, least of all the children, need. No one knows what ExP/SM's home set up his, or how much support she receives, and everyone knows what hard work newborns are. She might be resentful at having to pick up the bulk of the domestic labour, nor would I blame her for that.

Hopefully there will be some tactful way of suggesting ExDP picks up some of the slack for the benefit of his child. As her father, it's the least he can do, albeit with some fathers it can be a tall order.

Whether SM shares any of the blame for this or otherwise, there's nothing productive to be gained from raising this with her.

PinkTonic · 23/08/2022 12:59

This thread really highlights what a shit deal children get in so called ‘blended’ families and what they have to put up with to facilitate the selfish whims of the adults who produce them. If you marry a man with children, the interests of those children must be prioritised. They remain in your family and of equal status even when you go on to have more children. Division of labour within the household is between the two adults but it shouldn’t lead to a child being treated differently or feeling excluded.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 23/08/2022 12:56

Topgub · 23/08/2022 08:20

@Catfordthefifth

Yeah I've noticed. Mn has very weird ideas about sahm and wm.

Most of them a load of pish.

It's all rot, isn't it? Then there are protestations that 'you never hear men splitting hairs over the division of their domestic and family labour; THEY don't care what other men do!'

Damn straight, they don't. And I wonder precisely why that might be?

Meraas · 23/08/2022 12:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not a SM but this is uninformed, goady, inflammatory bollocks.

If anything makes you want to vomit, it must be your own bullshit.

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 12:20

Actually, it doesn’t sound like the SM has significantly changed tbh. She was never a stay at home mother to her husband’s daughter, or provided after school childcare. I take it she never took the DD on a holiday either, just the two of them?

As for the making of beds and picking out Father’s Day presents, the daughter is 9. There’s a difference between what a 9 year old can do, and a 6 year old. The stepmother probably thinks the DD is perfectly capable of doing both by herself, or capable of requesting help if she needs it.

of course she’s going to treat her own son like he’s her own son. She has one child she’s responsible for, and that’s him!

Meraas · 23/08/2022 12:13

OP, you sound like a lovely mum who wants the best for her dd. I veer between yabu and yanbu.

Where I think yabu:

  • you say 'we are all guilty a bit of not encouraging chores enough'. I don't think it's fair to say this in relation to DSM. It's down to dd's parents to parent her
  • you say it's off that DSM doesn't do after school care. Again, this is not DMS's responsibility
Where I feel sorry for DSD:
  • it must be so hard to see affection lavished on her brother by his DGPs and feel left out. I don't think it's the responsibility of his DGPs to do the same for your dd but I can imagine how left out your dd must feel. I think her dad needs to step up and have more 1-2-1 with dd.
  • the change from a doting DSM to a less available DSM must be hard. Again, why isn't her dad making up for this?
Sellorkeep · 23/08/2022 12:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

How utterly offensive to those of us who hang out on the SP board either seeking advice or offering a shoulder.

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 12:04

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 11:49

Again, we have no evidence that the child's father has 'palmed her off' to the sm 🤷‍♀️

You are absolutely right that a woman (or man) can decide that they don't want to be a parent to someone else's child. And the other partner can accept that or end the relationship.

Now personally, I can't understand being someone going into a relationship with someone with a child and taking the perspective of not being an 'additional parent' (if I wasn't overstepping my bounds in the eyes on the actual parents). I also wouldn't have a relationship with someone if they didn't want to love and care for my dc as a team. As a family. But as I said, people have a right to make those choices.

BUT in this situation, the sm did not decide that and make it clear from the beginning. She appears to have taken on this role and only since having her own dc has she stopped. That is OBVIOUSLY hurtful to a child who has always known her to be loving and attentive.

Palmed off = the assumption that being in a relationship with someone makes them responsible for your child. it does sound like the father is comparatively lazy however, and it’s very possible that the stepmother is no longer willing to pick up his slack. Choosing to do in the beginning does not mean that millstone has to remain around her neck.

I don’t understand why there’s an assumption that having a romantic relationship with a parent means you automatically have to take on a parenting one. It’s one thing being kind to a child when you’re around them, but quite another to be responsible for them.

The stepmother is not in the same position that she was previously. If the daughter needs to compensated for the change in dynamic now stepmother has her own child, then her actual father needs to step up.

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 12:04

aSofaNearYou · 23/08/2022 11:59

BUT in this situation, the sm did not decide that and make it clear from the beginning. She appears to have taken on this role and only since having her own dc has she stopped. That is OBVIOUSLY hurtful to a child who has always known her to be loving and attentive.

A) we don't actually know if she has "stopped" or if things are just different now and DSD perceives it they way.

B) People, including parents, do sometimes have to disappoint their children by changing dynamics later down the line. Take the parents divorcing in the first place. You can't always just carry on in a situation that isn't right just because the change will be upsetting to the DC.

You're absolutely right. But ideally that change should be gradual, or at the very least discussed with the child so they understand the change and have had it explained in a loving and supportive way.

And yes we also don't know that this isn't just skewed in the eyes of the child, which is why op should discuss with the child's father. Just because the child's perspective might not be 'accurate', that doesn't mean her feelings on it should be ignored. Maybe if there was a discussion, her perspective would shift and she'd feel differently.

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 12:00

@Catfordthefifth yes I know, I added that bit as a caveat to my post below just in case anyone jumped on my wording.

Like I said below, I know others don't feel the same as I do, but in this situation it isn't just about sms having every right to not be a parent, it's about the fact that she seemingly was and then stopped.

aSofaNearYou · 23/08/2022 11:59

BUT in this situation, the sm did not decide that and make it clear from the beginning. She appears to have taken on this role and only since having her own dc has she stopped. That is OBVIOUSLY hurtful to a child who has always known her to be loving and attentive.

A) we don't actually know if she has "stopped" or if things are just different now and DSD perceives it they way.

B) People, including parents, do sometimes have to disappoint their children by changing dynamics later down the line. Take the parents divorcing in the first place. You can't always just carry on in a situation that isn't right just because the change will be upsetting to the DC.

Marvellousmadness · 23/08/2022 11:58

She was kind to YOUR dd
But she now has her OWN kid
Lets be realistic op. Your dd is not her kid. And now that she has her own, her feelings would have changed 180 degrees understandably

It also sounds that you dd needs to learn to do things for herself. She sounds like the stereotype for an only child ...

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 11:57

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 11:53

Also just to be clear, I wouldn't want or expect be an additional parent from the get go because you obviously have no idea how the relationship is going to go initially. But I'd be going into that situation prepared and willing to be one down the line if and when the relationship became serious.

I mean, good for you. But that's not the set up a lot of people want. Equally many mother's absolutely do not want another woman parenting their child.

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 11:53

Also just to be clear, I wouldn't want or expect be an additional parent from the get go because you obviously have no idea how the relationship is going to go initially. But I'd be going into that situation prepared and willing to be one down the line if and when the relationship became serious.

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 11:49

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 11:40

@wherearetheturrets

"I really don't get this Mumsnet perspective that sms have NO obligation to scs! If you get into a relationship with someone then you are accepting that they have a child/children whose lives you will be a part of."

she is part of it though? Being part of a child’s life is not the same as being responsible for that child, or being duty bound in taking on a parental role.

she is part of it though? Being part of a child’s life is not the same as being responsible for that child, or being duty bound in taking on a parental role. You believing they have this obligation is not the same as them actually having it.

The ex chose to embark on a relationship with a woman that he was aware wasn’t the mother of his child. If he expected her to work as a nanny for his existing child in perpetuity he should have made it known. Same as OP. Anything she did before was a favour.

a step parent is perfectly entitled to take a hands off approach. If that’s a problem then the actual parent is quite welcome to end the relationship. What they’re not welcome to do is palm off their responsibilities onto someone else.

Again, we have no evidence that the child's father has 'palmed her off' to the sm 🤷‍♀️

You are absolutely right that a woman (or man) can decide that they don't want to be a parent to someone else's child. And the other partner can accept that or end the relationship.

Now personally, I can't understand being someone going into a relationship with someone with a child and taking the perspective of not being an 'additional parent' (if I wasn't overstepping my bounds in the eyes on the actual parents). I also wouldn't have a relationship with someone if they didn't want to love and care for my dc as a team. As a family. But as I said, people have a right to make those choices.

BUT in this situation, the sm did not decide that and make it clear from the beginning. She appears to have taken on this role and only since having her own dc has she stopped. That is OBVIOUSLY hurtful to a child who has always known her to be loving and attentive.

Naunet · 23/08/2022 11:45

lookluv · 23/08/2022 11:08

Her father is responsible for parenting.

However this woman built up a relationship with a child/person made friends, was supportive etc and is now effectively gaslighting the child. Who unsurprisingly is upset.
The SM is responsible for her relationship with her DSD - no one else. She needs to own that relationship and not be so rude.
Her DF needs to sit with his DW and work out what works for both of them
Poor girl - effectively being dumped by one of the adults she thought cared for her - v hard to explain

So this woman who invested so much and was such a great step mother, deserves no benefit of the doubt whatsoever, and instead we just take a 9 year olds story as gospel? We go with the narrative that she’s now suddenly cold and rude? It couldn’t at all be down to normal childhood jealousy of being the only child and then having the upset of a new baby being added to the mix and no longer being the single focus of attention?

blueberry20 · 23/08/2022 11:42

I am a stepmum to a 13yo and a 10yo – I’ve been in their lives for six years. They spend a lot of time with us but not full time. My partner and I now also have a baby and it has been so important to us to keep things as consistent as possible for the older two. The last thing I wanted was for them to feel I was prioritising the baby over them, or that their dad was too busy with his ‘new family’. We are one family, even if we’re not together all the time.

Sometimes I do miss out on activities now (eg cinema) but only because if I have the baby it means their dad can spend that time with the older two. Tbh this doesn’t happen often as baby can come along to most things with us. It has also always been normal for us that I don’t come along to absolutely everything either. Their dad has always been very hands on with them.

I can only speak from my own experience, but while I am fully invested in my stepkids’ lives and do a lot for them and with them, I am not their mother. They have two excellent parents already. It’s really, really hard to find the right ‘stepmum balance’ for your family. I went through a bit of turbulence with this a few years ago and realised it wasn’t my role to take on too much. Your daughter’s stepmum has perhaps come to a similar realisation, but the change has been too abrupt for your daughter.

At 9 she is still very little – and don’t forget that covid (with lockdowns, home school etc.) has held some children back in learning independence and spreading their wings. We’ve certainly seen this with the 10yo.

Your daughter’s stepmum isn’t balancing things well – regardless of whether she was doing ‘too much’ before, it’s not fair to suddenly change things like this – but ultimately it’s your ex’s responsibility to be your daughter’s main support in their household. It sounds like he perhaps wasn’t taking on enough of this responsibility previously. You can’t change that now, so you need to figure out what will help your daughter from this point onwards.

Life with a new baby is intense – your daughter’s stepmum might not realise how much the balance has shifted or how your daughter is feeling. Same for her dad. Personally, I would want to know if my stepchildren were feeling like this (and their dad would want to know too), but only you know how that conversation would be received in your family. For us, even though it is sometimes difficult and there can be resentment between the adults, open communication about the kids is ALWAYS the best thing for them.

A new sibling is a big adjustment for any child, and there are extra difficulties with blended families. Your daughter needs to know that the adults in her life still love and care for her – through both their words and their actions. Some honest conversation and one-on-one time will go a long way. But don’t assume that what is obvious to you is obvious to the other household! If you can, I would find a non-confrontational way to raise this with your daughter’s dad. Good luck xx

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 11:40

@wherearetheturrets

"I really don't get this Mumsnet perspective that sms have NO obligation to scs! If you get into a relationship with someone then you are accepting that they have a child/children whose lives you will be a part of."

she is part of it though? Being part of a child’s life is not the same as being responsible for that child, or being duty bound in taking on a parental role.

she is part of it though? Being part of a child’s life is not the same as being responsible for that child, or being duty bound in taking on a parental role. You believing they have this obligation is not the same as them actually having it.

The ex chose to embark on a relationship with a woman that he was aware wasn’t the mother of his child. If he expected her to work as a nanny for his existing child in perpetuity he should have made it known. Same as OP. Anything she did before was a favour.

a step parent is perfectly entitled to take a hands off approach. If that’s a problem then the actual parent is quite welcome to end the relationship. What they’re not welcome to do is palm off their responsibilities onto someone else.

Hankunamatata · 23/08/2022 11:35

It's a really tough one. She is prioritising her child and leaving dd parenting to ex dh. Which is what lost step parents are encouraged to do on here.

EL8888 · 23/08/2022 11:33

She probably had less time and money, as do most people when they have children. At the end of the day she’s not her child, your child already has 2 parents

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 11:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Utter utter bollocks.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 23/08/2022 11:27

It could be the SM's family are paying for the abroad holidays, particularly as DD's dad doesn't go on them?

I think it's a situation where SM isn't doing anything wrong as such, but you DD's feelings are understandable.

I would wonder whether the 50/50 arrangement is still working for DD, though I appreciate that could open up all kinds of other issues.

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 11:26

MeridianB · 23/08/2022 11:14

Sad for your DD. Whatever the reasons for this, she is feeling hurt and that's a shame.

I'm a mum and a SM. I suspect, as many other have said, that your ex wasn't doing enough for DD, so SM stepped up. And now, if he's also not doing enough for his toddler then SM will have much less time and headspace.

It's possible that SM's parents can only cope with a 3yo and dont have the energy/confidence to add another child into the mix. Or they're doing favours/childrcare with DGS and assume DD doesn't need this. But I can see how this won't be immediately obvious to a 9yo.

I'd speak to your ex, explain how DD is feeling, ask him to suggest solutions that he can provide. Is he spending enough 1:1 time with DD? Could they do a regular activity together? Ask him if 50:50 is working (be wary of him resisting change to avoid paying maintenance though).

Might be worth trying to understand why your DD needs to stay in after-school club when SM is at home. It may be that collection time clashes with the toddler's routine. But it's something that stood out for me in your examples - it would be good to know more. Even if it still won't change, it may help your DD to understand why.

Im not sure anyone needs to "understand the reason why" she's in after-school club. SM not offering to do childcare is a perfectly okay reason. There shouldn't have to be a secondary reason.

Conchersbonkers · 23/08/2022 11:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wherearetheturrets · 23/08/2022 11:22

@Catfordthefifth I don't see anywhere it saying that the sm previously did everything and dad did nothing.

The op said that sm would previously take dc places and help out in the holidays, help dc buy Father's Day/bday presents (obviously it's not ideal for dcs dad to do the presents), help her tidy her room and change her sheets.

I know the ops just given some examples so I'm sure sm did more than this. But I do a hell of a lot more than this for my dc so the examples certainly don't show sm did 'everything', and there's no evidence to suggest that the dcs dad didn't also help her tidy her room/change her sheets/take her out/look after her in the holidays/buy presents for his new wifes bday/Mother's Day from dc etc.

Again, maybe he doesn't do that stuff, and he deserves to be slammed for it. But without being told that this is the case, it's unreasonable to just assume he doesn't and make it all about that than the fact that ops dd feels hurt and less loved by her sm.