Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter's step mum

366 replies

BonnieBobbet · 23/08/2022 07:56

I don't know where to start with this and may well be being unreasonable but it's really hard for me to see my child upset and I'm after some advice about this.

Basically me and ex-p share one 9 year old DD. He now has a child with his wife too, a 3 year old.

My daughter loves her brother but she's really struggling with how things have changed so much with her stepmum and her family since he came along.

She used to be very invested in my daughter's life, they spent time together going places, she'd help out in the school holidays and things, and yes admittedly she's helped me out on a few occasions too. I've always been very grateful and it was never expected but she's offered in the past and we get on well enough.

Since her son was born is like she never really has time for DD. Never takes her anywhere anymore, doesn't help out ex-p making some logistics difficult.

Her family were really good with her too and she enjoyed their company. They weren't grandparents to her but she really liked them. Now it's the same, she feels they are only interested in her brother, she doesn't really understand why he can go for sleepovers and SMs mum and dad's house but she can't for example.

She no longer bothers buying her things to give him on father's Day or his birthday saying she could buy him something herself with her pocket money. She could of course and she then does but it's just another example of how things have just abruptly stopped for her since SM had her real baby iyswim.

Ex-p has never taken our DD abroad saying they prefer UK holidays anyway and I've never been bothered by this obviously as UK holidays are still great and it's not my business. DD has made comments in the past but I've told her not to be ungrateful. I take her away abroad every year anyway. Except now SM is off what seems like every 6 months on holidays with her son, one of which was Disneyland just before the school hols. They can afford all of this but never prioritise a family holiday including DD.

She's a SAHM and according to DD has just stopped doing anything like helping tidy her room or change or sheets and things leaving them to either her or her dad when he remembers all the while ensuring her son's room is spotless every day.

I know he's her dad and it's his responsibility not hers. But the change is just so obvious and hurtful to DD. She says her brother is all SM cares about now and I don't know what to say or do.

Do I say something or stay out of it? Obviously it's technically none of my business what her family do or where she goes or what she does with or for her child but it's affecting DD and she prefers staying with me now.

OP posts:
Catfordthefifth · 24/08/2022 07:36

OrlaCarmichael · 24/08/2022 00:22

Maybe it is. But the way the OP was written doesn’t suggest a recent reaction by OP’S daughter. It’s based on 3 years of lived experience. A third of her life

And? That doesn't suggest this has all been some bizarre game plan by the SM.

user58486267489 · 24/08/2022 07:18

@SpaceshiptoMars absolutely agree

SpaceshiptoMars · 24/08/2022 07:14

When women who are not SMs have their first child, people are very understanding of all the changes in her life she has to accommodate. Massive bodily changes, lack of sleep, the constant demands of breast feeding etc.

When a woman who is an SM has their first child, I see on these boards an insistence that she is immediately up to speed with all of this - simply because she has had the partial care of a 6 yr old prior to that, what else does she need? I don't have my own, only the DSCs, and to me this attitude seems ludicrous, tragic even. Allow the SM to be a mother and learn at the same speed as other mothers do - why add in crazy extra demands when a woman is so vulnerable?

OrlaCarmichael · 24/08/2022 00:22

Maybe it is. But the way the OP was written doesn’t suggest a recent reaction by OP’S daughter. It’s based on 3 years of lived experience. A third of her life

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 23:03

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 23:03

If there’s anything like that going on here then OP’s instincts are correct and she needs all the support she can muster to advocate for her daughter’s experience of home life in her other home

That's a big fat if, isn't it.

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 23:03

If there’s anything like that going on here then OP’s instincts are correct and she needs all the support she can muster to advocate for her daughter’s experience of home life in her other home

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 22:56

Not going to speculate what the situation is here but can affirm that a marked change in SM behaviour it’s not always due to being more busy after having own child, or dad not stepping up, though both are possible reasons.

I’ve seen such a marked change (happened in DH’s extended family) where it was more that the proactive pre bio children behaviour towards SD was a mix of playing happy families and showing what a good partner/mother she would make. But the end goal was her own unit (with the new partner co opted). Does happen

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 22:44

I’d have to scroll back. But I think OP said along the lines that it was always preempted by SM and in the end she stopped. But was absolutely happy to do that part of her role as mother

HandbagAtDawn · 23/08/2022 22:37

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 22:34

BabyDreamers · Today 21:49
Sounds like she was doing all the stuff you and your ex should be doing. Defo not down to a step parent to organise gifts for bdays and fathers day.

OP already clarified this up thread:

She was ready and willing to do these gifts and only stopped because SM was doing it

She only stopped because the SM was doing it? Why? She’s the child’s mother! Why let the SM take over unless it actually suited her to do less for her own DD?

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 22:35

Earlier on, pre her DS

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 22:34

BabyDreamers · Today 21:49
Sounds like she was doing all the stuff you and your ex should be doing. Defo not down to a step parent to organise gifts for bdays and fathers day.

OP already clarified this up thread:

She was ready and willing to do these gifts and only stopped because SM was doing it

BabyDreamers · 23/08/2022 21:50

Or do childcare

BabyDreamers · 23/08/2022 21:49

Sounds like she was doing all the stuff you and your ex should be doing. Defo not down to a step parent to organise gifts for bdays and fathers day.

HandbagAtDawn · 23/08/2022 21:47

I was in a similar position to your DD’s SM.

Before my own DC were born, I did similar things with my DSD.

Some PP on here have described it as ‘playing at parenting’, but that wasn’t the case. How I see it now, over a decade later is that my DP wanted to manoeuvre me into a pseudo-mummy role as a fuck you to his ex and also so that he didn’t have to do all the heavy lifting of parenting his DD. That should never have happened. He was setting expectations for his DD that I would never be able to meet.

When my first DC was born, I was overwhelmed with having an EBF baby attached to me every second of the day. I had to take a massive step back from DSD because I realised that if I didn’t, I was in the position of doing the lion’s share of the childcare for both children, while DP sat on his arse staring at his phone. (Also, during this time, his ex would ask if we could have DSD a lot more because she knew I was on mat leave and it suited her to use me as childcare, but I’m sure that’s not the case with you.)

So in order to make him step up and do his fair share, I had to stop doing as much for DSD.

No doubt it was noticed and commented on. But it was more than my mental health and well-being was worth to be a martyr to the step mum guilt. At the end of the day, DP is her parent and I am not.

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 21:41

@Catfordthefifth what? I'm so confused, do you think me saying we continue on doing normal life stuff when she's away as me proving life stops? ... maybe for you days out and trips away are normal life stuff? If so then that's great.. but for us it's not ... so yes life continues as normal and we plan any "extras" when we have her to make the most of it as we' wouldn't be well off enough to make up some of the more expensive trips to her or even have the time, me and DP both have busy schedules out of the house mon-fri 9-5:30/6 so we make our days off count for all the kids not just two of them ... oldest child's dad has flexible schedule and we don't have a set in stone arrangement/custody and he let's us take the lead so we can tell him if we have whatever planned on whatever day and he'll just have her on days we don't have any plans, that way she isn't missing out as all we'd really be doing is dinner /bath and bed if it's a weekday & maybe a trip to the park or beach (we live in a coastal town) with an ice cream movie night if it was a weekend but that's hardly unusually unless you are saying your able to do more on weekday evenings with your kids or plan days out every weekend? Again that's great if you can afford it but our weekends are typically pretty modest, and I know my oldest dad would be doing pretty much the same stuff we do so she isn't getting extra from him.... and I'm OK with my kids thinking we only do fun stuff all together 🤷‍♀️ maybe you do more fun stuff individually with your kids if you have the time etc. but we don't, our days out are typically a family event, but I do do some mummy daughter dates with girls usually we get our hair done or do a bit of shopping and go to Costa for hot cocoa or an ice drink,

I had to go back and find your other question sorry I wasn't tagged in it so I missed it, but off course I'd have no issue with a step mum, my oldest daughters dad hasn't stuck it out long enough with anyone to really give them the title but there was a girl he was dating for over a year that had spent some time with my DD from all accounts she seemed lovely, she had an art degree and my daughter dreams of being an artist and got some cool lessons to improve her drawing, she was also a big Terry Pratchett fan so she got my DDs approval but it didn't work out in the end... I'd love if he found someone, not just for my DD but for himself and I know myself well enough to not be threathen by someone caring for my child, if anything I'd feel relieved that my DD wouldn't feel like a 3rd wheel or unwanted in her dad's house. Nothing horrible can come from my daughter having more people in her life that love her.

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 20:29

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 20:22

@Catfordthefifth but life isn't "stopping" whatever that's meant to mean, you seem to have a warped view ... but DP doesn't change or cancel plans he has promised the youngest he just ensures he makes these plans for a day he knows we have the oldest... yes oldest sees her dad but my youngest live full time with theirs so it's not like my dp disappears when the oldest isn't around, he's here with his kids but big days out or trips away etc. Are done with the oldest. The oldest dad doesn't do big days out, he's pretty chill, and his budget is tight, he'll play video games or help oldest with her guitar lessons etc. And have a pizza nights etc. But my dp would do the same with the youngest when oldest is away I mean obviously life continues as normal ... I'd understand you if maybe my oldest child's dad was just one of those drop in once a while lavish her with extravagant gifts/days out types but he's just a normal dad who spends time with her in his place just doing normal dad stuff with her while dp does normal dad stuff with his kids too

Life doesn't stop... Then explains all the ways it does 🤣

Its not a warped view at all. I just don't agree with you - that is allowed.

Did you see my other question or?

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 20:22

@Catfordthefifth but life isn't "stopping" whatever that's meant to mean, you seem to have a warped view ... but DP doesn't change or cancel plans he has promised the youngest he just ensures he makes these plans for a day he knows we have the oldest... yes oldest sees her dad but my youngest live full time with theirs so it's not like my dp disappears when the oldest isn't around, he's here with his kids but big days out or trips away etc. Are done with the oldest. The oldest dad doesn't do big days out, he's pretty chill, and his budget is tight, he'll play video games or help oldest with her guitar lessons etc. And have a pizza nights etc. But my dp would do the same with the youngest when oldest is away I mean obviously life continues as normal ... I'd understand you if maybe my oldest child's dad was just one of those drop in once a while lavish her with extravagant gifts/days out types but he's just a normal dad who spends time with her in his place just doing normal dad stuff with her while dp does normal dad stuff with his kids too

OrlaCarmichael · 23/08/2022 20:03

I agree that a child doesn’t ‘need’ 3 parents if their bio parents are fully engaged. But if 50:50 means a child properly lives in each as their home, then what happens when a half sibling is born has such a bearing on the older child.

This is a time when the older one cements relationships they have with other adults like the grandparents.

In the context of this particular 9 year old, who doesn’t have much contact with bio gps for various reasons, it appears to have gone in the other direction and yes, the step grandparents can’t be forced to treat her as they did before, but it’s just so sad and not surprising that she’s feeling it this very keenly. And if more siblings arrive? And she’s still 50:50, she’d absolutely notice if she still can’t go home after school but her db could (if sm still sahp).

I’ve seen many situations and combinations, including ones where the change in dynamic wouldn’t have such an impact but I really feel for the child in this specific situation.

Does she get much time with her dad - at their house and out and about?

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 19:53

My DP comes from a blended family himself, he actually axclusively refers to his DSF as just his dad, his bio dad walked out when he was 7 .... actually his mum is also the product of a blended family, my DP only learned that his mum and aunt have separate fathers about 7 years ago when his mum casually mentioned it in her kitchen over tea and a chat he was shocked and I remember him saying to his mum he didn't know they were half sisters and she snapped at him that they "most certainly weren't half sisters.. just sisters and one wasn't treated different from the other" which I suppose must be true if dp didn't even know they had different dads.

Anyway DP and his DSF have a very close relationship and DSF has children from a previous marriage, his daughter was bridesmaid for DP's mum along with DPs sisters. They recently made their wills wherein all of their combined children are equal beneficiary's on both his DSF and DMs. His mum has a close relationship with her husbands bio kids. My children and DPs sisters kids all refer to their DSFs children as aunt/uncles and their children as cousins and vice versa even without being blood relation. His family gatherings are huge lol. Everyone gets on really well, my kids have always called DPs DSF grand dad and he is an absolute wonderful man that all the grand kids adore.

My DP has experience being a DSC, and his DSF was an amazing role model.

Bananarama21 · 23/08/2022 19:50

Prinnny hit the nail on the head its down to you to mange expections. Are you a step parent yourself? It's almost as if you expect her to be a third parent to your child. You have no insight to how disneyland came about and you take your on child away on holiday. You would have a point if yout ex was going but it's not the case here.

Shes not there to provide you childcare, for her family to be surrogate grandparents or for her to tidy up and clean after an 9 year old. Your can deflect at that age but you seem to be expecting she goes above and beyond for a child she hasn't had any part in making. By all means she can be a supportive role model but she doesn't need or should have to be another parent.

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 19:27

And to answer your question, yes I think it's perfectly fine to not treat a child like "your own". As I've said probably eleventy billion times on these boards, being a friendly trusted adult is absolutely fine.

I'm not saying exclude children or literally ignore them, but you don't HAVE to aim to be another mum or dad.

Out of interest how would you feel if another women essentially became a second mum to your children?

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 19:24

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 19:04

Why sad?? My kids don't see themselves as only "half sisters" and younger middle child adores and looks up to big sister. why do you think that they would feel sad that their sister is included on fun days out? .... maybe it's a perspective thing but my immediate family is very close knit and all my DC have large age gaps (13, 7 & 8 week old) so oldest has always doted on the younger and middle dc has always looked up the the oldest, they genuinely love each other ... obvi the 8 week old is too young to have much of an opinion but my older kids adore her .... I feel the age gaps have prevented any rivalry between them as they are all at different stages ....is this really abnormal though? I have a lot of friends with blended families similar to mine that are the same .... so for example do you think if my dp planned a trip to Disney for just the youngest kids and left my oldest behind, I should just except this as reasonable? He wouldn't do this anyway cause he would never be so cruel but in your opinion this would be perfectly fine? And in this scenario does my oldest child's feelings count? Or should I sit her down and just explain that obviously she's not as important to my dp as her sisters 🤔 why on earth would she ever think that the man who has lived with us for 8 years, who was present for her first day of school, every Xmas morning, every birthday, attended every school play, been on holidays with, that played hours of hide and go seek and monoploy with her when she was little and video games as she got older, taught her to swim and bought her first bike would actually care about her as much as his own bio DD...

Obviously the way your family runs works for you and your husband. No one has said that stepparents shouldn’t treat children as their own, what’s been said is that they shouldn’t be expected to, and they’re not terrible people if they don’t.

For some parents it’s vital that a prospective stepparent would view their child in this way, but other parents don’t have that ideal. That’s presumably something that’s figured out at the ‘are we compatible?’ stage, and if there isn’t a sharing of views in this regard then the relationship doesn’t have to continue.

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 19:20

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 19:04

Why sad?? My kids don't see themselves as only "half sisters" and younger middle child adores and looks up to big sister. why do you think that they would feel sad that their sister is included on fun days out? .... maybe it's a perspective thing but my immediate family is very close knit and all my DC have large age gaps (13, 7 & 8 week old) so oldest has always doted on the younger and middle dc has always looked up the the oldest, they genuinely love each other ... obvi the 8 week old is too young to have much of an opinion but my older kids adore her .... I feel the age gaps have prevented any rivalry between them as they are all at different stages ....is this really abnormal though? I have a lot of friends with blended families similar to mine that are the same .... so for example do you think if my dp planned a trip to Disney for just the youngest kids and left my oldest behind, I should just except this as reasonable? He wouldn't do this anyway cause he would never be so cruel but in your opinion this would be perfectly fine? And in this scenario does my oldest child's feelings count? Or should I sit her down and just explain that obviously she's not as important to my dp as her sisters 🤔 why on earth would she ever think that the man who has lived with us for 8 years, who was present for her first day of school, every Xmas morning, every birthday, attended every school play, been on holidays with, that played hours of hide and go seek and monoploy with her when she was little and video games as she got older, taught her to swim and bought her first bike would actually care about her as much as his own bio DD...

I feel sad because your eldest is essentially favoured. Your younger kids will soon learn that nice things only happen when the eldest is there.

I'm not saying take them to Disney without her ( which I think you know) but you literally said you only ever make plans when she's there. That's not really fair on the other kids imo.

She has a dad, and it's great your husband treats her well, but stopping life eow or whatever for the other kids isn't great I don't personally think.

whumpthereitis · 23/08/2022 19:18

Endlesslypatient82 · 23/08/2022 18:50

There is a world of difference between treating equally to your own and loving equally to your own (personally the gulf would be…. Enormous. Gargantuan)

I don’t think stepparents should be expected to treat them as their own either (assuming that the child/ren would want them to, nevermind their actual other parent). That’s not to say they shouldn’t be treated kindly and welcomed.

funnkly enough a stepfather has recently posed on the step parenting board, and the mix of advice is the same as it would be for a stepmother.

Skittlesthough · 23/08/2022 19:04

Catfordthefifth · 23/08/2022 18:23

I don't either.

But pp is right.

What are step dad's actually expected to do in terms of parenting? Not changing beds etc I imagine.

Also I feel a bit sorry for the younger kids mentioned above who's dad never makes plans for them unless their older sibling is there. That's quite sad.

Why sad?? My kids don't see themselves as only "half sisters" and younger middle child adores and looks up to big sister. why do you think that they would feel sad that their sister is included on fun days out? .... maybe it's a perspective thing but my immediate family is very close knit and all my DC have large age gaps (13, 7 & 8 week old) so oldest has always doted on the younger and middle dc has always looked up the the oldest, they genuinely love each other ... obvi the 8 week old is too young to have much of an opinion but my older kids adore her .... I feel the age gaps have prevented any rivalry between them as they are all at different stages ....is this really abnormal though? I have a lot of friends with blended families similar to mine that are the same .... so for example do you think if my dp planned a trip to Disney for just the youngest kids and left my oldest behind, I should just except this as reasonable? He wouldn't do this anyway cause he would never be so cruel but in your opinion this would be perfectly fine? And in this scenario does my oldest child's feelings count? Or should I sit her down and just explain that obviously she's not as important to my dp as her sisters 🤔 why on earth would she ever think that the man who has lived with us for 8 years, who was present for her first day of school, every Xmas morning, every birthday, attended every school play, been on holidays with, that played hours of hide and go seek and monoploy with her when she was little and video games as she got older, taught her to swim and bought her first bike would actually care about her as much as his own bio DD...