Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I hit DH

310 replies

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 03:32

I slapped DH on the arm.

For context, my 3-year-old DS is a terrible sleeper. We usually put him to bed at around 8 or 9 but he’s often awake by midnight screaming hysterically and wanting to go downstairs. We’ve tried the “cry it out” method to no avail and we’re both sleep deprived.

I came back from work tonight and DS was
asleep. When I started to drift off around midnight, he woke up and started screaming. At this point, I was irrationally annoyed with DH who was gaming with his online mates. I’ve been up since just before 6 am but I stayed up with DS the night before last (I think. I’m actually getting my days mixed up). I asked DH to help me settle him and he seemed so pissed off I interrupted his precious game. DS was screaming that he wanted to go downstairs but DH wanted to let him cry it out. His crying became more and more hysterical whilst DH told me I’m the cause of his behaviour for giving into him at bed time. Truthfully, I just can’t let him cry it out, especially when he starts thrashing and hyperventilating like he’s going to be sick and sometimes even head butting (suspected ASD).

I swore at DH and told him to go to bed because I would stay up with DS. He didn’t move and without a thought I slapped his arm and told him to get out. He turned around and told me that if I ever hit him again he would break my fingers. I know I shouldn’t have slapped him but it honestly wasn’t hard at all. DH even said so but said there was malice there. Again, I know I’m making excuses for myself but he has (playfully) slapped my bum twice as hard when I’ve stood up next to him. Still, if he’d have done that to me tonight I’d be shocked and angry.

I'm just incredibly frustrated. He doesn’t really do anything with DS when he finishes work. It would be nice if he took him to the park for half hour or even kicked a ball around with him (he’s such a busy, active child). Yesterday, he shouted and swore at me in front of DS and my MIL who actually pulled him up on it and texted me
today to see if I was okay.

I want to create a sensory room for DS to see if it helps his sleep but DH isn’t interested so I have to pay for all of it. Despite being on less than half his salary.

I still hit him though.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 23/08/2022 15:49

People minimising the husband’s behaviour would do well to avail themselves of the search function.

The op absolutely should not have hit him, especially since it gives him ammunition to use against her. There is much more to this than the op hitting the husband. Maybe posters could consider the whole situation here?

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 15:48

HailAdrian · 23/08/2022 15:34

There will probably NEVER be a situation described here in which a man is sleep deprived and doing absolutely everything while his useless female partner plays games and threatens to break his bones in response to a light slap on the arm. It ain't the fucking same and you know it.

Yes, the fact it sounds so unlikely is exactly because it’s DARVO tissue paper cast over the situation to make the person doing the hitting look like a victim and the person being hit look like the abuser.

Note how she describes herself as sleep deprived and doing everything. How she plays down the second slap to hint that it’s not really abuse because she didn’t hit him hard.

Note how she describes him as useless (despite being the high earner) and obstructive. How he’s sworn at her- making it a big deal while mentioning the times she swears at him fleetingly. How he’s so horrible he’s gaming online at midnight (when the DC is asleep and she’s just home from work- but she’s conveniently glossed over that the DH will have cared for the DC while she was at work and done dinner and bed routine- doesn’t quite match the useless narrative so she’s just skipped over the gaps hoping you won’t notice them).

FrippEnos · 23/08/2022 15:47

Interesting how we have gone from hit to slap to tap to a light tap.

What ever the minimising that going on its time to leave the relationship for the sake of everybody involved.

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 15:37

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 15:34

@Whiskeypowers
Have a read up about fight or flight and reactive abuse.
God that is terribly insulting to say that @SunnyD44 who is a survivor of DV. She doesn’t need to “read up” on anything. She’s got the lived experience.

Not remotely insulting
i am also a survivor and someone explained it to me too

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 15:34

@Whiskeypowers
Have a read up about fight or flight and reactive abuse.
God that is terribly insulting to say that @SunnyD44 who is a survivor of DV. She doesn’t need to “read up” on anything. She’s got the lived experience.

HailAdrian · 23/08/2022 15:34

There will probably NEVER be a situation described here in which a man is sleep deprived and doing absolutely everything while his useless female partner plays games and threatens to break his bones in response to a light slap on the arm. It ain't the fucking same and you know it.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 15:26

@Whiskeypowers
you and everyone else piling in on someone who knows what she did was wrong Yes we all know how charming and oh so sorry a partner who hits can be. How deeply ashamed they are and the promises they won’t do it again.

”But she also contextualised a relationship where the following occur:” Oh yes, the classic DARVO context which you have lapped up. “I slapped him…but it honestly wasn’t hard at all” and so on.

  • Financial control - nope. A disagreement about creating a “sensory room” for a DC isn’t an example of financial control/abuse. OP has full control over her money that she earns. There’s no evidence she cannot buy necessities or that he is wilfully holding money back for necessities.
  • lakc of equality and access to assets despite children being involved- that’s a stretch as well. The DH said he doesn’t agree with creating a “sensory room” for their child, that’s an unresolved disagreement on what should be a joint purchasing decision. Not getting her way (yet) isn’t evidence of lack of equality. In fact the DH not being able to decide for himself when to go to bed without getting sworn at and slapped, is evidence of lack of equality.
  • total lack of interest in parenting- yes well abused partners do often get depressed, disconnect from family life and do escapist behaviours. Especially if they don’t want their child to see mummy smacking daddy.
  • physically blocking the OP from tending to a hysterical or sick baby / child- Yes he should not have physically blocked her during a disagreement on CIO but standing in someone’s way is nonviolent disobedience, her reaction to this remember was to hit him, (which did teach him a lesson so to speak as he didn’t block her ever again but still he offended her this time by not immediately going to bed when sworn at and ordered to and so earned himself another slap).
  • sinister threats of disproportionate retaliation to what she has admired was unacceptable lashing out lack of care and respect- Ok but slapping someone is a bit more than “lashing out” and no amount of “lack of care and respect” justifies slapping a person. (Nice bit of minimising DV with victim blaming there.) We have seen from a pp it is a common reactive defence mechanism after being hit for the victim to say an extreme verbal threat to try and get the abuser to not hit them again. And we know OP has hit her DH more than once.
SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 15:05

@Whiskeypowers i get reactive abuse but that shouldn’t be a reason to defend someone hitting their partner.

Of course they are many scenarios where you could say someone is justified for hitting their partner eg self defence, to stop them hurting themselves or someone else etc but none of that happened in this situation.

What’s shocking is that posters have said his threat of violence is worse than her actual act of violence - which is awful.

The men who hit their partners always blame their partner and accuse them of driving them to it.

Of course OP is going to play the victim here and say he’s this and that.
If she is being abused then she should leave.
Just like if a man is apparently being abused then he should leave too instead of attacking his wife.

It’s not an excuse for violence as that’s the same excuse that men use all of the time and people like you saying it’s ok because they were driven to it, does not help the thousands of women who hear this everyday.

MaryMcCarthy · 23/08/2022 14:56

If a man came on here talking about slapping someone in anger and then provided "context" or tried to justify it, or started talking about 'playful' bum slaps in the same context, he'd be absolutely crucified and rightly so.

It's only the inherent sexism of this place preventing that happening here.

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 14:51

@SunnyD44
perhaps this explains it better

breakthesilencedv.org/reactive-abuse-what-it-is-and-why-abusers-rely-on-it/?cn-reloaded=1

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 14:48

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 14:46

@Whiskeypowers so you’re saying in some circumstances it’s ok for a man to hit a women if he feels she’s pushed him to do it?

I knew you’d write that
what I’m saying is abuse is abuse and men and women can be abusive

what distinguishes intentional abuse form reactive abuse is the critical factor
I happen to believe the OP is guilty of the latter the partner the former

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 14:46

@Whiskeypowers so you’re saying in some circumstances it’s ok for a man to hit a women if he feels she’s pushed him to do it?

DillAte · 23/08/2022 14:45

I'm not sure why my reading of this is so different. It seems like the husband complied with OP and went to see to their child.

They had a difference in opinion in how a difficult situation should be handled.
It seems like OP wanted to acquiesce, that she had done so in the past and it has led to having to deal with the same difficult behaviour.OP's husband suggested that they try something new.

OP was adamant that her opinion on how to rear their shared child superceded his to the point that she slapped him for having the temerity to have an opinion on how to raise his child.

She tell a whole story about how he suggested a solution for a problem they are having with their child and disregarded it off hand.Then she complains that he "doesn't do enough".

I can definitely see how the former set of habits would lead to the latter perception if the only valid he can parent is doing what OP tells him to.

kripp · 23/08/2022 14:45

Meh, I can't find an atom of sympathy for your useless jerk of a husband.

You are not an abuser. Leave him.

Walkden · 23/08/2022 14:42

"You are under extreme pressure, snapped and did something wrong"

Right do next time a woman posts on here about being hit by her DH , we can excuse it as his being under extreme pressure and snapping?

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 14:40

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 14:16

Oh yes it’s the domineering abusive controlling man that is abusing his obviously oppressed and intimidated wife. That’s why when she swore at him, slapped him and told him to go to bed he……went to bed.

Come on. If he were the one in control, he would not have obeyed her. He’d have refused and hit back harder to show her he was the boss.

It’s weird and concerning how many women are trying to victim blame here.
And we wonder why DV rates are so high.

Let’s hope that when a women is hit by her partner she doesn’t come on here and think it’s acceptable because she apparently drove him to it.

OP snapped because her child is not sleeping and she is stressed and has sleep deprivation - does that mean it’s ok for her to hit her child or would it be acceptable because they have also drove her to it?

If she said her DH just snapped for the same reasons and hit her would the same posters tell her it’s fine and it’s not his fault?

If you love someone you don’t physically attack them. End of.

Parts of your post don’t even make sense to me in fact they seem to contradict each other.

you and everyone else piling in on someone who knows what she did was wrong but she also contextualised a relationship where the following occur


  • Financial control

  • lakc of equality and access to assets despite children being involved

  • total lack of interest in parenting

  • physically blocking the OP from tending to a hysterical or sick baby / child

  • sinister threats of disproportionate retaliation to what she has admired was unacceptable lashing out

  • lack of care and respect


Means this is clearly a situation where abuse and control is taking place.

With that in mind REGARDLESS of whether the OP was a man or a woman then there are dynamics present which mean it’s not “just” about deploying violence in this context.
it is also entirely possible to unpick that and provide non judgmental advice if you actually understand why and how this occurs in abusive relationships without condoning the fact OP smacked / slapped her partner.

Have a read up about fight or flight and reactive abuse. Thankfully there appears to be growing awareness of this so that people who lose it after months , years of being ground down and treated like shit, controlled, belittled, dismissed and literally held hostage because of children or financial abuse can get the help they need without wrongly being labelled as the abuser in a longitudinal context.

38daystogo · 23/08/2022 14:30

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 14:16

Oh yes it’s the domineering abusive controlling man that is abusing his obviously oppressed and intimidated wife. That’s why when she swore at him, slapped him and told him to go to bed he……went to bed.

Come on. If he were the one in control, he would not have obeyed her. He’d have refused and hit back harder to show her he was the boss.

It’s weird and concerning how many women are trying to victim blame here.
And we wonder why DV rates are so high.

Let’s hope that when a women is hit by her partner she doesn’t come on here and think it’s acceptable because she apparently drove him to it.

OP snapped because her child is not sleeping and she is stressed and has sleep deprivation - does that mean it’s ok for her to hit her child or would it be acceptable because they have also drove her to it?

If she said her DH just snapped for the same reasons and hit her would the same posters tell her it’s fine and it’s not his fault?

If you love someone you don’t physically attack them. End of.

Was it an attack? OP has addressed herself.

Stop clutching at straws here. The man probably went to bed because he sounds pretty useless anyway.

OP needs to get rid of him!

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 14:16

Oh yes it’s the domineering abusive controlling man that is abusing his obviously oppressed and intimidated wife. That’s why when she swore at him, slapped him and told him to go to bed he……went to bed.

Come on. If he were the one in control, he would not have obeyed her. He’d have refused and hit back harder to show her he was the boss.

It’s weird and concerning how many women are trying to victim blame here.
And we wonder why DV rates are so high.

Let’s hope that when a women is hit by her partner she doesn’t come on here and think it’s acceptable because she apparently drove him to it.

OP snapped because her child is not sleeping and she is stressed and has sleep deprivation - does that mean it’s ok for her to hit her child or would it be acceptable because they have also drove her to it?

If she said her DH just snapped for the same reasons and hit her would the same posters tell her it’s fine and it’s not his fault?

If you love someone you don’t physically attack them. End of.

beastlyslumber · 23/08/2022 14:09

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 13:47

@Hiddenmnetter also completely agree with what you have written.

the fact that the OP knows what she did is wrong is not enough for all these people who have only come on to witter about her behaviour in exactly the way the real
abuser in their relationship wants them to do.

i bet any amount of money all the aspects of the “partner’s” behaviour - which all those virtue signalling posters know is also wrong and is behind the regrettable slap but won’t acknowledge it in this discussion - he would never admit to. He would minimise and explain them away. He would deflect.

Still better to keep admonishing someone who is isolated and dependant upon the sort of man who gets defended even when he an abject failure as a father and a controlling bully to the child’s mother.

no wonder women - and yes it IS mostly women - daren’t open up to what they’re enduring in real life when droves of who I suspect are women come on here and keep adding another layer to the hair shirt she’s already dressed herself in.

Exactly. A lot of people on here making excuses for abusive men and gaslighting a woman who has come here for help.

MissMaple82 · 23/08/2022 13:58

I suggest you leave him, find peace in a life without this waste of space, thst drives you to do things you wouldn't normally do. You'll get time to yourself amd to relax when he has his child for contact.

PurpleDaisies · 23/08/2022 13:54

user29 · 23/08/2022 13:49

Stop making excuses. You hit your DH in anger. End of

Except it isn’t end of. Look at what else is going on and say that it’s the end of it. This is clearly a toxic relationship that needs to end. The op was absolute wrong to hit her husband. That doesn’t mean he is suddenly a saint. There are lots of worrying things going on on both sides. Thinking about what went on before and after might help the op to come to the conclusion that for the sake of her son, serious changes need to happen.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 23/08/2022 13:54

You're sleep deprived and at the end of your tether.

My DS didn't sleep well and cried constantly it definitely pushed me over the edge for a few years.

DustinsHat · 23/08/2022 13:53

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 04:28

@PurpleDaisies I’m starting to realise this but I have no savings and the house is in his name. He also earns nearly triple what I earn and has no MH history (that’s logged anyway). He told me once that if I left him he’d fight me for full custody and they probably would favour him tbh because he comes across so well.

I earned the most when we got together and he moved out of his mum’s into my flat. Had a substantial amount of money saved too.

They always say that. If he can't be arsed taking him to the park for half an hour do you think he'll actually want to be arsed with 24/7 care?

Whiskeypowers · 23/08/2022 13:51

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 13:42

Oh yes it’s the domineering abusive controlling man that is abusing his obviously oppressed and intimidated wife. That’s why when she swore at him, slapped him and told him to go to bed he……went to bed.

Come on. If he were the one in control, he would not have obeyed her. He’d have refused and hit back harder to show her he was the boss.

many many controlling abusive men never raise a finger or their voice. it is a key component of their wearing down and provoking their victim to fulfil their brief of “proving” she is in fact the abusive and crazy one.

The sort of narrative and scenarios you are describing indicate you know very little about the many nuances across the spectrum of less obvious but devastating abuse.

JudgeJ · 23/08/2022 13:49

Yes you shouldn't have hit him but he sounds really unkind. Does he actually offer anything in the relationship, do you love him?

Would you be as quick to make excuses for a man or are women judged on a different scale?