Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I hit DH

310 replies

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 03:32

I slapped DH on the arm.

For context, my 3-year-old DS is a terrible sleeper. We usually put him to bed at around 8 or 9 but he’s often awake by midnight screaming hysterically and wanting to go downstairs. We’ve tried the “cry it out” method to no avail and we’re both sleep deprived.

I came back from work tonight and DS was
asleep. When I started to drift off around midnight, he woke up and started screaming. At this point, I was irrationally annoyed with DH who was gaming with his online mates. I’ve been up since just before 6 am but I stayed up with DS the night before last (I think. I’m actually getting my days mixed up). I asked DH to help me settle him and he seemed so pissed off I interrupted his precious game. DS was screaming that he wanted to go downstairs but DH wanted to let him cry it out. His crying became more and more hysterical whilst DH told me I’m the cause of his behaviour for giving into him at bed time. Truthfully, I just can’t let him cry it out, especially when he starts thrashing and hyperventilating like he’s going to be sick and sometimes even head butting (suspected ASD).

I swore at DH and told him to go to bed because I would stay up with DS. He didn’t move and without a thought I slapped his arm and told him to get out. He turned around and told me that if I ever hit him again he would break my fingers. I know I shouldn’t have slapped him but it honestly wasn’t hard at all. DH even said so but said there was malice there. Again, I know I’m making excuses for myself but he has (playfully) slapped my bum twice as hard when I’ve stood up next to him. Still, if he’d have done that to me tonight I’d be shocked and angry.

I'm just incredibly frustrated. He doesn’t really do anything with DS when he finishes work. It would be nice if he took him to the park for half hour or even kicked a ball around with him (he’s such a busy, active child). Yesterday, he shouted and swore at me in front of DS and my MIL who actually pulled him up on it and texted me
today to see if I was okay.

I want to create a sensory room for DS to see if it helps his sleep but DH isn’t interested so I have to pay for all of it. Despite being on less than half his salary.

I still hit him though.

OP posts:
StreetwiseHercules · 24/08/2022 18:57

The hatred and bigotry on this thread is very disturbing.

MeetthemoveratDover · 24/08/2022 18:54

Bnxybee · 24/08/2022 17:39

Look, I realise that hitting him was wrong. I can’t justify it.

DS was screaming and I wanted to take him downstairs. DH wanted to let him CIO as we’re both exhausted from lack of sleep. DH insisted on the CIO although I wanted to tend to him. He ignored me so I slapped his arm to get his attention but it was harder than I intended. (But not hard enough to physically hurt him.)

You don’t need to keep justifying yourself to unhelpful people on here.

You’re clearly with a man who is unpleasant and doesn’t respect you and you don’t like him let alone love him and things are getting worse. Potentially dangerous for you.

I assume this has gone past fixable with relationship counselling? What are you going to do? You need to access support irl.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/08/2022 18:50

Worrieddaughter29 · 24/08/2022 09:45

@MaryMcCarthy OP’s husband is a groper, sex pest, controlling and manipulative arsehole if you look through her posting history.
it doesn’t justify her hitting him but I don’t think the ongoing victim in this relationship is the husband.

So if a husband slapped a wife who had previously groped, been sexually demanding, controlling and manipulative, you'd be defending the husband?

Elleherd · 24/08/2022 18:37

I'm not judging you here. I am going to say please don't ever hit him again, he probably will break your fingers.
Once you remove the barrier that we don't have the right to hit each other, it always goes downhill, and regardless of who started it, it's usually the man who finishes it.

Bnxybee · 24/08/2022 17:39

Look, I realise that hitting him was wrong. I can’t justify it.

DS was screaming and I wanted to take him downstairs. DH wanted to let him CIO as we’re both exhausted from lack of sleep. DH insisted on the CIO although I wanted to tend to him. He ignored me so I slapped his arm to get his attention but it was harder than I intended. (But not hard enough to physically hurt him.)

OP posts:
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 24/08/2022 17:36

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 17:29

You've ended up in the age old situation of having no money and no job so he thinks you won't leave. No easy fixes for that.

OP has a job and money.

She has no money and the house is in the DH name....good they're married, but still.

She does work, but he earns triple what she does.

FrippEnos · 24/08/2022 17:30

NovaDeltas · 24/08/2022 17:24

"It is very clear to me that the DH is a victim of domestic violence"

If the definition is now that a swearing, aggressive male who gets a slap on the arm is a boo-boo victim in need of counselling, treatment and a parade, we may as well give up now. Words have meanings. He hasn't been lamped across the face with a saucepan. I'm sure he'll get over his trauma.

As you think that there are acceptable levels of violence maybe you should write a list so that we can understand what is acceptable and what is not.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 17:29

You've ended up in the age old situation of having no money and no job so he thinks you won't leave. No easy fixes for that.

OP has a job and money.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 17:28

NovaDeltas · 24/08/2022 17:24

"It is very clear to me that the DH is a victim of domestic violence"

If the definition is now that a swearing, aggressive male who gets a slap on the arm is a boo-boo victim in need of counselling, treatment and a parade, we may as well give up now. Words have meanings. He hasn't been lamped across the face with a saucepan. I'm sure he'll get over his trauma.

The OP was also swearing and aggressive. But shes the only one hitting her partner and has done so more than once.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 17:26

DontBlameMe79 · 24/08/2022 17:02

I’m not sure what many posters on this thread are on, but of course he deserved a slap based on OPs description. Bleating on about male DV is just silly and overdramatising. He’s a grown man for goodness sake and OP needed to get his attention. So I do excuse her hitting him. When did men become so delicate? They are men…

No he did not “deserve a slap”

Slapping is often seen as just a slap, rather than a form of physical abuse.
www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/insight-is-2020/201207/how-define-physical-abuse-in-relationships-slap-push

”Allowing for any circumstances in which slapping or other types of physical violence is okay is a serious problem that threatens your own emotional stability, as well as the stability of your romantic relationship. Should you ever find yourself slapping or getting slapped by a partner — even just once — your relationship is in major trouble, and possibly beyond repair.

Violence is one of the ugliest colors of human nature, and engaging in any violence at all often begets further violence. If you tell yourself that there are some situations in which it would be understandable — though not ideal or right — to slap your partner, what you’re doing is giving yourself the option in the future to hit your own partner if sufficiently provoked. If you tell yourself it’s never okay to slap or hit your lover, you will hold yourself more accountable, not make excuses for yourself, and force yourself to manage your angry feelings when they overwhelm you.”

“If you ask anyone who's ever been violent toward another person — as I've asked many clients over the years — what it feels like to hit someone, you'll hear that hitting someone provides a powerful dose of immediate gratification for all the rageful, pent-up feelings. This kind of gratification is hard to get over, making the hitter more likely to do it again. Beyond the obvious reason that slapping or hitting someone is wrong and immoral, you shouldn't hit because you don't want to open the door to indulging a highly destructive catharsis that hurts everyone in its path.”

NovaDeltas · 24/08/2022 17:24

"It is very clear to me that the DH is a victim of domestic violence"

If the definition is now that a swearing, aggressive male who gets a slap on the arm is a boo-boo victim in need of counselling, treatment and a parade, we may as well give up now. Words have meanings. He hasn't been lamped across the face with a saucepan. I'm sure he'll get over his trauma.

NovaDeltas · 24/08/2022 17:22

He doesn't exactly sound like he brings anything to the table. I can't really get worked up about a tap on the arm.

You've ended up in the age old situation of having no money and no job so he thinks you won't leave. No easy fixes for that.

But it's over, really. You're lashing out, he's threatening you and swearing at a child. Your son will be far more damaged by his disinterested father than your DH will be by a slap on the arm.

FrippEnos · 24/08/2022 17:18

DontBlameMe79

The point is that all violence is wrong.

When did men become so delicate? They are men…
that type of view is exactly the problem

DontBlameMe79 · 24/08/2022 17:02

I’m not sure what many posters on this thread are on, but of course he deserved a slap based on OPs description. Bleating on about male DV is just silly and overdramatising. He’s a grown man for goodness sake and OP needed to get his attention. So I do excuse her hitting him. When did men become so delicate? They are men…

beastlyslumber · 24/08/2022 14:08

OMG the MRAs are out in force on this thread.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 12:27

PurpleDaisies · 24/08/2022 12:07

To be clear, I’m not excusing the op hitting her partner. She should not have done that. There are long standing issues in this relationship for which they are both at fault. They need to urgently change things for the benefit of their child.

Agreed.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 12:27

Thornethorn · 24/08/2022 10:27

If the man in question was a victim of DV or felt himself to be such, it seems highly unlikely that he would deliberately place himself and his wife in a position where she couldn't comfort her crying child. He would be trying to avoid such volatility. Instead he doesn't give a toss.

After the first slap under similar circumstances, I think he was trying to avoid a repeat.

The DC was crying, the DH kept on playing his game as he knew OP was home and was in control. He thinks the DC should CIO. Last time he tried to convince OP to leave the DC to cry, he was slapped. So he probably feels it’s best to leave the DC to the OP to do what she wants and keep well away from it all when the OP is at home.

The OP woke up hearing the DC crying saying she was feeling “irrationally angry” with the DH. She first went to him, “interrupted his precious game” telling him to go to the DCs room. When they’re both there, the DC is screaming that he wants to go downstairs. The DH disagrees and says the OP giving in is causing the DCs behaviour. The OP then swears at her DH, tells him to go to bed, and when he doesn’t move she slaps him on the arm and tells him to get out.

He didn’t place himself in the DCs room to block access. She had sent him to the DCs room, only to then order him to bed. Why did she not go direct to her “hysterically” crying DC?

PurpleDaisies · 24/08/2022 12:07

To be clear, I’m not excusing the op hitting her partner. She should not have done that. There are long standing issues in this relationship for which they are both at fault. They need to urgently change things for the benefit of their child.

PurpleDaisies · 24/08/2022 12:04

And in a case like this where the female partner is doing 100% of the hitting

You need to read the op’s other threads or pay attention to what has been posted on this one.

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 11:58

Meraas · 24/08/2022 07:22

She explained that her DH was acting as a physical barrier between her and her hysterical child.

Whst mother can bear that?

The mothers that don’t hit their partners.

You’re also conveniently ignoring the sequence of events where upon waking to hear the DC crying around midnight, she felt “irrationally angry” towards her DH, she went to where he was online gaming “interrupted his precious game“ and told him to go to the DCs room. He went to the DCs room. The DC was screaming he wanted to go downstairs, but the DH said he shouldn’t be allowed to and that OP giving in is the cause of this behaviour. OP disagreed so she swore at him. Told him to go to bed. He didn’t move. So she slapped him on the arm and told him to get out. All in front of the DC.

He wasn’t there in the DCs room with her to block her, he was there because she’d told him to go there. If she hadn’t “interrupted his precious game” he’d not have been there to express an opinion and be slapped for it.

Sorry, but the “physical barrier” is an excuse for the inexcusable, and it’s also concerning OP has worded this in a way that dehumanises her partner into the equivalent of a traffic cone to be batted to one side.

Did you know that the England and Wales 2017/18 crime survey found that 32% of male victims of domestic abuse and 23% of women suffered a physical injury? Did you know that the England and Wales 2018/19 crime survey also found that 2.8% of heterosexual men and 5.6% of heterosexual women were victims of partner abuse? So 1 in 3 victims of heterosexual partner abuse are men. It’s more common than you are willing to admit.

And in a case like this where the female partner is doing 100% of the hitting, and is incredibly invested in justifying her actions and seeking support on MN- not to stop slapping, but to hear she isn’t abusive, to hear she was ‘at the end of her tether’ so it’s excusable, to hear ‘he’s a useless piece of shit and deserved it’ so she was justified and so on. And you’ve given her the victim blaming ammunition she’s needed to quiet what little bit of a conscience and guilt she feels about hitting her partner being wrong. You’ve done everything you can to support her into feeling like a righteous slappy hand of justice and to feed her anger towards her DH by calling her the victim because he’s ‘driven her to it’ with his ‘appalling behaviour’.

It is very clear to me that the DH is a victim of domestic violence and your “advice” is encouraging an abusive woman. If not to continue using violence in the current relationship, then to think it’s acceptable for her to slap any partner in similar situations when it is unequivocally unacceptable domestic violence.

Meraas · 24/08/2022 11:06

Thornethorn · 24/08/2022 10:23

My wife didn't do as I asked, so I slapped her.

It's not as simple as that. A man could simply move a woman out of the way if he wished to reach and tend to his distressed child. He would be able to achieve this easily (although there are no threads like this because that scenario doesn't happen, if only men wanted to tend to their crying babies!!). A woman is in a completely different position.

Exactly!

Sometimeswinning · 24/08/2022 10:29

PolishingCandles · 24/08/2022 09:41

@Sometimeswinning Ah well, don't worry about it, I don't.

If I didn't worry I wouldn't have posted on this thread. You carry on not worrying (whilst replying in quick succession to my posts)

Thornethorn · 24/08/2022 10:27

If the man in question was a victim of DV or felt himself to be such, it seems highly unlikely that he would deliberately place himself and his wife in a position where she couldn't comfort her crying child. He would be trying to avoid such volatility. Instead he doesn't give a toss.

Thornethorn · 24/08/2022 10:23

My wife didn't do as I asked, so I slapped her.

It's not as simple as that. A man could simply move a woman out of the way if he wished to reach and tend to his distressed child. He would be able to achieve this easily (although there are no threads like this because that scenario doesn't happen, if only men wanted to tend to their crying babies!!). A woman is in a completely different position.

Worrieddaughter29 · 24/08/2022 09:46

@PolishingCandles OP’s husband is a groper, sex pest, controlling and manipulative arsehole if you look through her posting history.
it doesn’t justify her hitting him but I don’t think the ongoing victim in this relationship is the husband.