Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I hit DH

310 replies

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 03:32

I slapped DH on the arm.

For context, my 3-year-old DS is a terrible sleeper. We usually put him to bed at around 8 or 9 but he’s often awake by midnight screaming hysterically and wanting to go downstairs. We’ve tried the “cry it out” method to no avail and we’re both sleep deprived.

I came back from work tonight and DS was
asleep. When I started to drift off around midnight, he woke up and started screaming. At this point, I was irrationally annoyed with DH who was gaming with his online mates. I’ve been up since just before 6 am but I stayed up with DS the night before last (I think. I’m actually getting my days mixed up). I asked DH to help me settle him and he seemed so pissed off I interrupted his precious game. DS was screaming that he wanted to go downstairs but DH wanted to let him cry it out. His crying became more and more hysterical whilst DH told me I’m the cause of his behaviour for giving into him at bed time. Truthfully, I just can’t let him cry it out, especially when he starts thrashing and hyperventilating like he’s going to be sick and sometimes even head butting (suspected ASD).

I swore at DH and told him to go to bed because I would stay up with DS. He didn’t move and without a thought I slapped his arm and told him to get out. He turned around and told me that if I ever hit him again he would break my fingers. I know I shouldn’t have slapped him but it honestly wasn’t hard at all. DH even said so but said there was malice there. Again, I know I’m making excuses for myself but he has (playfully) slapped my bum twice as hard when I’ve stood up next to him. Still, if he’d have done that to me tonight I’d be shocked and angry.

I'm just incredibly frustrated. He doesn’t really do anything with DS when he finishes work. It would be nice if he took him to the park for half hour or even kicked a ball around with him (he’s such a busy, active child). Yesterday, he shouted and swore at me in front of DS and my MIL who actually pulled him up on it and texted me
today to see if I was okay.

I want to create a sensory room for DS to see if it helps his sleep but DH isn’t interested so I have to pay for all of it. Despite being on less than half his salary.

I still hit him though.

OP posts:
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 25/08/2022 18:30

DillAte · 25/08/2022 12:40

@QNC
Good to know. I will bear it in mind in future.
The poster I replied to seemed to suggest that OP was being abused and the husband was not.

I can't imagine how you can see the lead-up to the situation she described as abusive, whilst not finding her striking her husband abusive UNLESS you think there are certain behaviour that would justify a wife striking her husband.

The easiest way to help people see the issues with this is a role reversal because empathy seems to correlate with a person's ability to find similarities between themselves and the target.

The husband has a view on parenting. One of her previous posts even states that his CIO idea worked for a period. The idea that it is ok for differences in parental approach to be settled by physical violence is absurd to me.

If the relationship is not working for her (and it does not sound like it is), the correct response is some sort of mediation/counselling or leaving.

Can I remind you of the Sally Challen case? She was driven to killing someone, so yes sometimes otherwise wrong actions are a result of historic abuse suffered by the perpetrator.

Having read OPs previous posts, I think this could be a classic example.

Whiskeypowers · 25/08/2022 17:02

DillAte · 25/08/2022 12:40

@QNC
Good to know. I will bear it in mind in future.
The poster I replied to seemed to suggest that OP was being abused and the husband was not.

I can't imagine how you can see the lead-up to the situation she described as abusive, whilst not finding her striking her husband abusive UNLESS you think there are certain behaviour that would justify a wife striking her husband.

The easiest way to help people see the issues with this is a role reversal because empathy seems to correlate with a person's ability to find similarities between themselves and the target.

The husband has a view on parenting. One of her previous posts even states that his CIO idea worked for a period. The idea that it is ok for differences in parental approach to be settled by physical violence is absurd to me.

If the relationship is not working for her (and it does not sound like it is), the correct response is some sort of mediation/counselling or leaving.

Why didn’t you read the other posts then?
or did you and get a better idea of her situation and how he absolutely is abusive.

Lovelock1984 · 25/08/2022 13:18

It is clear even through reading just this thread and the replies from the OP not only does he physically abuse her (after all he hits her bum even though she doesn't like it), mentally and financially abuses her too. There is a clear difference in being kept away from your child while they become hysterical and lashing out than being abused.

To the OP - please don't for one second that your husbands actions or words are reasonable. He doesn't care for you and you do not deserve to be treated as you are. I know its hard but please prioritise yourself and your own mental health. Ignore the comments cruxifying you - they don't know what it's like living in an environment such as yours and have jumped on you trying to make you the scapegoat. You are not and are simply broken by a man who doesn't deserve you or your child. You deserve better.

DillAte · 25/08/2022 12:40

@QNC
Good to know. I will bear it in mind in future.
The poster I replied to seemed to suggest that OP was being abused and the husband was not.

I can't imagine how you can see the lead-up to the situation she described as abusive, whilst not finding her striking her husband abusive UNLESS you think there are certain behaviour that would justify a wife striking her husband.

The easiest way to help people see the issues with this is a role reversal because empathy seems to correlate with a person's ability to find similarities between themselves and the target.

The husband has a view on parenting. One of her previous posts even states that his CIO idea worked for a period. The idea that it is ok for differences in parental approach to be settled by physical violence is absurd to me.

If the relationship is not working for her (and it does not sound like it is), the correct response is some sort of mediation/counselling or leaving.

PurpleDaisies · 25/08/2022 12:01

How irritating does a husband need to find his wife's behaviour before he is justified in slapping her?

Nobody should be slapping each other. Male on male. Male on female. Female on male. Female on female. Adult on child. Child on child.

The op should not have slapped her husband. That event did not happen in isolation though. She has said many worrying things about their relationship and the fact she slapped her husband doesn’t negate that. She needs support to leave or seriously change things.

QNC · 25/08/2022 11:51

DillAte · 25/08/2022 11:42

@QNC
I don't see anything in OP's posts that suggest that. I don't have a premium account so I can't see any of her previous topics.
This also has absolutely nothing to do with my question.
How irritating does a husband need to find his wife's behaviour before he is justified in slapping her?

You don't need a premium account to see her previous threads.

I'm actually not sure what your question has to do with the post you originally quoted, given Lovelock doesn't seem to be suggesting that the husband being "irritating" meant the slap was justified.

Whiskeypowers · 25/08/2022 11:49

@DillAte
you don’t need a premium account to do a search
just put op’s username in the search facility. You will be able to read them …….

DillAte · 25/08/2022 11:42

@QNC
I don't see anything in OP's posts that suggest that. I don't have a premium account so I can't see any of her previous topics.
This also has absolutely nothing to do with my question.
How irritating does a husband need to find his wife's behaviour before he is justified in slapping her?

Thornethorn · 25/08/2022 11:15

QNC
So here's allowed to hit her regularly despite her protests because in his head he's doing it for fun, while she's not allowed to slap him lightly when he is blocking her way to her distressed baby?

That's awful. There is so much misogyny on this thread.

QNC · 25/08/2022 10:47

DillAte · 25/08/2022 10:38

How irritating does a woman need to be before it's ok for her husband to hit her?
Is the standard the same?

OP's husband is already doing that. He slaps her bum every time she bends over despite knowing she doesn't like it. If OP's two slaps mean she us a violent abuser, what does that make her husband who is slapping and groping regularly?

DillAte · 25/08/2022 10:38

Lovelock1984 · 25/08/2022 09:28

The people that are actually supporting the husband here need to give their head a wobble. You need to have a serious think about the environment the husband has caused for the OP - it is clear she is being abused and needs to leave for her safety as well as her sons. Take a minute to leave all your clear grudges at the door and look at this situation in its form. The OP here is the victim.

How irritating does a woman need to be before it's ok for her husband to hit her?
Is the standard the same?

Lovelock1984 · 25/08/2022 09:28

The people that are actually supporting the husband here need to give their head a wobble. You need to have a serious think about the environment the husband has caused for the OP - it is clear she is being abused and needs to leave for her safety as well as her sons. Take a minute to leave all your clear grudges at the door and look at this situation in its form. The OP here is the victim.

Whiskeypowers · 25/08/2022 08:54

FrippEnos · 25/08/2022 07:59

Whiskeypowers

Again the insult is thrown about.

But you do you.

Your response is steeped in ignorance in that it has no basis in fact.
You don't know if he will be "abusive" again.
You don't know if the OP will hit someone again.

Its all supposition and are you saying that this situation isn't toxic as you said ignorant.

Have you read her other posts? Go and do just that.

a response to facts can also be as ignorant as one based on supposition incidentally.

a toxic relationship requires sustained bouts of mutually damaging and reinforcing behaviour and considerably less inequity on every basis. Neither of those things are at play here.

as I’ve stated to another poster more then happy to disagree with someone. Applies to you too.

Whiskeypowers · 25/08/2022 08:47

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 25/08/2022 06:47

Thats what this whole thread screams, it's not ok but.... it kind of is because he did... That is what people will read this as, what women who are 'just' slapped a little will take from it. What abusive men will. We don't teach out kids it's not ok, but .. the law doesn't say it's not ok, but... its kinda of ok because you were forced into it. We shouldn't be repeating the things gaslighting abusive men say as if they were ever valid arguments for why what they do is ok. I wish I had no idea. I should
have hidden this thread when I saw where it was going, I feel sick reading people sprouting the same justifications as him, so I will click away and you can think what you will.

It’s the language you mistakenly apply that causes the issue - “justify”

nobody is justifying anything. If you are being abused why is it your role to justify what is being done to you or your response?

Discovereads · 25/08/2022 08:46

I think a lot of posters have experience with only female victims of domestic abuse, and are not familiar with male victims of domestic abuse.

And in this instance, her husband wasn't actually hurt at all, given that it was less forceful than a playful bum slap.

Thats what the person doing the hitting says. It’s very common for partners who hit to claim their hitting didn’t actually hurt or wasn’t that hard in an effort to deny the abuse. I wonder whether the person on the receiving end would agree that being slapped didn’t hurt? And I thought we were long past the you must have bruises or its not abuse myth.

And then there is a partner who is simply not stepping up when it's required, by his wife and child, because he wants to play his video game.

Many female abusers of men establish a narrative of the useless partner/father to justify their actions. She hit him during one night crying incident, so now he leaves her to handle the night crying sessions. That’s a pretty normal reaction really to try and avoid situations where you’ve been hit. Then when she decides she wants him present at a midnight one, she orders him away from his online mates & game to the DCs room, then she swears at him and hits him again in response to nothing amounting to any kind of abuse at all from him. Now she can complain she does all the night wakings which is yet more ammunition to claim he’s a useless father. But is he? OP complains about the food he cooks for himself and DC. She skips over the fact he’s on his game late at night after caring for the DC and doing the bedtime routine while she’s at work. Is cooking dinner for the DC and getting them to bed before playing a game in the evening the act of a neglectful father?. She complains bitterly that he makes more than twice as much money than what she does, so he’s contributing financially.

FrippEnos · 25/08/2022 07:59

Whiskeypowers

Again the insult is thrown about.

But you do you.

Your response is steeped in ignorance in that it has no basis in fact.
You don't know if he will be "abusive" again.
You don't know if the OP will hit someone again.

Its all supposition and are you saying that this situation isn't toxic as you said ignorant.

QNC · 25/08/2022 07:49

Discovereads, did you actually look up OP's previous threads about her husband, as PPs suggested?

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 25/08/2022 06:47

Thats what this whole thread screams, it's not ok but.... it kind of is because he did... That is what people will read this as, what women who are 'just' slapped a little will take from it. What abusive men will. We don't teach out kids it's not ok, but .. the law doesn't say it's not ok, but... its kinda of ok because you were forced into it. We shouldn't be repeating the things gaslighting abusive men say as if they were ever valid arguments for why what they do is ok. I wish I had no idea. I should
have hidden this thread when I saw where it was going, I feel sick reading people sprouting the same justifications as him, so I will click away and you can think what you will.

Whiskeypowers · 25/08/2022 04:01

@LunaAndHerMoonDragons
”Leaving aside who is abusive or toxic or whatever, is it really best for women suffering DV to have this narrative be supported that slapping is ok in certain circumstances?”

it’s not ok. Who said it was “ok”?
what some of us have done is tried to place this reaction/ behaviour in the context of what we believe is an abusive dynamic, the abuse being inflicted by the husband. There is nobody who has explored this who is handing her a Blue Peter badge. Neither is she to herself.

in answer to your “question” above, it is appropriate women are supported in such circumstances if they are indeed suffering domestic violence and said abuse is the catalyst for this sort of reaction. Supported to get help and leave and develop mechanisms to identify abuse as well as prevent it happening again. Part of that involves a series of realisations about the abused and the abuser. In this specific context parroting that violence is wrong is unnecessary. They already know. That knowledge and shame that this is what they been reduced to is not the mark of an abuser.

if you and other people - particularly women - cannot cope with this analogy and consider its implications then it’s as harmful as telling women in these desperate situations that it’s all their fault or that you don’t believe them. It reminds me of the “why doesn’t she just leave” vantage point. Mostly those trotting that out have no idea.

MangyInseam · 25/08/2022 03:07

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 25/08/2022 02:07

I wonder if all the posters saying it's ok because.... realise that they are putting a narrative out their that abusive men will read and will take onboard? They're not going to read this and think oh this is different because it's the woman who hit. They're going to see all these posts and think all these women agree that slapping someone because you were angry and exhausted is ok. They aren't going to take on any nuance, they are going to see this as an excuse for their behaviour. Leaving aside who is abusive or toxic or whatever, is it really best for women suffering DV to have this narrative be supported that slapping is ok in certain circumstances? Any men that are capable of understanding any possible difference between this and systemic abuse won't be the ones that are abusing women.

What you are saying here is that it is ok to be less than truthful about what happens in real, specific circumstances, if it serves your purpose.

If you can't talk about what's real, you have nothing.

MangyInseam · 25/08/2022 03:05

BrimFullOfAsher · 23/08/2022 06:47

Completely agree @GiltEdges

Had this been her husband to her, there wouldn't be a single person making excuses and defending him.

My opinion would be the same. It's not good, shows a loss of control, but not totally surprising under the circumstances with a tired parent who is totally unsupported with a child who isn't easily managed. These are the kinds of situations where child abuse can happen too, because the parent is not able to cope. It doesn't mean they don't love their kids. And in this instance, her husband wasn't actually hurt at all, given that it was less forceful than a playful bum slap.

And then there is a partner who is simply not stepping up when it's required, by his wife and child, because he wants to play his video game.

The idea that all physical aggression is the same is just not true. No matter whether it involves men or women.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 25/08/2022 02:41

Your husband sounds horrible OP, he could well be abusive. Your behaviour is at least toxic though, not ok to hit or make excuses afterwards. Stbxh is abusive, I could understand losing it and hitting out reactively, but what makes no sense to me is he hasn't done whatever necessary to get back in control, to gaslight and blame you. If I hit stbxh the moment after I slapped him I'd feel terrified. At best he would make me feel utterly horrible and worthless and to blame for everything including his behaviour for the whole of our relationship, there'd be a good chance he'd throw or kick things and scream, he's scary, at worst I really don't know if he'd escalate to something like pushing. I can't imagine hitting him and not being made to pay for it.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 25/08/2022 02:07

I wonder if all the posters saying it's ok because.... realise that they are putting a narrative out their that abusive men will read and will take onboard? They're not going to read this and think oh this is different because it's the woman who hit. They're going to see all these posts and think all these women agree that slapping someone because you were angry and exhausted is ok. They aren't going to take on any nuance, they are going to see this as an excuse for their behaviour. Leaving aside who is abusive or toxic or whatever, is it really best for women suffering DV to have this narrative be supported that slapping is ok in certain circumstances? Any men that are capable of understanding any possible difference between this and systemic abuse won't be the ones that are abusing women.

Discovereads · 25/08/2022 00:00

Whiskeypowers · 24/08/2022 23:37

You wlll be waiting a long time if you think anything that comes out of your mouth - so to speak - regarding domestic abuse will resonate with me.

you are ignorant
happy to pass that insult your way

Happy to be anywhere but on the same page as you.

i’m not insulted by your response. It’s validation for me. It’s a huge compliment that you find me ignorant because I would never want to be associated with the retrograde claptrap you’re spouting

hope that helps clarify things

I didn’t say you were ignorant! I was quoting your insults to me and the equal sign meant they’re exactly the same as just calling me ignorant. Ignorant seems to be your go to insult, no matter how flowery you word it. It’s all over this thread.

ManateeFair · 24/08/2022 23:43

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 15:53

i don’t abuse my husband full stop. I don’t routinely insult his intelligence and make underhand remarks disguised as “banter” leaving him confused as to whether I’m being serious or whether he’s too sensitive. He does that shit to me though.

I sometimes mispronounce words or get them jumbled. I mispronounced the name of a town years ago and I’m still the butt of his jokes in front of family and friends. I had major brain fog in work the other day (probably from sleep deprivation) and told my mil that my colleagues must think I’m thick as two short planks. He retorted by telling her how I mispronounce stuff and laughing at me. He’s laughed about my lack of qualifications in front of his family. I mentioned I was going to take my (19 y/o) little brother to an empty car park and let him play around with the gears in my car, get used to the clutch, etc. He saw fit to shout and swear at me and tell his family how I can’t even park in our driveway without crashing into his car (i
barely touched it). His own mother told him he was behaving like his father who reportedly abused her for years. DS was crying at this point. His response was to block his mum on social media and call her a bitch.

I come home from work and he can’t even put his fucking crisp packets in the bin because apparently he has OCD. Tons of dirty dishes and he’s lying on the sofa watching YouTubers shoot people on Fortnite. Or he’s watching Pokémon for the 51748th time. He whinges about the food I cook but will shove 20 chicken nuggets in the air fryer for him and DS whilst moaning to his family that i make spaghetti bolognese every week (it’s the only food I can hide vegetables in).

He’s the main earner but has no money to take us out for the day. Didn’t stop him fucking off to
chester for three days (his mate’s wedding) and leaving me with a poorly ds. But he has “no money”.

But I can see how I’m a horrible person.

OP, I absolutely believe your husband is a horrible man.

But the solution is to leave him, not to hit him.

You literally despise each other, from the sound of it, and you should not be in a relationship.