Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I hit DH

310 replies

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 03:32

I slapped DH on the arm.

For context, my 3-year-old DS is a terrible sleeper. We usually put him to bed at around 8 or 9 but he’s often awake by midnight screaming hysterically and wanting to go downstairs. We’ve tried the “cry it out” method to no avail and we’re both sleep deprived.

I came back from work tonight and DS was
asleep. When I started to drift off around midnight, he woke up and started screaming. At this point, I was irrationally annoyed with DH who was gaming with his online mates. I’ve been up since just before 6 am but I stayed up with DS the night before last (I think. I’m actually getting my days mixed up). I asked DH to help me settle him and he seemed so pissed off I interrupted his precious game. DS was screaming that he wanted to go downstairs but DH wanted to let him cry it out. His crying became more and more hysterical whilst DH told me I’m the cause of his behaviour for giving into him at bed time. Truthfully, I just can’t let him cry it out, especially when he starts thrashing and hyperventilating like he’s going to be sick and sometimes even head butting (suspected ASD).

I swore at DH and told him to go to bed because I would stay up with DS. He didn’t move and without a thought I slapped his arm and told him to get out. He turned around and told me that if I ever hit him again he would break my fingers. I know I shouldn’t have slapped him but it honestly wasn’t hard at all. DH even said so but said there was malice there. Again, I know I’m making excuses for myself but he has (playfully) slapped my bum twice as hard when I’ve stood up next to him. Still, if he’d have done that to me tonight I’d be shocked and angry.

I'm just incredibly frustrated. He doesn’t really do anything with DS when he finishes work. It would be nice if he took him to the park for half hour or even kicked a ball around with him (he’s such a busy, active child). Yesterday, he shouted and swore at me in front of DS and my MIL who actually pulled him up on it and texted me
today to see if I was okay.

I want to create a sensory room for DS to see if it helps his sleep but DH isn’t interested so I have to pay for all of it. Despite being on less than half his salary.

I still hit him though.

OP posts:
SophieIsHereToday · 23/08/2022 11:55

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 11:47

OP, your husband sounds abusive.
Threatening to break your fingers is scary.

This has got to be a joke surely!

How is threatening to assault someone abusive but actually physically assaulting someone not abusive?

When my partner hit me I told him to leave and that if he ever tried it again I would kill him - he was in the wrong not me.

This is sad. But the really damaging thing with DV is often the mental intimidation and fear. This can have a longer lasting impact than bruising.

If the threat of broken fingers was genuinely credible, believed or caused intimidation, then this is also abusive. .... So I wouldn't underestimate the impact of a credible threat of violence. It depends on how the threat is received, if the threat is laughed at/scoffed at then it did not intimidate.... Perhaps your threat to kill your husband wasn't taken seriously? But if it was then it could be as bad as being hit

....OP was also in the wrong, both are wrong

Margot78 · 23/08/2022 11:52

Please don’t leave your child to cry anymore. No child should be left to cry it out, but a child with possible additional needs is even more vulnerable to being ignored. It will just make him more and more distressed and consequently you will be more stressed and things will quickly turn toxic. Please seek professional help for his sleep issues so that you can have better techniques to respond calmly. Please.

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 11:47

OP, your husband sounds abusive.
Threatening to break your fingers is scary.

This has got to be a joke surely!

How is threatening to assault someone abusive but actually physically assaulting someone not abusive?

When my partner hit me I told him to leave and that if he ever tried it again I would kill him - he was in the wrong not me.

longtompot · 23/08/2022 11:42

My dd (22) has one of these, or a similar one, for when her pain levels are so high in the middle of the night she can't do anything to help. It's just something to watch instead of looking at a blank ceiling. It might be something that helps your ds go back off to sleep.
homeactyve.com/products/galaxy-projection-lamp?currency=GBP&variant=41436827713729&utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&utm_campaign=Google%20Shopping&gclid=Cj0KCQjw9ZGYBhCEARIsAEUXITXAxkb5gho8NnJidx8_KdPlw4O7h8yxX8GU9mTmiKYqqJWqoyLX0hAaAu67EALw_wcB
You both need to talk as resorting to violence is not the answer, whether it was a hard hit or not. Too many people have spoken on here about how their other half starred with a light tap and it just escalates. He needs to understand that playing whilst his child is so upset is not on, especially when you are the one doing the early starts and working. But you need to talk, agree an amicable way to deal with this, and then if you really are on different pages, you need to work out how to do this apart.

Choconut · 23/08/2022 11:39

It's not ideal but I think it's different from a man hitting a woman mainly because of the balance of power - at the end of the day he is much stronger and more powerful than her.

She slapped him on the arm but no one seems to notice that his idea of retaliation would have been to break her fingers. That's the difference. Hers is a slap leaving probably no mark, no fear (clearly from what he said) just a bit of surprise - and in return he would break her fingers. That's the difference.

OP it's wasn't the ideal way to deal with the situation and isn't going to move things forward in useful or positive way. This man doesn't sound like a good husband or good father and it sounds like you're at the end of your tether. There are huge cracks starting to show in this relationship and I think it's time to go your own way. This is no way to live.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/08/2022 11:33

I would slap someone who was standing between me and my extremely distressed child. If you don't like the heat, get out of the kitchen.

That's fine, and if they slapped you back, that's okay with you I guess. Don't like the heat, get out of the kitchen I suppose

SoupDragon · 23/08/2022 11:32

And yes, pearl clutchers, you're right, I wouldn't say that if he was the one slapping her. Why not? Because he's a man. It's different

no, it's because you're a hypocrite.

Thornethorn · 23/08/2022 11:30

I would slap someone who was standing between me and my extremely distressed child. If you don't like the heat, get out of the kitchen.

You know this is not your finest hour OP but your faults are massively overshadowed by your husband's. I would think seriously about leaving if things don't improve with counselling. Which you both need individually and together.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/08/2022 11:23

beastlyslumber · 23/08/2022 11:22

And I don't think a slap on the arm is a 'violent attack'. No, it's not good, but it's completely understandable. And yes, pearl clutchers, you're right, I wouldn't say that if he was the one slapping her. Why not? Because he's a man. It's different.

No it's not different. It's still not excusable for a woman to hit a man.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/08/2022 11:22

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 10:56

this is so tiresome. It’s just not the same thing. The point about abuse is not that there is violence full stop, but is this part of a pattern of control, or intimidation. Does OP sound to you like she is routinely battering her husband? This is basically reverse what-aboutery.

Are you seriously saying that it’s ok for a man to hit a women as long as it’s not an ongoing thing or part of a pattern of abuse?

FFS raise your bar.

It’s never ok for a man to hit a women, even if it’s ‘just once’.
And it’s never ok for a women to hit a man or couples to hit each other in same sex relationships.

This. No one should be using physical violence.

Hiddenmnetter · 23/08/2022 11:22

Oh come on, the bar for DV isn’t “are you being routinely hit?”

no it obviously isn’t. Good thing that isn’t what I said. Fuck the level of general comprehension is poor. I’m saying that a one-off incidence of violence that does not fit within a wider pattern of coercion, intimidation and other attempts to undermine, isolate and control the partner are not quite the same thing as abuse are they?

please note- I’m not saying that it’s ok- it’s not a “well done OP you slapped your husband” - I’m just saying it’s not the same thing as abuse.

complaining that an incident like this in reverse would be immediately treated differently is reflective of the different context- that men are in the overwhelming majority of cases physically dominant, and that it doesn’t sound like OP is attempting to coerce, control or intimidate her husband, would make me say this is not abuse.

it’s almost like people are so frightened of the fact that men might not be able to be held accountable for violence, that the only possible means of dealing with it socially is to ascribe all violence the absolutely same category and thus a woman driven to distraction who slapped her husband once on the arm while exhausted is “abusive” the same as a man who manipulates, controls, terrifies, and oppressed his wife, and has only hit her, once, not even that hard, but which she has directly understood as a threat “do that again and you’ll be in real trouble”.

they’re not the same. No amount of stupidity and unwillingness to engage with the context is convincing that “all violence is abuse”.

beastlyslumber · 23/08/2022 11:22

And I don't think a slap on the arm is a 'violent attack'. No, it's not good, but it's completely understandable. And yes, pearl clutchers, you're right, I wouldn't say that if he was the one slapping her. Why not? Because he's a man. It's different.

beastlyslumber · 23/08/2022 11:21

OP, your husband sounds abusive. Threatening to break your fingers is scary. The fact that he's lazing around doing fuck all while you're exhausted and stressed to breaking point.

Honestly, I would leave him. Is there somewhere you could go, any family nearby? What's your housing situation?

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 11:16

This is the same excuse that men tried to use for decades, if not centuries, that they were harassed, nagged, and bullied and they just snapped.

It was wrong for them to use it to explain violence and it’s wrong for you to use it.

I completely agree.

No wonder so many women stay with violent men when apparently it’s fine to be hit if you’ve done something to deserve it.

This is why so many women stay in violent relationships because they’re made to believe it’s their fault.

What’s ironic is the amount of times have women come on here and said they’ve been hit, pushed or even had a pillow punched in front of them and not one poster accuses the OP of bringing it on herself.

JobSeekingMissile · 23/08/2022 11:10

Bnxybee · 23/08/2022 04:28

@PurpleDaisies I’m starting to realise this but I have no savings and the house is in his name. He also earns nearly triple what I earn and has no MH history (that’s logged anyway). He told me once that if I left him he’d fight me for full custody and they probably would favour him tbh because he comes across so well.

I earned the most when we got together and he moved out of his mum’s into my flat. Had a substantial amount of money saved too.

They all say that. It's a script intended to control you.

Sometimeswinning · 23/08/2022 11:07

LaFemmeNicola · 23/08/2022 11:02

This is the same excuse that men tried to use for decades, if not centuries, that they were harassed, nagged, and bullied and they just snapped.

It was wrong for them to use it to explain violence and it’s wrong for you to use it.

If you are having trouble telling the difference between men using nagging as a reason and the years of violence and mental abuse of some women from their physically and mentally stronger partner/husband. Its time to educate yourself.

You are wrong to compare them.

RubbishRobotFromTheDawnOfTime · 23/08/2022 11:05

He wasn’t in fear, he wasn’t worried she might hurt him or worse. He was annoyed she was going against what he told her to do. He threatened to do her much more harm in retaliation, harm that she couldn’t ever to do to him. He was blocking access to their crying child.

LaFemmeNicola · 23/08/2022 11:02

Sometimeswinning · 23/08/2022 07:48

Dont be ridiculous, her dh won't last 5 minutes by himself with a child.

Plus how about reading the post and the history. I don't blame her for breaking! When you're trapped with an absolute useless excuse of a partner something will happen. I have zero sympathy for him!

This is the same excuse that men tried to use for decades, if not centuries, that they were harassed, nagged, and bullied and they just snapped.

It was wrong for them to use it to explain violence and it’s wrong for you to use it.

Sometimeswinning · 23/08/2022 11:01

SophieIsHereToday · 23/08/2022 10:49

Surely, you would use words to ask him to move. Reason with him. Maybe you would express you are really upset and this is important to you. But that should never translate to physical abuse

How do you reason with someone who does that? Do you wait for them to accepte your reasons for wanting to do something? Or do you sit there and accept you've been told to stay where you are?

We always hear about women pushed to violence every day because they are in abusive relationships. Physical and mental. He has been abusing her, but not many posters want to think too much about that.

LaFemmeNicola · 23/08/2022 10:59

Isaidnoalready · 23/08/2022 06:38

Like he is really going to want custody of a child who disturbs his gaming

The children can’t be left with a violent parent.

LaFemmeNicola · 23/08/2022 10:57

iknowthismuchis · 23/08/2022 04:21

Yes you shouldn't have hit him but he sounds really unkind. Does he actually offer anything in the relationship, do you love him?
Also, have you been to GP about DS sleep? Sleep can be very difficult in children with ASD

“But”…

There’s no but. Physically assaulting your partner is domestic abuse. There is no “but.”

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 10:56

this is so tiresome. It’s just not the same thing. The point about abuse is not that there is violence full stop, but is this part of a pattern of control, or intimidation. Does OP sound to you like she is routinely battering her husband? This is basically reverse what-aboutery.

Are you seriously saying that it’s ok for a man to hit a women as long as it’s not an ongoing thing or part of a pattern of abuse?

FFS raise your bar.

It’s never ok for a man to hit a women, even if it’s ‘just once’.
And it’s never ok for a women to hit a man or couples to hit each other in same sex relationships.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 10:53

The point about abuse is not that there is violence full stop, but is this part of a pattern of control, or intimidation. Does OP sound to you like she is routinely battering her husband?

Oh come on, the bar for DV isn’t “are you being routinely hit?”

SunnyD44 · 23/08/2022 10:52

YABU obviously.

Physical violence is never ok.

We tell women all of the time how violence escalates and if you were the one that was hit then posters would be telling you to call the police and LTB.

If a man ever hit me out of anger or frustration it would be over and I wouldn’t blame DH for leaving you or if he had hit you back.

What’s even more concerning is you are obviously stressed out and you did this because your son was crying, so if you snapped at your DH then what’s stopping you from snapping at your DS.

You need to nip this in the bud asap as your hit may not have hurt DH but it would hurt a 3 year old.
Don’t be afraid to reach out for more help.

Hiddenmnetter · 23/08/2022 10:49

Had this been her husband to her, there wouldn't be a single person making excuses and defending him.

this is so tiresome. It’s just not the same thing. The point about abuse is not that there is violence full stop, but is this part of a pattern of control, or intimidation. Does OP sound to you like she is routinely battering her husband? This is basically reverse what-aboutery.

the fact is that in 99.99% of situations, husbands/boyfriends etc can physically dominate their wives/girlfriends in ways that simply aren’t possible in the reverse. The same physical lashing out from him means something very different than it does from her.

does anyone read her OP and think “oh my goodness, she’s been so dreadful and absuive?” Or so you read it and think “my goodness she’s pushed to her limit and snapped”. That doesn’t make it ok, but it also doesn’t make it abusive and it also doesn’t make the relationship toxic.

OP, when children don’t sleep it’s just the fucking worst. First, yes, it’s not good that you slapped his arm, but I’m sure he’s perfectly fine. It’s slightly more concerning that his reaction was to threaten serious harm, however no doubt he also is feeling a heightened stress reaction. You guys need to have a conversation about all that when you are both well rested. It is a very bad idea to have that conversation while you’re both stressed/tired. Everyone will say and do things they normally wouldn’t while under duress. That doesn’t mean that’s “who they really are”- it just means they’re human, and frail, and make mistakes.

it does also sound like your DH is slack and could do a lot more. If your son is ASD/ADHD, he will need more input simply because those kids just do (have 2 with ASD myself). I mean a sensory room sounds like gold standard but it’s probably not necessary. If he will only sleep with someone else, maybe get him a double bed so you or your DH can lie down with him in comfort and once he’s asleep he can be left.

the issues around threatening to fight for full custody etc- well your relationship sounds like it needs work. Only you can decide if that’s terminal or not.