Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to change the way I dress?(very exciting first world problem)...

85 replies

gaymeanshappy · 22/08/2022 23:50

Partner and me both in our 40s both female. This isn't a huge deal, I know she'd love me no matter what. But it gets mentioned.

I dress a little quirky. She dresses very 'on trend' (she's very masculine in her presentation anyway, so jeans and 'men's' shirts/T shirts etc).

She loves clothes, is the kind of person who buys new clothes every holiday, every night/day out etc, won't keep anything if It's not still 'new'.

I like clothes too, but I buy a lot second hand, and I have some in my wardrobe older than me, I'll wear things until they've worn out, and I don't mind keeping clothes that have faded, are past their best, with holes in to just to wear to walk the dog or for gardening or such.

Aside from this, my style is a bit quirky/bohemian ish. I like clothes that are a bit different. I'm a bit different (short of sounding like one of those 'oh I am so crayzee' people) and I think it reflects this, I think fashion is about fun and expression, not wearing whatever the latest trend says to.

I also wear my make up a bit different, I'll wear bright colours at appropriate events (I go to gigs and festivals and the like) and I wear false eyelashes.

I don't do this all the time, sometimes I am in scruffy clothes with no make up, I do sport so wear the usual running tights/shorts and sports tops. When I worked in an office I dressed very professionally, but for going out somewhere I like having a bit of my own style.

Partner buys me clothes as gifts (which is lovely of her) and I usually like them, some nice summer dresses and blouses and jeans etc (I very seldom wear jeans but I've worn the ones she's bought).

She hates that I don't throw old things away. Some of my 'going out' things she really dislikes and if we go out anywhere she'd rather I didn't wear-that's fine of course, but I just have the knowledge that if it were up to her, I'd wear minimal make up always and jeans and a shirt/t shirt 'normal' things. She tells me I look better without make up and that she wishes I'd just wear jeans and sportier/more casual clothes if we go to the pub/out to eat/out to see something.

I feel I'd be losing a little part of me if I changed-It's not just about clothes to me, It's just a little thing that's 'me'. If that makes any sense.

WIBU to not change?

OP posts:
lugeforlife · 23/08/2022 07:43

My husband has opinions on what I wear but he is quiet about them and only offers them when I ask. He has opinions about my hair too (he likes it a bit longer).

I generally ignore him and he expects me to. He gives good feedback on outfits BUT only if I ask. He really likes me in jeans and a nice top kind of outfits for example.

To me this is fine. He has an opinion which he shares when asked but doesn't expect me to embrace if I don't want to. I like that he has a view and a preference and I do consider that on occasion as I like to look nice for him sometimes. If he told me what to wear or suggested I change my style because he wanted me to, I'd tell him to get to fuck.

Importantly he does the same for me. That beard is never coming back.....

category12 · 23/08/2022 07:41

Have you said to her "hey, you seem like you don't really like my style? Could you back off from trying to change my look, tho, as I enjoy playing with my appearance that way, and you did know how I dressed before we got together. "

neverbeenskiing · 23/08/2022 07:37

Ask your Partner this; if she had a straight female friend whose male partner was always telling her how to dress, what would she think of him? Because most reasonable people would think he was a dick.

IrisVersicolor · 23/08/2022 07:33

Personally OP, I prefer your style of dress. I don’t see why your dress sense her business, you’re not trying to get her to dress quirky

Meraas · 23/08/2022 07:31

She…is the kind of person who buys new clothes…won't keep anything if It's not still 'new'.

That’s insane. Her way of doing things sounds terrible. And I agree with pp, she sounds controlling.

MangyInseam · 23/08/2022 07:30

I guess one possibility OP is that your sense of what is appropriate is off. My husband suffers from this, and while usually I say nothing, on occasion I do when I think he is really making a faux pas.

But I suspect that is not what is going on. It sounds to me like your partner is strongly motivated to fit in, and do what is socially seen as "normal" and mainstream, and the fact that you are more unusual and artistic makes her feel uncomfortable. She may not really have thought about it much and so doesn't recognize that is what is going on, but that is my guess.

It might be worth having a bit of a chat about it. And the idea that it is a good idea to throw out perfectly good clothes, it's so wasteful!

RedHelenB · 23/08/2022 07:28

To cut to the chase, are you mutton dressed as lamb? But at the end of the day of course it's your decision. I wouldn't say your partner is controlling to express an opinion if that's the only area of concern either.

GirlOfTudor · 23/08/2022 07:25

Your clothes are an expression of who you are. Don't change that!
It sounds like your partner is trying to morph you into her.
I love that you buy second hand, don't throw away unless needed. I bet you save a lot of money and a lot of waste compared to your partner!

Pegasushaswings · 23/08/2022 07:21

I hate to say it but it sounds like she is embarrassed about the way you dress? Is she the sort of person who cares what people might think?

either way you can’t make someone change their style against their will and you are much more environmentally friendly than she is which is something everyone should be thinking about and making changes in their buying habits.

SilverOnToast · 23/08/2022 07:20

We’re also gay (40s) and very similar in that my DW wears trendy branded items and I’m more offbeat and colourful. Though she loves me for who I am, I naturally “stand out” in what I wear, which I think makes her feel a bit ‘seen’ by association rather than blending in and I think this aspect scares her a bit as she’s naturally introverted. Could this be the case?

I also love charity shops and dressing up as you can find such bargains whereas my DW had a different upbringing where second hand was not as culturally acceptable. I guess I’m wondering if it is controlling, or rather a need for acceptance or to fit in after feeling “other” at some point in her life? Either way, not your problem if you’re finding it all suffocating.

lightcurtains · 23/08/2022 06:19

You have your own style, as does she and I don't think changing that now would make you happy, especially as you feel you'd lose a part of you. That's what dress is about isn't it, it is an expression of who you are, and not everyone does that.

My partner (also female) sometimes makes fun of some of the things I wear and will say "tell me you're not going to wear that". If anything it makes me want to wear it even more! (I'm stubborn sometimes).

Have you spoken to her about how you feel?
I wonder if you described it in the way you've told us, she would hear what you're saying and the impact it could have on you changing a part of who you are.

Nekomata · 23/08/2022 06:14

I don't know. I used to work with a woman who had a very boho style and it just really didn't suit her. She looked terrible most of the time. She was really nice and I would never have said anything to her, but maybe the OP just genuinely doesn't suit the clothes she's wearing. Sometimes, we have to dress to our frame and our coloring. I feel we need Tan France to take a look!

TabithaTittlemouse · 23/08/2022 06:13

She must have been attracted to you as you are when you met?
she sounds really controlling.

ChaToilLeam · 23/08/2022 06:07

I’d be telling her NO, I like my style and have no wish to change it. Have you told her that bluntly? Her reaction might be telling.

Similar to you, I don’t like dressing conservatively, I like second hand and vintage, and spending all my time in jeans and T shirts would make me miserable. It’s not up for negotiation.

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 06:06

No, don't change the way you dress for anyone! I can't stand people who think they can control what another person wears. You sound like you have a real sense of style OP, stay with it and carry on enjoying being you.

ChloeKellyIsAnIcon · 23/08/2022 06:04

From an environmental perspective your way is much better too.

yellowsmileyface · 23/08/2022 05:58

People modify their dress and behaviour for work, is it so bad to occasionally do that for love?

Yes. You should feel comfortable and able to be 100% yourself with a partner. If you're having to modify any aspect of your personality or behaviour, they're not the one.

OP your dress sense sounds awesome!

I can relate to this a lot. An ex of mine didn't like how I dressed (funny how it didn't bother him when we met...). I love bright colours and funky prints, he wanted me to dress very minimalist and neutral. I remember posting about it to reddit (wasn't on MN at the time) and got similar responses telling me we either needed to compromise or we were inherently incompatible.

It didn't feel like something I could compromise on without sacrificing my sense of identity. It also felt silly to break up over something as trivial as dress sense. However over time it really chipped away at my confidence to be with someone who I knew didn't like how I dress.

How you dress is obviously an important aspect of your identity and self expression, and you deserve to be with someone who appreciates it.

Phrenologistsfinger · 23/08/2022 01:30

Your dress sense sounds great! Hers sounds a bit dull and superficial, not to mention unsustainable buying/chucking new clothes regularly - this kind of behaviour needs to change and fast - fashion is a huge carbon source and consumer of water. I’d say she needs to adopt your approach to clothing actually, buying second hand and wearing things for a long time.

FunnyBeaux · 23/08/2022 01:25

Welcome to MN where everything is controlling or abusive. The truth of the matter is that people rightly or wrongly (probably rightly) usually feel that their partner reflects on them. Which is why they want their partner to behave in a way that they feel is appropriate.

If you love her and get enough value out of the relationship, perhaps it's worth sometimes compromising. She's not telling you to completely change your entire identity and personality, just to sometimes dress somewhat more conservative.

People modify their dress and behaviour for work, is it so bad to occasionally do that for love?

Appleblum · 23/08/2022 01:24

No absolutely don't change! You sound like you really have your own sense of style. That's wonderful!

milkyaqua · 23/08/2022 00:53

*begin

Madwife123 · 23/08/2022 00:50

She probably doesn’t realise that you feel like you in your clothes. Maybe suggest to her some clothes that she wouldn’t like and wouldn’t feel like her in so she sees your point.

milkyaqua · 23/08/2022 00:44

She's the one who should change, buying seasonally, and wearing boring clothes! And throwing out/wasting clothing that isn't "new" is reprehensible in my view. There is no time in a woman's life when she needs to start dressing like a straight dull person - unless it's for work, I suppose. There is certainly no reason in your 40s or indeed 80s to being to dress more "demurely".

Itstrueiagree · 23/08/2022 00:36

Don't give up your quirky dress sense! Let her know she's has to accept your style as you are the way that you accept her style.

NoSquirrels · 23/08/2022 00:28

How long have you been together?

Not liking particular outfits - meh. I don’t like some stuff my DH wears, or my teens. I have asked my DH not to wear something before - I’m really the least controlling person ever though! So I don’t think that’s terrifically out of the norm.

She tells me I look better without make up
this is fine, if it’s expressed positively e.g. my DH prefers minimal make up, I’m not offended by this, it’s a preference and he’s never negative about makeup if I’m wearing it.

and that she wishes I'd just wear jeans and sportier/more casual clothes if we go to the pub/out to eat/out to see something.
This IS unreasonable though.