Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to change the way I dress?(very exciting first world problem)...

85 replies

gaymeanshappy · 22/08/2022 23:50

Partner and me both in our 40s both female. This isn't a huge deal, I know she'd love me no matter what. But it gets mentioned.

I dress a little quirky. She dresses very 'on trend' (she's very masculine in her presentation anyway, so jeans and 'men's' shirts/T shirts etc).

She loves clothes, is the kind of person who buys new clothes every holiday, every night/day out etc, won't keep anything if It's not still 'new'.

I like clothes too, but I buy a lot second hand, and I have some in my wardrobe older than me, I'll wear things until they've worn out, and I don't mind keeping clothes that have faded, are past their best, with holes in to just to wear to walk the dog or for gardening or such.

Aside from this, my style is a bit quirky/bohemian ish. I like clothes that are a bit different. I'm a bit different (short of sounding like one of those 'oh I am so crayzee' people) and I think it reflects this, I think fashion is about fun and expression, not wearing whatever the latest trend says to.

I also wear my make up a bit different, I'll wear bright colours at appropriate events (I go to gigs and festivals and the like) and I wear false eyelashes.

I don't do this all the time, sometimes I am in scruffy clothes with no make up, I do sport so wear the usual running tights/shorts and sports tops. When I worked in an office I dressed very professionally, but for going out somewhere I like having a bit of my own style.

Partner buys me clothes as gifts (which is lovely of her) and I usually like them, some nice summer dresses and blouses and jeans etc (I very seldom wear jeans but I've worn the ones she's bought).

She hates that I don't throw old things away. Some of my 'going out' things she really dislikes and if we go out anywhere she'd rather I didn't wear-that's fine of course, but I just have the knowledge that if it were up to her, I'd wear minimal make up always and jeans and a shirt/t shirt 'normal' things. She tells me I look better without make up and that she wishes I'd just wear jeans and sportier/more casual clothes if we go to the pub/out to eat/out to see something.

I feel I'd be losing a little part of me if I changed-It's not just about clothes to me, It's just a little thing that's 'me'. If that makes any sense.

WIBU to not change?

OP posts:
GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 11:15

“Worn out” is holes/rips big enough to be visible from a distance or to mean that the clothing isn’t as warm as it should be I suppose - at that point the fabric is only useful to be cut up and turned into something else

Ponoka7 · 23/08/2022 11:14

I get the hole thing. I've got a black cardi with slight glitter going through that I love for a chilly night out. It's got a small hole in the back, because I wear black you can't really see it. I'm loathe to part with it because no-one is selling anything similar and being 5'2" well fitting clothes aren't easy to replace.
OP it depends on your style, I think that we all start to change once we hit 40. I still wear similar stuff to my DD'S but it's a different version. It's a shame that you can't put a picture up. Tina Carter on EastEnders was starting to just look stupid.

grey12 · 23/08/2022 11:07

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 10:40

“Sloppy and unkempt” 😄honestly I think that’s silly. My clothes aren’t dirty. I dress smartly/professionally where that’s appropriate. But if I’m doing something casual I don’t think small holes are a problem, wouldn’t care if I noticed them on somebody else, and don’t really care what others think, I’d much rather not be wasteful and just wear stuff until it’s genuinely worn out.

Holes IS worn out! 🤔 if they can't be fixed properly then the clothes aren't looking like they're supposed to, the fabric is damaged.

Ok, what is "worn out" for you?

Btw, I have clothes in my closet that I bought over 20 years ago, I have clothes that were my mum's when she was young or even my grandmother's 🤷🏻‍♀️ old clothes are perfectly fine if the fabric is still good. I have a dress that ripped a little on the back the other day and it was sewn back on and looks fine.

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 10:40

“Sloppy and unkempt” 😄honestly I think that’s silly. My clothes aren’t dirty. I dress smartly/professionally where that’s appropriate. But if I’m doing something casual I don’t think small holes are a problem, wouldn’t care if I noticed them on somebody else, and don’t really care what others think, I’d much rather not be wasteful and just wear stuff until it’s genuinely worn out.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/08/2022 10:39

I also think you could try telling her you’d rather she wore dresses like you and wear lots of make up so you could both look similar to gauge her reaction.

Most of the time my dh can’t be bothered to buy his own clothes. I buy them for him but I choose the brand / style he likes in colours, which suit him.

KimberleyClark · 23/08/2022 10:13

Because once you start telling someone how to dress and behave, it doesn’t feel like a partnership anymore. It feels like someone has decided they want a partner, ANY partner - and if they can’t get the one they want, they’ll take who they can get and try to mould them into the partner they actually wanted.

This. A partner is not like a house you can do up until you have it the way you want it.

TheOriginalEmu · 23/08/2022 10:06

Just a perspective that may or may not be in any way relevant. I hate certain clothes because of a phobia I have. I would never wear them, and when other people wear them I don’t want them to touch me as the clothes make me want to bleach myself. I can’t look at people wearing these clothes. This is entirely my issue and I would not ever tell someone else they can’t wear a certain thing, but when my husband wears those things I do not want him near me. I can’t help it it’s a visceral reaction.

as I say might be totally irrelevant but just food for thought.

grey12 · 23/08/2022 09:47

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 08:11

I’m curious - why are small holes “not ok”? Big holes that reveal lots of flesh I can see could be an issue. But loads Of my clothes have small holes, I don’t see a problem with it.

It looks sloppy and unkempt 🤷🏻‍♀️ I suppose it depends on the hole and where it is. You can have fashionable holes in cool vintage tshirts or jeans or wtv.

I had this pair of jeans that completely ruined a lot of my tops 😭 I walked around with little holes on my belly for a while. And family would point it out and it looked messy and I was just struggling to let go because I liked those tops! And no, they couldn't be darned, not on the belly, not those fabrics.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 23/08/2022 09:20

FunnyBeaux · 23/08/2022 01:25

Welcome to MN where everything is controlling or abusive. The truth of the matter is that people rightly or wrongly (probably rightly) usually feel that their partner reflects on them. Which is why they want their partner to behave in a way that they feel is appropriate.

If you love her and get enough value out of the relationship, perhaps it's worth sometimes compromising. She's not telling you to completely change your entire identity and personality, just to sometimes dress somewhat more conservative.

People modify their dress and behaviour for work, is it so bad to occasionally do that for love?

Have I missed the point of having a partner somewhere along the line? Isn’t a partner someone you’ve chosen to be with above everyone else; someone who makes your life better by their presence in it?

Because once you start telling someone how to dress and behave, it doesn’t feel like a partnership anymore. It feels like someone has decided they want a partner, ANY partner - and if they can’t get the one they want, they’ll take who they can get and try to mould them into the partner they actually wanted.

Some people talk about being single as if it’s the worst thing that could happen to a person - yet you look at some relationships and wonder why people bother, because they’re clearly more invested in not being single than they are in the actual person.

And of course sometimes people dress differently for work. Work is an essential - so if wearing an ugly uniform or dressing ‘office smart’ is what’s required to get a certain job, most of us do it (although the continuing growth of casual dress environments suggests it’s not a welcome thing for many). But work is something we HAVE to do. A relationship is something you should want. Any job might be better than no job, but it sounds pretty depressing to think of a relationship in those terms.

If we’re making the work comparison, when you get home from work, you can take your uniform off when you get home and wear what feels comfortable. It sounds pretty miserable to have to wear a uniform for your partner too.

RaRaRaspoutine · 23/08/2022 08:58

YANBU, I bet you look amazing.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/08/2022 08:58

Imagine your partner was a man for a minute, would you call that controlling behaviour? Yes you would because it is.

Clamp down on it hard. Clothes are an expression of who we are. You are not an extension of your partner and you do not need to dress like her. She might prefer no make up, but you don’t.

Sit her down and tell her all this. Explain that you have very different styles, and that’s an expression of who you are as people. You don’t want any more of the endless criticism. You also might point out, gently, that endlessly buying new clothes is really bad for the environment.

Obviously, you want to be considerate to your partner, so perhaps recycle the stuff that is really worn out if it bothers her.

This needs to be nipped in the bud.

mountainsunsets · 23/08/2022 08:42

You should dress how you like but equally I don't think she's being controlling either.

She's allowed to have preferences about what you look good in, just as I'm sure you think she looks better in certain styles than in others.

She's not forcing you to change outfits or refusing to be seen in public with you unless you get changed. The way I read it, she's just saying it's fine not to dress up to go to the pub and that's jeans and a t-shirt look just as a good as a more complex/colourful outfit.

ThreeImaginaryBoys · 23/08/2022 08:35

What would her response be if you asked her to dress your way? I doubt she would like it.

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 08:27

I used to work with a woman who had a very boho style and it just really didn't suit her. She looked terrible most of the time.

In YOUR opinion. Presumably she was happy with her look - and who knows what she thought about your fashion style.

brianixon · 23/08/2022 08:27

Two separate comments:
If you have always been like this, style wise surely that was part of you that she was attracted to? So it is she that has changed, Why what brought it on?

As an observer after lockdowns It has been nice to see women out and about confidently wearing colours and nice fabrics that move and flow with the wearers movements.

honeylulu · 23/08/2022 08:25

She sounds ridiculously controlling but to mention wasteful. Constantly buying new jeans and t shirts? Why? They all pretty much look the same. Why bother?

TheVolturi · 23/08/2022 08:13

I think your dress sense sounds fab. And your partner is wrong to try to get you to change what is essentially a big part of you. Is she insecure? Maybe she thinks you attract attention dressing the way you do. Which you may do, but she should trust you.

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 08:11

I’m curious - why are small holes “not ok”? Big holes that reveal lots of flesh I can see could be an issue. But loads Of my clothes have small holes, I don’t see a problem with it.

grey12 · 23/08/2022 08:01

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 07:55

nothing wrong with clothes with small holes in. Loads of mine have small holes or visible darning repairs. That’s not financial (we are wealthy), it’s environmental, everybody should be wearing old darned clothes. We could make no new clothes at all for a few hundred years and still clothe the whole planet adequately. Fast fashion is insane.

Darning is ok 🤷🏻‍♀️ holes are not

Calphurnia88 · 23/08/2022 07:56

She loves clothes, is the kind of person who buys new clothes every holiday, every night/day out etc, won't keep anything if It's not still 'new'.

This is not something to aspire to IMO.

Ragwort · 23/08/2022 07:56

Sunshine I wouldn't dream of buying clothes for my DH ... in fact in our 33+ years of marriage I think I bought him one shirt which he hated. Grin

OP are you very "out there and look at me" in your dress sense, that would put me off but if you've always dressed like that then surely your DP knows your sense of style?

I have zero interest in fashion and dress in whatever fits me in the charity shops, I would be offended if my DH commented on what I wore ... and I couldn't care less what he wears. But the continual buying of new clothes would offend me, such a waste of money and I hate supporting the fashion industry (I used to work in it).

GoldenGorilla · 23/08/2022 07:55

nothing wrong with clothes with small holes in. Loads of mine have small holes or visible darning repairs. That’s not financial (we are wealthy), it’s environmental, everybody should be wearing old darned clothes. We could make no new clothes at all for a few hundred years and still clothe the whole planet adequately. Fast fashion is insane.

grey12 · 23/08/2022 07:49

Don't give up on your lovely quirky dress style 😉

But you CAN stop wearing clothes with holes 🤷🏻‍♀️ i say this because I did the same. Just stop. Just do a Marie Kondo, say thank you and throw away. You are worthy of better. You can even wear the jeans and tshirts to walk the dog 😅

Sunshineboo · 23/08/2022 07:48

how many women buy clothes for their male partner/tell them not to wear the scruffy band t shirt & socks and sandals to the pub with them/ throw away items of their clothes that they hate?

if my real life friends are anything to go by, loads do. I wonder how many people have talked about this being controlling in the OP situation do that to their other half's.

at the end of the day OP, this is upsetting you and you need to tell her this. you shouldn't give up being yourself for anyone. if you are the type to wear incredibly outlandish clothes that garner a lot of attention, and she is embarrassed by that and you are not, then she is embarrassed by you. and that is not a good place to be with a partner - don't let this erode your self confidence away.

perhaps start telling her you would prefer it if she made more of an effort - wore makeup/a dress and see how she feels? see if this changes her? however - you may find it's time to walk away unfortunately.

good luck with this OP - this is tricky territory x

RaininSummer · 23/08/2022 07:44

Tell her you would like her to wear dresses more and a bit of make up.