Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands inheritance

335 replies

lisaloves · 22/08/2022 22:17

DH has inherited 15k from an Aunt who sadly passed.

We are very happily married with 2 DCs. Comfortable financially but certainly not loaded. Huge mortgage and things we need to do to the house etc.

DH wants to put the entire amount in to Bitcoin. He's reluctantly agreed to just put half in to Bitcoin and the other half in to our joint ISA.

AIBU to think this is selfish?

For reference I am the bread winner by a country mile and we share all of our income. I never question this so it now feels unfair that his money is 'his' money - when for a long time I've earned much more and it's all been shared money.

I don't know much about Bitcoin but from what I've read it's very risky business.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Blackbird2020 · 23/08/2022 08:46

You might as well have written “DH inherited 15k and wants to have a blow out at the casino with it.”

girlmom21 · 23/08/2022 08:46

basically you are saying that someone who has to work their personal bollocks off to earn money with all the stress and stain of that, has to share that with their spouse.

whereas money obtained by one partner through sheer luck, and no graft at all on their part, they can keep all to themselves…even if they’ve not contributed anything in terms of income and sat on their arse all day watching their partner graft for money

Except nobody's said that.

Op and her husband both work. They both contribute to the family finances and they have both made the decision to have children and live their lives according to those incomes.

OP has said they're comfortable. She's not slaving away every day while he does nothing.

Being the higher earner doesn't automatically make you the harder worker, either.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:46

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:30

i simply don’t Understand how on earth you could think such a statement is in the best interest of a happy partnership

basically you are saying that someone who has to work their personal bollocks off to earn money with all the stress and stain of that, has to share that with their spouse.

whereas money obtained by one partner through sheer luck, and no graft at all on their part, they can keep all to themselves…even if they’ve not contributed anything in terms of income and sat on their arse all day watching their partner graft for money

how on earth do you figure that is remotely conducive to a happy marriage? You are completely bonkers.

If it’s an unhappy partnership it will be because one partner is sitting on their arse all day doing fuck all to contribute. Not because their inheritance is theirs to do with as they wish.

For most happy couples, both are contributing equally if not financially then through hours of labour being a SAHP or working a low pay job. Then an inheritance comes along.

It’s not wrong to agree, that we each decide what to do with our own inheritance
even in cases where one partner knows they will have no inheritance to speak of ever.

It’s not going to ruin an already happy partnership to agree that it’s not an all or nothing when it comes to contributing. Especially when the family is “comfortable” financially and the inheritance is a mere £15k. If it were a life changing amount like a multimillion pound one or the family were in poverty, then yes would expect/like some sharing but the decision to do so is still not a joint one.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:38

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:33

And, I’d add, in the event of divorce it is seen, quite rightly, as a marriageable joint asset .

only in a few specific circumstances will a court allow it to be “ring fenced” …usually where marriage is very short and person inherited before marriage.

I know this as I divorced last year. No question that ex inheritance, after 26 years of marriage, was part of the joint assets even though it was in his sole name.

You do understand that your divorce isn’t all divorces? Nor does a non matrimonial asset being added to your financial settlement mean they always are added, or even that it’s correct to call inheritance a joint marital asset, when it clearly isnt under the current law.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:34

This so simply not true under English law, if you get an inheritance after you are married it most certainly is seen by divorce courts at joint marriageable asset.

No, it’s really not. The starting point is that it is not a joint asset. And in the case of a high earning OP who is financially comfortable in her own words it is highly doubtful that a mere £15k would be deemed necessary to be added to the financiak settlement for her post divorce financial stability. Even if it is included in the financial settlement it is still added as a nonmatrimonial asset:

“If money is inherited by either husband or wife during the marriage, whether or not it will be added to the matrimonial pot will depend upon several factors, including:

Passage of time – In a long marriage, where either party brings non-matrimonial property (money from inheritance) into the marriage, the source of these assets will become less important as time goes on and may gradually come to be seen as matrimonial property.

Mingling of property – Where the non-matrimonial property ends up being intermingled with matrimonial property over time so that it becomes difficult to distinguish one from the other, it is more likely that it will all be added to the matrimonial pot. This could be where a portion of the inheritance is used to purchase shares as joint stakeholders, which then significantly increases in value over time.

Matrimonial home – If an inheritance is used to purchase a matrimonial home, this is more likely to be considered as having been added to the matrimonial pot and divided accordingly.

However, the factors above will generally only come into play if the matrimonial assets are adequate to meet the needs of both parties in terms of a financial settlement. If the matrimonial property is insufficient, then the non-matrimonial property will need to be added to the overall matrimonial pot in order to cover the financial needs of both parties following the divorce – this is especially the case where there are young children involved.

It is important to note that there are no hard and fast rules when it comes to dividing inherited assets; the outcome will always be decided on the facts of the individual circumstances.”

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:33

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:30

i simply don’t Understand how on earth you could think such a statement is in the best interest of a happy partnership

basically you are saying that someone who has to work their personal bollocks off to earn money with all the stress and stain of that, has to share that with their spouse.

whereas money obtained by one partner through sheer luck, and no graft at all on their part, they can keep all to themselves…even if they’ve not contributed anything in terms of income and sat on their arse all day watching their partner graft for money

how on earth do you figure that is remotely conducive to a happy marriage? You are completely bonkers.

And, I’d add, in the event of divorce it is seen, quite rightly, as a marriageable joint asset .

only in a few specific circumstances will a court allow it to be “ring fenced” …usually where marriage is very short and person inherited before marriage.

I know this as I divorced last year. No question that ex inheritance, after 26 years of marriage, was part of the joint assets even though it was in his sole name.

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:30

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 22:55

I think YABU because inheritance isn’t earned.

I think inheritance belongs 100% to whoever inherited it and their wife/husband has no say over it, nor should they accuse them of “being selfish” if they don’t want to spend it the way the husband/wife thinks they should.

It doesn’t matter that you’re the breadwinner and have contributed more, you earn more so of course your contribution is higher. He’s not in debt bondage to you because he earns less than you.

That said, I think Bitcoin is risky, but it is at a low currently and many are hoping for a repeat of the 2018 to 2021 rise. But as you say, you can afford for him to lose all the cash if it goes the other way. So, I’d just let him as it’s his inheritance and £15k isn’t very much anyway. It’s not a life changing sum that would make or break your pensioner years. If he’d bought a motorcycle, he’d spend just as much..so I say keep your beak out.

i simply don’t Understand how on earth you could think such a statement is in the best interest of a happy partnership

basically you are saying that someone who has to work their personal bollocks off to earn money with all the stress and stain of that, has to share that with their spouse.

whereas money obtained by one partner through sheer luck, and no graft at all on their part, they can keep all to themselves…even if they’ve not contributed anything in terms of income and sat on their arse all day watching their partner graft for money

how on earth do you figure that is remotely conducive to a happy marriage? You are completely bonkers.

blindedbythefright · 23/08/2022 08:26

Like your husband I had heard stories of crypto success and I wanted to learn more about it so a couple of years ago I put £150 in bitcoin (it was an amount I could afford to lose) - it's now worth £25. I'm leaving it there in the hopes it goes back up long term but it's a terrible way to invest, as pps have said there's no protection.

During the same time some shares I own have increased by 7%

Bitcoin success is for people who hopped on the bandwagon in 2010

Isthisit22 · 23/08/2022 08:26

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:22

He earns money too that he also shares. They both share their earned money.
Inherited money isn’t earned and isn’t a matrimonial asset. It doesn’t have to be a share everything or share nothing choice.

You are missing the point.
Yes you are legally correct but any decent person would use this money to help their family. This is the point.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:26

@BuildersTeaMaker
Might also want to point it that if you divorce that inheritance most certainly is a joint marriageable asset, and therefore it’s a joint decision where it goes.

Not if you are in England. It’s not a joint marital asset unless/until the beneficiary puts it in a joint account of some sort. Your DH paying off your joint mortgage with it is what made it a marital asset.

“As a rule, most assets that are acquired during a marriage or a civil partnership are added to the ‘matrimonial pot’ and are then divided upon divorce or dissolution.

But any assets which have been inherited by either spouse are often treated differently by courts in the context of divorce. The precedence for this was set out in the case of White v White on 26 October 2000 which stated:

This distinction is a recognition of the view that property owned by one spouse before the marriage, and inherited property whenever acquired, stand on a different footing from what may be loosely called matrimonial property.

In this article we will look in more detail at what happens to inherited assets in divorce and how to protect a future inheritance in a divorce settlement.”
www.divorce-online.co.uk/finances/assets/inherited-assets-in-divorce/

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 23/08/2022 08:24

You don't have a joint isa!

It's an individual account, so not sure whose name it's in, you should check?

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:24

MayThe4th · 23/08/2022 07:48

A lot of double standards on this thread.

There are often threads on here by women who are SAHP who have had an inheritance, and whose dh’s feel that is family money. And almost always they are told that although some might choose to put it into the family pot, it is their inheritance to do with as they please.

The desire to invest in bitcoin is an entirely separate discussion, but inheritance is not family money and isn’t a marital asset.

As to PP saying that most marriages are just friends with benefits, how incredibly offensive. While some people do get married for their own protection, especially if they have DC, most people do actually marry for love and not just for money. In fact I think society does still have a pretty strong view on people who only marry for money.

This so simply not true under English law, if you get an inheritance after you are married it most certainly is seen by divorce courts at joint marriageable asset. Only in some specific circumstances would cost “ring fence” it. Usually if inheritance was before a short marriage, or shortly after a short marriage. Or where it’s tied into trust etc. In the majority of cases it only is “kept” when the 10 or so criteria about “fair” settlement have been satisfied and there is money to spare.
it’s like people who spout that 50:50 split is default- it’s not. The 10 or so criteria are used. It may well be 50:50 will get to that “fair” outcome but it may not be, and the “fair” settlement criteria will alway take precedent.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 08:22

Isthisit22 · 23/08/2022 08:12

What??
She earns the money so she must share it but he inherits it so can blast it on what he wants.
Total bollocks

He earns money too that he also shares. They both share their earned money.
Inherited money isn’t earned and isn’t a matrimonial asset. It doesn’t have to be a share everything or share nothing choice.

Batfastard22 · 23/08/2022 08:16

Interesting responses. My thoughts are without knowing income specifics, what if he didn't have OP subsidising him and received this money? Would he be wanting to do something so risky or would he be more sensible?

It seems like he feels he can do this because your joint income is high enough anyway - and that's because of you.

Yes, it's his money. But there's something that feels incredibly selfish about what he's choosing to do. OP pays most of the bills, he gets his fun money. We don't know what they both do for a living. Perhaps he is a low earner but works incredibly hard, but perhaps he is cruising along comfortably on OPs income. There's a lot of factors to consider but ultimately I do think he's being selfish.

Isthisit22 · 23/08/2022 08:15

He has shown you how he truly feels about what's his now. Act accordingly by starting to keep a percentage of your wages for yourself.
Awful to find out how he would put himself first rather than the family.

BuildersTeaMaker · 23/08/2022 08:13

I had the same issue. My ex had mental health problems that meant he didn’t work at all for the last 13 years of our marriage. Not even a paper round ! I worked stupid hours and was, due to his issues, effectively single parent and sole carer for him as well as that job. I earnt good money and had been main bread winner by far for a further 7 years on top of that

He inherited after his parents died. He decided to keep their flat and rent out - but invested a stack of money in refurb to do that, that took 5 years to then turn a profit . When he switched the deeds he did so into his sole name. And always referred to it as “my” house. The cash he inherited went into accounts in his sole name.

we used a chunk of cash to pay off last of mortgage and he always said “I paid off mortgage”.

now there was some logic to him holding cash in his name, as he was a non tax payer,, so it really would have made no sense to move some to my name and me pay 40% tax on interest etc.

however, when he spoke about it, it was always “my house” , “my savings”. We never saved any of my income as it all went on paying the bills, mortgage, 2 kids etc- that was always referred to as “our income”.

most of the time I’d brush it off- we were married and legally it was all “ours”. And when we did divorce that’s how it was treated.

But it was the attitude - the miserlinesses and grabby attitude …the lack of recognition that whilst he paid a good slug of mortgage capital off with the inheritance , I’d been paying all the interest and even more capital on that mortgage solely for years and years (e.g, 27) He had no appreciation of where my earnings and “my” money had gone vs what he had contributed and then sat on, counting ”his” beans

it wasn’t the reason I divorced him though. Just one of his less attractive traits, 🤣🙄. I think it was his way of trying to gain some control and self esteem- it never sat comfortably with him that I earnt all the money despite that not being a choice of my making or wanting, and him not being able to hold down any job .

Op, there could be an element of that going on. That his self esteem is impacted by you earning more, and this is his way of trying to be more in control of your financial picture. Not saying it’s ok..but might help you approach the situation.

Might also want to point it that if you divorce that inheritance most certainly is a joint marriageable asset, and therefore it’s a joint decision where it goes.

Isthisit22 · 23/08/2022 08:12

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 22:55

I think YABU because inheritance isn’t earned.

I think inheritance belongs 100% to whoever inherited it and their wife/husband has no say over it, nor should they accuse them of “being selfish” if they don’t want to spend it the way the husband/wife thinks they should.

It doesn’t matter that you’re the breadwinner and have contributed more, you earn more so of course your contribution is higher. He’s not in debt bondage to you because he earns less than you.

That said, I think Bitcoin is risky, but it is at a low currently and many are hoping for a repeat of the 2018 to 2021 rise. But as you say, you can afford for him to lose all the cash if it goes the other way. So, I’d just let him as it’s his inheritance and £15k isn’t very much anyway. It’s not a life changing sum that would make or break your pensioner years. If he’d bought a motorcycle, he’d spend just as much..so I say keep your beak out.

What??
She earns the money so she must share it but he inherits it so can blast it on what he wants.
Total bollocks

goldfinchonthelawn · 23/08/2022 08:07

A friend of my adult DS put his inheritance into Bitcoin a few years ago. After years of stress as it soars and plummets he now has pretty much what he started with. There are loads of very hard sell tactics that promise the earth for a few quid, but he needs to talk to real investors, not ones he accesses through the money for nothing chatrooms. Does he know anyone who has invested?

It's very hard to get money out. As soon as you try to sell, it seems to plummet, so basically you are paper rich but have no access to your theoretical funds.

I wouldn't touch it, but I'm very risk averse.

Why not suggest he puts a grand in to see how it does and puts the rest in an ISA which he could easily move into the bitcoin fund if it does well?

perimenofertility · 23/08/2022 08:07

How utterly selfish of him! You've shared finances all this time and then he decides the inheritance is his to choose what to do with. If my DH did this it would completely change how I felt about him.

MrsOwainGlyndŵr · 23/08/2022 08:06

Bitcoin has lost a lot of its value recently. The only way is back up or further down.
Talk him out of it.

DilemmaDelilah · 23/08/2022 08:03

We have had a couple of inheritances over the past ten years, from my mum and DH's mum. While we both kind of agreed they were personal inheritance they were both large enough to be too much to keep to ourselves, if you know what I mean. Mine was spent on paying off our mortgage, his went on a new kitchen. We both had a nice sum left over, I believe around the same amount. I haven't asked what he has done with his, he hasn't asked what I have done with mine (it's in a savings account). So between us we both spent most of our individual inheritances on our shared home.

rookiemere · 23/08/2022 08:02

Sorry I misread the amount. £7k isn't going to buy much of a Porsche Blush.
I think it's the vanity of it that would really wind me up. Anyone with half a brain knows now is not the time for get rich quick schemes and Bitcoin is over. I think I'd prefer it if he bought cycling gear or whatever as at least he'd get some enjoyment from those and they would retain some value for resale.

He could use it for solar panels - that would help with the winter bills and increase the value of the property.

Zilla1 · 23/08/2022 08:01

Perhaps ask him to show a graph of bitcoin prices then show why he would have known to sell before the last reduction of 1/2 - 2/3 this Summer? In investment terms, the price of Bitcoin now looks linked to the price of other investments some which at least have the benefits of having an underlying link to substantive businesses.

Good luck.

Phineyj · 23/08/2022 07:59

@Summergirl5 put it better than my waffle.

"When someone shows you who they are: believe them."

CaptainMerica · 23/08/2022 07:58

I don't think he is being selfish - he doesn't want to blow it on a cycling holiday or a motorbike. He wants to save it, presumably for the benefit of the full family. He realises that you won't want to risk the full amount, and so is suggesting splitting it 50/50 between very high risk and very low risk savings.

That seems like a perfect compromise position to me! Just because OP is the higher earner, it doesn't mean they get to make every financial decision. Sharing money doesn't mean handing it over for the higher earner to control.

Obviously, there is a lot of arguments against bitcoin. But I think this should be a financial discussion about different investment options, not framed as an argument about whether he gets a say on how to invest the money.