Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands inheritance

335 replies

lisaloves · 22/08/2022 22:17

DH has inherited 15k from an Aunt who sadly passed.

We are very happily married with 2 DCs. Comfortable financially but certainly not loaded. Huge mortgage and things we need to do to the house etc.

DH wants to put the entire amount in to Bitcoin. He's reluctantly agreed to just put half in to Bitcoin and the other half in to our joint ISA.

AIBU to think this is selfish?

For reference I am the bread winner by a country mile and we share all of our income. I never question this so it now feels unfair that his money is 'his' money - when for a long time I've earned much more and it's all been shared money.

I don't know much about Bitcoin but from what I've read it's very risky business.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
riceuten · 23/08/2022 11:52

I bought about £30's worth of bitcoin a while ago, which ascended the dizzy heights of around £180, before slipping back to not much more than I paid for it. I certainly wouldn't've invested any more. I very much doubt it will ever rise to that degree again.

bridgetreilly · 23/08/2022 11:46

I think he can do what he wants but (a) it’s sad if he doesn’t want to use it for his family and (b) bitcoin is the absolute stupidest thing to do with it.

Nothingtoseehereok · 23/08/2022 11:43

He's a mug to gamble so much of a sum that could have done a lot for your family; unlike shares, Bitcoin doesn't have assets etc underpinning it so the risk is high.

That said I do have a positive story about Bitcoin - fourteen years ago my husband had an affair with a colleague; mostly emotional, but they then met once for sex. I confronted him as he was behaving weirdly after and he confessed - it was a mistake, it went too far, he wanted his old life & family back etc.

Thing was, I knew she was emailing him still and trying to convince him to leave and he was lying, so I looked up hacking her mail (I know - madness). I went as far as buying £250 of bitcoin to pay the hacker, then came to my senses and chickened out (and what would it have achieved - I left him anyway). But... I held onto the bitcoin and forgot about it. True, I should have cashed it in when it was worth twice as much, but that £250 is still £5,500 today. Next year my kids and I will be taking a holiday somewhere exotic and I'll drink a cocktail to her - fuck you, W!

W00p · 23/08/2022 11:38

A fool and his money are easily parted.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 11:11

LindaEllen · 23/08/2022 10:15

We bought 3 when they were £3k, sold them at £52k each and paid our mortgage off and got a new car each, plus added to our premium bonds significantly.

Mug's game?

Only if you don't know how to play.

This is exactly the same as boss babe bollocks. You didn't know how to play you just got lucky and are stupid enough not to realise it.

Bernie Maddoffs early "investors" could same the same thing. Only they don't because they are self aware.

MrKlaw · 23/08/2022 10:58

I agree with OP but..

It isn't your money and he can do what he likes with it. But you've clearly set an expectation that there is a shared pool of money and you pay more into it, so your expectation is that he would do the same. He isn't obliged but you think (reasonably IMO) that this is what he should do.

The wrinkle is potentially in the disproportionate earnings. If he earns a lot less, then perhaps he rarely has a lot of disposable income so he's gone along with your system because it (obviously) works for him, but has never had to face the flip side before. And now he is, he doesn't like it or doesn't want to apply that to 'his' money.

It could be a gap in expectation - he could turn around with all sorts of reasons. 'you earn more than me so of course you pay in more'; 'I wouldn't tell you what to do with an inheritence' etc etc.

Bitcoin is a mugs game. If you got in super early (or could mine for free) and cashed in a few years ago - great. But by the time its well known in the mainstream its already too late.

ISA is fine - perhaps a compromise would be to split the money in half - you put half in an ISA with your 'risk profile' and he puts his half in another with perhaps a higher risk:reward ratio if he wants to see better returns (with some but limited risk)

Everanewbie · 23/08/2022 10:57

goldenshoe · 23/08/2022 10:42

Going against the grain here, I don't think it's that bad an investment. Risky for sure, but it has potential to make better gains than sitting in premium bonds or an isa. Bitcoin is about as reliable as you'll get in crypto, but there are definitely better gains to be made in other coins.

I don't really understand why people get so het up about crypto, those who invest aren't stupid and know it's risky (I know, generalising). I'd say you have a good compromise with using half for crypto, but 'only invest what you can afford to lose' is valid here.

Oh, someone made a suggestion of spending it on solar panels - that's what I'd do tbh (and spend the change on crypto 😉).

You may be right about having the potential to exceed premium bonds. ISA performance depends on the underlying asset.

But the point about Bitcoin is the potential for loss, not just gain. And that downside risk is total loss. Its difficult to tell from the OP, but I would suggest that the capacity for loss isn't there to accept total loss without an adverse effect on the OP.

An ISA whether Stocks and Shares or Cash is protected from institutional risk by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. Investment risk can be managed by using a diversified portfolio.

Stupid is a bit of a loaded term. I would suggest the DH is either ignorant of the characteristics of cryto and the associated losses, or is being willfully gung ho.

If he is set on this, maybe use a very small proportion, or acquire a "gambling fund" from excess income to enable to "dabble".

viques · 23/08/2022 10:55

Thelnebriati · 22/08/2022 23:01

That money was earned by someone else's labour, and lump sums don't appear very often. Its shameful to waste all of it on something so risky. At least put some into premium bonds.

“ earned by someone’s labour “

You are making an assumption there. The money could have been a lottery win or the proceeds of a very small bank robbery.

I would persuade him to invest £500 in bitcoin, if, as he hopes, bitcoin defies the pundits and becomes the investment of choice he will make a decent amount on it, otherwise when it tanks he has had the fun of the investment, learned a lesson and suffered the loss of a smallish amount of money and more importantly you will have had the satisfaction of being right! Worth £500.

GettingStuffed · 23/08/2022 10:54

My husband is in the process of inheriting a nice amount as his well off rather died and he was left half and we also have LPA for his mum. At no point has he ever indicated that this is his money not our money. He's also really tight on frivolous spending from his mum's half so it's not wasted.

5zeds · 23/08/2022 10:51

Put it all in the mortgage and feel the benefit every month.

madasawethen · 23/08/2022 10:46

Does he have form for ideas like this?

If he wants to do the bitcoin, go with 500 and then forget about it.

CurlyTop1980 · 23/08/2022 10:45

Don't do it. My husband "invested" 10 grand in Forex and lost the lot. Ots a mugs game.

goldenshoe · 23/08/2022 10:42

Going against the grain here, I don't think it's that bad an investment. Risky for sure, but it has potential to make better gains than sitting in premium bonds or an isa. Bitcoin is about as reliable as you'll get in crypto, but there are definitely better gains to be made in other coins.

I don't really understand why people get so het up about crypto, those who invest aren't stupid and know it's risky (I know, generalising). I'd say you have a good compromise with using half for crypto, but 'only invest what you can afford to lose' is valid here.

Oh, someone made a suggestion of spending it on solar panels - that's what I'd do tbh (and spend the change on crypto 😉).

Rosehugger · 23/08/2022 10:41

It's his money but personally I would treat everyone including myself and then spend it on the house or invest it more wisely than on Bitcoin.

Gambling it all on Bitcoin is ridiculous.

budgiegirl · 23/08/2022 10:37

Charlieiscool · 23/08/2022 09:49

Regardless if the legal position about inheritance, for him to consider it solely his rather than family money shows him up to be horribly selfish. It is something you should decide on together for the benefit of all of you. He really is selfish. I would never do that and I’d be very upset if DH did it.

I think inheritance belongs 100% to whoever inherited it and their wife/husband has no say over it, nor should they accuse them of “being selfish” if they don’t want to spend it the way the husband/wife thinks they should

I totally disagree. My DH, many years ago, inherited about £10000. We had a young family at the time, we both worked. If he had considered it solely his, I would have thought him to be terribly selfish and it would have damaged our relationship. As it was, he's not selfish, he put the amount into our joint account, and we discussed together how it should be spent. The same will happen should we inherit any money in the future (for what it's worth, I am likely to inherit far more than he will, but we will still consider all money to be family money).

I think the only situation in which this may be different is if your marriage is rocky, so one party may be trying to protect the money, or if you are so wealthy that any inheritance will make sod all difference to your life/spending patterns.

Seafretfreda · 23/08/2022 10:30

Recent inheritance, chunk into joint mortgage, one blowout holiday, a few bits around the house. All shared, no question. And it was a hell of a lot more than that!

WireSkills · 23/08/2022 10:25

I stuck £100 in BitCoin in December 2021. It's now worth £46. I just did it as an experiment.

I know others that are making a lot of money on crypto's though, but they know what they're doing and can spend a fair amount of time on the markets.

Just sticking some money in to Crypto's without spending time and research, etc, will likely end up in the same scenario as mine.

If I were him I'd put it in to something like Moneybox where you can invest money and choose your risk profile. I've been investing in a Moneybox stocks & shares ISA for a couple of years now and have growth of 12% in there on a modest risk profile.

theremustonlybeone · 23/08/2022 10:23

So your money is shared and his money is his. Time for you to reconsider your finances. I would be separating them out as he has shown you who he is. What a selfish individual.

Everanewbie · 23/08/2022 10:23

LindaEllen · 23/08/2022 10:15

We bought 3 when they were £3k, sold them at £52k each and paid our mortgage off and got a new car each, plus added to our premium bonds significantly.

Mug's game?

Only if you don't know how to play.

I'm happy for you. But several people over the years have won big at roulette or the lottery. Anecdotes like this don't constitute sound long term financial planning.

VerinMathwin · 23/08/2022 10:20

I hope you paid your capital gains tax^^

HaveringWavering · 23/08/2022 10:17

Charlieiscool · 23/08/2022 09:49

Regardless if the legal position about inheritance, for him to consider it solely his rather than family money shows him up to be horribly selfish. It is something you should decide on together for the benefit of all of you. He really is selfish. I would never do that and I’d be very upset if DH did it.

She hasn’t said that he isn’t treating it as family money. She says he wants to invest it in Bitcoin. She doesn’t say he wants to keep the profits to himself rather than put them into the family pot. This isn’t him wanting to keep the money to/for himself, it’s about him wanting to make the investment decision without OP’s agreement.

penelopeisland · 23/08/2022 10:16

I agree using premium bonds is much saver.

But that husband of yours… Selfish! never learned to share?

If there is no getting through to him - I would start another ISA (in your own name) and start putting a little money aside each month for yourself too!
If he does it, why dont you?

Don’t let him take advantage of you. You are valuable, dont let anyone make you feel otherwise.

LindaEllen · 23/08/2022 10:15

Hotandbothereds · 22/08/2022 22:25

Bitcoin is a complete mugs game, he’s an idiot to consider putting even half into it.

We bought 3 when they were £3k, sold them at £52k each and paid our mortgage off and got a new car each, plus added to our premium bonds significantly.

Mug's game?

Only if you don't know how to play.

Figgygal · 23/08/2022 10:11

Much better ways to invest at the moment - hes being irresponsible with whats not a huge sum of money
I could spend £15k easily on life stuff - holiday, new kitchen appliances, boring stuff like boiler servicing, pay off any debt which would benefit the family overall

Everanewbie · 23/08/2022 10:11

So much wrong here. No such thing as a joint ISA, it literally means "Individual Savings Account". Bitcoin? He'd be insane. Unless you are already well set up and wealthy. If he must, maybe a small percentage that you are both prepared to write off with the very realistic possibility of a total loss and not mourn it.