Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands inheritance

335 replies

lisaloves · 22/08/2022 22:17

DH has inherited 15k from an Aunt who sadly passed.

We are very happily married with 2 DCs. Comfortable financially but certainly not loaded. Huge mortgage and things we need to do to the house etc.

DH wants to put the entire amount in to Bitcoin. He's reluctantly agreed to just put half in to Bitcoin and the other half in to our joint ISA.

AIBU to think this is selfish?

For reference I am the bread winner by a country mile and we share all of our income. I never question this so it now feels unfair that his money is 'his' money - when for a long time I've earned much more and it's all been shared money.

I don't know much about Bitcoin but from what I've read it's very risky business.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
redskyatnight · 23/08/2022 19:33

FloydPepper · 23/08/2022 19:20

Ooh, imagine a post where a higher earning husband demands his wife’s inheritance go into the pot or he’ll stop contributing…

Indeed. Inheritances are one of the areas where MN (the majority, clearly not individuals) have completely different views depending on whether it's a man or a woman that's inherited. If it's a man, it must be spent to the benefit of the family. If it's a woman, it's perfectly ok to keep it for yourself, and in some cases not even to tell your husband about it.

Flutterbybudget · 23/08/2022 19:33

Tbf, my now ex-husband was the main breadwinner for the duration of our marriage. When I was given an inheritance from an uncle, that money was “ours”, and was spent on house improvements, to benefit all of us. I genuinely can’t imagine having come into a large sum of money and deciding that it was “mine” to keep for myself.

FloydPepper · 23/08/2022 19:20

RayneDance · 23/08/2022 17:07

Op I think you need to tell him that if he won't put it into the family pot then you need to totally change finances because you share your earnings with him..

Ideally he should give himself and family maybe 2 grand for fun or into funds for fun.
The rest should go to where it needs to go.

Ooh, imagine a post where a higher earning husband demands his wife’s inheritance go into the pot or he’ll stop contributing…

Zilla1 · 23/08/2022 17:09

Am always puzzled at the suggestion to use bitcoin to make purchases. The last time I looked though thingss may have moved on, Bitcoin struggled with 5? transactions per second and with an enormous carbon footprint. One traditional network, Visa, whizzes 1700? transactions per second in the same period. Bitcoin as a Digital asset with a value based on scarcity makes more sense than bitcoin as a medium for exchange.

RayneDance · 23/08/2022 17:07

Op I think you need to tell him that if he won't put it into the family pot then you need to totally change finances because you share your earnings with him..

Ideally he should give himself and family maybe 2 grand for fun or into funds for fun.
The rest should go to where it needs to go.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/08/2022 17:01

Miffee · 23/08/2022 16:09

Lol. I can buy petrol or bread with pounds. Can I use bitcoin at Asda? Texaco?

Stop speaking bollocks.

Well if you have a horizon beyond Tesco’s, yes you can use bitcoin to buy things directly, especially online. Not as many as normal currency of course because it’s new, but it’s growing.

But it doesn’t sound like you’re interested in facts or learning about something new. Always amazes how those with the least understanding are the firmest in their position, hurling insults at those trying to clarify things for them. Let no good deed go unpunished and all that…

rookiemere · 23/08/2022 16:17

Putting it towards the mortgage makes guaranteed money - by reducing the amount you pay each month.

If interest rates are at 5% then you will have made a 50% profit in 10 years and full payback in 20 - probably less than that because of compound interest but my brain isn't good enough for the calculations.

I don't think people have done the maths on big mortgages and high interest rates. Unless you're on a fixed rate they are going to be crippling for many people and things like ISAs and premium bonds make sense whilst interest rates are low as no point paying it off then, but now they're creeping up any way you can reduce the mortgage makes sense.

larkstar · 23/08/2022 16:09

One of the most eye opening things on MN from my POV has been seeing how wide the spectrum is when it comes to the way behaviour and finances are handled inside marriages/relationships - being honest - I find it quite hard to relate to a lot of what gets written about. One area that comes up regularly is the issue of money - bills, earnings and now and again inheritance.

We have always only ever had one joint account - in any long relationship there are ups and downs in employment - well there has been for us. At times I have earned double what my wife earned (as she wanted to work 4 days part-time) and at other times, when I changed career and also when I became a house-husband and part-time self-employed (to work around my kids, school hours and their education - on 2 separate occasions - for 4 years and 5 years) - I earned less than half what she earned plus I took time out between jobs of 3-4 months when my children were born - an inheritance (not from my one remaining estranged parent!) of about £140k was split roughly 3 ways - I created an account in my wife's name only and stuck 1/3 in that for her, did the same for myself and the rest in our joint account - we've never had any money in separate accounts until now. We then gave £10k to our DD who wanted to buy a house.

We have always made all our financial decisions together - I wouldn't spend more than about £10 without my wife knowing about it. I wanted to share my luck with the most important person in my life - it wasn't a decision that needed to be thought about.

If I was you @lisaloves I'd separate your financial affairs and put your salary into your own account if he's not going to show an equal commitment to your relationship in terms of agreeing decisions together and your financial security. I have no regrets or second thoughts about splitting the inheritance into thirds.

I understand that people perhaps haven't been together long enough to 100% trust their partners and bad experiences in previous relationships obviously makes it harder to trust - and of course - some people either don't understand financial matters or aren't smart about decisions with money.

With mortgage interest rates rising as well as bills for everything else - I'd perhaps value having the cash on hand to cover the mortgage more than anything. It's a very uncertain situation for the majority of people in the UK right now.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 16:09

DontBlameMe79 · 23/08/2022 15:23

You can say that about any currency. What is a pound? They used to exchange it for gold on demand. Now they just give you another pound. So what is it other than a number in a ledger (like bitcoin).

How does it “make money”? it doesn’t, it goes up and down in value because there is a limited supply and variable demand. If you pick the right timing you can make money. Like bitcoin.

So trading or investing in BC is most analogous to foreign currency trading - and more like in emerging markets. High risk but high reward. Maybe…

Lol. I can buy petrol or bread with pounds. Can I use bitcoin at Asda? Texaco?

Stop speaking bollocks.

BasiliskStare · 23/08/2022 15:42

DH. has some shares in companies he has worked for - they are hard enough to think through whether they are are with vesting or not. A friend of ours told him she was taking a job solely paid in bit coin and his view was Good luck for that. So not to say DH wears the trousers here but on this particular point he does understand it better then me & I think his view is give it a tiny shot in an amount you can afford to lose, It is not a magic money machine. As PPs have said.

On a side issue - DH's parents have sadly died - it has gone into the family pot. I reckon my parents are very good for some years yet ( I hope so ) But if ever I were to get something ( and it would be small ) It will go into the family pot - just a way you look at finances I suppose )

DontBlameMe79 · 23/08/2022 15:23

Miffee · 23/08/2022 14:23

Buy what? What are you buying and how does it make money?

You can say that about any currency. What is a pound? They used to exchange it for gold on demand. Now they just give you another pound. So what is it other than a number in a ledger (like bitcoin).

How does it “make money”? it doesn’t, it goes up and down in value because there is a limited supply and variable demand. If you pick the right timing you can make money. Like bitcoin.

So trading or investing in BC is most analogous to foreign currency trading - and more like in emerging markets. High risk but high reward. Maybe…

Choconut · 23/08/2022 14:29

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:22

Another link showing case history and clarifying this applies to money inherited during the marriage, not just before
www.divorce-online.co.uk/finances/assets/inherited-assets-in-divorce/
“As a rule, most assets that are acquired during a marriage or a civil partnership are added to the ‘matrimonial pot’ and are then divided upon divorce or dissolution.

But any assets which have been inherited by either spouse are often treated differently by courts in the context of divorce. The precedence for this was set out in the case of White v White on 26 October 2000 which stated:

This distinction is a recognition of the view that property owned by one spouse before the marriage, and inherited property whenever acquired, stand on a different footing from what may be loosely called matrimonial property.

In this article we will look in more detail at what happens to inherited assets in divorce and how to protect a future inheritance in a divorce settlement.”

I disagree, I'd say that is probably legal companies just hoping you'll pay them to fight to try to keep your inheritance out of the matrimonial pot. It really is very much on a case by case basis from what I've seen and depends on when it was inherited, length of marriage, children, making sure both parties can maintain a similar lifestyle to what they had before etc. Another website said:

If you inherited assets during your marriage, there is a high likelihood that the Court would consider them part of the matrimonial pot. You might be able to prevent this by creating a post-nuptial agreement to ring-fence assets.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 14:23

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 13:57

That you might never see again. You get a chance at making more money. And insofar as bitcoin goes it’s probably the best time to buy since 2018 if youre going to take that risk.

Buy what? What are you buying and how does it make money?

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 13:57

bcc89 · 23/08/2022 13:01

Your comment makes no sense.

Buying a car/holiday/decorating might be "blowing" money, but at least you GET something for your money. You're not just giving away £15k cash in gambling that you'll never see again.

That you might never see again. You get a chance at making more money. And insofar as bitcoin goes it’s probably the best time to buy since 2018 if youre going to take that risk.

Thelnebriati · 23/08/2022 13:12

Gambling is risky and gives a high that can become addictive. MLM relies on social pressure/approval. Bitcoin and the way it is marketed contains elements of both.

The high and the social approval make people feel they are getting something for their money at the time; until they wake up. The spell wears off, they realise they've been had and have given all their money away to other people.
You rarely hear them talk about their regret on social media, and that helps keep the spell going.

bcc89 · 23/08/2022 13:01

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 06:22

No, it is a different thread altogether. The same principle I have is applied- that inherited money isn’t joint money. In several cases the SAHM OP has wanted to spend it on a big holiday, renovating her DCs rooms, or buying an expensive car. All of which are definitely blowing money compared to bitcoin which might be blowing money or it might make money. You can say it’s a different answer because of what he wants to spend his paltry £15k inheritance on, but that’s just an excuse for double standards.

Your comment makes no sense.

Buying a car/holiday/decorating might be "blowing" money, but at least you GET something for your money. You're not just giving away £15k cash in gambling that you'll never see again.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/08/2022 12:43

Thelnebriati · 23/08/2022 12:32

Yes premium bonds are 'boring'; because they aren't gambling. If you are attracted to bitcoin by the risk and find that creates a high then you are doing 'investing' wrong.

They are not investing either as some tragics believe. They are loaning money to the government at less than market rates. If you want government risk rates buy a Bond ETF. Premium Bonds are for mugs.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 12:34

Thelnebriati · 23/08/2022 12:32

Yes premium bonds are 'boring'; because they aren't gambling. If you are attracted to bitcoin by the risk and find that creates a high then you are doing 'investing' wrong.

Bitcoin isn't gambling its a bigger fool scam.

I know you probably know this but it really bears repeating.

I am shocked by how many people think this is legitimate. Can you imagine if OPs DH wanted to invest in an MLM?

Thelnebriati · 23/08/2022 12:32

Yes premium bonds are 'boring'; because they aren't gambling. If you are attracted to bitcoin by the risk and find that creates a high then you are doing 'investing' wrong.

alwayscheery · 23/08/2022 12:30

chillipenguin · 22/08/2022 22:46

Is this "joint ISA" in his name or yours? Have you seen the statements?

There are no joint Isa's !

Michellexxx · 23/08/2022 12:25

I think the ‘it’s my inheritance’ suits people if they have their own ability to find a lump sum or save up separately.

I would be very miffed if my husband suggested this. He did in fact do similar with 3k we were gifted and put it into a certain account- not as volatile as bitcoin- without discussing with me first. I told him I was annoyed about the lack of communication more than the choice and he agreed. He’s been better since.

but, he would never try to keep money solely for himself. We have some In crypto but not much.

I would probably accept a nominal sum going somewhere of his choosing but maybe only about 1/2k. The rest should be for family and I would hope to discuss the most sensible place for the 1/2k too..

Zilla1 · 23/08/2022 12:06

Of course it's not a mug's game... How is an investment in Tether/Luna doing?

How is Bitcoin doing over the last few month's?

Other than being lucky about when to invest and divest (if anyone really invested and are not just trying to talk up the market) by what evidenceble, replicable means could anyone know when to invest and divest and in what digital assets?

How is the investment doing in the digital asset “for carrying on an undertaking of great advantage, but nobody to know what it is”?

DontBlameMe79 · 23/08/2022 12:05

I think the bitcoin investment is reasonable if the money isn’t needed in the short term, and he can afford to lose it in a pinch. Bitcoin is way down and will likely go up again so he could be timing it just right.

There are a lot of financial mugs on here. if I hear Premium Bonds mentioned again (the worlds most boring and poorly paying investment) 😂😂😂😂

TiddleyWink · 23/08/2022 12:02

Sounds like what’s yours is shared and what’s his is his. If he doesn’t treat all income as household income then time to stop sharing everything you have with him. My DH and I put everything into one pot despite him earning more than me for years, and we have the same amount of ‘pocket money’ out to play with. As a result when I inherited £15k last year it didn’t cross my mind that it wasn’t ‘ours’ to decide jointly what to do with. Same when either of us gets a work bonus or another windfall.

Bitcoin may pay off or may not but that’s beside the point. I wouldn’t be happy with risking such a lump sum when there are better ways to use it and would question sharing my finances with someone who was prepared to take but not share.

cexuwaleozbu · 23/08/2022 11:58

Bitcoin is a pyramid scheme. The current investors can only maintain or increase the value of their current holdings by hyping it up to new converts and sucking in new money, but like all pyramid schemes it will run out of new victims eventually and then pretty much all recent investors will lose everything. Some of the early adopters who rode the initial surf wave and re-converted their winnings back to hard currency at the right time will make a profit, but that profit will be bought from duping people like your DH.

It is very foolish to be sharing finances with a fool like this.