Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands inheritance

335 replies

lisaloves · 22/08/2022 22:17

DH has inherited 15k from an Aunt who sadly passed.

We are very happily married with 2 DCs. Comfortable financially but certainly not loaded. Huge mortgage and things we need to do to the house etc.

DH wants to put the entire amount in to Bitcoin. He's reluctantly agreed to just put half in to Bitcoin and the other half in to our joint ISA.

AIBU to think this is selfish?

For reference I am the bread winner by a country mile and we share all of our income. I never question this so it now feels unfair that his money is 'his' money - when for a long time I've earned much more and it's all been shared money.

I don't know much about Bitcoin but from what I've read it's very risky business.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/08/2022 01:32

Bitcoin?

I'd be pissed off as well. I'd normally say it's his inheritance so up to him, but it sounds like you pool all finances as a family so I'd be pissed off too.

What a waste.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 23/08/2022 01:22

lisaloves · 22/08/2022 22:17

DH has inherited 15k from an Aunt who sadly passed.

We are very happily married with 2 DCs. Comfortable financially but certainly not loaded. Huge mortgage and things we need to do to the house etc.

DH wants to put the entire amount in to Bitcoin. He's reluctantly agreed to just put half in to Bitcoin and the other half in to our joint ISA.

AIBU to think this is selfish?

For reference I am the bread winner by a country mile and we share all of our income. I never question this so it now feels unfair that his money is 'his' money - when for a long time I've earned much more and it's all been shared money.

I don't know much about Bitcoin but from what I've read it's very risky business.

Have you questioned him on his thinking re 'his money'?

I would suggest to him you'll be keeping half of your wage back each month for yourself, since you now realise you don't have to share it all with him.

Cailleachian · 23/08/2022 00:47

He should definately buy at least £10 of bitcoin to learn how it works.
(and you should too). You can learn how bitcoin works with very small amounts of money. But you shouldnt put large sums in until you understand it.

Some advice if he does decide to buy bitcoin.

  1. Its better to put it in gradually (say 6 x £2.5k over 6 months) than all at once, because bitcoin is very volatile
  2. Don't keep it on an exchange. Once he buys it, he should move it to a wallet that he controls the private key (or seed phase) to
  3. With £15k, a hardware wallet is a very good idea (google trezor or ledger)
  4. Back up the seedphrase on paper and make sure that you know how to access it, in case there is an emergency.
If he wants to try trading, set aside a very small amount to play with on the exchanges, and when its gone its gone. If it shoots up to a squillion, he;s not a trading genius just lucky. "Trading" is really a form of gambling unless you really know what you are doing and have a sophisticated and well thought out strategy and thesis. If you see signs that he's losing money and putting more into the exchanges, you need to have a serious talk with him.
KatySp · 23/08/2022 00:31

Is inheritance not a matrimonial asset? That's news to me

LightDrizzle · 23/08/2022 00:31

Bitcoin! 🙄
Tell him to invest it in tulip bulbs. That’s where the smart money is.

Itstrueiagree · 23/08/2022 00:27

I'd just be passed of that hes regarding it as his money and not shared esp as you're the high earner and sharing at that. Would make me totally rethink my finances and wouldn't bother to consult him on anything you wanted to buy in the future.

As for Bitcoin, he might as well go and empty a bag of money down the drain as that's where it'll be going anyway.

Discovereads · 23/08/2022 00:25

Cantstandbullshit · 23/08/2022 00:11

Totally disagree with that, when you’re married you’re one and should we working together and making decisions together. Majority of the marriages today are just friends with benefits if we are honest, saying it’s my money is ridiculous.

Imagine a family struggling with bills and debt and one spouse gets an inheritance you’re saying it’s fine he spends it on whatever he wants and ignores his families needs because it’s his money? Ridiculous

We made the decision as one to be consistent with the law on what is a matrimonial asset and what is not. Inheritance is not. I hardly see how deciding to mirror the law can be “ridiculous”?

SameTimeNextWeek · 23/08/2022 00:14

God no. Definitely no to crypto. Start keeping some of your wages to one side.

Cantstandbullshit · 23/08/2022 00:11

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 22:55

I think YABU because inheritance isn’t earned.

I think inheritance belongs 100% to whoever inherited it and their wife/husband has no say over it, nor should they accuse them of “being selfish” if they don’t want to spend it the way the husband/wife thinks they should.

It doesn’t matter that you’re the breadwinner and have contributed more, you earn more so of course your contribution is higher. He’s not in debt bondage to you because he earns less than you.

That said, I think Bitcoin is risky, but it is at a low currently and many are hoping for a repeat of the 2018 to 2021 rise. But as you say, you can afford for him to lose all the cash if it goes the other way. So, I’d just let him as it’s his inheritance and £15k isn’t very much anyway. It’s not a life changing sum that would make or break your pensioner years. If he’d bought a motorcycle, he’d spend just as much..so I say keep your beak out.

Totally disagree with that, when you’re married you’re one and should we working together and making decisions together. Majority of the marriages today are just friends with benefits if we are honest, saying it’s my money is ridiculous.

Imagine a family struggling with bills and debt and one spouse gets an inheritance you’re saying it’s fine he spends it on whatever he wants and ignores his families needs because it’s his money? Ridiculous

AlpineSue · 22/08/2022 23:42

parietal · 22/08/2022 23:25

Bitcoin has fallen 50% in the last year. A lot of other crypto currencies have done a lot worse.

is your DH prepared to lose that much money? Because it is a great big ponzi scheme and has no long term prospects.

An ETF that tracks the stock market is a much better option - look at Vanguard.

This is spot on. Crypto has had huge falls this year. Bitcoin is risky and volatile. There are many better investments out there.

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:39

parietal · 22/08/2022 23:25

Bitcoin has fallen 50% in the last year. A lot of other crypto currencies have done a lot worse.

is your DH prepared to lose that much money? Because it is a great big ponzi scheme and has no long term prospects.

An ETF that tracks the stock market is a much better option - look at Vanguard.

Its dropped from a 1yr high of $65k to $21k….
He won’t though? As he’s buying at a low. So he literally can’t lose $40k per share? Yes, he could lose all his £15k, but at least he’s buying on a low so the risk is lower than buying at record highs?

It may be a gamble as BTC is volatile, but if you look at the historical chart, it’s still double what it was 2yrs ago. It’s risky, but I don’t think it’s recklessly stupid.

Husbands inheritance
CactusBlossom · 22/08/2022 23:35

Bitcoin is volatile and not protected by the usual financial safety nets. I tend to think of it as "you invest money, and you get a bit of a coin back". The bargepole long enough has yet to be manufactured... then there's NFTs. I think he would be daft to put that amount in Bitcoin. He could try the stock market (again, volatile, but there are tools and techniques for making sensible investments) so that dividends would provide an income, or buy and sell to generate a profit. Nothing wrong with government back savings: premium bonds, savings certificates etc; at least they are secure.

FloydPepper · 22/08/2022 23:34

It’s a very different thread where it’s the woman doing the inheriting…

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:33

ShandaLear · 22/08/2022 23:27

Let him have a few hundred to spend on bitcoin as a ‘pilot study’ before you discuss committing further funds. Hopefully that’ll be enough to help him learn his mad lesson.

I’m sorry but that comes across as financially controlling? OP has no authority to “let” him spend what is his inheritance. It’s not her money, it’s not joint money.

bloodyunicorns · 22/08/2022 23:33

No way! He knows nothing about it and he could lose the lot. It's not fair for him to do that when he doesn't bring much money in. In this climate he won't make a killing on bitcoin. He's years too late!!!

I'd protect your own money here, op.

Lunar270 · 22/08/2022 23:31

Bitcoin though, no thanks.

Lunar270 · 22/08/2022 23:30

I agree with @Discovereads. I'm also the breadwinner by a country mile but would never begrudge my OH if they used 100% of their inheritance for themselves.

If I didn't want to share all of my money I wouldn't and I didn't do it to feel hard done by, in the event of a situation like this.

ShandaLear · 22/08/2022 23:27

Let him have a few hundred to spend on bitcoin as a ‘pilot study’ before you discuss committing further funds. Hopefully that’ll be enough to help him learn his mad lesson.

parietal · 22/08/2022 23:25

Bitcoin has fallen 50% in the last year. A lot of other crypto currencies have done a lot worse.

is your DH prepared to lose that much money? Because it is a great big ponzi scheme and has no long term prospects.

An ETF that tracks the stock market is a much better option - look at Vanguard.

Husbands inheritance
Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:25

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:18

I don’t think so. Depends where you are. In England if inheritance is never put in a joint account or joint asset, it doesn’t count as a marital asset. It keeps its status in law as a non matrimonial asset.

www.co-oplegalservices.co.uk/media-centre/articles-may-aug-2017/matrimonial-and-non-matrimonial-assets/

Ah that's really interesting thank you for clarifying that, I always operated under the assumption that it was treated the same as the rest of the joint assets.

Heartrate · 22/08/2022 23:23

Either all money is family money or if his isn't neither is yours.

You can't have a joint ISA though.

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:22

Discovereads · 22/08/2022 23:18

I don’t think so. Depends where you are. In England if inheritance is never put in a joint account or joint asset, it doesn’t count as a marital asset. It keeps its status in law as a non matrimonial asset.

www.co-oplegalservices.co.uk/media-centre/articles-may-aug-2017/matrimonial-and-non-matrimonial-assets/

Another link showing case history and clarifying this applies to money inherited during the marriage, not just before
www.divorce-online.co.uk/finances/assets/inherited-assets-in-divorce/
“As a rule, most assets that are acquired during a marriage or a civil partnership are added to the ‘matrimonial pot’ and are then divided upon divorce or dissolution.

But any assets which have been inherited by either spouse are often treated differently by courts in the context of divorce. The precedence for this was set out in the case of White v White on 26 October 2000 which stated:

This distinction is a recognition of the view that property owned by one spouse before the marriage, and inherited property whenever acquired, stand on a different footing from what may be loosely called matrimonial property.

In this article we will look in more detail at what happens to inherited assets in divorce and how to protect a future inheritance in a divorce settlement.”

AnneLovesGilbert · 22/08/2022 23:21

It needs to go in the shared pot. He’s taking the piss.

Summerfun54321 · 22/08/2022 23:20

Bitterbean · 22/08/2022 23:13

I'm not sure it matters who is the breadwinner, unless he's sitting on his backside doing nothing.

Yes exactly, it may be the reason he wants some control over a pot of money if he feels he’s constantly being provided for.

ThinWomansBrain · 22/08/2022 23:19

Just start withdrawing your own earnings into your own savings account ASAP.
And try not to smirk too much or say "I told you so" when the inevitable happens.