Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the tangible benefits to you from Brexit, whichever way you voted

343 replies

Bunnyfuller · 22/08/2022 20:35

I genuinely want to know, what’s improved? Specific to you/your family?

is Brexit as it is what you thought it would be, or if you voted Remain, has it been more positive than you expected?

anyone calling it ‘goady thread’ is possibly saying Brexit isn’t going that well?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Clavinova · 23/08/2022 08:35

Travelled to EU quite a bit in last year. Supermarkets full and although some rising prices, absolutely nothing compared to what we are facing.

Did you travel to Germany?

gript.ie/german-aldi-set-to-raise-prices-by-up-to-50-from-today/#:~:text=Aldi's%20German%20branch%20says%20it,a%20wide%20range%20of%20items.

Pugdogmom · 23/08/2022 08:22

Trying to think of any benefits....Still struggling....maybe some more duty free....

Chaos at ports ( I wasn't watching on TV, I was in it). A fortune for visas and paperwork for DD's obligatory year abroad. Half empty supermarket shelves. Yeah it's been just great.

Travelled to EU quite a bit in last year. Supermarkets full and although some rising prices, absolutely nothing compared to what we are facing. DD is back from living in EU, and came shopping with me, and asked WTF has actually happened to this country.

Neverendingdust · 23/08/2022 08:17

I really do feel like we have become an even more Gloriously Strong Independent Super Power, our standing and influence on the international stage is quite truly the highest it’s ever been, of course this isnt only due to Brexit but the impeccable leadership of our dear PM. The economic effects are simply astounding, the NHS is thriving, our police forces brimming with officers.

The ease with which we can now travel internationally is the envy of everyone, Manchester airport really does have the dynamism of an International transit hub with the ease of which you can travel around the world with a British passport, the key to the world.

I think it’s made the Nation as a whole much more vibrant and dynamic, it’s truly brought out the Great British spirit in everyone, made everyone Britishly Great. Education and schools just couldn’t be any better now that we have Sovereign Independence, classrooms are thriving, teaching is now an aspirational vocation many could only dream of entering.

Our independence now means we are fully self sufficient in growing and producing everything we ever needed, fields upon fields filled with plenty of produce for all of us just waiting to be picked.

Brexit really has given us everything we could have ever imagined and more, the future gleams with optimism and opportunity for us all. Future generations will be forever praising and proudly proclaiming the Britishly Greatness Brexit brought forth for them.

Bunnyfuller · 23/08/2022 08:16

@Kitkatcatflap lazy post! You will see I’m a long time regular here if you checked!

OP posts:
Miffee · 23/08/2022 08:09

I'm a leave voter. Would vote leave again. Haven't seen any personal benefits and didn't expect to. It's impossible to say if I have seen personal hardship as the global economy is fucked by so many disperate compounding factors it's unclear how big an impact Brexit had on them.

My issue with the EU is broad and ideological and they have done nothing since I voted leave to make me wish I had voted remain.

I take no joy in remainers being upset and even less joy in the reaction of other leavers to that upset.

The whole thing was an utter shit show. Neither "side" seemed to have a grasp on the stakes. The whole thing was, and remains, a ridiculous example of tribalism with both sides being incredibly annoying.

Alexandra2001 · 23/08/2022 08:06

Our country is no longer a free for all for any poverty stricken eastern european who wants a "better life" at our expense

Instead fruit n veg rots in fields and we have to import limited labour from SE Asia, often victims of trafficking gangs (around 40k) EU migrants came here to work, single people cannot survive on our benefits system.

Plus 20 or 30k migrants come across the channel seeking a "better life" at our expense.
How many crossed in 2016? about 10, because we could send back failed asylum seekers to the eU country they came via.

It's also stopped the Common Fisheries Policy allowing EU vessels to plunder our North Sea Fishing stocks. (Whether they will ever recover is another discussion.)
That's why the East Coast from the Tyne to the Wash had some of the biggest Leave vote

Yes no market for the fish they do catch and downgrade of UK waters.

So all n all, Brexit has been a stunning success.

Brefugee · 23/08/2022 08:06

You need to send goods to the EU witt the incoterm DAP, then it's in the receiver to pay the import charges etc if there are any.

that's fine if you have customers. If people are thinking "meh, I'll order inside the CU instead" then DAP isn't any help. You would need to have a very good niche product for that to work.

Those who were sick of he poverty stricken East Europeans - well, fine. They have left/are leaving. Now you have a deal for visas from the Philippines and India (soon to be followed by Pakistan i guess) so that means at least you will be able to "see" who they are. (except you won't and that was hyperbole so don't jump on me)

Fishing - no. The large fishing fleets, owned by foreign companies, loved Brexit i guess. Small independent fishing boats? I don't think they are so keen now. see also the shellfish industry.

Fruit picking? as i always say on these threads. If the price of labour is right, the farmer will get the labour. I would hate to see the cost of soft fruit if the Living Wage had to be paid. (but i still don't understand why students don't do these jobs as they used to. All on a gap year to peru? or working full time elsewhere to build up funds to reduce their loans?)

In theory the price of care home workers, nurses etc should have gone up due to Brexit. That's why the unions were generally in favour. So what is stopping that? We all know the answer to that: the billionaire owners of everything. Brexit benefitted them just fine.

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/08/2022 08:03

Carpy88999 · 23/08/2022 07:29

I see this kind of thing all the time and have never had a single issue. I don't understand if you're lying (probably) and dramatising a fair bit. Don't get me wrong sometimes I can't get the exact lettuce I want because I shop at 8pm and they've all been sold but its no different to how its ever been from my personal experience.

You've been lucky then. I had three consecutive shopping trips where I failed to get a cucumber in Sainsbury's. They haven't had any plain flour for about a month and a very reduced range of own brand breakfast cereal. I haven't been searching elsewhere for these things (although I did pick up some flour in Aldi) because I shop once a week and I haven't suffered from the lack of them but there are problems in supply. Whether it's due to a shortage of the product, the packaging or delivery issues I don't know but there are plenty of gaps on the supermarket shelves where I am.

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 23/08/2022 07:59

Well it made me get my finger out and get my Irish passport and renew my ds's. I also now say I'm Northern Irish or Irish if asked. Other than that, no benefits at all and I believe this shitshow will get worse.

PeriodBro · 23/08/2022 07:56

capedavenger · 23/08/2022 07:49

The vote was a long time ago, Brexit is in the history books at this point. It's a bad look for Remainers to still be bleating about "their freedoms being taken away" and "idiotic people who didn't understand what they were voting for". Everyone else has moved on

We get to see Remoaners frothing at the mouth. That's always amusing.

Not sure if this is just a Mumsnet thing or not but I find it depressing that this type of non-answer is still the most prevalent "leaver" answer to any question. "We won, we're amused by other people being upset, move on" and despite being invited to explain the benefits to them they won't (or can't ) because there's "no point".

It's not just a Mumsnet thing. Some people are defensive and can only converse on a very shallow level.

Brefugee · 23/08/2022 07:49

it finally pushed me into getting citizenship of the EU country where I've lived for most of my life, and therefore i was able to vote in the General election.
That felt good after years of paying tax but not being able to take part.

capedavenger · 23/08/2022 07:49

The vote was a long time ago, Brexit is in the history books at this point. It's a bad look for Remainers to still be bleating about "their freedoms being taken away" and "idiotic people who didn't understand what they were voting for". Everyone else has moved on

We get to see Remoaners frothing at the mouth. That's always amusing.

Not sure if this is just a Mumsnet thing or not but I find it depressing that this type of non-answer is still the most prevalent "leaver" answer to any question. "We won, we're amused by other people being upset, move on" and despite being invited to explain the benefits to them they won't (or can't ) because there's "no point".

Exasperatednow · 23/08/2022 07:45

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/08/2022 03:19

"Our country is no longer a free for all for any poverty stricken eastern european who wants a "better life" at our expense"

Agree wholeheartedly.

It's also stopped the Common Fisheries Policy allowing EU vessels to plunder our North Sea Fishing stocks. (Whether they will ever recover is another discussion.)

That's why the East Coast from the Tyne to the Wash had some of the biggest Leave vote.

Fishing is going so well, isn't it.

Carpy88999 · 23/08/2022 07:29

LifeSucksBigTime · 22/08/2022 23:44

I really like how going to the supermarket is now like a big lucky dip, and you can only get about 25% of the things you hoped to buy. Really adds a certain edge of excitement to what was once a humdrum experience. And how you feel like you’ve beaten the system if you manage to get the last one on the shelf of something you wanted. It’s brilliant 🤩. Ooh and also how even though you can only get 25% of the things you wanted, it’s costing about the same as it did back when you’d be buying everything you wanted. That’s my favourite bit.

Really can’t see what the problem is 🤷‍♀️.

I see this kind of thing all the time and have never had a single issue. I don't understand if you're lying (probably) and dramatising a fair bit. Don't get me wrong sometimes I can't get the exact lettuce I want because I shop at 8pm and they've all been sold but its no different to how its ever been from my personal experience.

Flatmountains · 23/08/2022 07:27

So nice to see the nasty xenophobes coming on here to froth with joy. How many of you don't have any foreign ancestors, huh?

I know from watching the likes of Priti et al it only takes one generation to "forget" the fact that this country gave your family somewhere to live.

Carpy88999 · 23/08/2022 07:23

My life hasn't altered either way. If it was that important they wouldn't have let a bunch of plebs vote for it.

fluffyducky21 · 23/08/2022 04:17

VickyEadieofThigh · 22/08/2022 20:43

Absolutely NO benefits. Utter shit show, as anyone with a brain knew would be the case.

Exactly this.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 23/08/2022 04:15

I voted Remain. However, I was not a hardcore remainer. I'm very left-wing, and a huge admirer of the late and wonderful Tony Benn.
I'm extremely fortunate in that I'm entitled to an Irish passport, which I'll apply for after my current British one expires. That mitigates any personal negative effects for me.
There has been one positive - I'm self-employed, but sometimes have to get short-term casual work in between to make ends meet. It used to be hard where I live, now it's easy. I picked fruit on a farm for a few weeks in June and July, and they paid above the minimum wage, which would have been unheard of before. It has to be acknowledged that there has been a benefit to many lower paid British workers.
So overall, Brexit has not been as bad as I feared (nothing like) for me personally. I recognise it's been terrible for some.
I would love it if house prices and rents went down. They said that might happen. But sadly, they seem to have gone the other way, though I don't think that's due to Brexit?

MarshaMelrose · 23/08/2022 04:01

Skills shortages means employees have more power.

We send so many kids to university but we don't have enough skilled people. Maybe a good effect of Brexit will be getting our education system sorted so that we actually start to give proper training rather than getting young people to run up thousands of debt on courses that often leave them with few job prospects.

Pilipalapal · 23/08/2022 03:48

I’m another in the ‘it’s forced me to emigrate and that’s turned out to be a good thing’ position.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/08/2022 03:37

@DdraigGoch
"A fruit farm near me had to let acres rot this year. No EU pickers and no British people want the work.
What conditions was he offering? A lot of these jobs were very exploitative, paying minimum wage and then docking rent for living in barracks on the farm."

You nailed it.

Where I used to live these male EU workers were crammed into caravans ( 6 in a 4 berth for example) on a field with no access to proper facilities.
At night and weekends they had nothing to do so they wandered around the local town getting drunk, urinating in peoples' gardens, getting into knife fights, and terrorising women and the elderly.
They seemed determined to turn market towns into the Eastern European
$£it£ole$ they came from.

Some even managed to blow themselves up making 'hooch' as a sideline. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lincolnshire-18154900

Another reason why the East of England had such a huge turnout for Leave.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/08/2022 03:19

"Our country is no longer a free for all for any poverty stricken eastern european who wants a "better life" at our expense"

Agree wholeheartedly.

It's also stopped the Common Fisheries Policy allowing EU vessels to plunder our North Sea Fishing stocks. (Whether they will ever recover is another discussion.)

That's why the East Coast from the Tyne to the Wash had some of the biggest Leave vote.

DdraigGoch · 23/08/2022 02:48

MnPrem · 22/08/2022 23:14

I don’t pay any roaming charges in Europe? O2 - just use as at home Twocats. Might just be your package.

I also rather nicely got a much smaller queue at all passports than the EU lane - AND a stamp. All i need is a new blue passport now…

I don't pay roaming charges in the EU either - I'm with Virgin Mobile.

Fat lot of good it is when both my last holiday was, and my next one will be in non-EU states, though I can at least surf while passing through EU states on the train there.

Frequency · 23/08/2022 02:40

There is a reason British people don't want to fruit pick and it's not because they're lazy, contrary to popular belief. Most fruit farms are miles away from local towns with poor public transport links meaning you have to live there which is not suitable for parents or people with pets or other jobs. Otherwise, it's a long commute by car with fuel costing more and more each day for NMW.

It's seasonal work so it's not worth relocating for and if you're on the old tax credits system taking up seasonal work is virtually impossible. UC was supposed to make this easier but I have no experience of how this works in practice. Given their zealous sanctioning of people for minor infractions I can understand why people wouldn't be willing to rock the boat for a few week's work on NMW or less.

Migrant workers would come here especially for fruit picking, live on the farm and then take the money back home where it was worth more.