Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the tangible benefits to you from Brexit, whichever way you voted

343 replies

Bunnyfuller · 22/08/2022 20:35

I genuinely want to know, what’s improved? Specific to you/your family?

is Brexit as it is what you thought it would be, or if you voted Remain, has it been more positive than you expected?

anyone calling it ‘goady thread’ is possibly saying Brexit isn’t going that well?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Miffee · 23/08/2022 09:25

Fifife · 23/08/2022 09:17

Well that's why the lower paid people voted for Brexit! I'm not happy about it but that's the cusp of it. The EU was inflexible There should have been some quotas, total freedom of movement should have been between countries with similar wealth.

Indeed. Ultimately the writing was on the wall from Thatcher. It only works if poorer people see the benefits in other ways like robust public services and government intervention in things like housing.

Fifife · 23/08/2022 09:17

Miffee · 23/08/2022 09:09

They can't have done that as that is the point of the EU. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what it exists to do.

Well that's why the lower paid people voted for Brexit! I'm not happy about it but that's the cusp of it. The EU was inflexible There should have been some quotas, total freedom of movement should have been between countries with similar wealth.

OliveTreees · 23/08/2022 09:14

The one and only benefit for us has been to be forced to relocate to our home country in the EU as we can no longer do our jobs from the UK. Quality of life massively improving. It's a pity for the UK as we used to pay big taxes whilst not using state schools or NHS... (we are not an isolated case - we know so many people in the same situation)

Dotjones · 23/08/2022 09:13

There are a few benefits so far but the government hasn't exploited the opportunities to the maximum yet.

Obvious benefits to me are:


  • Reduced traffic from Ireland travelling to Europe on British roads. Pre-Brexit, it was easier for the Irish to put their lorries on a ferry to Britain, travel on our motorways to Dover and then cross to Calais. This meant the Irish were causing traffic delays and wearing out our roads. Since Brexit a lot of them seem to have vanished, presumably it's easier for them to go straight from Ireland to Europe directly.

  • End of freedom of movement. I can't afford to travel abroad so anything that inconveniences the travel of others is a good thing. People need to travel less.

  • Scottish independence is more likely. Now, I don't want Scottish independence, but if that is the price we must pay to get rid of the SNP thugs from our political system, so be it.

  • No more Nigel Farage on TV (unless you watch GB News, but that's easily avoided).

  • Better pay since Brexit.

  • A better vaccine programme when the rollout started.


It's a mistake though to assume that the benefits would all come immediately. I knew that it would be at least a decade before we were better off leaving than remaining. I hadn't factored in it taking three and a half years to actually leave, then the pandemic happening of course, so we're probably still about ten years away from feeling the real benefits.

The biggest long term benefit will be our removal from the ever-increasing scope of the EU. Integration there will grow, until it is effectively a United States of Europe. We weren't voting to freeze things as they were in 2016, we were voting to cede ever more power to Brussels or say "no thanks" and go our own way.

A key thing Remainers ignore is that most of the EU hated us anyway. They liked our money, but despised us. (Remember France blocked us from joining for years, de Gaulle never forgave us for sheltering him during WWII.) We weren't an equal partner, we were a cash cow to be exploited.

Did they even want us to remain? They could easily have made enough concessions to David Cameron that vote would have swung in favour of remain, but chose not to.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 09:13

Sandinmyknickers · 23/08/2022 09:09

But if I notice events, draw random unsubstantiated conclusions without bothering to understand or research for myself or listen to any of the numerous commentators on the subject....then yes, you would be accurate in calling me thick.

I don't see how you can twist that into being someone else fault for not explaining things to them. There were plenty of explanations...and plenty of stubborn headed people who wouldn't listen and thought their anecdotes made them experts so that they wouldn't listen to actual experts.
I think that is the definition of thick to me.

What is the explanation then? What is the answer?

Tell me.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 09:09

Fifife · 23/08/2022 09:07

Brexit could have been avoided if the EU allowed a cap on unskilled migrants from poorer countries. It definitely did have an affect on poorer paid jobs. Minimum wage workers with families and homes were expected to compete with people living in HMOs.

They can't have done that as that is the point of the EU. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what it exists to do.

Sandinmyknickers · 23/08/2022 09:09

Miffee · 23/08/2022 08:58

Yeah, your typical Brexiteer doesn't give a fuck about any of that. Why would they?

They care that the site they used to work on hired three EU migrants and wages stagnated. They care that their mate John hurt his back and the company didn't care but replaced him with more EU migrants. They care that the factory shut down and moved operations to Poland or Germany.

That's what they saw and nobody give them any kind of explanation as to why leaving the EU wouldn't make it better. They just called them thick racists.

But if I notice events, draw random unsubstantiated conclusions without bothering to understand or research for myself or listen to any of the numerous commentators on the subject....then yes, you would be accurate in calling me thick.

I don't see how you can twist that into being someone else fault for not explaining things to them. There were plenty of explanations...and plenty of stubborn headed people who wouldn't listen and thought their anecdotes made them experts so that they wouldn't listen to actual experts.
I think that is the definition of thick to me.

Fifife · 23/08/2022 09:07

Brexit could have been avoided if the EU allowed a cap on unskilled migrants from poorer countries. It definitely did have an affect on poorer paid jobs. Minimum wage workers with families and homes were expected to compete with people living in HMOs.

Treabrea · 23/08/2022 09:04

I quite enjoy a good row so I've got to have plenty of them.

I also like the term gammon as it is both amusing and accurate so thanks Brexit for bringing that one into every day usage.

justaladyLOL · 23/08/2022 09:04

As hubby is a builder his rates have shot up from £200 a day to £400 a day
I am a partner in a house developer company we are selling more now than ever before
My buddy is a teacher she says it is easier where she is as she has very few kids who cannot understand or speak good English which means she spends more time on other kids - she is in London not sure about other areas
Brothers business has certainly benefitted from Brexit

Sandinmyknickers · 23/08/2022 09:03

After 10 years in the UK, my ex left to go back to live in their home country....so I guess I no longer run the risk of bumping into him in the supermarket

I also got a stamp in my passport when I went on holiday...

Sorry that's all I got.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 09:02

well done for being honest with your first post. That view is often denied by Leave voters, but if that’s why you voted Leave, then you should own it

I can't imagine why Brexiteers think remainers and patronising holier-than-thou pseuds.

Exasperatednow · 23/08/2022 09:01

DorchaAndLouis · 23/08/2022 08:41

YABU. Any benefits (or disadvantages) won't become apparent for a long time.

Deferred benefits (if there are ever any) were not what people were promised.

Saracen · 23/08/2022 08:59

Can only think of one benefit, which is insignificant compared with the disbenefits. Now that so many European workers have left, there are more low-skilled job vacancies in my area, and they pay rather better than they used to. This is the sort of job my teenager will be wanting to take up in a few years, so her prospects have improved.

However, if I remember that those low-skilled job vacancies also extend to local care home work and hospital support staff, my blood runs cold thinking of the terrible conditions being suffered by residents/patients and staff. And I expect the big local factory will close, which would send unemployment up again. I'm surprised they are still here: they get parts from the EU and then export their products to the EU, which has become an expensive hassle for them.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 08:58

KonTikki · 23/08/2022 08:50

I live in the UK but have property in the EU.
Brexit has had a direct impact;
Limited my access to 90/180 days
Cost more in so many ways, specifically international bank transfers
Beurocracy - importation of any equipment needed
Suppliers I used to rely on in the EU no longer importing from the UK, owing to customs dues, delivery costs and paperwork.

For me personally there has been no advantage WHATSOEVER in leaving the EU.
The Brexiteers need to own this catastrophic mess that they have created.

Yeah, your typical Brexiteer doesn't give a fuck about any of that. Why would they?

They care that the site they used to work on hired three EU migrants and wages stagnated. They care that their mate John hurt his back and the company didn't care but replaced him with more EU migrants. They care that the factory shut down and moved operations to Poland or Germany.

That's what they saw and nobody give them any kind of explanation as to why leaving the EU wouldn't make it better. They just called them thick racists.

Bunnyfuller · 23/08/2022 08:56

Can we (either side of the issue) avoid the snarky comments - Leavers, I genuinely want to know the tangible benefits the Brexit you voted for has brought. ‘What’s the point’ etc just fans the flames of the view that there are no benefits to you.

@outlanderfan88 well done for being honest with your first post. That view is often denied by Leave voters, but if that’s why you voted Leave, then you should own it.

I’ve deliberately not posted my stance, because I truly want to hear what I’ve asked for - tangible benefits to you, that was part of your decision to vote as you did.

Very interesting to hear about fruit picking, fishing, building, hauliers and agriculture - have those changes affected you personally? What effects have they had (like the posters citing pay rises etc). So, focus on YOU, YOUR FAMILY - what positives has Brexit brought to your household.

OP posts:
DoNotWorryBeHappy · 23/08/2022 08:55

Awful lack of staff in care homes and home care... Impacted my family greatly.
Awful lack of staff in hospitals, heartbreaking to see nurse friends exhausted and upset.
Awful availability of building materials and fixtures and fittings, and much more expensive (before Ukraine invasion made it even trickier)
Heard from friends about hideous queues for non European holidaymakers.
Overwhelming sadness we no longer have the EU freedoms.

Fifife · 23/08/2022 08:53

Better pay before I qualified pay was shite , some agencies are now paying £16-£19 per hour for complex care workers/ autism LD. It was a minimum wage job before obviously they can't find people with that skill set.

KonTikki · 23/08/2022 08:50

I live in the UK but have property in the EU.
Brexit has had a direct impact;
Limited my access to 90/180 days
Cost more in so many ways, specifically international bank transfers
Beurocracy - importation of any equipment needed
Suppliers I used to rely on in the EU no longer importing from the UK, owing to customs dues, delivery costs and paperwork.

For me personally there has been no advantage WHATSOEVER in leaving the EU.
The Brexiteers need to own this catastrophic mess that they have created.

Miffee · 23/08/2022 08:46

DorchaAndLouis · 23/08/2022 08:41

YABU. Any benefits (or disadvantages) won't become apparent for a long time.

This is (half) my view. I think some people have certainly seen disadvantages but I don't think that means that it won't be an overall net good.

That said I am by no means sure it will be good, time will tell.

Clavinova · 23/08/2022 08:46

Alexandra2001
we could send back failed asylum seekers to the eU country they came via.

Not very successfully according to these stats:

Commons Library -
between 2015 and 2018, 7,365 incoming requests were made to transfer people into the UK under the Dublin regulation, from which 2,365 people were transferred to the UK (some requests may still be pending).

This means that the UK accepted around 33% of requests. During the same period, the UK made 18,953 outgoing requests to transfer people to other Member States, from which 1,395 people were transferred abroad. This amounts to around 7% of outgoing requests by the UK resulting in a transfer.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/what-is-the-dublin-iii-regulation-will-it-be-affected-by-brexit/

Exasperatednow · 23/08/2022 08:46

Where as on fishing

www.york.ac.uk/news-and-events/news/2022/research/brexit-fisheries-deliver/

And ofcourse the sewage discharge as a result of relation of rules is now affecting shellfish- reported today.

BlancmanegeBunny · 23/08/2022 08:42

Nothing positive has come out of Brexit for my family!!! I voted remain and the reality of Brexit is pretty much what I anticipated.

DorchaAndLouis · 23/08/2022 08:41

YABU. Any benefits (or disadvantages) won't become apparent for a long time.

Hoppinggreen · 23/08/2022 08:39

Clavinova · 23/08/2022 08:35

Travelled to EU quite a bit in last year. Supermarkets full and although some rising prices, absolutely nothing compared to what we are facing.

Did you travel to Germany?

gript.ie/german-aldi-set-to-raise-prices-by-up-to-50-from-today/#:~:text=Aldi's%20German%20branch%20says%20it,a%20wide%20range%20of%20items.

Yes I did, 2 weeks ago.
No shortages of anything in the 4 supermarkets I visited.

Swipe left for the next trending thread