Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the tangible benefits to you from Brexit, whichever way you voted

343 replies

Bunnyfuller · 22/08/2022 20:35

I genuinely want to know, what’s improved? Specific to you/your family?

is Brexit as it is what you thought it would be, or if you voted Remain, has it been more positive than you expected?

anyone calling it ‘goady thread’ is possibly saying Brexit isn’t going that well?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
LarkspurLane · 23/08/2022 11:30

Florenz · 23/08/2022 00:03

What is the point of this thread? An outpouring of hate aimed at Brexiters? Why would anyone want to post their positives about Brexit when it's going to be torn to bits by bitter remainers who still haven't got over the fact that for once in their lives, they didn't get their own way?

The vote was a long time ago, Brexit is in the history books at this point. It's a bad look for Remainers to still be bleating about "their freedoms being taken away" and "idiotic people who didn't understand what they were voting for". Everyone else has moved on.

Honestly, if there were benefits, for me or for other ordinary people, I would move on.
Also, it's an anonymous forum, you could just name change and post some of your benefits. If the benefits were far reaching and actually good for the country, they should not be so easy to tear apart by remainers.
Some have mentioned getting spaces in schools due to Europeans leaving. I don't love this, but it's a benefit for them and I respect that.
What are the others?

And why should remainers not still be concerned about their freedoms being taken away? Do you think because it happened a few years ago that people should stop fighting for this?

Miffee · 23/08/2022 11:29

baroqueandblue · 23/08/2022 10:23

How fortunate. Because it hasn't caused you any personal hardship, you get to sit on the fence through the defining debate in our country's modern history. And complain that everybody who 'got involved', regardless of their position, was simply engaging in tribalism at great inconvenience to you. Didn't stop you picking a 'tribe' and exercising your right to vote though, did it? 🙄

I was answering the question in the OP.

Yes I voted in line with my ideology. I don't think you know what tribal means.

It's not the defining debate of anything. It's the most persistent debate but the debate itself is shallow as fuck.

HRTQueen · 23/08/2022 11:28

By left I meant Labour

centrist Labour which held power for much of the time (which I tend to be but not stuck there, the refusal to acknowledge issues has been a huge mistake for Labour)

Brefugee · 23/08/2022 11:15

Increased paperwork seems to be the biggest issue.

that is exactly the point. Previously? zero paperwork. It all adds to costs.

so often (more so the left) dismissed these concerns and of course people get angry when then are once again dismissed which working class communities so often are other speak for them

but i think you will find that is the centrists - the hard left ("hard") like Benn, Corbyn and most unions were all for Brexit for EXACTLY that reason. So any leavers should totally be backing the strikes. Are they? because the strikes are now the tool for these workers to obtain the increased wages that Brexit was supposed to get for them. But didn't because as it turns out the UK is governed and run for corporations whose only obligation is to their shareholders.

I'd be interested if there are statistics on who are supporting the strikes and how they voted in the referendum.

Hoppinggreen · 23/08/2022 11:12

MintJulia · 23/08/2022 10:50

To be fair, on FoM, I've just employed a European in the U.K., no issues, and my niece has taken a job in Brussels so I've yet to see a problem with FoM.

Increased paperwork seems to be the biggest issue.

But in a situation where there are 2 candidates who are equally as good I imagine most employers would go for the one who involved the least paperwork etc.

baroqueandblue · 23/08/2022 10:53

Excellent post @neverbeenskiing . It's a national as well as a personal tragedy, but some people will never surrender their right to be 'right', despite the heartbreaking evidence.

HRTQueen · 23/08/2022 10:52

I think for many people who votes remain they refuse to believe that freedom of movement did have a negative impacts in some areas

so often (more so the left) dismissed these concerns and of course people get angry when then are once again dismissed which working class communities so often are other speak for them

I’ve heard many claim the FOM was to improve all our lives, it’s not so we can pop off and live in Spain if we choose it’s based on providing business what they need sadly we do not have strong unions so cheap labour force is easy for businesses to take advantage of

I voted remain but there were problems with being in the EU (if I voiced this in person or online I was called a leaver how has political debate and discussion become so black and white it’s ridiculous)
that were difficult to address we already had a divided society MP’s choose to ignore this (why? They have never had to answer
to this I hope on time they are made to) and push ahead with a referendum which was absolute madness

this has been addressed by Michael Barnier that divisions in the UK were being ignored and what a mistake that was as they are being in France and Germany it’s dangerous too do we never learn from history

Daisy03 · 23/08/2022 10:51

1dayatatime · 23/08/2022 10:19

Whether it is a benefit depends on where you sit on these topics:

  1. Brexit and the handling of it by the Tory Government particularly under Boris has ironically done more for the cause of a United Ireland than 40 years of the Troubles ever did.

  2. Scottish Independence - which was a dead issue after the results of the referendum. However post Brexit it had come back to life.

  3. vacations in the UK has risen (and so have the prices) as it becomes a lot more hassle to travel abroad

  4. in part inflation has risen due to less flexibility in the labour market. Great if you are a builder but not great if you are paying for a builder.

I'd argue about the vacations in the UK as it's become more difficult to travel abroad, it really isn't more difficult, hardly anything has changed, however it's harder to move abroad.
The reason people are staying in the UK is more to do with covid restrictions, or fear of them coming back in.
That or the fear of flights being caused by staff shortages.

MintJulia · 23/08/2022 10:50

To be fair, on FoM, I've just employed a European in the U.K., no issues, and my niece has taken a job in Brussels so I've yet to see a problem with FoM.

Increased paperwork seems to be the biggest issue.

Baoing · 23/08/2022 10:49

Great post neverbeenskiing I'll add 2 molecular scientists, two microbiologists and two more excellent teachers.

We get to see Remoaners frothing at the mouth. That's always amusing

This kind of reductive, moronic response is why Brexit keeps on pitting the country against itself.

People have seen beloved friends and family members leave the country. But that amuses you. Pitiful.

neverbeenskiing · 23/08/2022 10:41

Our country is no longer a free for all for any poverty stricken eastern european who wants a "better life" at our expense.

Eastern Europeans I know personally who have left due to Brexit include

A Child Psychologist who worked for the NHS
2 Teaching Assistants
2 school cleaners and a caretaker
A solicitor
A pharmacist
A qualified social worker working in Child Protection.

None of these people were living at your expense and I'd be interested to know what you contribute to society that makes you superior to them.

The NHS is really struggling to recruit staff at the moment, particularly within Mental Health services and people will suffer as a result. Friends who are working in the NHS tell me staff are exhausted and feel unsafe on the wards and they are adamant this is not because of covid, but politicians will certainly use it as an excuse.

Kids I work with are reliant on short-term agency social workers who don't give a shit because they know they're going to disappear after a few weeks and I know some very vulnerable families who have been waiting weeks to be allocated a social worker at all. In our area unqualified Support Workers are being expected to take on more and more responsibility to make up the short fall.

At the school where I work we are desperate for cleaners, caretakers and TA's and have been advertising for these posts constantly but people are just not applying.

Brexit has already been disastrous for our public services which were already facing a skills shortage and I dread to think what the situation is like in care homes. But none of this will change your bigoted view of Eastern Europeans.

Brefugee · 23/08/2022 10:37

End of freedom of movement. I can't afford to travel abroad so anything that inconveniences the travel of others is a good thing. People need to travel less.

Aside of the fact that FoM does not only refer to holidays, where are people going now? People who can afford to travel will continue to do so. People who stay in the UK are ensuring that the price of a UK holiday will go up. Now instead of not being able to afford foreign travel, you may not be able to afford travel in side the UK. That's your problem, i feel.

The problem of many EU migrants living in HMOs and driving down the wages of already poorly paid jobs was an issue even without making it a topic for Brexit. But someone needs to do those jobs. If students (or other groups of workers) no longer do them, as they did in the past - the vacancies are still there. So who will do those jobs? The whole point of trying to push the majority of school-leavers to uni was to make UK a high-skills economy. Closure of heavy, and not so heavy, industry (what do you produce in the UK now?) and focussing on making it a service economy didn't do anyone any favours. Well paid so-called blue-collar jobs were good jobs to have, but now they have gone too. All the people who would have gone into those jobs are now in service industries. A lot of them on low pay.

I wouldn't have voted for Brexit had i been allowed - but i absolutely understand why the working class thought, hoped, believed that it would push up their wages. I know a few industries have benefitted (building, forestry i think too, etc) but where they haven't - why is that? How do you get the fruit picked, etc, if you don't have cheap workers either from inside or outside the country or EU?

Clavinova · 23/08/2022 10:33

Freedom of movement devastated the building trade which was a traditionally ok paying job

That's certainly what Jeremy Corbyn claimed in 2017;

What there wouldn’t be is the wholesale importation of underpaid workers from central Europe in order to destroy conditions, particularly in the construction industry.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/jeremy-corbyn-grilled-over-brexit-10855886

MintChocTea · 23/08/2022 10:25

Yet immigration into UK has increased since the Brexit referendum.

‘The UK is now seeing immigration from “poorer” countries rather than Europe, US, Canada etc.’ - Neil O’Brien Tory MP

baroqueandblue · 23/08/2022 10:23

Miffee · 23/08/2022 08:09

I'm a leave voter. Would vote leave again. Haven't seen any personal benefits and didn't expect to. It's impossible to say if I have seen personal hardship as the global economy is fucked by so many disperate compounding factors it's unclear how big an impact Brexit had on them.

My issue with the EU is broad and ideological and they have done nothing since I voted leave to make me wish I had voted remain.

I take no joy in remainers being upset and even less joy in the reaction of other leavers to that upset.

The whole thing was an utter shit show. Neither "side" seemed to have a grasp on the stakes. The whole thing was, and remains, a ridiculous example of tribalism with both sides being incredibly annoying.

How fortunate. Because it hasn't caused you any personal hardship, you get to sit on the fence through the defining debate in our country's modern history. And complain that everybody who 'got involved', regardless of their position, was simply engaging in tribalism at great inconvenience to you. Didn't stop you picking a 'tribe' and exercising your right to vote though, did it? 🙄

Kendodd · 23/08/2022 10:22

I suppose Brexit was a massive win for Putin so at least it made someone happy.

1dayatatime · 23/08/2022 10:19

Whether it is a benefit depends on where you sit on these topics:

  1. Brexit and the handling of it by the Tory Government particularly under Boris has ironically done more for the cause of a United Ireland than 40 years of the Troubles ever did.

  2. Scottish Independence - which was a dead issue after the results of the referendum. However post Brexit it had come back to life.

  3. vacations in the UK has risen (and so have the prices) as it becomes a lot more hassle to travel abroad

  4. in part inflation has risen due to less flexibility in the labour market. Great if you are a builder but not great if you are paying for a builder.

Kendodd · 23/08/2022 10:18

Freedom of movement devastated the building trade which was a traditionally ok paying job.

What a load of bollocks.
You struggle to get a trades person to even look at a job round here for well over a decade, and they all charged a fortune. There was and still is a massive shortage of tradespeople and that shortage has held up house building and infrastructure projects like crossrail.

Clavinova · 23/08/2022 10:08

Exasperatednow
People do know that the government had rules that they could apply to migrants whilst in the EU?

Yes - I was reading about that the other day. This was bad timing a week before the referendum, highlighting EU meddling in our domestic policy;

June 14 2016
The British Government is within its rights to restrict benefits to some EU migrants, the European Court of Justice has ruled.

In a move that will be greeted with profound relief by David Cameron and the Remain campaign, the court threw out a challenge by the European Commission to the Government’s benefits crackdown.

The Commission had argued that the UK's decision to restrict payment – such as child benefit and tax credits – to migrants who were "economically inactive" on the grounds that they did not have the right to live in the UK was discriminatory.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/eu-court-backs-uks-ability-to-restrict-child-benefits-for-migrants-a7081046.html

But Vote Leave said it was "absurd that the UK had to run every nut and bolt of domestic policy" past a court in Luxembourg and engage in "lengthy and expensive" legal battles.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-36526158

Fifife · 23/08/2022 10:06

Exasperatednow · 23/08/2022 09:35

People do know that the government had rules that they could apply to migrants whilst in the EU but chose not to? Other countries do.

Now they're planning to extend visas to thousands of people from countries outside of the EU to address the issues that we face.

So nothing much has changed except UK citizens have lost FoM.

Well yes but the visas will be subjected to quotas for specific job shortages so harder for employers to exploit and depress wages. My workplace (healthcare) we recruit mainly from Nigeria for oversees staff , wages are still rising. Freedom of movement devastated the building trade which was a traditionally ok paying job.

Anniegetyourgun · 23/08/2022 09:57

Posters on here saying "it was a long time ago, it's in the history books now, it's time to move on" etc: the referendum (not the actual leaving) was in 2016, which was only 6 years ago. That's the same length of time as WW2 lasted. It's a pretty short time really, but long enough for a lot of devastating things to happen and definitely far too short to say "that was then, this is now, just forget about it". And my word, has this been an eventful 6 years for a lot more reasons than just Brexit.

I may add that DSis is no fan of the EU, indeed she would have been delighted to see us leave, but voted Remain in the referendum as she said she couldn't trust this lot not to turn it into a disaster. (I was firmly Remain, but agreed with her that it didn't have to be a disaster if it were handled right. Such a big if!) Which reminds me, here is my Brexit benefit, the one and only as far as I can see: British politicians can no longer hide behind "Brussels made me/won't let me do it". Now we know it's all them. Not that it will stop them trying to blame bleedin' foreigners, of course. They're still blaming a Labour government that wasn't even elected for things they might have done worse if they'd had the chance...

p.s. The Common Agricultural and Common Fisheries policies were a bit shit, to be fair - though not nearly as shit as their reputation, and potentially not nearly as shit as not having them. It all depends who's working on the replacement. Liz who, did you say...? OK, we're fucked.

Exasperatednow · 23/08/2022 09:35

People do know that the government had rules that they could apply to migrants whilst in the EU but chose not to? Other countries do.

Now they're planning to extend visas to thousands of people from countries outside of the EU to address the issues that we face.

So nothing much has changed except UK citizens have lost FoM.

recentlyseparated · 23/08/2022 09:33

MrsTerryPratchett · 22/08/2022 20:39

Scotland might get independence.

😄

bumblingbovine49 · 23/08/2022 09:31

None at all. I have just been speaking to the daughter of one of my friends who got a degree through covid and is on a study exchange on Spain before she graduates. She loves it there and does not want to come back yet . Before Brexit she would have got a job of some sort and stayed for longer. As it is she will need to come home. Not a massive thing but just an indication of how we have narrowed the opportunities for our children

Clavinova · 23/08/2022 09:25

Exasperatednow
Deferred benefits (if there are ever any) were not what people were promised

Future EU enlargement was discussed. I don't mind giving sanctuary to a few hundred thousand people (mostly women and children) during the war, but free movement with an extra 40/45 million people is an all together different matter - Ukraine was the poorest country in Europe even before the war.

Swipe left for the next trending thread