Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel sad that our ex DIL is getting married today?

56 replies

ClaphamLane · 22/08/2022 18:22

Very mixed feelings, of course she deserves to be happy, but can't help that sense of sadness.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClaphamLane · 28/08/2022 21:11

@Andromachehadabadday ‘And no blame on your part in any of this.’

What am I to be blamed for? What did I do in this difficult situation? Enlighten me Andro, please.

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 26/08/2022 08:40

You may think my post is ‘unfair’ but as I said (several times) that’s how your posts read to me. All (apart from the last one) centering blame on her and her family, with a little bit on your ds. But still painting him as her victim. And no blame on your part in any of this. Even though you paint her as the villain. She will know that’s how you see her.

bloodyunicorns · 25/08/2022 20:04

I really feel for you. You're losing out on seeing both GC because of your DS's selfish, unthinking behaviour.

You sound like a lovely, sensible person, and I hope you manage to come to some sort of resolution.

ClaphamLane · 25/08/2022 19:46

@Andromachehadabadday @SaggyBlinders

I think your comments are unfair. This post was about my Ex DiL not DS, so I've not added much information about him.

Assuming that she has raised her daughter with no financial or parenting input from your son for at least two years,
He has paid maintenance throughout.

And yet you seem to have accepted your sons behaviour. the equivalent of ‘that’s not good, son, well let’s move on’
Nope, we were disgusted with his choice, how quickly he moved on without thinking of the consequences for his DD, how he hadn't learnt any lessons from his first quick marriage and baby, how he hasn't addressed the damage caused in our family. We've held him to account for all of this, resulting in no contact and very low contact. As parents we tried to advise. He is a grown adult, he doesn't have to accept and act on our advice. I'm not sure what more we can do. Us holding him to account, of course, means we don't see his new DS ( our DGS) either!

Would you have accepted not seeing your ds as a child, at all, because it would disrupt your job?
Never and neither should. As above - he is a grown adult as is ex DiL, they have both made their own decisions in this. We haven't been involved. I will also add, that as a single parent, with a very difficult ex, I never stopped them from having a relationship with their dad.

Did you feel this level of sadness when you son remarried and had another baby, without sorting the situation with his first child out?
Absolutely and more, upset, angry, difficult conversations with him as we held him to account. As you know from above, resulting in no contact and now very occasional contact (texts occasionally). He didn't ask us to the wedding.

Advice about what else we can, should do is appreciated because at the minute we have very little contact with either of the adults and both DGC’s involved in this mess.

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 24/08/2022 16:21

To be honest op, you last post (basically) reads

‘everyone else has behaved badly. Her and her family have behaved badly. Ex dil is using her child. Ds didn’t behave the best he is at fault but isn’t ‘able’ to fight anymore. And we have behaved brilliantly and kept out of all the trouble and not taken sides and are the ones being punished’.

Everyone behaved badly, except you? And yet you seem to have accepted your sons behaviour. the equivalent of ‘that’s not good, son, well let’s move on’

This is your aide, which is fair enough. But the language about your son is very different. Not ‘able to fight because he is worried about his job and new family’. That’s very different to the tone of the words used about your dil.

You make it sound like your son can’t do anything now. He made a couple of poor decisions but there’s no going back.

Dils concern for her dd, is her using the child as a weapon.

Your son moved on and couldn’t be arsed fighting because it will disrupt his life too much. Would you have accepted not seeing your ds as a child, at all, because it would disrupt your job?

Did you feel this level of sadness when you son remarried and had another baby, without sorting the situation with his first child out?

The way it’s written, to me, is like you are painting a picture of someone who is failing to understand what Dils point of view is, or disbelieve she has concerns at all and just pushing the blame her way. Putting a little on your son so you can’t be accused of being biased and turning a blind eye to the actual issues.

Things must be very bad between you if, you can’t even send a card. And I doubt it’s because you behaved too well.

I suspect, her version is very different. And as your posts have gone on, it does read as you slagging her off to me

SaggyBlinders · 24/08/2022 13:10

Yes. Reread your last post. You've slagged off your ex DIL and her family. You've accused ex DIL of using her daughter as a "pawn". It would be interesting to hear ex DIL side of the story. Assuming that she has raised her daughter with no financial or parenting input from your son for at least two years, because he is "too scared" to try and get contact with his own daughter. Or can't be bothered.

If I were you, I would ask for this thread to be deleted, and try talking to you ex DIL as an adult.

If she reads this thread and recognises herself, she's hardly likely to think "oh fair enough, what an objective overview of the situation" - she's more than likely going to be quite pissed off.

ClaphamLane · 24/08/2022 13:00

SaggyBlinders · 24/08/2022 12:50

It's definitely a better idea than slagging her off on mumsnet.

Slagging her off - do my posts read as a slagging off? @SaggyBlinders

I hoped I was being quite objective in the issues and circumstances of DS & EX DiL.
It would be really difficult to follow PP’ advice and write to her, if communicating as I have above, would be taken as a ‘slagging off’.

OP posts:
SaggyBlinders · 24/08/2022 12:50

felulageller · 23/08/2022 23:52

I think writing her a nice letter, saying what you've said here can't make the situation any worse...

It's definitely a better idea than slagging her off on mumsnet.

felulageller · 23/08/2022 23:52

I think writing her a nice letter, saying what you've said here can't make the situation any worse...

Dinoteeth · 23/08/2022 23:45

Show not shoe - duh!

Dinoteeth · 23/08/2022 23:43

I think send a card to ex-Dil shoe willing.

Then talk adult to adult with her, you'd like to see your DGD but are worried about contact being stopped again and don't want to yo-yo in and out the child's life.

4hrs isn't exactly easy to manage, that's an 8hr round trip, work out what is possible, two or three long weekends per year, collecting her afterschool on a Friday bringing her back on a Monday.

I think you need to use the card to open communication with ex dil.

ClaphamLane · 23/08/2022 21:50

Thank you for your range of responses - all read and considered.

This will be a slow process if we are to rebuild a relationship. We don't live nearby, nearly 4 hours away, so contact was always going to be more limited.

DS has been an a*se, ex DiL too - and her family haven't helped the situation, interfering, clingy. DS should never have married.
Ex DiL has her own issues too. DGD is the pawn. Ex DiL maintains she has to keep DGD away from her daddy, for DGD’s mental health. I'm not so sure, attachment/abandonment are pretty damaging.

We have had some contact, a visit out with Ex DiL and DGD, when we took them both to a children’s show at the theatre. It was just before lockdown. We always send presents and cards, we sometimes receive a message that they have arrived, sometimes I have to ask, sometimes we get a thank you, sometimes nothiing.

Ex DiL assumed that we would ‘take DS’s side’ - we haven't, we expect decent adult behaviour, who ever that adult is. We’ve kept out of the disagreements and have no information about the court case. A generalisation is DS has behaved badly, giving Ex DiL some events to dramatise. DS, it seems, is too scared of the effects, financially, on his job and on his new family to be able to fight much more. He should have behaved himself and then on Divircing put DGD first, establishing/ fighting for contact before having a child and marrying someone else. Talk about rushing in!

Ex DiL is in touch sometimes, then we are blocked at other times from SM, mobile access etc. No reasons given. We have only just been able to share with her that we have very limited contact with DS, something she had assumed otherwise.
Newly married she will be moving house. We are in her hands as to whether we will have a new address.
If we can pick up contact again, I'm really feel we need a commitment from Ex DiL so that DGD isn't repeatedly let down. It must be awful for her - ‘ I see my grandparents...then I don't’ . Even if it was minimal but agreed and consistently carried out, at least DGD would be secure in that.

More mulling, I'm afraid!

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 23/08/2022 14:55

My sympathies are with you OP. I have something similar going on in my family and it's truly heartbreaking.

For those who are talking about court for grandparents, it's not that straightforward. If the childs mother doesn't want the grandparents involved then she pretty much holds all the cards. If there's no access then there's no relationship and the child will always side with their mother (of course). Court sometimes is only an option if the children are very young. It's a complicated situation but ultimately the child misses out.

I hope you can build some sort of a relationship with your DGD OP x

StrawberryQuartz · 23/08/2022 14:45

@fairycakes1234 yes I did read the post. It’s all too easy to villainize the Mother, the son is clearly a waste of space whose has shirked his responsibility but never mind as that doesn’t fit the narrative.

pinkyredrose · 23/08/2022 14:15

I think your son needs to learn how to use condoms.

Twocrabs20 · 23/08/2022 13:56

I love what @Hopeandlove proposed. I send that letter

fairycakes1234 · 23/08/2022 13:27

StrawberryQuartz · 22/08/2022 23:47

Oh behave. It’s on the child father to facilitate a relationship with his parents.

@StrawberryQuartz Did you even read the post, the son hasn't had access for years so is on the mother to let her child see her grandmother, have a heart, i hate hearing these stories, women holding all the cards and even though it is best for the child to have lots of family to love her they withhold access, its horrible and hope the OP gets sorted. My aunt went to court, her son wasnt interested in his daughter so mother stopped my aunt seeing her, even though she had been around since baby was born till she was 6, she got access every second sunday for two hours. Its worth fighting for.

alwayscheery · 23/08/2022 13:22

I would keep a card and good wishes for the future separate to messages about contact.
Just Wish your xdil and her new DH happiness in their future together.

EachandEveryone · 23/08/2022 09:55

What was the favour she wanted?

notanothertakeaway · 23/08/2022 09:48

I think you could send a friendly card "Congratulations on your wedding. Hope you have a wonderful day"

And try to develop a relationship with granddaughter that doesn't involve your son. Leave him out of it. She's 5 years old and you haven't seen her for 2 years. That's a long time for a child

It's unclear whether you have made an effort to maintain contact, or have sat back and blamed ex DIL for not facilitating it. But it's never too late to improve a situation. Perhaps you could ask to take her out for a cake at a local cafe (and reassure ex DIL that your son won't be present, as you wish to develop your own relationship with the child)

EarringsandLipstick · 23/08/2022 00:38

I'm so sorry OP. It sounds like a very sad situation.

You sound like a kind & caring person, trying to be reasonable.

Is there really nothing further you can do to re-establish contact with DGD?

Dinoteeth · 23/08/2022 00:35

Op send a card, wish them well, ask for some photos of DGD.

What's the worse thing that can happen, she's say no or ignores you.

Mythreefavouritethings · 23/08/2022 00:25

I’m sorry you are feeling this way, of course you are not being unreasonable. I don’t know how your relationship with DS is and nor do I need to, I’m just sorry that this situation between two people means you and your DGD can’t have that time together right now. I hope in time this changes 💐

Notimeforaname · 22/08/2022 23:54

I really hope you get to see your granddaughter soon. Yanbu 💐

StrawberryQuartz · 22/08/2022 23:50

That was in reply to @Mariposista

Swipe left for the next trending thread