Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About the random man who commented on my baby in the supermarket?

285 replies

Pbbananabagel · 22/08/2022 17:12

so I honestly don’t know if I was a bit too touchy about this and should’ve just smiled and moved on-

Random man leaned into my face and said “he looks like he’s smoking a cigarette, look how he’s holding that crisp”

it completely rubbed me up the wrong way and I said “thanks for that random man in the supermarket, that’s exactly the kind of comment a mum on her own in the supermarket needs to hear.”

he responded “don’t be stupid it was only a joke’

to which I said “you don’t know what might be on someone’s mind when you make comments like that” and he tutted and said
”really it’s a joke, so ridiculous” and walked off.

I felt so uncomfortable, people were staring and I thought maybe that was a step too far and I should’ve just let it go.

I lost two parents to cancer and one of the anniversaries is in two days. Today is the anniversary of me getting the call out of the blue at work that said “it’s cancer and he’s dying so get down here (300 miles away)” when my dad had just felt unwell on holiday and gone to the walk-in. So maybe I’m too touchy.

So, thank AIBU or was this random man really in need of my response?

OP posts:
KeepYaHeadUp · 23/08/2022 14:21

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 13:33

And this was in response to other posters rather than the OP by the way. The people who insist that no one owes anyone else any kind of politeness.

I didn't say no-one owes anyone politeness, I said interactions. If someone if polite to me I will be polite back. I don't think a weird comment from a man to a woman who then challenges her when she responds to make it clear she didn't appreciate his comment is particularly polite.

Either way, what you're saying is "I guess if ok not to be comfortable or happy about a man making a slightly odd. comment about your child but whatever you do don't upset them". Why should the OP or someone in a similar position be the one to check and modify their behaviour in response to an interaction they didn't even want or invite?

The way I see it the sort of interactions a poster's unwell, elderly father might benefit from are at risk of not happening precisely because when women react in a less than polite and docile way they're told theyre awful and should have been nicer. The men (because it is usually men) who make women feel uncomfortable with unwanted, uncomfortable comments are the ones to blame here

Singingtherapy · 23/08/2022 13:40

Totally ott OP which it looks like you get now. I struggle to understand the motivation to deliberately humiliate someone just for the crime of gauging a harmless comment slightly wrongly. The man hate on this thread is insane. Do none of you have sons? Does it not feel unbearable to think of them being spoken to like that?

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 13:33

And this was in response to other posters rather than the OP by the way. The people who insist that no one owes anyone else any kind of politeness.

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 13:33

KeepYaHeadUp · 23/08/2022 13:22

Maybe he did, but the OP (or any woman on her own in a supermarket) doesn't owe him an interaction to make him feel better. She might be happy to engage in
Conversation, in which case great, but if she doesn't she shouldn't feel obliged to carry on to make him happy

I get what you're saying, but do we not have some kind of obligations to the people round us if we live in a functioning society? Yes no one "owes" anyone interactions, in which case there were easier ways of shutting down an interaction than what the OP did. She could have smiled in a not smiling way and moved away, for example. Would have given a clear message.

During the pandemic people on MN moaned a lot about "selfishness" - people not doing exactly what the moaner wanted in terms of social distancing, isolation etc. Well, we didn't owe anyone that, but most of us did it anyway, even if we thought it was all bullshit, because we kept being told we owed it to people to help them feel comfortable. There's a happy medium between the stupid excesses of #bekind and deliberately shutting down all attempts at interaction.

Someone mentioned upthread about how worried threads like this make her feel with regard to her elderly father, and how a reaction like the OP's would have greatly upset him. Either we are #beingkind and #walkingamileinsomeoneelse'shoes or we're not.

KeepYaHeadUp · 23/08/2022 13:22

ThePelicansBriefs · 23/08/2022 11:48

I actually feel sorry for the man. Maybe he himself has a backstory and just wanted a little human interaction.
He wasn't being aggessive or offensive, just trying to make a little joke. Maybe it really did look like the child was holding a cigarette. You could have just smiled politely, whether it was a man or a woman making the comment. No need to turn it into a big deal. Then you could always have a moan later to your friend or something.

Maybe he did, but the OP (or any woman on her own in a supermarket) doesn't owe him an interaction to make him feel better. She might be happy to engage in
Conversation, in which case great, but if she doesn't she shouldn't feel obliged to carry on to make him happy

DarkShade · 23/08/2022 12:23

Johnnysgirl · 22/08/2022 22:58

At least you know you have the balls to react if ever someone does say something truly rude to you!
Sure, practise pissing all over the one's who aren't rude, just so you'll be at the top of your game when someone is. Top advice, that.

Sure, except I didn't say that. I clearly said that the OP made a mistake, which she admits, and then tried to offer a silver lining. It's a good thing to know that you can defend yourself (and a bad thing to not be able to tell when you don't need to, but the OP admits that).

SallyWD · 23/08/2022 12:02

"I’m glad young women are standing up to male superiority, instead of staying quiet, as you seem to want them to do."

Wow, someone making a harmless joke about a sweet scene is an example of male superiority?! Women make these comments all the time about babies. Are they trying to display" female superiority" or is it just a natural need for human interaction? Some people don't talk to anyone for days and exchanging a few words with strangers at the shops is a lifeline for them.

ThePelicansBriefs · 23/08/2022 11:48

I actually feel sorry for the man. Maybe he himself has a backstory and just wanted a little human interaction.
He wasn't being aggessive or offensive, just trying to make a little joke. Maybe it really did look like the child was holding a cigarette. You could have just smiled politely, whether it was a man or a woman making the comment. No need to turn it into a big deal. Then you could always have a moan later to your friend or something.

Johnnysgirl · 23/08/2022 11:22

I’m glad young women are standing up to male superiority, instead of staying quiet, as you seem to want them to do
Christ alive! And you're blissfully unaware that you've just completely proved her point 🤣

fairycakes1234 · 23/08/2022 11:21

sorry totally ott, he was just making a stupid joke.

phishy · 23/08/2022 11:12

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 11:05

That's funny, as you seem to have taken offence to my post.

Ha, ha - I rarely take offence, and I certainly haven't taken offence to your post. Just pointing out that older people have been around a while and can brush aside things which younger people (on MN anyway) find so offensive. Most of us don't take ourselves so seriously - thank goodness!

What a lovely, fake laugh to show how unbothered you are.

You seem to take yourself seriously enough to declare young people think the world revolves around them and their ridiculous notions. Reading threads on MN, your generation seems to have been complicit in the sexism against women. I’m glad young women are standing up to male superiority, instead of staying quiet, as you seem to want them to do. And as for the other poster, who said OP should have smiled at him - 🙄

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 11:05

That's funny, as you seem to have taken offence to my post.

Ha, ha - I rarely take offence, and I certainly haven't taken offence to your post. Just pointing out that older people have been around a while and can brush aside things which younger people (on MN anyway) find so offensive. Most of us don't take ourselves so seriously - thank goodness!

BeggarsMeddle · 23/08/2022 10:36

There's a shit-load of hypocrisy on this thread.

phishy · 23/08/2022 10:21

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 08:30

See how ageist that sounds? Don’t do that, it’s shitty.

Oh do get over yourself. Older people - generally - don't take offence nearly as much as the young seem to do.

That's funny, as you seem to have taken offence to my post.

OneTC · 23/08/2022 09:36

thanks for that random man in the supermarket, that’s exactly the kind of comment a mum on her own in the supermarket needs to hear.”

And then everyone clapped and cheered and you got your shopping for free from a crying manager?

CulturePigeon · 23/08/2022 09:34

I'm not a mother of young children any more and one of the things I look at MN for is to keep a finger on the pulse of modern parenting...partly so I don't put my foot in it with younger colleagues and friends.

But OP, what I'm taking away from your post (and others previously) is that 'Woe betide anyone who dares to speak to a parent, even if it's with friendly intention.'

I get that you thought the man's remark was lame - but it doesn't sound offensive to me. OK, I wasn't there, and his tone might have been unpleasant for all I know. But the remark in itself - I can't see what's offensive about it. How can mentioning smoking harm your child? I'd be more concerned if he dropped ash and blew smoke at them.

Was it because he was a man? I'm just struggling to understand the problem here. It wasn't a sexually offensive comment - just a (in your view) poor joke.

Though I rarely do it myself I think it would be awful if it became socially unacceptable for a stranger to speak to a parent and child in a friendly way - I see it all the time and it's great, especially when it's an old person - it might be the highlight of their day. Once sat in a coffee shop on holiday and an elderly couple came over to say (of my toddler son) '"He's going to be a heart-breaker, isn't he!" I laughed and had a chat with them, and didn't take offence.

But maybe I should have?? Implying that my innocent child was going to be emotionally abusive??

Lottie2shoes · 23/08/2022 09:29

Read a few pages. I am actually sorry at the state of how things are going. All these people getting upset about people randomly talking to them on the street.

What is the world coming to? I have had random men as well as women joke in the past with me, sometimes the jokes aren't even funny, but I just smile and walk away. Isn't that the thing to do?
I mean how many times have you told a joke and its fallen flat. Sometimes jokes are funny, sometimes they are not.
I personally could not get het up about someone making an observation about something, whether I agreed with it or not.
But to be passive aggressive back, with the " hey random man", it does not make someone look good. It seems mumsnet is selling this as making someone feel superior or cool but it actually is not. Just makes someone look like an idiot tbh. I would give that someone a wide berth next time.

KeepYaHeadUp · 23/08/2022 09:13

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 08:33

Chatting is part of what holds social life together, the ability to have casual community interactions is important to social function and it's not a good sign for our culture that it's become so fraught.

Exactly. However, sadly, we seem to have reached a stage where people aren't interested in social function or holding social life together.

If you can't see the difference between chatting with someone who's happy to chat and an unwanted comment then I can imagine you'd think OP was unreasonable.

If the man had made a passive, non-direct remark which OP had respond to giving a signal she wanted to chat and in conversation the man had made the same comment I imagine Op might have reacted differently. But that wasn't the scenario here AT ALL. I'm surprised at how many people can't tell the difference

IdiotSandwich05 · 23/08/2022 08:37

The joke was totally stupid and unnecessary, but I would have just ignored it. Sorry for your losses.

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 08:33

Chatting is part of what holds social life together, the ability to have casual community interactions is important to social function and it's not a good sign for our culture that it's become so fraught.

Exactly. However, sadly, we seem to have reached a stage where people aren't interested in social function or holding social life together.

SorryButThatsAFact · 23/08/2022 08:32

Witnessed it more than once, much to my frustration

onlythreenow · 23/08/2022 08:30

See how ageist that sounds? Don’t do that, it’s shitty.

Oh do get over yourself. Older people - generally - don't take offence nearly as much as the young seem to do.

SorryButThatsAFact · 23/08/2022 08:29

Nope, I've been there when it's happened.

I even sarcastically asked one woman if she could actually see me as thought I might be invisible!

MangyInseam · 23/08/2022 07:16

And an anniversary of parents death, while sad, is no excuse. We've all lost people, we still have to be able to function in basic social interactions.

HesterShaw1 · 23/08/2022 07:16

You were way way OTT.

Is no one supposed to say anything to anyone ever again in case they inadvertently trigger them!

The "random man" comment was funny the first time a MNer used it on a random man. This was just bizarre