Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-law and the ex

37 replies

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 15:33

Posting here to vent as I guess there’s nothing really I can do on a practical level. Name changed as some close friends are on here and don’t want this to be too outing.

Been with my partner 4 years and we have an 8 month old baby. We live in his home town close to his parents who we are on really good terms with. My entire family and most of my friends are 300 miles away down south. Since having my baby I’ve struggled. I’ve made some ‘mum friends’ but no one really close and most of my other friends from this area are working and busy. It’s lonely…like many new mums find it. Partner works long, demanding hours and we’ve been renovating our house until recently. Baby doesn’t sleep well at night and has never been a good napper in the day so I’m utterly exhausted. I also have a medical condition- not serious thankfully- but a big part of that is tiredness. I also do nearly all of the housework/life admin.

Which brings me to my next point. Partner and his ex (split 11 years ago well before he met me) have a child who we have regular contact with. The child is 12 so self sufficient in many ways but yet my in laws constantly go on and on about how his ex is struggling and needs help and has had it tough. They say it’s hard because she must be skint etc. They are constantly offering to babysit to the point they are taking my stepdaughter away on holiday next week so the mum can have a breather. I am under no doubt being a single mum is tough and I admire single parents everywhere, I’ve learnt how hard parenting is. But it’s like they constantly feel sorry for her. She works two afternoons a week only despite her daughter being in secondary school so if she was truly skint she’s got the ability to work more hours. My partner pays over the minimum amount and always has done, he’s been a great hands on father over the years and her family-whom I know she is close to and also provide childcare- are 2 mins away.

i don’t understand the need to be so supportive to her yet I’m genuinely finding things hard. My partner told MIL I was struggling months ago so she offered to take the baby a morning a week but never followed up. Recently when I asked her to take baby for a few hours she was too busy. Do they feel sorry for her or have some sort of feeling of loyalty?

I appreciate it was my responsibility to have a baby and I know it shouldn’t feel like me against her but it does. Where does this mindset of their’s come from?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BibbleandSqwauk · 28/03/2023 17:36

He doesn't have the child 50% of the time. He has one evening a week, Eow and half the holidays. The ex no doubt does all the hands on practical stuff, uniforms, kit, hobbies, homework, dramas, moods, tech issues (sorting out phone storage, contracts, password issues takes an unusually large chunk of my time). I actually find my 12 yo DD and teen son far more emotionally draining than when they were babies and hugely appreciate the help I get from grandparents. Sorry Op, but assuming your partner is a decent father to your baby and does his share of parenting, YABU.

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 17:22

Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 15:56

Yes but OP is minimising the other parents struggles when she doesn’t have a clue what those might be.
yea babies are tiring but easy AF compared to older kids

She has more than a clue what they might be. She knows that the ex has far more help and support than she does.

It's interesting that the posters here are reinforcing exactly the thing that OP is talking about.
Single parent: always thought to have the harder life, no matter what. No matter if they have a co parent who has the child/ren 50% of the time so lots and lots of free time, even if they work extremely part time, even if they have family on both sides giving childcare, holidays, and support.
Married parent: no family near, young baby, uninterested inlaws...told to shut the fuck up and get on with it and feel sorry for the single mother.

It's not only grossly unfair, its patronising as fuck to single mothers.

Danni73 · 28/03/2023 16:24

I think you are focusing too much on your DPs ex. You can’t control how much spare time she does or doesn’t have, but you should be able to control the workload is split between you and your DP.

As others have said, is he doing a fair and equal share with your joint child and around your joint home? If not then the solution is for him to step up more, rather than expect his parents to make up for his lack of support.

I do think that there is an issue with you being so far away from your family and therefore the fact that they cannot support you more. I think you / your DP need to ask his parents to babysit occasionally so that you can spend time just the two of you. I still think that you need to change the focus from, ‘they should babysit because they are helping out DPs ex’, to ‘it will be nice for DC to spend time with grandparents and you and DP will get some time together’.

Ktime · 28/03/2023 16:04

Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 15:56

Yes but OP is minimising the other parents struggles when she doesn’t have a clue what those might be.
yea babies are tiring but easy AF compared to older kids

The ex has a 12yo and works 2 afternoons a week and has family 2 mins away and exPIL constantly offering to babysit and taking their DGD away for a week to give her a break. I'd say she has it pretty good.

Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 15:56

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 14:13

No matter how difficult you found 12 year olds, they are objectively far more self sufficient than a baby under one year.

Yes but OP is minimising the other parents struggles when she doesn’t have a clue what those might be.
yea babies are tiring but easy AF compared to older kids

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 14:13

Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 13:43

I’d like to say wait h til yours is 12 and then tell me how self sufficient they are. They might not want to need their mum but they do need guidance a lot and they step wrong a lot. It’s emitjjbally a very hard age for them too, my DS was so emotional at 12 and my DD is just so grumpy now that she is 12.
also doing it alone (10 years for me with 3 DC) is tough, everything falls on just you.

maybe instead of asking them to take your baby out for a few hours you ask them round for coffee and encourage them to just hold baby.

No matter how difficult you found 12 year olds, they are objectively far more self sufficient than a baby under one year.

Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 13:43

I’d like to say wait h til yours is 12 and then tell me how self sufficient they are. They might not want to need their mum but they do need guidance a lot and they step wrong a lot. It’s emitjjbally a very hard age for them too, my DS was so emotional at 12 and my DD is just so grumpy now that she is 12.
also doing it alone (10 years for me with 3 DC) is tough, everything falls on just you.

maybe instead of asking them to take your baby out for a few hours you ask them round for coffee and encourage them to just hold baby.

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 13:43

MomwasCasual · 22/08/2022 16:33

She's on her own, and you have a partner. Who incidentally sounds like he needs to step up.

She has an involved co parent and family help from both sides. OP has no family help at all.

Itsbytheby · 28/03/2023 13:35

so she is alone with a child 12 out of 14 days (minus 2 days "after school") and you think that's not tough? You have your child 100% of the time of course, but that's not really much less than her and you have a partner helping and earning and sharing the emtional burden.

What your ILs are doing for the mother of their grandchild is kind. I would lay off the comparisons and stop being jealous. Because that is what it sounds like is the issue.

VeePee19 · 28/03/2023 13:28

Thanks

TheCatterall · 28/03/2023 13:25

VeePee19 · 28/03/2023 12:55

Hi I didn’t know where to post this. My daughter split with her partner about 3 months ago. They have a son who is 3 today. Ex’s mother isn’t showing up today for 3rd birthday, some lame excuse, but she was invited, she’s kept all his gifts at hers, but we found out she has sneakily organised a family (her family only) birthday party for him Friday knowing his mum is at work. The ex and my daughter have stayed friends and take grandson for teas etc together. So there’s no reason to exclude her, they still do things together . My daughter is very upset, is there anything she can do? She has been really reasonable about access etc.

I think you need to create your own post about this in relationships thread maybe? It will get more responses that way.

VeePee19 · 28/03/2023 12:55

Hi I didn’t know where to post this. My daughter split with her partner about 3 months ago. They have a son who is 3 today. Ex’s mother isn’t showing up today for 3rd birthday, some lame excuse, but she was invited, she’s kept all his gifts at hers, but we found out she has sneakily organised a family (her family only) birthday party for him Friday knowing his mum is at work. The ex and my daughter have stayed friends and take grandson for teas etc together. So there’s no reason to exclude her, they still do things together . My daughter is very upset, is there anything she can do? She has been really reasonable about access etc.

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 17:28

@Nyna thank you for your reply and for hearing it from that perspective. I’m sorry to hear you had a tough time and sounds like your GParents registered that and made a bigger effort. I did suspect that could be the case here too it’s just the only articulate it as to be doing the mum favours rather than just explicitly saying they want to see their granddaughter more etc.

i totally see your side in this now so thank you

OP posts:
Nyna · 22/08/2022 17:23

I have registered just to let you know my opinion. As a child of divorced parents my grandparents had always treated me differently from all the other grandchildren. It’s not out of pity from my mom, it was out of pity for me.
If a mom with so little to do feels really stressed with a 12yo, maybe grandparents think that there is some inequacy there she’ll be better with them and therefore offer to babysit and such.
My grandparents come from the age where they saw the divorce as the worst thing that could happen to me, and have been trying to compensate here and there, so other people think Im the preferred grandchild.
but in their view the other grandchildren didn’t need them that much, emotionally and financially. I agree with them btw, I did need them more comparatively.

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 17:21

@missbipolar every Tuesday after school. Alternate weekends and holidays are split 50/50.

OP posts:
MostlyHappyMummy · 22/08/2022 17:04

Your partner needs to step up to support you parenting the baby

missbipolar · 22/08/2022 17:01

How much does your partner actually see his other child?

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 16:59

Thanks for the replies, lots to think about there.

@luxxlisbon no sorry I meant my partner needs to take a week off to spend with me and the baby. I would never expect someone to take an 8 month old away on holiday for a week without me.

@EasterIssland he actually pays more than minimum and has taken her on holidays yes. He recently took her camping two weeks ago for the weekend and I stayed home. Prior to baby we took her away to Spain etc and she’s been away with him alone. Also I’d never expect the grandparents not to see her. I don’t want to ‘break’ anyones relationship. I’m just trying to understand their reasoning for the pity angle that’s directed a lot.

as PP have said above perhaps they assume my partner is more hands on. Or it’s simply easier to care for a 12 year old

OP posts:
Iliveonahill · 22/08/2022 16:58

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 16:24

Thank you for replying. I didn’t think of it from that angle they may find a baby demanding. That could be the case.

However it does genuinely have a vibe of pity towards the ex. That’s she’s somehow hard done by and I guess I find that frustrating as it’s not the case and she has the ability to have a better life money wise and she does have support around her.

My parents do visit but they both still work so they are limited in what they can do. My dad is also ill. I have asked partner to take an adequate amount of annual leave but says he’s too busy. The odd day here and there isn’t sufficient to provide a proper break. We need a full week off together or something. Childminder yes I’m looking into that and happy to do that. I just would love the family support to be directed differently.

appreciate your reply

You have a partner problem not an IL problem. Your partner needs to step up, take leave, do the admin etc etc. Why are you not sorting this out. Also agree with others they have know the 12 year old for 12 years. 12 year olds can be good company. They probably feel guilty too that their son failed in his marriage.

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/08/2022 16:50

I doubt his mum is particularly impressed that her adult son’s response to his partner struggling with the baby is to tell her that she should offer to help you with childcare. He needs to be the one giving you a break - if that means cutting his work hours down or putting the house renovation on hold for a while, that’s what needs to happen.

I have a friend with a ten-year-old and a friend with a baby. There’s no chance I’d offer to look after the baby, particularly not as a regular commitment such as a morning a week. Whereas I’ve taken the ten-year-old on day trips and away for weekends because it’s easier. They’re a proper person and can voice their needs rather than crying.

They’ll also want to retain the relationship they have with their son’s ex because they’ll lose regular contact with their granddaughter if they don’t. That isn’t a risk whilst you’re still in a relationship with their son.

HotWashCycle · 22/08/2022 16:48

Can your DH say to his parents - look I am working long hours and OP is finding it quite hard as she does not get enough sleep and her family are hundreds of miles away. He could then suggest that maybe they could help out a little - maybe have your DC for an afternoon or morning - keep it fairly short at first in case they find a baby too tiring. They may not have the imagination to realise you are struggling.

Carrotmum · 22/08/2022 16:45

I think you are looking to your DH’s parents for practical help and support rather than looking to him, he’s the one who should be stepping up and making sure you get decent rest. Yes the hospital appointment was unfortunate but maybe they had something else on, even now hospital clinics can reschedule appointments if you give them plenty of notice.
Your in-laws are going to see new baby because their son and you are together, so can enjoy grandparent time without having to do childcare. With the ex she’s probably not going to pop round to theirs or invite them over so the only way to see their older grandchild is to do childcare.
I had a gap of 11 years between my 2 children and my parents were much more involved with the older one because they were so much younger and in better health back then.

EasterIssland · 22/08/2022 16:43

Summerinparis · 22/08/2022 16:30

@MintJulia you’re right I agree I’m not entitled to help from them. And of course I understand they have a relationship with her, that doesn’t change.

it’s more the pity angle I’m confused at. I’m just struggling to understand directing so much help and somehow who likely doesn’t need it half as much as me. Not to say she doesn’t struggle I’ve acknowledged things will be tough but on a practical level she’s not up doing night feeds, changing nappies, baby screaming etc. Equally her childcare is covered by her sister during the holidays but she only works a few hours

Just because she’s not doing night feeds etc doesn’t mean her life is not tough. Imagine how your life would be if your partner wasn’t there , not a break etc. it’d be tough as hell. Being a parent isn’t easy. Please don’t try to break their relationship with their GD because your life isn’t easy currently or this might come back to you and bite you

MintJulia · 22/08/2022 16:41

I think you should stop comparing your situation with hers, and judging whether people should help her/feel sorry for her. It sounds like it's starting to get to you. It would be a shame to let it spoil your maternity leave.

Her hours are none of your business. I don't understand the benefits system but even I know there are points where working more hours isn't worth it. You can't know her financial situation so best to keep out of it. Enjoy your husband and baby and forget about what others have or don't have.

EasterIssland · 22/08/2022 16:40

Does your partner take the child on holiday (as this is their responsibility)
also your partner pays the minimum , does he also do the minimum to this child as a father ?

to be honest he doesn’t come out well from your op and the in laws are just trying to have a relationship with their GD which not sure what the problem is.