Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wales primary the sex education experiment

109 replies

justasking111 · 22/08/2022 14:13

Now Wales has been ahead with some things, kudos to that. But sex education in primaries, masturbation at nine, advice from the WHO . Parents not allowed to know the content of lessons. It's out of hand now IMO. Are the staff of primaries happy with this.

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/education/wales-sex-education-plans-court-23776923

gov.wales/curriculum-wales-relationships-and-sexuality-education-rse-code

I feel we're being bamboozled into this

YABU dinosaur thinking

YANBU primary is too early

OP posts:
pointythings · 22/08/2022 17:45

I seem to recall OP does live in Wales and was very excessively worried about sending her DC to school there because every lesson would be about sex. Or something.

While you're here again, what exactly is it that you find objectionable in the wales.gov document that you linked to?

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 17:43

justasking111 · 22/08/2022 17:40

I do live in Wales. Why would you think I don't

Because you were talking on another thread about living in Leeds for 3 years and then moving to West Yorkshire or something like that?

But okay so you are Welsh. Still doesn't explain all the other points people have raised on the thread.

justasking111 · 22/08/2022 17:40

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:34

The op also doesn't live in Wales 🙄

@justasking111 education in Wales is more or less devolved. You don't live in Wales, therefore why do you even have such a strong opinion on something that doesn't even affect you.

Are you Welsh? Is there a reason why you feel like you are in a strong position to be dictating what should or shouldn't be taught in Wales? If you are English have you considered the cultural and historical ramifications of doing so?

I do live in Wales. Why would you think I don't

OP posts:
womaninatightspot · 22/08/2022 17:13

I was a bit twitchy last year when my 6yo twins did d similar class. For weeks there was much chat of vulvas and vaginas. For examples she kicked me in the vagina. No I didn’t. Yes you did. Vagina is the inside bit I kicked you in the vulva. Muuummm she kicked me in the vulva. Bonus points for loud voices in supermarket.

Im sure it’s better for children to know proper names rather than twee euphemisms though so best just to suck it up.

sanluca · 22/08/2022 17:04

@NippyWoowoo

*In what decade?

All the info on Google seems to disagree with you*

So condescending towards what I say because Google told you differently... Seriously?

So for people who actually would like to know how it works in the Netherlands, there are guidelines from the Government roughly what is stated in the image Nippywoowoo provided. These are guidelines, not mandatory and nobody checks what schools do. I am sure there are some liberal schools in Amsterdam where the Dutch elite live that follow these guidelines, but all schools I know for my kids, family kids and friends kids do not.

Age 3 to 7 it is all about what is your family and where do you come from and other kids have other families and come from somewhere else and isn't that brilliant. And also mums and dads love each other and then there are babies. Also the flutters when you like someone.
Then from age 9 onwards a bit of biology, the basics the kids all already know because the parents told them. I know I went through the period talks with both my girls myself.
Then yes, sex ed in secondary school.

So guidelines, not enforced, not mandated, not followed. As if Dutch parents would allow the government to dictate something like this. The Dutch don't even trust the weather app when it comes to rain predictions, let alone our government when it comes to the raising of kids.

Why are teen pregnancies so low? A culture of open communication between parents and children, free conception like birth control pills, good college and university education possibilities and a mentality that you first get a degree or learn a trade, travel, then settle down, then have kids. That is why average age of first time mums here is nearly 30.

idiotmagnet · 22/08/2022 16:39

🦕🦖🦕🦖

MermaidEyes · 22/08/2022 16:34

YABU dinosaur thinking. The earlier children learn about sex, their bodies, pregnancy, contraception, the better.

pointythings · 22/08/2022 16:22

Yeah, I won't be clicking on the Christian fundie nutjob channel, thanks.

I'm going off the wales.gov document linked to in the OP and would like @kelsie2878 to tell me what they find objectionable about it.

Mardyface · 22/08/2022 16:13

@kelsie2878 what specifically in that curriculum is relevant to what the youtube account you've linked to is saying?

As an aside to others if you don't want to give clicks/money to right wing reactionaries don't click on it.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 16:13

kelsie2878 · 22/08/2022 16:02

I cannot actually believe this is happening and that the votes on this post are sort of 50/50. I hear you OP, they declare that the specific class material and content is sort of left up to the "teacher", you would need to sit in on the class to know what was going on - specifically.

However, you can easily learn what is going on bigger picture and why and how through getting into academic material/papers/journals/books. The sex education is just a slice of the rotten pie.

I strongly recommend New Discourses - start with the oldest videos and watch them all and get a really good grounding on what is actually going on.

School is just not safe or sensible or to be trusted it's not even debatable at this point.
😥

New Discourses is owned by an American Christian Nationalist. The Christian nationalists in America want to change the American state to be more Christian.

Because fundamental Christians (or any major religious groups) teaching sex education always has such an excellent success rate.

kelsie2878 · 22/08/2022 16:02

I cannot actually believe this is happening and that the votes on this post are sort of 50/50. I hear you OP, they declare that the specific class material and content is sort of left up to the "teacher", you would need to sit in on the class to know what was going on - specifically.

However, you can easily learn what is going on bigger picture and why and how through getting into academic material/papers/journals/books. The sex education is just a slice of the rotten pie.

I strongly recommend New Discourses - start with the oldest videos and watch them all and get a really good grounding on what is actually going on.

School is just not safe or sensible or to be trusted it's not even debatable at this point.
😥

JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 22/08/2022 15:45

I think on the face of it it's quite radical and scary compared to what most people experienced at school. However the actual policy seems sound and all subjects are taught in an age appropriate way.

My school is doing a session for parents to learn about the new RSE curriculum (and also aln reform) and as a school governor we've had several discussions and a sub committee dedicated to the topic so it doesn't feel like something that is being hidden in anyway.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:43

EmmaH2022 · 22/08/2022 15:40

Oh okay

confusing! But I did think we had already improved sex ed and that teen pregnancy was lower than when I was a teen.

We do, the likelihood is that the curriculum is updated every year or so (the one the op linked to is from 2021) and the OP has suddenly got her bee in her bonnet about it as if its some whole new thing that has never happened before

Honestly it doesn't look that much different to what I learnt in Wales in the 1990s except with some extra emphasis on learning that not all family set ups are the same and some focus on recognising the signs of domestic violence and what to do about it which I think its a great addition (it may have been in there previously and our school didn't just teach that bit well)

EmmaH2022 · 22/08/2022 15:40

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:37

I mean the OP has literally linked to a copy of the curriculum so I am unsure as to why she is claiming parents can't be told what on it as she has already found it freely available so I think that ones just been pulled out of thin air to be honest

Oh okay

confusing! But I did think we had already improved sex ed and that teen pregnancy was lower than when I was a teen.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:37

EmmaH2022 · 22/08/2022 15:35

I thought our teen pregnancy had reduced loads

re the OP, I don't understand why parents wouldn't be told what's on the curriculum.

I mean the OP has literally linked to a copy of the curriculum so I am unsure as to why she is claiming parents can't be told what on it as she has already found it freely available so I think that ones just been pulled out of thin air to be honest

SudocremOnEverything · 22/08/2022 15:37

EmmaH2022 · 22/08/2022 15:35

I thought our teen pregnancy had reduced loads

re the OP, I don't understand why parents wouldn't be told what's on the curriculum.

But they are being told. That document makes the content of the curriculum abundantly clear.

parents just don’t get to see the individual lesson plans or veto them

EmmaH2022 · 22/08/2022 15:35

I thought our teen pregnancy had reduced loads

re the OP, I don't understand why parents wouldn't be told what's on the curriculum.

mumonthehill · 22/08/2022 15:35

Parent in Wales and I do not object to any of this. We must teach children about respect, sex, puberty, and rights in age appropriate ways in schools. If we are open with our children and do not treat these subjects as if they are dirty secrets then our children will be informed, safe and without stigma.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:34

pointythings · 22/08/2022 15:28

OP started a similar thread a few weeks ago. At least this time the actual policy document is included, so we can easily point out how wrong OP is assuage OP's concerns.

The op also doesn't live in Wales 🙄

@justasking111 education in Wales is more or less devolved. You don't live in Wales, therefore why do you even have such a strong opinion on something that doesn't even affect you.

Are you Welsh? Is there a reason why you feel like you are in a strong position to be dictating what should or shouldn't be taught in Wales? If you are English have you considered the cultural and historical ramifications of doing so?

Mardyface · 22/08/2022 15:31

Have you read the document? There is absolutely nothing to object to in there. It is all essential education imo.

NippyWoowoo · 22/08/2022 15:28

sanluca · 22/08/2022 15:13

My kids were in Dutch schools, if you think at age 3 or 7 they are taught about body parts and reproduction at school you are misinformed.

Sex, reproduction, etc are taught in year 2 of secondary school. At 13-14 years. I believe condoms and bananas are involved...

In what decade?

All the info on Google seems to disagree with you

Wales primary the sex education experiment
pointythings · 22/08/2022 15:28

OP started a similar thread a few weeks ago. At least this time the actual policy document is included, so we can easily point out how wrong OP is assuage OP's concerns.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 15:28

I would also like to say @justasking111 that I fully support the Welsh governments method of not allowing pupils to be excluded from sex education.

Looking at the curriculum it shows over the years they are taught what consent is, how to flag it up if someone touches them without consent, what the signs of an abusive relationship are.

Unfortunately there are parents who would exclude their children from sex education specifically because they don't want to learn things like that. Those children absolutely need to be in those lessons.

MaryMcCarthy · 22/08/2022 15:28

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 22/08/2022 15:21

There’s really no need to teach masturbation, they’ll work it out themselves.

When I first masturbated I felt immense shame and guilt. I carried it with me for months and told no-one. I thought there was something wrong with me. I imagined the ghost of my dead grandmother watching me, disgusted.

So maybe a bit of education would help?

Janesmom · 22/08/2022 15:28

These threads are getting tedious. The one constant is some uninformed OP who thinks that some one-sided, hyperbolic newspaper article represents a full and honest picture.

Swipe left for the next trending thread