Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wales primary the sex education experiment

109 replies

justasking111 · 22/08/2022 14:13

Now Wales has been ahead with some things, kudos to that. But sex education in primaries, masturbation at nine, advice from the WHO . Parents not allowed to know the content of lessons. It's out of hand now IMO. Are the staff of primaries happy with this.

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/education/wales-sex-education-plans-court-23776923

gov.wales/curriculum-wales-relationships-and-sexuality-education-rse-code

I feel we're being bamboozled into this

YABU dinosaur thinking

YANBU primary is too early

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mardyface · 23/08/2022 17:40

I think it's an interesting point though. This would all be much easier if women's bodies were not culturally seen as commodities they or other people can use for purposes other than their own pleasure/reproduction. It's great to tell young women their bodies belong to them and their choices should be their own but when all the messaging everywhere else says the exact opposite it feels like a losing battle. The jump from child to woman is one most of us are not prepared for in terms of how everybody else suddenly sees us is it?

pointythings · 23/08/2022 17:31

We're going to have to agree to disagree here. I'm fully in favour of autonomy, but it would be utterly dishonest to tell young women that getting pregnant at 13 is just fiiiiine. It isn't. If it happens so be it, we deal, we make the best of it and absolutely there should be more support. But it should be avoided as a first priority. That isn't victim blaming, that's common sense.

Tandora · 23/08/2022 09:39

pointythings · 23/08/2022 09:05

@Tandora but it is important to teach young people about relationships - sticking to just the biological facts doesn't empower young people to say no to things they do not want to do. It is important to understand the negative influence of porn culture, and the risks of pregnancy and STIs has to be discussed. It just needs to be delivered in such a way that it is effective for everyone.

But the problem is there are so many values being communicated there that are subjective and problematic. For example a focus on “ risks” of getting pregnant undermines young people’s reproductive choices and contributes to stigma and exclusion of young mums (eg in education). you can teach people about pregnancy and contraception without couching it in terms of avoidance and risk. Young People need to be empowered with the knowledge that they need to make their own choices free from social judgement/ purity culture , which ultimately is the route of victim blaming/ rape culture.

pointythings · 23/08/2022 09:05

@Tandora but it is important to teach young people about relationships - sticking to just the biological facts doesn't empower young people to say no to things they do not want to do. It is important to understand the negative influence of porn culture, and the risks of pregnancy and STIs has to be discussed. It just needs to be delivered in such a way that it is effective for everyone.

Tandora · 23/08/2022 08:30

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 21:55

Almondsandraisins
A lot of sex education is victim blaming stuff.

I 100% support the proposals, and believe sex education should be taught in primary schools, however I do also agree with this. The sex education I had at secondary school was very much sexist and victim blaming- I think because it was all about “relationships” and teaching girls to avoid preg and the dangers of STIs.
The sex education I had in primary was much better and incredibly helpful as it was focused on biological facts.

pointythings · 23/08/2022 08:25

I'm completely in favour of the safety side being worded in such a way that young people know they are fully not to blame if they are coerced/tricked into giving out their number, but the message not to give out your number (or send photos etc) absolutely needs to be out there.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:47

TheSunnySide · 22/08/2022 23:38

There’s a LOT of scare mongering going on from groups set up to challenge sex education in Wales. There’s one which uses the words ‘child protection’ in their name who stir up so much unnecessary worry among parents and many of their member seem to have lost all sense of perspective. Having said that, I think each school is at the mercy of their SLT and some of the more dodgy gender identity stuff is going to be encouraged depending on the perspective of leadership.

Whilst there is some question around whether the curriculum is open ended enough to let some extreme gender identify ideology stuff through (and I have no issue with people being taught not to discriminate those who don't feel the sex they are born with is correct, but there is some more extreme stuff out there that would make me nervous), the OP had a thread awhile ago with some vague (homophobic?) concerns around primary school children being taught that gay people exist so I think fundamentally that might be the root cause here.

Other than a complete lack of faith in any education the welsh government can lay out of course...

TheSunnySide · 22/08/2022 23:38

There’s a LOT of scare mongering going on from groups set up to challenge sex education in Wales. There’s one which uses the words ‘child protection’ in their name who stir up so much unnecessary worry among parents and many of their member seem to have lost all sense of perspective. Having said that, I think each school is at the mercy of their SLT and some of the more dodgy gender identity stuff is going to be encouraged depending on the perspective of leadership.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:23

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:22

Almondsandraisins
I understood that perfectly well first time.

Apparently not as you then keep berating me for not knowing something before you said it. Enough, I am done now.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:22

Almondsandraisins
I understood that perfectly well first time.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:20

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:16

You mean when you posted at 22:38

When I posted at 22:38 it was in response to you complaining about why posters were saying that you didn't want sex ed, so I thought I would explain why I had thought that originally.

Hence why I said:

I think I was the first one to say about banning it.Because you are disagreeing with the posters arguing for sex ed it it really does read at least to start off with as if you are against the curriculum being discussed and sex ed.
If it is in fact that you want sex ed changing then that was not immediately clear.

i.e. I wasn't saying again that you weren't, I was explaining why I thought that in the first place.

I only actually said it once, at 20:58 before you ever said it wasn't the case.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:17

(Its also concerning you are complaining about the way sex ed is taught when you are in fact one of the people teaching it...)

I don't teach it in that way though do I, again another assumption of yours. I actually challenge everything at both subject level and safeguarding level but then given you seem to know a lot about me then you will already know this won't you?

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:16

You mean when you posted at 22:38

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 23:12

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:04

Almondsandraisins
My mistake they weren't for you but you said you had read my posts and you thought what was implied then somehow you didn't read those? Funny that?

Again, as I teach the children, people will be rude to you if you are rude back.

So you complaint is that essentially I hadn't read your posts at 22:11 and 22-28 when I posted at 20-58? Okay then apologies my mind reading abilities hadn't kicked in at that point

I really don't know what you are trying to accuse me of at this point. I, and several other posters, thought you meant 1 thing. You told me you didn't at 21:23 and you are now complaining that I ignored you the two subsequent times when I never said anything about it afterwards.

I wasn't rude in the first place, although my last post was frustrated. You were rude when you complained about our reading comprehension. Its concerning you are saying you are a teacher.

(Its also concerning you are complaining about the way sex ed is taught when you are in fact one of the people teaching it...)

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 23:04

Almondsandraisins
My mistake they weren't for you but you said you had read my posts and you thought what was implied then somehow you didn't read those? Funny that?

Again, as I teach the children, people will be rude to you if you are rude back.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 22:59

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:53

  1. At 21:23
  2. At 22:11

I'm sorry you are complaining about my reading comprehension because you had to reply to a completely different poster the same thing you replied to me

Unless I am somehow responsible for everything anyone who disagrees with you says I think perhaps it isn't my reading comprehension of your posts where the issue is 🙄

But no you didn't have to tell me the same thing twice. You told me once as I have already stated. Perhaps you will leave me alone now with your self proclaimed rudeness.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:53
  1. At 21:23
  2. At 22:11
Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 22:50

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:45

Almondsandraisins
I'm not at all. I am disagreeing that sex ed is good when it really isn't at all. I am against a lot in the curriculum in how it is delivered not the content.

I was very clear, I stated that 2 times for you and you ignored it. Not sure how much clearer I can be when I categorically state something and you ignore it? I was very clear.

I am rude to people who are rude to me and given that you were ignoring me and making statements about me then I have every reason to be rude to make you listen when stating it clearly is not working.

Please do point out where you had to tell me a second time as I can only see one post where you said this to me, the first one where you clarified it. I cannot see where I have ignored it at all after that.

I have not ignored you, or made statements about you, although I have responded to you.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:45

Almondsandraisins
I'm not at all. I am disagreeing that sex ed is good when it really isn't at all. I am against a lot in the curriculum in how it is delivered not the content.

I was very clear, I stated that 2 times for you and you ignored it. Not sure how much clearer I can be when I categorically state something and you ignore it? I was very clear.

I am rude to people who are rude to me and given that you were ignoring me and making statements about me then I have every reason to be rude to make you listen when stating it clearly is not working.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:42

Hercisback
Consent and relationships were already included where I have taught, I've never not known it to be. However, it is how it is taught that needs addressing. In much the same way that advice for the way we teach maths was recommended in 1982 but not really put into place until the past 10 years. That needs to happen for this subject.

Consent education is pointless without teaching kids why it mostly gets ignored. We need them to understand why people ignore consent and that is down to what we teach them through the media etc. Consent education alone is not good enough and pointless.

Internet safety again I've never not taught but we will struggle when the government release documents such as the new KCSIE which is victim blaming in some of the paragraphs. Those at the top need to sort themselves out.

Almondsandraisins · 22/08/2022 22:38

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:28

Hercisback
I've not asked for anything to be banned. 3 times I have said this now. Seems a few of you are really struggling to read.

Sex education is no better than 10 years ago at all. It is very much the same.

I think I was the first one to say about banning it.Because you are disagreeing with the posters arguing for sex ed it it really does read at least to start off with as if you are against the curriculum being discussed and sex ed.

If it is in fact that you want sex ed changing then that was not immediately clear. If several people misunderstand me I tend to assume I have not been clear about something rather than other people don't have clear reading comprehension.

If you want to change sex education to make it better, then see if MN will run a campaign on it. Ironically some of the people you are being rude to here would probably be the first to back you up.

Hercisback · 22/08/2022 22:33

In my school it is much better than 10 years ago. Consent and relationships is now included. Coercive control is covered. Safe use of social media. (There's more but this is just the top of my head). Perhaps we were at a lower stating point than some places.
My sons school it is infinitely better than anything I had at primary school 25 years ago.

I stand by you needing a separate campaign, apologies for misinterpreting your posts.

bigfootisreal · 22/08/2022 22:31

Hercisback
Let's keep refining the resources and funding training for teachers to ensure they are kept up to date.

It needs a complete overhaul of the system and not just training but a change in attitude from teachers and those above towards what sex education should be like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread