Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how many of today's children behave?

315 replies

PlutoCritter · 22/08/2022 13:50

Let me start by saying i'm in my early 30s and I definitely don't come from a "children are seen and not heard"/military-family type background where children weren't allowed to speak. my parents were quite laid back in some ways. however:

we've had our first child and this year i've started to make my first mum friends. (no dads, it's very traditional around here, all either SAHMs or part-time working mums as the primary carer, in a new fairly middle class area which we've only been living in for the last year or so, so don't have strong social networks yet.)

I've only really started to host "play dates" in the last few months and very often the baby's parents bring older DC along,which I thought was great!

So it's 2x babies plus (say) a 4 year old and a 5 year old. or a couple of 3 year olds plus a 7 year old. most recently, a 5 and a 6 year old with 2 babies visited.

and JESUS CHRIST, the average bahaviour is feral!

Most have been jumping on the sofa (to the point I thought it was going to break springs and had to tell them to calm it down myself eventually), one child going into our bedroom and looking through the wardrobe (!!) when going to the bathroom, one was repeatedly sneaking into the kitchen where i was making lunch and stealing stuff from the fridge 10 minutes before i was due to serve it, lunch just smashed up into a ball of mess and not eaten by older kids (5-7 years) regularly. Getting up halfway through a meal to run off and play with toys at age 8. Constant whining for snacks and sugar drinks. One refused to drink anything at all during a 2hr visit because we only had milk or water (i literally had no juice in the house to offer). Stealing food from other people's plates. Constantly interrupting adults having a chat - not while being ignored, just as the normal way of communicating. Ramming metal car toys into the wall so the wallpaper is scratched and the plaster has dents in it in the living room.

A few days ago, one little "darling" decided it would be funny to remove all the sofa cushions and drag them into the dining room so no one could sit down until it was all fixed as we helped the littler DC take shoes and coats off, then the %/6 (ish) child stood giggling while the adults just sorted it. if i'd done that as a kid as a guest my mum would have brought the wrath of god down on me there and then!

I genuinely don't believe a lot of this would have been accepted when I was a kid, and the first couple of play dates, i thought we'd just met a couple of bad apples, but it's now 5-6 visits with 3 different families. i'm not happy to accept further playdates at home if it's going to be like this and people think it's normal. DH is the same, he's been shocked at the state of the house when people have left and on the times he's been here, he's sick of people not telling their kids how to behave as a guest and feels similarly uncomfortable at e.g. having to intervene when a child has been doing something dangerous or damaing while the parent sits and ignores it.

please tell me this isn't normal????

(let me be clear, the kids seem perfectly NICE as children, and they play nicely, e.g. sharing toys, it's just the general disrespect for adults or breaking things that i am finding absolutely shocking.)

OP posts:
Spanielsarepainless · 22/08/2022 16:15

A lot of parents think they have to be friends with their children, rather than bringing up the next generation to be civilised members of society. They are also afraid to say no or establish reasonable boundaries. Then they blame it on the schools later on.

pinheadlarry · 22/08/2022 16:15

Kids are definitely more "free", these days and I'm only 27,
i wouldn't have been able to get away with it, that's for sure
my mum only had to give me that look ..

But in saying that , if my daughter came to your house, you would be talking about us right now!
She is autistic though, but she's like tasmanian devil whenever we go to someone's house..
I can't ever relax because I have to keep an eye on her constantly,
she likes to "explore" too, so I have to insist that any delicate items get put away, just to make sure nothing gets damaged and make sure bedroom doors are closed.
I will literally have to guide her back to the living room every few minutes but it is what it is..

I would never let her run wild and not do anything about it ..
I always bring things to occupy her like a board game, the ipad and make sure she's not wanting something but it is really hard to enforce rules into her,
I can tell her 1000 times not to go in to someone's fridge, not to go in their rooms, she's not going to listen, once shes transfixed on something,

She responds better to "on the spot" discipline,
so I would have to physically block her from going into the kitchen and tell her
" no " right there and then, take her by the hand and whisk her away, countless times.. until she gives up

And if she has a meltdown, starts kicking off screaming we have to take her somewhere quiet to calm her, and that usually means its time to go home..
We are probably not great guests to have 😅 which is why we don't really do visits that often, because its just too much and I'm always stressed about damaging someone's things
it can get awkward when I'm constantly jumping up and down in the middle of a conversation
Meeting up in a public space or an activity is more our style ..

MsTSwift · 22/08/2022 16:14

It’s part laziness and part wanting to “be kind” be their friend and not be a strict authoritarian Victorian type mother. Does the kid no favours as they up being as vile to other adults as they are to you and the other adults (utterly reasonably like the op) then think badly of them.

Sickened me how some parents would allow their young and primary aged children to treat them. Hitting/rude to their faces. Parents meekly taking it - being sappy and even often apologising to the kid! Setting the stage for nightmare teen years. Not how I was brought up nor Dh nor our two. Who are now funnily enough quite pleasant teens - must be a coincidence 🙄.

Duttercup · 22/08/2022 16:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CulturePigeon · 22/08/2022 16:14

RicherThanYew · Today 16:03
I have the same experiences op, I'm a scummy lower low class sort of person, think tattoos and swearing but my kid is well behaved because I'm not a fool. His buddies however are from higher earning families, nurses/business owners on naiice new build estates but when they come here I need valium for a while afterwards. Tbf if I behaved the way these kids do, my mother would have actually battered me to death for the shame of it.

I can completely relate to this!

Sorry for broad generalisations, but yes, both as a teacher and a parent I found the kids from the local council estate to be better behaved because their parents had no truck with trendy ideas about parenting. They said no, they meant no, and there were consequences. Result: civilised children I was happy to have in my class and my home. Just my own experience, but I think there's a lesson there.

Again, I know it's unfair to generalise, but it did tend to be the more affluent, well-educated parents whose children were allowed to get away with too much. These parents had read all the latest books and articles about child psychology and basically just over-thought everything. One dad genuinely believed it was wrong to stop children doing anything they wanted to and would damage them. I told him that, while of course he loved his kids, if he wanted other people to like them he needed to set some boundaries.

And as another PP has said, all these problems float along the river until they get to school and frankly, no wonder teachers are leaving the profession in droves.

justdontkno1 · 22/08/2022 16:14

@Bonheurdupasse loads of family in France and have lived there . In my experience kids are in school absolutely loads in France , far more than in the UK and Ireland so kids in school from 3 years old until 4pm everyday at least (except Wednesdays in some cases) . Schools are a lot stricter there too , however secondary not any better than the uk there. I’ve seen many parents openly hitting kids over there also which is grim but that’s just what I’ve seen , I’m in Ireland and have thankfully never seen a parent hit a child. In my experience of France parents overall are so much more supported to work as school much longer and get so much more help in general so therefore aren’t with their kids as much so hands off a lot. I don’t think kids are necessarily better behaved there though eating practices are better as they all eat in school together so agree with that part.
I’m definitely on the stricter side than my friends kids but don’t at all relate to what the op is saying (some of it is classic they have a baby and they can’t imagine having an older child vibe!!). I don’t think some countries are inherently better than others at raising kids , it’s v individual so I always eye -roll at the idea that the French or Scandinavia are sooooo much better than everywhere else.

BeanieTeen · 22/08/2022 16:13

Eh? What's the other meaning of military family other than a family with one or more family members in the armed forces? @BeanieTeen

@Rosehugger because the term ‘military’ is often used in connotation with precision and strictness. Which makes perfect sense in the context of the OPs post. As opposed to her randomly thinking of military families as all having perfectly behaved children due to an overly strict approach to parenting - which makes no sense at all.
Maybe she should have said ‘military style’ or something for those unable to understand words out of usual context.

hedgehogger1 · 22/08/2022 16:11

It's not normal but kids do need something to do. Suggest neutral ground next time

ZimZamZoom · 22/08/2022 16:09

I feel your pain OP!
We moved into a newish house a while ago. We lived here for around two months before having some friends to play. Within two hours, there were scratches on the paintwork all the way up the stairwell, stains on the carpet etc.
And this is why I now don't invite any children to my house for playdates. Always meet at the park, always!

i wasn't under any illusions that my own children are perfect angels but it certainly made me appreciate how relatively well-behaved and non- destructive mine are!!

I have no idea if it's normal or not, but the behaviour you describe in your OP does seem to be commonplace now. And, no, I wouldn't have dreamed of behaving in that way as a child myself (in the 80s).

ddl1 · 22/08/2022 16:07

I still remember the neighbour girl who came to our house, and:

(1) Asked for a glass of orange juice. My mum gave her a glass and pointed out the carton in the fridge. Big mistake. L. poured herself a glass and drank it; then another glass and drank part of it and poured the rest down the sink; then poured the entire rest of the carton down the sink.

(2) Went up to the bathroom; squeezed the entire tube of toothpaste out onto the towel; threw the towel down and stamped all over it.

My parents were generally very tolerant and welcoming of other children, but you may guess that this was the first and last time she was allowed in!

This was the early 70s. She was 10, not a toddler; and had no known special needs, though I suppose people were less aware of such things in the 70s.

My point is that some kids have always been badly behaved!

Oh, and did I mention the 4-year-old son of a family friend, who caused quite a lot of embarrassment by stealing the weights from the grocer's van- the grocer was Not Amused.

I think things like not sitting still at the table are pretty normal, but not trashing your house while their parents look on. But as I say, I don't think it's new.

RicherThanYew · 22/08/2022 16:03

I have the same experiences op, I'm a scummy lower low class sort of person, think tattoos and swearing but my kid is well behaved because I'm not a fool. His buddies however are from higher earning families, nurses/business owners on naiice new build estates but when they come here I need valium for a while afterwards. Tbf if I behaved the way these kids do, my mother would have actually battered me to death for the shame of it.

BeanieTeen · 22/08/2022 16:00

YANBU.

I think often it comes from a good but misguided place. Parents care about their children’s feelings and as PP said they don’t like to see them upset and actively feel guilty if they’ve made them feel upset by telling them off.

Sometimes it’s having misconceptions about ‘kids being kids’. This idea that pretty much everything a child does is just them acting naturally as children so it should be allowed because restricting their natural behaviour is somehow damaging - drawing on walls and jumping on furniture included. When actually, although jumping and drawing are of course natural things that need to be allowed and fostered, children still need adult guidance in how to express these natural behaviours in appropriate ways - for example with paper or a trampoline…
Children are not experts on their own needs - you teach them to cross a road, you teach them how to eat healthily, you teach them how to brush their teeth properly and yes, they definitely also need guidance on how to behave. Many parents are unwilling or don’t know how to give that guidance.

BackOnTheBandWagon · 22/08/2022 16:00

kegofcoffee · 22/08/2022 15:20

Just wait until you have a toddler Wink

Generally they are feral!

I have a toddler. If they're not behaving well then I stop them, or if they really can't manage to behave then I take them home. Kids will be kids, it's the parents that are the problem.

Louise0701 · 22/08/2022 15:56

This is definitely not normal behaviour! My eldest is 9 and I’ve met maybe 2 families through the years with a child displaying this kind of behaviour and it’s been down to additional needs.

Skye99 · 22/08/2022 15:53

NCNCNCN · 22/08/2022 14:23

Don’t worry, yours will be perfect, OP

There’s a big difference between ‘not perfect’ and ‘people don’t want to be near them’.

Mardyface · 22/08/2022 15:53

I think she meant military family like captain von trapp who parented with his whistle, not like actual families with soldiers in them who parent in all sorts of ways.

Rosehugger · 22/08/2022 15:51

I’m from a military family, and not for a second did I think the OP meant actual families with parents in the military

Eh? What's the other meaning of military family other than a family with one or more family members in the armed forces? @BeanieTeen

BeanieTeen · 22/08/2022 15:49

military families are also kind, loving places where children are allowed to speak.

I’m from a military family, and not for a second did I think the OP meant actual families with parents in the military.
Are people really taking that literally 😂

Mardyface · 22/08/2022 15:49

I have found that the posher the parents, the less they like telling their kids off. I live in a London neighbourhood that is gentrifying and my older kid's friends got told off and were generally well behaved but with the younger one three years later the parents were really really ineffectual and like 'Don't do that Ignatius, no please darling, oh dear' etc. The kids were a bloody nightmare as a result.

In some ways I think it's almost an unwillingness to engage with the kids in any way. Eg if your kid is jumping on someone else's sofa and you don't want to tell them off, find them something else to do! It doesn't have to be unpleasant all the time but it does take effort!

MrsLargeEmbodied · 22/08/2022 15:48

could it be lock down related?

Rosehugger · 22/08/2022 15:48

I didn't behave like that and didn't see other kids behaving like that when I was little. But then I never went to other kids' houses for a mass play date with 0-7 year olds. It sounds like quite a stressful environment for adults and kids, all those kids of varying ages together in a house at once, adults trying to have a chat and not supervising properly.

I used to get together with two other mums with babies the same age and take it in turns to go to one another's houses. Kids all in one room or garden and properly supervised. A mass play date/coffee morning etc with lots of kids of varying ages does sound a recipe for disaster in any time!

HoppingPavlova · 22/08/2022 15:47

Doesn’t surprise me at all as it’s the modern parenting fad of never saying no to a child (abusive apparently), letting them set their own boundaries and encouraging them to do/say/act however they want on the basis of letting them explore/express emotions and a million other newfangled batshit things.

A kid jumping on your lounge is no longer to be chastised, their parents will sing their praises because they are ‘spirited’ and ‘know their own minds’ and ‘a girl who isn’t afraid of being physical’ etc. The best you can hope for is some twee talk they may have with the child about feelings. Said child couldn’t give a shit, their mind is elsewhere while the parent is rabbiting on to them about potentially expressing feelings another way than demolishing your couch but the kid won’t even be listening. Your couch is fucked I’m afraid and don’t dare say anything to the child or you will destroy their self esteem for life seemingly.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 15:46

NCNCNCN · 22/08/2022 14:23

Don’t worry, yours will be perfect, OP

It's not black and white. It's not a binary choice between "perfect" and "feral".

Covid has made adults and children alike forget how to behave.

gogohmm · 22/08/2022 15:46

@Cinnabomb

I've brought up two children who never jumped on the sofa and none of their friends have attempted to either, ditto beds. Behaviour starts at home. Teach reasonable boundaries then you won't be embarrassed by your dc's behaviour out. Same goes for meals - you can spot the kids in restaurants who eat as a family at home vs the ones given food separately often on laps - even if you only manage it 3-4 times a week eat as a family at the table, teach them by asking to pass the condiments etc. parenting isn't rocket science, but it requires consistency

ShortOfShorts · 22/08/2022 15:44

I still do ‘house rules’ at the start of play dates now for my 11yo - only go into her bedroom, not any of the others, if you want food ask me and eat it in the kitchen, the toilet is upstairs.

Mine are older now, and while I can’t know if they ever behaved badly on a play date when I wasn’t there, I do know that I’ve reminded them to say please and thank you, help to tidy up, check house rules etc before and checked with the parent after about behaviour. And I’ve never had any complaints.

I haven’t forgotten the time I found one child first ransacking my pockets and then my cupboards looking for chocolate, then hiding in my room refusing to leave. In the end I retrieved her, as her mum had spent 10 minutes failing to, and handed her over at the door like a parcel. She didn’t seem to hold a grudge, and still asked for play dates!