Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how many of today's children behave?

315 replies

PlutoCritter · 22/08/2022 13:50

Let me start by saying i'm in my early 30s and I definitely don't come from a "children are seen and not heard"/military-family type background where children weren't allowed to speak. my parents were quite laid back in some ways. however:

we've had our first child and this year i've started to make my first mum friends. (no dads, it's very traditional around here, all either SAHMs or part-time working mums as the primary carer, in a new fairly middle class area which we've only been living in for the last year or so, so don't have strong social networks yet.)

I've only really started to host "play dates" in the last few months and very often the baby's parents bring older DC along,which I thought was great!

So it's 2x babies plus (say) a 4 year old and a 5 year old. or a couple of 3 year olds plus a 7 year old. most recently, a 5 and a 6 year old with 2 babies visited.

and JESUS CHRIST, the average bahaviour is feral!

Most have been jumping on the sofa (to the point I thought it was going to break springs and had to tell them to calm it down myself eventually), one child going into our bedroom and looking through the wardrobe (!!) when going to the bathroom, one was repeatedly sneaking into the kitchen where i was making lunch and stealing stuff from the fridge 10 minutes before i was due to serve it, lunch just smashed up into a ball of mess and not eaten by older kids (5-7 years) regularly. Getting up halfway through a meal to run off and play with toys at age 8. Constant whining for snacks and sugar drinks. One refused to drink anything at all during a 2hr visit because we only had milk or water (i literally had no juice in the house to offer). Stealing food from other people's plates. Constantly interrupting adults having a chat - not while being ignored, just as the normal way of communicating. Ramming metal car toys into the wall so the wallpaper is scratched and the plaster has dents in it in the living room.

A few days ago, one little "darling" decided it would be funny to remove all the sofa cushions and drag them into the dining room so no one could sit down until it was all fixed as we helped the littler DC take shoes and coats off, then the %/6 (ish) child stood giggling while the adults just sorted it. if i'd done that as a kid as a guest my mum would have brought the wrath of god down on me there and then!

I genuinely don't believe a lot of this would have been accepted when I was a kid, and the first couple of play dates, i thought we'd just met a couple of bad apples, but it's now 5-6 visits with 3 different families. i'm not happy to accept further playdates at home if it's going to be like this and people think it's normal. DH is the same, he's been shocked at the state of the house when people have left and on the times he's been here, he's sick of people not telling their kids how to behave as a guest and feels similarly uncomfortable at e.g. having to intervene when a child has been doing something dangerous or damaing while the parent sits and ignores it.

please tell me this isn't normal????

(let me be clear, the kids seem perfectly NICE as children, and they play nicely, e.g. sharing toys, it's just the general disrespect for adults or breaking things that i am finding absolutely shocking.)

OP posts:
1HappyTraveller · 23/08/2022 22:32

NCNCNCN · 22/08/2022 14:23

Don’t worry, yours will be perfect, OP

This attitude is part of the problem.

The OP never said her kids would be perfect but the behaviour she describes is completely unacceptable. If you’re taking offence because this is how your children behave and because it highlights the lack of discipline you demonstrate in your home and the disrespect for other people’s homes, then that’s your problem. It’s lazy parenting.

Shitpot · 23/08/2022 22:24

NCNCNCN · 22/08/2022 14:23

Don’t worry, yours will be perfect, OP

Is that a sarcastic tone I sense

Discodreams · 23/08/2022 22:18

Yep gentle/woke parenting where kids are taught they are the most important and have never heard the word no.

my eldest are adults/teenagers now but I remember following Gina Fords baby books which today are classed as completely unacceptable parenting, akin to abuse. Disciplining a child is frowned down upon because naughty behaviour is just them expressing emotions and they should be listened to.

I work in a secondary school and over the last 10years I’ve watched as behaviour has gone completely downhill, accelerated by lockdowns and too much time at home with zero boundaries. I worry for the future generations I really do.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/08/2022 22:13

YANBU thinking this behaviour is terrible - you’re unreasonable thinking it’s unusual.

According to some posts on here where according to a certain contingent of posters a child must never ever be made to feel like something they do is wrong, or their fault, or that they should apologise for something they’ve done that’s upset someone or broken something if it’s an accident.

I do agree with pp it’s because parents don’t know how to discipline their kids. I can tell you I would have bundled my kids up and taken them home with many apologies had they done even one of those things.

Noodles1234 · 23/08/2022 22:09

I have had a couple of difficult play dates, we can’t afford to replace the things we have bought (appreciate we have kids and the stuff won’t last that long). So I just meet at parks / somewhere neutral to keep it easy. Most kids need a good run about anyway. If I know they’re ok they’re welcome over.

I do feel parenting has slipped a bit, I just think parents have such busy lives it’s hard for many. I would never allow mine to do this, they’d be frogmarched home with me profusely apologising whilst leaving.

Shitpot · 23/08/2022 22:07

So disrespectful 😒

Fireflybaby · 23/08/2022 22:07

I wouldn't blame the children, is their parents that you have to choose better. And if the parents are not saying anything to their little darling s, i would if they it was happening in my house. They're in my house, I make the rules. No going upstairs, no access to fridge, no jumping on sofas/ beds, etc. And I would say that out loud in front for their parents so they are informed of the house rules and if the kids don't listen, their parents know why they're not allowed in the house.

Backtoblack1 · 23/08/2022 22:06

Secondary teacher here. It’s hell and the kids get worse every year. Been teaching for 24 years so am saying this with conviction. People have no idea what we put up with on a daily basis.

SeahorseBlue · 23/08/2022 22:00

Definitely not normal (or acceptable) OP. I have 3 children under the age of 8 and I wouldn't allow my children to behave like that, even when they were all younger. Like you I also don't think children should be seen and not heard, but this sounds disrespectful.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 17:56

@Cinnabomb young to mid primary age, but tbh this is not a new thing for us, it’s been pretty much since they were tiny. We’ve always eaten together and eaten all the same thing; we’ve always allowed input to choosing dinner when possible and when dates and stocks in the house allow. We’ve become more structured about it as they’ve got older, but even when quite little they would not have been able to refuse dinner and demand snacks 10 minutes later. We’ve always had alternatives available, if someone really doesn’t fancy what’s on offer that day they might get a boiled egg. They also don’t have to clear their plate (though they often will). My kids would happily live on chocolate, crisps and sweets if allowed, and I think many other kids would too.

but I know so many fussy kids, my sister’s child (now a teen) still seems to be restricted to beige food. And there are quite a few friends of ours whose kids make mealtimes restrictive. I don’t think kids should be force fed, but I also think that some kids need and respond well to boundaries to help them learn about healthy balance when it comes to food.

fairycakes1234 · 23/08/2022 17:17

definately not normal behaviour, my kids never went on like that and neither did their friends, we arent middle class either :)

MsTSwift · 23/08/2022 17:01

Yes our local outdoor pool since covid has a strict half an hour a lane booking system. At the end of the half hour out you get and the next swimmer gets that lane.

This sends the sappy gentle parents into a flat spin. Their kid just HAS to get out - no negotiation. Some of scenes are painful to watch as some parents are actually incapable of getting their primary aged kid to do something. I just get in and start swimming while they flap about. It’s pathetic how little control they have.

Cinnabomb · 23/08/2022 16:22

@CaptainBeakyandhisband out of interest how old are your kids?

ddl1 · 23/08/2022 15:38

I think one has to remember that parents may react very differently when visiting than at home. Partly because they don't want to inflict tantrums as well as everything else on their hosts. Partly out of embarrassment.

This often leads to either of two extremes. Either the parents become passive and don't interfere with their children's behaviour at all, like some of those described here; or they micromanage and seek to anticipate and prevent anything that can go wrong. I definitely prefer the latter extreme, but I've noticed that some MN-ers sneer at it as 'performance parenting'.

I think that hosts have every right to tell visiting children, 'In this house, we don't jump on the sofa' or whatever it might be.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 15:35

I don’t think I’ve said that children should be forced to eat (mine certainly aren’t forced to eat things they don’t like). But as a parent I certainly would not be happy if mealtimes were that disastrous and the kids were eating an endless stream of junk instead. And it pretty much was the ‘unless’ you mention i.e. whining for snacks.

I think we maybe are a bit old fashioned in our house though because whilst I would never force a child to eat something they actively dislike, mine are told (on refusing dinner) that it will be waiting for them later when they are ready for it. If I left it entirely up to their whims on what they will eat on what day we would struggle to get a balanced diet in. Each child has one evening per week where they choose dinner, if they don’t want to eat someone else’s choice (but it is something they would ordinarily eat) it’s just tough luck.

ddl1 · 23/08/2022 15:27

Goldbar · 23/08/2022 15:26

I agree with the rest of your post, but I don't think willingness to eat food should be used to judge whether a child is well-behaved or not. It sounds like the parents were lax on treats and discipline, but imo food should be offered to children who can choose whether or not to eat it and how much, and then it should be taken away without comment. Children should sit politely at table whether or not they want to eat the food offered. I wouldn't judge a child as being badly behaved for refusing food unless they then started whining for more pudding or 'snacks'. It's entirely their choice whether to eat it or not - they just need to be taught to exercise their choices politely.

I entirely agree!

Goldbar · 23/08/2022 15:26

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 15:14

I think this is a natural consequence of the push towards ‘gentle parenting’ … I’m not saying that this is what gentle parenting is (it’s absolutely not, it should be full of rigidity and boundaries) but tons of people seem to interpret it as ‘oh darling please don’t’.

we visited some old friends recently at their house. They cooked some beautiful food that their own kids didn’t touch (ours wolfed it down), their kids had three ice lollies (helped themselves) and ice cream. Later another delicious meal was provided, my kids ate, theirs refused. Kids under the table, screaming about eating, running around. The kids are 3 and 6, yet are ruling the roost. My own kids (who can be fairly demonic in their own right) were just watching in bewilderment.

I agree with the rest of your post, but I don't think willingness to eat food should be used to judge whether a child is well-behaved or not. It sounds like the parents were lax on treats and discipline, but imo food should be offered to children who can choose whether or not to eat it and how much, and then it should be taken away without comment. Children should sit politely at table whether or not they want to eat the food offered. I wouldn't judge a child as being badly behaved for refusing food unless they then started whining for more pudding or 'snacks'. It's entirely their choice whether to eat it or not - they just need to be taught to exercise their choices politely.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 15:16

Oh and I had a bunch of 8 year olds round a few months ago for a birthday party. My inner fish wife came out when I had to tell a child ‘will you get out of my flowerbed’ as he decided to plough through it (and over a patio wall) instead of walking round.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 15:14

I think this is a natural consequence of the push towards ‘gentle parenting’ … I’m not saying that this is what gentle parenting is (it’s absolutely not, it should be full of rigidity and boundaries) but tons of people seem to interpret it as ‘oh darling please don’t’.

we visited some old friends recently at their house. They cooked some beautiful food that their own kids didn’t touch (ours wolfed it down), their kids had three ice lollies (helped themselves) and ice cream. Later another delicious meal was provided, my kids ate, theirs refused. Kids under the table, screaming about eating, running around. The kids are 3 and 6, yet are ruling the roost. My own kids (who can be fairly demonic in their own right) were just watching in bewilderment.

CulturePigeon · 23/08/2022 14:59

On the topic of 'gentle parenting':

I used to run a Forest School in partnership with our local First School - so, 4 year olds. The children came every week for a term, and before we welcomed them to FS, we would visit the school for a meeting with the parents where we explained the philosophy/aims/practicalities etc of FS. They were given lots of verbal and printed info. One non-negotiable was that the children must always have legs and arms covered, even in summer, because of scratchy things and nettles. We explained this carefully.

One week a child arrived with a vest top on, and before we set off for the FS, I spoke to the mum about this...and she told me that the girl didn't want to wear a sleeved top today and had chosen her vest top. We had to break the news to mum and child that she wasn't going to join the FS unless she wore the right clothes. We had spare clothing available, so all was well, but clearly they had never encountered 'rules' before, or the concept that something wasn't just up to the child's whim.

And no, there were no ND or SEN issues - we checked.

Deadringer · 23/08/2022 14:08

Often these parents are coming around to get a break from their kids, to get a break from providing endless snacks, telling them off, and tidying up after them. They are passing all this work and responsibly on, so the host has to deal with it, or quietly seethe.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 23/08/2022 13:26

I agree with @InChocolateWeTrust and I'd also add - sometimes you just have to bloody pick them up and get them out of the room/into a pram/out of Tesco or whatever else, and physically stop them. I am generally quite a gentle parent - I'm one of those people that get eye rolled because I say things like "I'm going to pick you up now" to my pre-verbal baby - but I say "No" when I need to, and if they ignore that no once they're at an age to understand it, I remove them. Not rocket science surely?

Mardyface · 23/08/2022 13:23

I sort of wish I hadn't posted on this thread now. I do think kids should be told off but I don't think the world is going to hell in a handcart.

I don't think the only way to impose boundaries is by having consistent 'consequences' either. I think there are lots of different techniques appropriate for different situations and different kids too. The distraction thing, for example, is not setting a bad example necessarily - it might be creating an environment where it's easier for the kid to behave properly. I also think encouraging kids to TELL you what the problem is is great training for future assertiveness. Obviously they have to accept it if they can't jump on the sofa but engaging with them is as valid (and what I would choose) as going straight to a 'consequence' or punishment.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 23/08/2022 13:21

KimberleyClark · 22/08/2022 17:29

I did speak sharply to a child in the park who was chasing ducks. His mother looked a bit embarrassed.

Well, when me and my DM went to a local park (local outing) - we saw 2 sets of mums/kids chasing ducks/birds and we told one off as his parent wasn't doing it (the disciplining). Got a load of abuse off the mum (who did look a bit embarrassed) but basically we were made to feel as if we were the bad guys for telling a brat off.

Cam22 · 23/08/2022 12:42

Those ghastly parents who try to explain to their obnoxious child why it should do this or that are to blame and they are certainly storing up trouble for themselves. Children should NOT be the decision makers.