Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how many of today's children behave?

315 replies

PlutoCritter · 22/08/2022 13:50

Let me start by saying i'm in my early 30s and I definitely don't come from a "children are seen and not heard"/military-family type background where children weren't allowed to speak. my parents were quite laid back in some ways. however:

we've had our first child and this year i've started to make my first mum friends. (no dads, it's very traditional around here, all either SAHMs or part-time working mums as the primary carer, in a new fairly middle class area which we've only been living in for the last year or so, so don't have strong social networks yet.)

I've only really started to host "play dates" in the last few months and very often the baby's parents bring older DC along,which I thought was great!

So it's 2x babies plus (say) a 4 year old and a 5 year old. or a couple of 3 year olds plus a 7 year old. most recently, a 5 and a 6 year old with 2 babies visited.

and JESUS CHRIST, the average bahaviour is feral!

Most have been jumping on the sofa (to the point I thought it was going to break springs and had to tell them to calm it down myself eventually), one child going into our bedroom and looking through the wardrobe (!!) when going to the bathroom, one was repeatedly sneaking into the kitchen where i was making lunch and stealing stuff from the fridge 10 minutes before i was due to serve it, lunch just smashed up into a ball of mess and not eaten by older kids (5-7 years) regularly. Getting up halfway through a meal to run off and play with toys at age 8. Constant whining for snacks and sugar drinks. One refused to drink anything at all during a 2hr visit because we only had milk or water (i literally had no juice in the house to offer). Stealing food from other people's plates. Constantly interrupting adults having a chat - not while being ignored, just as the normal way of communicating. Ramming metal car toys into the wall so the wallpaper is scratched and the plaster has dents in it in the living room.

A few days ago, one little "darling" decided it would be funny to remove all the sofa cushions and drag them into the dining room so no one could sit down until it was all fixed as we helped the littler DC take shoes and coats off, then the %/6 (ish) child stood giggling while the adults just sorted it. if i'd done that as a kid as a guest my mum would have brought the wrath of god down on me there and then!

I genuinely don't believe a lot of this would have been accepted when I was a kid, and the first couple of play dates, i thought we'd just met a couple of bad apples, but it's now 5-6 visits with 3 different families. i'm not happy to accept further playdates at home if it's going to be like this and people think it's normal. DH is the same, he's been shocked at the state of the house when people have left and on the times he's been here, he's sick of people not telling their kids how to behave as a guest and feels similarly uncomfortable at e.g. having to intervene when a child has been doing something dangerous or damaing while the parent sits and ignores it.

please tell me this isn't normal????

(let me be clear, the kids seem perfectly NICE as children, and they play nicely, e.g. sharing toys, it's just the general disrespect for adults or breaking things that i am finding absolutely shocking.)

OP posts:
theruffles · 24/08/2022 12:45

I wouldn't put up with that kind of behaviour in someone else's house from my DC but I can see how it can happen with younger children, especially when they're in a new environment and around other children. We recently had a friend round with her baby (younger than my DC) and I found my eldest (4) starting to act up (trying to talk over us, whining for snacks, snatching toys off the babies) and I think it's an attention thing. I didn't put up with that behaviour however. I've noticed when we've gone round to a friend's house that my DC wants to go explore and see what's in other rooms/cupboards etc but I don't let her and make sure I follow her if she disappears off or is too quiet. I do think it needs to be kept in hand so kids don't think it's acceptable.

inflationhorror · 24/08/2022 12:03

I think this so subjective …

This was me:

“Because children who are too well-behaved and who are never allowed to push the boundaries tend not to do so well later on in life.”

Result=

I am in my 40s and still afraid of lots of people and situations. I often stay silent when something shit happens to me or my family. I lose opportunities. i am certainly not the most successful person.

I try to mitigate the above to get through life but it’s hard to work against the strict reflexes you’ve been brought up with.

The fear of doing things wrong never fucking goes away and it’s exhausting.

So I think it’s fine to have children that are polite for them to know boundaries but also for kids to know the world won’t implode if they cross them…

Goldbar · 24/08/2022 11:25

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 24/08/2022 10:14

I agree with this. Friend's DC when young (now 24) wouldn't eat e.g. tomatoes - but it was almost like, she can't/won't eat them so don't force them. Okaaayyy...

As a child I didn't like chicken but only because of where it came from but ate most other things and wasn't given the choice to be fussy!

As a child, I was taught that it was polite to clear your plate and would essentially force down food even if I wasn't hungry or was almost retching because that was what being "good" required at that time. Not eating food provided by your host was unacceptable. As an adult, I will eat almost anything but there are still some foods I have incredibly unpleasant associations with from my childhood and I am terrible at recognising when I'm full because I'm so used to clearing my plate however much food is on it.

It is absolutely none of my business what my children's friends or friends' children eat nor am I responsible for providing them with a healthy diet. If they don't eat tomatoes, they don't eat tomatoes - why should that bother me? If I know that they will eat pizza or spaghetti, then that is what I will usually serve because it's no skin off my nose to make them feel at home by providing an option which is safe and uncontroversial. If they refuse food and are hungry, we only have limited junk food in the house, but there's usually fruit, toast and crackers kicking about.

As for my own DC, just like me they go through stages of eating everything and stages of being off their food and I really don't see it as the end of the world or as them being "fussy". I haven't felt much like eating in the hot weather recently and have preferred to snack on picnic food rather than eat hot food, so it doesn't strike me as a big deal if my DC refuses curries, burgers and roast meals and prefers just to have a plate of some cheese, bread and carrot sticks, or a slice of toast and peanut butter. I think people can get too focused on what children eat, in a way we don't do to adults.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 24/08/2022 10:22

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/08/2022 22:13

YANBU thinking this behaviour is terrible - you’re unreasonable thinking it’s unusual.

According to some posts on here where according to a certain contingent of posters a child must never ever be made to feel like something they do is wrong, or their fault, or that they should apologise for something they’ve done that’s upset someone or broken something if it’s an accident.

I do agree with pp it’s because parents don’t know how to discipline their kids. I can tell you I would have bundled my kids up and taken them home with many apologies had they done even one of those things.

I actually had this the other week with DNephew. Very rude and then told me he didn't like me (he's 4 but very advanced). Apparently he's said this to his grandmother (his DM's mum). I told him I'd take away a toy I'd bought him.

His DM does some form of gentle parenting I think. His DF (my brother) does do this too a bit but is firmer.

So he was left to think and apologise for upsetting me... my DM (we were visiting her) did explain to him why he shouldn't say this.

I mean generally we get on well but his DM doesn't like to say if he's been naughty etc. He did used to get tantrums but she ends up e.g. carrying him a lot - he can walk and is tall and active. It's almost like anything for a quiet life with her.

SIL's parenting is in complete contrast to her own DB's and his DW's parenting with kids - they're firm but boundaries, not gentle parenting really at all but nice but the DW there definitely wouldn't be carrying her children and likes prompt bedtimes etc!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 24/08/2022 10:14

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 23/08/2022 17:56

@Cinnabomb young to mid primary age, but tbh this is not a new thing for us, it’s been pretty much since they were tiny. We’ve always eaten together and eaten all the same thing; we’ve always allowed input to choosing dinner when possible and when dates and stocks in the house allow. We’ve become more structured about it as they’ve got older, but even when quite little they would not have been able to refuse dinner and demand snacks 10 minutes later. We’ve always had alternatives available, if someone really doesn’t fancy what’s on offer that day they might get a boiled egg. They also don’t have to clear their plate (though they often will). My kids would happily live on chocolate, crisps and sweets if allowed, and I think many other kids would too.

but I know so many fussy kids, my sister’s child (now a teen) still seems to be restricted to beige food. And there are quite a few friends of ours whose kids make mealtimes restrictive. I don’t think kids should be force fed, but I also think that some kids need and respond well to boundaries to help them learn about healthy balance when it comes to food.

I agree with this. Friend's DC when young (now 24) wouldn't eat e.g. tomatoes - but it was almost like, she can't/won't eat them so don't force them. Okaaayyy...

As a child I didn't like chicken but only because of where it came from but ate most other things and wasn't given the choice to be fussy!

LuaDipa · 24/08/2022 09:06

That’s really not normal. We had loads of kids over here and only one misbehaved to that extent, most were lovely. The misbehaving child was not invited back.

PetraBP · 24/08/2022 08:25

MsTSwift · 23/08/2022 08:16

We put ours in the porch for 4 minutes for the worst crimes (hitting and biting others). Nicked from my friend. Remove small child immediately from the fun and no attention. They quickly got the message. Dd2 used to whisper “E needs to go in the porch” when she saw other kids being vile !

The Chokey from Matilda!

🤣🤣🤣

RaggedBlousedPhilanthropist · 24/08/2022 08:23

It felt like one!

OakAshBeech · 24/08/2022 05:16

Sounds terrible overall, but I think the age of the children needs to be taken into account. Some of the behaviour you've described is perfectly normal in a 3 year old, for example. At this age they typically haven't properly learnt correct social strategies such as not interrupting, and they will innocently wander into bedrooms (to explore) if allowed. This is normal behaviour for that age group. Parents should be keeping an eye on them, of course.

1HappyTraveller · 24/08/2022 04:43

RaggedBlousedPhilanthropist · 22/08/2022 17:02

It’s called “Gentle Parenting”.

It’s a nice idea whereby you never tell
off or criticise your child, or force them to do anything until they are ready.

In theory it is a lovely idea and I really did consider adopting it for DD, but I went to a few group meets when she was tiny and the devastation that I saw put me off.

The kids were all from middle class type families and actually had very articulate speech but the way they behaved was universally appalling. The following were all articulate and appeared neurotypical:

Think (without any adult correction):

  • 9 year old “expressing himself” by drawing on the walls without correction, being rude to adults, never saying “please” or “thank you” and snatching.
  • 6 year old in wanting nothing but Wotsits and yoghurt for lunch, and being given them. Constantly interrupted the adults. Jumped all over the furniture (think standing on kitchen units). Played with washing machine settings. Not toilet trained (wore a nappy).
  • Three year old singing “Old MacDonald had a farm” with the same verse over and over and over again without being asked to change the record.
  • Six year old pulling books from the shelves and throwing them claiming they were “paper aeroplanes” and shrieking loudly.
All the above while Mums with very little between the ears made comments about them “expressing themselves” and not wanting to “damage them” or “brainwash them” with “establishment” or “authoritarian” ideals.

It put me right off the whole thing.

Sounds like a cult!

Thepossibility · 24/08/2022 04:02

My kids wouldn't do that but ALL of their cousins would.
Their behaviour is largely ignored by their parents (three different sets) for an easy life. Which ultimately leads to a much harder life, really.

user1471452428 · 24/08/2022 03:27

UWhatNow · 22/08/2022 20:19

“Because children who are too well-behaved and who are never allowed to push the boundaries tend not to do so well later on in life.”

Wow. What absolute horse shit.

Yeah, in practice this kind of parenting = fat kid addicted to minecraft. Because guess what? Pushing boundaries (barf) means trying to get candy and screens when you are 9.

Frances0911 · 24/08/2022 03:10

Last year I had a stall at the local church Christmas Fayre, which is in a posh area of London. There were lots of children there running around hysterically in and out of the various stalls, whilst there parents just stood there ignoring them and chatting. I had some handmade xmas decs, which were glittery Pinecones, cinammon sticks, orange slices, all on sticks which I had arranged in a vase like a large bouquet. I saw a boy of around eight eyeing it up from a distance. He then ran towards it, jumped on it and knocked it over sending it all flying every where. The boy then proceeded to jump around with his younger brother looking very pleased with himself whilst I looked on in horror. His father who was quite posh, then came over, apologised profusely whilst never saying a word to his son, then turned around and said in a jolly voice, come on you two, lets go and get your face painted! I was also selling hand blown glass baubles a woman came over with her baby and allowed her to pick up a bauble and squeeze it hard in her hand, after around a minute of watching this I then said I really don't think that's a good idea, they're very delicate and could shatter in her hand - she just looked at me and walked off! I found the whole experience with these children absoulutely frustrating, and put me off from ever doing another fayre there.

itsjustnotok · 24/08/2022 03:02

The main thing that gets me is the lack of parent intervention. Kids do misbehave, what I loathe are the excuses, if a parent does what they can to resolved it then I am fine. It’s when they barely acknowledge their kids behaving like this I get wound up, more so if they use excuses and im
sorry the covid excuses wind me up the most. Yep 2 years at home, lack of socialisation was seriously crap but don’t let your child hit someone or wreck something and then look at me and say it’s cos of covid and do sweet FA, just attempt to parent, have a conversation or consequence but don’t blame the world around you.

mackthepony · 24/08/2022 02:45

I definitely think kids have less respect than they used to for adults.

I include my own kids in this observation.

antelopevalley · 24/08/2022 02:16

Look at how parents react to kids poor behaviour, and choose your friends based on that.
I have a close friend who has the same type of parenting style I do. It works well. Neither of us accept nonsense.

Canthave2manycats · 24/08/2022 00:37

PlutoCritter · 22/08/2022 14:17

thank you all, i've been wondering if i just have got old quickly "we wouldn't have behaved like this in my day"... but genuinely i don't believe we would have got away with it if we'd tried. DH is saying the same (same age, 30s, but from a totally different area of the country originally, in NI)

i feel less of an ogre now.

i feel like crying every time i see the living room wall where the cars were being "raced" up the wall and rammed into it.

NEVER again - parks only!!

I'm also in NI, through my kids are all adults now.

We had our share of misbehaving little sh!ts! Also had my three in my 30s, 3rd child I was 40.

I soon learned who to avoid having in my house, and often they were the children of parents whom you wouldn't have expected it from!

Birthday parties are best away from the house, and playdates are best limited to a couple of children, so they are containable!

As kids we would have literally been murdered for such behaviour, though a local family who used to come to our family business, were lethal!! They ran unfettered through our house; they jumped on the roof of their mother's car - and all that happened was, she said, "don't do that darling"!!! So, it's not entirely new behaviour!

Devilmakesworkforidlehands · 24/08/2022 00:15

Good idea about taking play dates outside to playgrounds/parks etc. One point- kids tends to get naughty/destructive/hyper when they are bored.. had you set up activity for the older kids to do?(or asked parent visitor to bring something) If they are engrossed in an fun age-suitable activity they are less likely to ‘make their own fun’ which might be more boisterous or intrusive than you like.

Decidualcast · 23/08/2022 23:51

I don’t think it’s normal. Just spent time in France, where loads of families dined out late with their kids. I didn’t see a single instance of bad behaviour - it was noticeably different to the UK.

DonnyBurrito · 23/08/2022 23:27

I think you need to get some courage and assert yourself in your own home.

Z0rr0 · 23/08/2022 23:03

I don't think it's right but I do think it's common. A lot of parents I see are terrible at moderating or even monitoring their children's behaviour. It drives me fecking nuts. I take my children to their dance classes at a local gym club and the parents there are so selfish and don't give any care for their kids doing cartwheels through the cafeteria while the staff try to deliver plates of hot food to the tables. They park however they want making it ridiculously hard to access the club, they ignore the requested one-way system that's designed to help people leave and arrive safely but instead forcing everyone to queue down the road as they try to get in. They litter everywhere. Their kids steal from the changing rooms and try to smash stuff up. Outside the toddlers throw stones around despite the signs asking them not to touch the stones (which are part of the soak away). Ugh. It's not the kids fault. It's all on the parents.

Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 23/08/2022 22:58

Your not being unreasonable... I work in a shop and some kids are feral... my kids aren’t perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but they know how to behave indoors and outdoors. I give them the look and they know instantly to stop what they are doing. How some of these kids behave nowadays my parents would have killed me and my brother if we acted the same way, back in the old days. There’s blurred lines nowadays about what’s acceptable kids behaviour and what’s not...

Sh05 · 23/08/2022 22:50

What were the parents doing throughout all this?
If any of my 5 had jumped on sofas, pulled cushions off I'd be taking them home.
We have a similar issue on our street recently, new family with a few children, the older ones are fine, youngest is 4 and has taken to just walking into the neighbors house and helping herself, to toys to food even to makeup left in an upstairs bedroom!
Parents are inside their own house have left it to the older siblings.
They treat everybody's gardens as their own, never take their rubbish in with them and I'm Just so glad the summer holidays are nearly over.
My nearly 3 year old wants to know why she can't pick flowers from someone else's garden when the other kids just help themselves.

Sartre · 23/08/2022 22:45

Not normal. I have 5 DC and they most certainly are not feral, they definitely wouldn’t behave this way in someone else’s home at all. I’d be mortified if my DC did this, honestly so I can’t believe those parents aren’t. I wouldn’t be hosting at home again personally, arrange to meet at softplay or the park.

fUNNYfACE36 · 23/08/2022 22:32

I run a sports club for children aged 4 to 12 and never come across this kind of behaviour. Kids are certainly better behaved now than when I was a child ( born in 1968)