Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said no on this occasion?

240 replies

CrockOff · 22/08/2022 13:37

Seems like I'm enemy number one at the moment with this but anyway..

DH is going away on Friday for the weekend with work. He doesn't travel with work that often but it's needed this weekend.

I'm actually really looking forward to it! We have a young son together who is 5 and my plan was to have some well needed down time together. I've booked the cinema Friday night and was going to take him shopping on the Saturday for some treats and go out for tea together. He's really looking forward to his "mummy weekend" as he calls it.

My husband and his ex share two DC who are 8 & 10.

She has been invited to a wedding on the Friday and has asked DH if he'll swap the weekend so she can go (it's a childfree wedding apparently). He originally said no then she asked me and I've said no sorry too.

This is where its hard. She's difficult sometimes. If there is something she really wants to do but can't, she gets very nasty and will sometimes refuse to let DH see them the next time he's due to because in her mind he doesn't care about seeing them extra blah blah. She usually comes around quite quickly so he doesn't go without seeing them for long but he'll go through a day or so of stress trying to reason with her.

DH is asking me to concede on this weekend to save him the stress of dealing with his ex or risk not being able to see DSC when he gets back, asking me to 'do it for him'. But I just don't want to. I hate that this woman can control my life like this and I'm just expected to meekly change my plans around hers whenever she snaps her fingers. She has family, she should ask them if we've said no (she doesn't like putting on her parents apparently but is happy to put on me...).

I'm aware my resentment on her is probably being a big driving force behind my refusal to help this weekend but I'm honestly sick of her. She thinks she is in control of everyone around her and we, even my son, are just expected to agree to whatever she wants.

I don't want to take DSC with us. I want this to be our weekend, they will change the entire time and as much as I do like them, I want to focus the time entirely on my son and spoil him a bit.

If she can't go to her wedding well frankly I really don't care!

OP posts:
Creepymanonagoatfarm · 22/08/2022 17:10

Dh can tell her he won't work and will have the dc but her Cms will reflect that this month.

WhereYouLeftIt · 22/08/2022 17:08

"DH is asking me to concede on this weekend to save him the stress of dealing with his ex or risk not being able to see DSC when he gets back, asking me to 'do it for him'."
His ex-wife is not your problem, she is his problem. And he needs to shoulder his own problem, not try and offload it onto you. Save him the stress? By stressing you? Fuck that for a game of soldiers! And 'do it for him'? How about he keeps his ex off your back? He should 'do it for you'!

"She has family, she should ask them if we've said no (she doesn't like putting on her parents apparently but is happy to put on me...)."
And by extension, so is he (happy to put on you). To 'save him the stress'.

Every time you concede, you are teaching her that kicking up a stink gets her what she wants. But you know that already. It's time for your husband to learn it.

Personally, I would give him a very hard time over this. It has to be more 'stress' for him to put on you than the 'stress' he gets from her. Make him reluctant to pull this stunt on you ever again. I suspect that is the only way he will stop outsourcing his 'stress' onto you.

TooHotToTangoToo · 22/08/2022 17:06

Sounds exactly like the situation my friend is in, she wouldn't agree to him seeing the dc more often, on a regular basis (he wanted 50/50) as this would mean less cm, however when she wants him to change arrangements to fit in with her changing shifts, or wants a weekend away - all of a sudden he's a terrible dad, doesn't want to spend time with his dc, his new family are taking priority. It's so bad that his new wife is getting seriously pissed off, he may find himself divorced and not living with any of his dc.

Brideandpredjudice · 22/08/2022 17:00

Do it once and you'll do it a thousand times. Just say no and get out of this silly routine where she's the boss.

pinheadlarry · 22/08/2022 17:00

My ex partners childrens mother dropped their kids at my house and we weren't even together any more, she didn't even know if i was at home!
She also dropped her kids off at their grandparents house without asking! Just disgusting behaviour, I know not all exes are like that, I would never behave like that but some do act so entitled and stroppy, if she was threatening to withhold the kids like they are chess peices, I would tell her to crack on
I will never be disrespected like that again..

Inertia · 22/08/2022 16:57

If it were his scheduled contact weekend then you would be helping him out.

Ex needs to be told no - he has already prioritised his children by arranging to work on a non- contact weekend, so that he is there for contact on the scheduled weekend.

Ex needs to arrange a babysitter, or husband needs to reschedule work.

pinheadlarry · 22/08/2022 16:55

I'm annoyed at your dh for accommodating her behaviour ...
He shouldn't be asking you to do that , who the hell does she think she is the queen of sheba?
If you said no, she should respect that and she shouldn't go behind your back and ask your dh to ask you to reconsider, that is beyond disrespectful
Your dh should say " you need to ask my wife, if she said no I can't help you, sorry"

Crumpleton · 22/08/2022 16:49

HotWashCycle · 22/08/2022 16:41

Have you posted about this before OP. I seem to remember a similar thread where the DH said yes to his Ex without consulting the OP.

Probably just appears to be so many DH's/DP out there that have forgotten they've split with their Ex's but still say "how high" when they ask them to jump.

Maybe a lesson to learn here is if you're about to marry someone that has DC and there's no formal CO in place to do some sort of pre-nup in regards to what is expected from the SP and what the SP is actually prepared to do.

Whadda · 22/08/2022 16:49

Your husband needs to sort this.

What would he have done if they were still married and she had a wedding at the same time he was traveling? That’s his starting point.

SunnyD44 · 22/08/2022 16:45

Well I'm amazed - where are all the posts crying about the poor stepchildren, how you should of course take them with you OP!

No one hates step parents.

Its just something that is often said on threads when the opinions aren’t going the way they want.

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 22/08/2022 16:44

HotWashCycle · 22/08/2022 16:41

Have you posted about this before OP. I seem to remember a similar thread where the DH said yes to his Ex without consulting the OP.

Just thinking it sounded similar but I think this is a different one. That poster stuck to her guns as I recall, wasn't that one something to do with the ex visiting the mother who had a brother she didn't want the child around?

HotWashCycle · 22/08/2022 16:41

Have you posted about this before OP. I seem to remember a similar thread where the DH said yes to his Ex without consulting the OP.

SudocremOnEverything · 22/08/2022 16:34

HirplesWithHaggis · 22/08/2022 16:21

Most people with reasonable exes don't need the faff or expense of a Child Arrangements order. It's not a failing on the part of DH here.

Except that it’s been apparent for some time before this that he does not have a reasonable ex. He’s got one that uses withdrawing contact as a weapon and is willing to emotionally abuse her own children to get her own way.

“If there is something she really wants to do but can't, she gets very nasty and will sometimes refuse to let DH see them the next time he's due to because in her mind he doesn't care about seeing them extra blah blah.“

“Whenever we say no to something as well she usually starts with how it's all about our son now isn't it and so on and that she'll tell them we have said we don't want them.”

So maybe he should have done something to prevent this, rather than just giving in because that’s the path of least resistance - for him.

BarnabyRocks · 22/08/2022 16:34

Not your problem.
Hold firm, do not concede.
Worst case she will give your husband shit about it for a few days max then it will fade.
She's a CF.
Hold the line m'lady!

SunnyD44 · 22/08/2022 16:32

Maybe if it was DHs weekend and he needed to go away for work then you could do it as a favour to him.

But no way should you be doing this when you already have plans (even if those plans involved lounging in your PJs all day).

She’s asked DH if he can do it - which is fair enough.
He is away and can’t do she needs to try and find a family member or babysitter or not go.

I think step parents should do things for their SDCs and their partners but they have no obligation to do anything for the SDCs parents.
It’s different if it was a hospital appointment or something.

TiddleyWink · 22/08/2022 16:31

Say no. And say it in a way that next time your husband doesn’t see pissing you off as an option. The way he apparently doesn’t his ex. He needs to get his contact time court ordered, he should have done that the first time she attempted to withhold contact. I would have very little respect for him as a husband or father, the way he is dealing with this situation. Where is his backbone or respect for you? He would rather inconvenience you than his ex or himself. How do you feel about your position in the pecking order? It’s not one I could tolerate personally.

WilsonMilson · 22/08/2022 16:31

This is a DH problem. He needs to stand up for you over his ex and her demands.

He has no right to dictate what your do with your weekend when he is away, his kids are not your responsibility at all. It’s him who is being a dick here.

Meraas · 22/08/2022 16:27

Say no!

TeeBee · 22/08/2022 16:26

CrockOff · 22/08/2022 14:05

Whenever we say no to something as well she usually starts with how it's all about our son now isn't it and so on and that she'll tell them we have said we don't want them.

Well yes, in this instance it is all about your son, because you are his mother...not the mother of her children. Cheeky cow (and so is your DH). You have plans for one-to-one time with your son. Tough tits to the pair of them.

elisenbrunnen · 22/08/2022 16:26

Well I'm amazed - where are all the posts crying about the poor stepchildren, how you should of course take them with you OP! They will be feeling unwanted, poor things. Everything that your child does, they should do, otherwise they are deprived. You should of course drop everything so that you can look after them, can't you imagine how they are feeling - no parent wants them? Hmm Neither of the actual parents want them there, so of course OP should be the one to parent them?

Where are the handwringers, stating that 'of course I would take them with me, they are faaamily after all...' (regardless of the fact that the step children have 3 or up to 4 parents, actual or step, whereas your child only has 2 Hmm )

Whatever happened to 'step parents can do no right'?

DelphiniumBlue · 22/08/2022 16:23

2 things...
Firstly, don't even mention why you can't have the DC, just a straightforward, "No, I'm busy/already got plans". If you give reasons, you give people like this ammunition to argue why should be able to do what they want..
Secondly, why are you her default childcare? Does she look after your DC? Is there a reciprocal arrangement?
I can see why DH would be her first port of call, and it's his children so he should accommodate having them if he can, but if he's already arranged to work knowing that he won't be having them, then there's not very much he can do.
If you say yes, she will keep on asking you. And if she knows why you are saying no this time, it will make you look bad to anyone she tells the story to, but that's not your problem.

aloris · 22/08/2022 16:22

I would not change my plans because you have already made a promise to your son and he is looking forward to spending "mummy time" time alone with you. You have a social event planned with him and your husband and his ex want you to cancel your social plan with your son to suit his ex's social plans. If you change plans now then it tells him that your plans with him are less important than your plans with other people. That will create insecurity for him that he cannot rely on the plans you make with him. It would be different if she had an actual emergency (eg. a medical emergency) or if you were planning to just chill at home.

HirplesWithHaggis · 22/08/2022 16:21

Spohn · 22/08/2022 16:19

Really poor of him to not have bothered getting court ordered access sorted years ago.
His options are:stay home and parent all his kids. Or, decline his ex.
Nothing to do with you.

Most people with reasonable exes don't need the faff or expense of a Child Arrangements order. It's not a failing on the part of DH here.

MsRosley · 22/08/2022 16:21

So your husband is happy to tout you out as a human resource just to save himself any hassle. Got it.

diddl · 22/08/2022 16:20

If they will "be no trouble" perhaps there's someone else he can ask who doesn't have plans for the Fri/Sat?

Swipe left for the next trending thread