Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To only pay for hours worked?

39 replies

BecauseICan22 · 22/08/2022 12:21

Going to keep this very basic.

Cleaner paid to clean for set hours twice a week.

Cleaner is paid cash 4 sessions worth at a time. Cash is cleaners preference.

Cleaner has repeatedly left early, 30-45 minutes over the last couple of months. I've let it slide thinking it's currently the summer holidays and she has kids.

Today cleaner arrived at 10am.
I'm at work so left an envelope of cash for her paying for her next 4 sessions of cleaning.

Called DH about something unrelated, he's WFH today, I can hear cleaner saying goodbye to him and that she's going now but she's done all the cleaning.

I've messaged politely to say as she left an hour early today, I'll deduct an hour from her next set of payments.

AIBU or not?

For context, we NEVER not pay.
We clear our space before she gets there to enable her to clean without hindrance.
We empty bins and set clean bedding sets on each bed to be changed.
She's generally really good at what she does and she's been with us since March. No overt issues otherwise.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
girlmom21 · 22/08/2022 20:36

Is there anything she could have cleaned that she didn't?

Ultimately if she's doing the work in 2 hours fair play to her. You might find you're paying another cleaner 3 hours and they take the full 3 hours and still don't finish the tasks.

Strangeways19 · 22/08/2022 20:27

If you play her by the job then yabu, and if you pay her by the hour I'd say that if she has finished the usual jobs in lesser time ask her to fill the rest of the time doing other jobs you need doing. That's the fairest way to deal with this

ShyMaryEllen · 22/08/2022 19:56

When I last had a cleaner I used to leave ironing out and if she finished cleaning she would start on that. You could try that, or if you don't have much ironing ask her to pull out beds, or clean the oven or fridge - things that don't need doing every time and it doesn't matter if the time runs out half way though as some progress is better than none.

Duettino · 22/08/2022 19:45

@BecauseICan22 has she responded to your message?

itsgettingweird · 22/08/2022 19:29

If it was an issue her leaving at that time why didn't your DH ask her to do a few jobs and give her a list instead of happily waving her on her way and then you texting that?

MumEeeee · 22/08/2022 19:21

I think the way you’ve dealt with it may mean it’s no longer an issue- you’ve lost a cleaner.
Rather than informing her of lost pay it would have been better to open a dialogue, after looking at the work. If there were bits missed raised it, if it’s ok ask her if two hours is enough or if she’d like to re-discuss tasks and time.

MrsMontyD · 22/08/2022 18:53

If you think she's not doing everything she could be doing, I would give her the choice of doing the things she's missing and keep the agreed hours. You'll have to identify what she's missing though.

If you're happy with her work and you're just annoyed she's doing it quickly that's more difficult. If you drop her hours because she's too efficient I would expect her to walk.

Chooksnroses · 22/08/2022 17:17

I feel a bit upset at the 'they all do this' comments. I am an ex cleaner, and I definitely did not do it. As someone else said, often as you get used to a house, (and get things clean!)it takes less time, but there are always extra jobs you can find. I used to tell new clients that my first couple of times might take 3 hours, but in time I might be able to do it more quickly, and ask what they would prefer me to do. In every case they said they would like me to find extra jobs to make up the time. In one house I cleaned one window inside every week, so over a few weeks all the windows were cleaned. In another I cleaned the husband's gym equipment, and in a third I washed down the decking and the children's outside toys, or sorted out the children's bookcase.
When you first meet your cleaner, you should discuss the "what ifs", and make a list of what jobs you particularly want done every time. For example, one new client said she wanted the tiles behind the bath cleaned every week, as her previous cleaner never did them. Another lady wanted her front door wiped down every week.

SirChenjins · 22/08/2022 17:11

Univalve · 22/08/2022 16:55

This. If you live in a ‘large house’ and she’s doing a good job maybe just let her get on with it instead of depriving her of the little income she has? What do you want her to do, clean things that are already clean just so you don’t feel cheated?

I would really doubt she’s cleaned everything on a big house in 2 hours.

AmongstTheCosmos · 22/08/2022 16:59

Some odd replies here. The cleaner is being paid by the hour. Therefore, if she leaves an hour early, she should be paid for an hour's less work.

I'd be pissed off too OP. Finding a good and reliable cleaner is a massive pain.

Univalve · 22/08/2022 16:55

Vikinga · 22/08/2022 13:31

It depends. If she did a good job but was quick and efficient, I wouldn't care.

This. If you live in a ‘large house’ and she’s doing a good job maybe just let her get on with it instead of depriving her of the little income she has? What do you want her to do, clean things that are already clean just so you don’t feel cheated?

KyaClark · 22/08/2022 16:49

My cleaner started leaving earlier and earlier every week. She hasn't finished, she just wasn't doing things!

She only lasted for 8 weeks and I don't think she cleaned the shower at all in that time. I thought I needed to re-grout because it was looking discoloured but it literally just needed a clean!

Finding a decent cleaner is so difficult.

gatehouseoffleet · 22/08/2022 16:44

I think the outcome is more important than the time spent here. Is she doing what you ask, to the requisite standard? If so, job done.

If she's rushing things, or not doing everything you've asked for, that's a different issue.

BestMammyEver · 22/08/2022 16:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

coconuthead · 22/08/2022 16:37

She should ask if there's anything else to be done if she's finished early and yea she should charge you for the full time but in my experience they all do this.

coconuthead · 22/08/2022 16:36

It's notoriously hard to find a good and reliable cleaner. So imo if you are happy with the work being done i would pick your battles. It is really annoying, and we've had the same and other issues from cleaners over the years. A friend of mine started inspecting his cleaners work and cutting her money for leaving early et. and his cleaner sacked him! It seems they aren't short of work where we are.

HardRockOwl · 22/08/2022 14:24

They all do this (well, in my experience!) it's the reason I no longer have a cleaner.

You pay her an hourly rate, she should stay for those hours. It's as simple as that.

Just tell her you expect her to stay for her agreed hours and deduct pay when she doesn't. There is no employment out that they would allow you to slope off at 4pm when your office contracted hours were 9-5

Or alternatively, sack her

Duettino · 22/08/2022 14:18

I used to be a cleaner a long time ago. With a standard 3 bed house, you get into the swing of things and can get the house done in less time. You're paying for a job to be completed rather than time sometimes.

I used to have an agreement they would pay less or give me a list of more things to do. I would never leave early (maybe 10 mins max if there was nothing that needed doing) with the assumption that there wasn't more and especially if they were in the house so I could literally ask!

She's taking the piss a bit. Is she doing a good job?

Haysmiths · 22/08/2022 14:01

It sounds as because you pay by the hour, you are expecting that she should clean for the amount of hours worked. (I would be the same). It's fine if it is a one off event leaving 10-15 mins early - but not every visit and an hour early is just cheeky. It is the principle.

If she is leaving because she has completed all the jobs you outlined, I would wonder why why she did not use her initiative to clean something else or why she didn't call or ask whether she could do anything else.

Even though I don't get paid by the hour, I'm sure if I regularly left everyday it would not create a great impression.

Have a chat with her and outline your expectations - whether you want her to stay for 3 hours and do as much as possible, or do X tasks for a set price regardless of the time taken.

Ottersmith · 22/08/2022 13:47

So she manages to get all the tasks done and is doing it quickly so you want to dock her wages. Do you go to work for two hours at a time? We have minimum calls in my work where you get paid for three hours at least as it's insulting to call someone in for two hours. I bet you wouldn't do a shift that short. She could have gone slow and let the work drag out to three hours but that is such a waste of everyones time.

cooldarkroom · 22/08/2022 13:34

Why dont you just have extra jobs she can do if the main chores are done ?
Windows
Clean washing machine filter
Clean door step
Sweep terrasse
Clean oven
The list is obviously endless.
She cannot just leave because the hoovering is done & the beds are made.
Tell her you pay for 3 hours, if she wants the money she needs to clean for the 3 hours

Wonnle · 22/08/2022 13:31

VeganCow · 22/08/2022 13:27

Is she completing all tasks though? If she is faster but still as good, does it matter if the jobis completed? Why should she go slow so you get your moneys worth in your head?

Because the cleaner is being paid by the hour not the task

Vikinga · 22/08/2022 13:31

It depends. If she did a good job but was quick and efficient, I wouldn't care.

VeganCow · 22/08/2022 13:27

Is she completing all tasks though? If she is faster but still as good, does it matter if the jobis completed? Why should she go slow so you get your moneys worth in your head?

Wonnle · 22/08/2022 13:16

Simple question to ask

"Is there any reason why you think i should pay you for 4 hours work when you seem to be only here for 3 ?"

Swipe left for the next trending thread