Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH can't just buy a pet for his child without me agreeing?!

89 replies

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 09:56

H is a bit of a Disney parent to DSC.

I get on really well with my step children but his inability to say no sometimes really winds me up. He carries a lot of guilt about them being from a split family and going on to have more DC with me. That's another thread.

But anyway, the issue...

One of my step children has been asking for a guinea pig for a while. H is now waining and looking to give in.

I am absolutely against the idea for a number of reasons:

  1. There's no way DSC will actually stick to being the one to care for it (like all kids promise to do I imagine), they are 11.
  1. I'm the one at home all day so likely will fall to me to do cleaning out, feeding and so on.
  1. We have other animals including 2 cats (not a good mix, one in particular is a hunter).
  1. DHs solution to this is they can keep it in their room where the cats never go (DSC very keen on this idea) but the smell, the mess!!! Ugh.

Anyway, I've said no way and H is now thinking I'm awful and mean and 'id get one if our child wanted one'. No I wouldn't, any pet we got in the future would be thought about at the time and whether it worked at that point in time (for example perhaps one day when the cats are no longer with us and both of us are around more to care for one) and everyone was in agreement etc.. but right now it doesn't work for us (or me anyway).

AIBU to put my foot down about this, I feel on edge like he's just going to get one for him for his birthday (in a few weeks) and "promise" he'll do everything. I'll be so mad if he does.

OP posts:
Connie2468 · 22/08/2022 11:14

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 10:39

I had a solitary guinea pig. Never seemed to suffer just being the only one. Was always out in the run or being fussed.

They do suffer, it's cruel to keep social animals in solitary confinement. Just because it can't tell you it has a miserable life doesn't mean it isn't suffering.
It would be like putting a human in solitary confinement with just another species to fuss over.

Guinea pigs aren't an easy animal to keep well, they need lots of space. We have indoor and outdoor cages (5ft long) and a run, they need a varied diet of fresh vegetables and hay, they poo constantly and need a lot of cleaning out and daily attention.
You can't keep them in the bedroom of children who aren't even living there full time.

Gremlinsateit · 22/08/2022 11:13

Also, like all small pets, guinea pigs always die tragic, heart-wrenching deaths and guess who will have to console the weeping children when they find their pathetic little corpses.

Midlifemusings · 22/08/2022 11:13

How and when did the cats come to be part of the household?

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 22/08/2022 11:08

Actually I think it's a great idea. Dsc will have to live with it. Literally if it's in their room. Dh can feed and clean it out. Absolutely no reason you need to even remember it is there... When dh gets fed up he can tell his dc why it is being rehomed. A good parenting lesson for him.

seaweedhead · 22/08/2022 11:07

Has he even looked at how to look after guinea pigs? They're not an easy pet and, as others have already pointed out, you can't just have one-they need company.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 22/08/2022 11:03

Having had Guinea pigs before, I'd say no way!
They smell, need a lot of space to run, you need two, they need more care than you think and they can get very noisy.

LorW · 22/08/2022 10:58

Piggies are also expensive, not only to set up (massive enclosure needed), toys, enrichment etc, you also have to make sure they have hay constant, greens and pellets, I also would recommend insurance (all my piggies were insured since I got stung on a vet bill- you’d be surprised how expensive it is for such a small animal)

Just put your foot down! I don’t agree with buying animals for children, it’s ridiculous putting that responsibility on someone who can’t even look after themselves.

Hiphophippityskip1 · 22/08/2022 10:50

I have been in this exact situation and husband went out and brought 9&11 dsc a bunny and a guinea pig. The novelty soon wore off and when the dark wet nights came interest was lost and they would not go out to feed and clean. Even worse the kids were only here fifty per cent of the timeLike you i could bot let an animal suffer as i was raised that if you have an animal you must give it the best life possible. I ended up being the main carer and the resentment I felt was huge. Be firm and stand your ground or at least set v clear ground rules and a schedule for feeding and cleaning which if bot adhered to means no tv/phone or screen time until its done. Sadly none of those options were available back when our pets were purchased.

Eeksteek · 22/08/2022 10:48

Sprogonthetyne · 22/08/2022 10:05

A few more negatives for the list.

You can't keep a single guinea pig, they're a social animal so you need two, so it's twice the responsibility.

They need a massive enclosure (70x140cm minimum for 2), so unless your DSC had a very big bedroom, it's not going to fit.

Not that you should need to justify beyond you don't want them, but it might stop DH wavering if he looks at the practicallies, without being able to paint you as the bad guy.

The hay gets absolutely EVERYWHERE (and they must have it) and if you keep them on shavings or straw it’s even worse. You can keep them on fleece mats, but it needs washing all the time (every other day I reckon) or it stinks. They poop for England (rodents!) which doesn’t smell bad, but also ends up everywhere.

They are absolutely lovely pets, but you don’t want any other pets (which I totally sympathise with. I also don’t want any more responsibility!)

Can you pet sit one and let everyone see what it’s like?

ThisIsAddiction · 22/08/2022 10:43

DD used to have house Guineas. Lovely things but they do smell, they do kick poo out and hers had a tendency to be more nocturnal (though google will tell you they aren’t supposed to be)

i found when I looked after them if she was away I was forever cleaning and washing their fleece lining because I became a bit pre occupied with the smell. After they passed she had an incredibly small dog and I’d take half a dozen of him over the pigs. Cute, but far too much work for my liking.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 22/08/2022 10:40

Guinea pigs are not bedroom animals. They need a bigger hutch than most people realise, and usually a mate. They need access to an outdoor run and enrichment.

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 10:39

I had a solitary guinea pig. Never seemed to suffer just being the only one. Was always out in the run or being fussed.

Trivester · 22/08/2022 10:34

Tell him it has to be kept on his desk at work.

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 22/08/2022 10:34

fufflecake · 22/08/2022 10:08

True but if its just the dsc's room then it's their problem if it stinks of piss for eternity. Then when they move out charge them for the damage.

Meanwhile, back in the real world.......

Seriously, who charges their DC clean up/ repair fee when they move out?? 🙄

DisappearingGirl · 22/08/2022 10:32

YANBU OP.

We have two guinea pigs and we love them but they are quite a lot of work. They live in a big C+C cage in our kitchen. It is 145 x 75cm. I do a mini clean out every day and wash the fleece liners every 3-4 days which is a faff. I don't think the kids would be able to reach in to clean it properly.

The piggies themselves don't smell at all, but the cage does quite quickly, and to be honest I think our kitchen always smells faintly of piggy wee. The hay and poos end up on the floor which is easy to sweep off a hard floor. But in a carpeted bedroom with the door shut I think there would be mess and smell.

They are also not as personable as a cat/dog, and although they are cute and comical, kids can get bored of them quite quickly I think, and they can live for up to 8 years.

I wouldn't get them unless YOU want them.

gingeristhenewblack43 · 22/08/2022 10:30

Guinea pigs are a massive commitment, as said you need a minimum of two and enough space for their cage.

My DD has 2 and they are kept in the dining room where the floors are wooden. The mess they create on a daily basis by kicking the shavings out, which DD then stands in and treks through the house 🤯 I vacuum the mess up about 3 times a day.

If they are indoor pigs then you also need a run in the garden too for them to spend time on grass. The outdoor run will need to be enclosed to protect them from other animals.

As you have cats you're indoor cage will need to be enclosed too. The cage needs spot cleaning at least once a day, and a full clean out at least once a week. It takes me an hour to do a full cage clean.

They need their nails trimmed monthly, I tried to do it and it was so stressful. Now I take them to a guinea pig border to get their nails trimmed.

They pee and poo wherever they are so if you cuddle them then expect to be peed and pooed on. We use puppy pads on our laps.

They are prey animals so will run and squeal when you try to pick them up.

After getting my DD's guinea pigs I found out that I'm allergic to them so have constant watery eyes and a snotty nose 🙄

thelittleapple · 22/08/2022 10:26

Apart from the fact that he shouldn’t be buying animals without your agreement, it’s really unfair to animals to put them in a child’s bedroom. They have to have quiet and peace.

sleepymum50 · 22/08/2022 10:24

When my Dd was younger we had a dog and a cat. She would often ask for things like a rabbit, hamster, usually after seeing friends who have small animals.

My answer was always no. I just don’t agree to animals in small cages. I read somewhere that rabbits are the most neglected animals. I know some people have these pets and give them plenty of outside time, but I believe they are in the minority. The way we keep small pets in cages is outdated and stems from a time when animal welfare was much much lower.

One tack might be to educate the child and your H exactly how cruel this is. I agree a parent who says that the child must be solely responsible for the care of the animal is irresponsible. My STBXH admitted once to having let his rabbit starve to death when he was a child. He was most surprised that I thought his lovely mother was equally to blame. Thinking about this still upsets me.

I am assuming the mother has already said no. I would look into how much space, size of cage, outdoors time etc etc it would need. It would be better for you if dh decides it’s much more expensive/time consuming/work than he at first thought and decides to say no himself.

YANBU but just in case he does it anyway, be ready to re home it responsibly
if there is neglect.

I used to say to my child, how would you like it if you were kept in your bedroom all the time. You could have all your food and toys but could never leave.

BackInBlackAgain · 22/08/2022 10:20

DP did this but for our DD, she wanted a rabbit, he got her one whilst i said it wasnt a good idea. As much as i like the bunny and she really is cute and gorgeous, its me who feeds her everyday, me who cleans her hutch out every week, me who makes sure she is let out for a run, me who covers her up every night (outdoor hutch) and me who has to do a slug check every night when its wet.

Everyone says to leave it to DP as he wanted to get it, but i know what would happen, and like OP i cant leave an animal to live in filth, water not checked, and not fed very day. It boils my piss but i wouldnt let her be mistreated.

fufflecake · 22/08/2022 10:08

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 10:06

I couldn't do this, firstly because I'd feel too bad for the pig. But also because it's my house, I own this too and I don't want it getting wrecked or carpets stinking of wee and things like that.

True but if its just the dsc's room then it's their problem if it stinks of piss for eternity. Then when they move out charge them for the damage.

GiantCheeseMonster · 22/08/2022 10:08

YANBU. Pets are something the whole household needs to agree on.

Also, Guinea pigs are social animals. You can’t get one on its own, you have to get two or three. Then you always at some point end up with a lonely one after the other dies and you’re stuck in the cycle of replacing them forever.

They also need a LOT more space than you think. The indoor cages sold at Pets at Home are all too small. Look up C&C cages which are the recommended indoor cages for GPs and look at the size of them. They need constant access to hay which gets everywhere and makes a mess. They are messy to take care of as they can’t be trained to use a litter tray like rabbits and wee/poo everywhere, so the whole cage needs cleaning regularly.

Hay is expensive and so are the veggies they need. I really wouldn’t want this.

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 10:07

And yes the fact they need another mate as well.

OP posts:
fufflecake · 22/08/2022 10:07

Can they not go to a petting zoo to visit them or something?

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 10:06

fufflecake · 22/08/2022 10:05

Poor guinea pigs. This sounds deeply unsuitable. But if he insists I'd let him, don't go into the DSC's room ever, don't feed them, if they get neglected then call the rspca on your husband. If they get attacked by your cats then that's just the natural order of things.

I couldn't do this, firstly because I'd feel too bad for the pig. But also because it's my house, I own this too and I don't want it getting wrecked or carpets stinking of wee and things like that.

OP posts:
AwkwardPaws27 · 22/08/2022 10:06

He's obviously not done any research or he'd know he needs at least two - guinea pigs are very social creatures and need a friend.

Keeping them indoors with fleece liners is relatively low smell, but they do tend to kick hay and poop out of the cage & the liners need washing once a week (which I'm guessing would fall to you!).