Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH can't just buy a pet for his child without me agreeing?!

89 replies

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 09:56

H is a bit of a Disney parent to DSC.

I get on really well with my step children but his inability to say no sometimes really winds me up. He carries a lot of guilt about them being from a split family and going on to have more DC with me. That's another thread.

But anyway, the issue...

One of my step children has been asking for a guinea pig for a while. H is now waining and looking to give in.

I am absolutely against the idea for a number of reasons:

  1. There's no way DSC will actually stick to being the one to care for it (like all kids promise to do I imagine), they are 11.
  1. I'm the one at home all day so likely will fall to me to do cleaning out, feeding and so on.
  1. We have other animals including 2 cats (not a good mix, one in particular is a hunter).
  1. DHs solution to this is they can keep it in their room where the cats never go (DSC very keen on this idea) but the smell, the mess!!! Ugh.

Anyway, I've said no way and H is now thinking I'm awful and mean and 'id get one if our child wanted one'. No I wouldn't, any pet we got in the future would be thought about at the time and whether it worked at that point in time (for example perhaps one day when the cats are no longer with us and both of us are around more to care for one) and everyone was in agreement etc.. but right now it doesn't work for us (or me anyway).

AIBU to put my foot down about this, I feel on edge like he's just going to get one for him for his birthday (in a few weeks) and "promise" he'll do everything. I'll be so mad if he does.

OP posts:
70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 12:19

00100001 · 22/08/2022 12:09

Just say "yes" on the understanding that DH and DSC do everything, you won't remind them or help or buy anything for it and the moment they don't clean it out the day it's needed/forget to feed it. You're getting rid of it that day.. No chances. No "oh but I was going to..."

Find the local animal rescue and be prepared to take the pig there.

No - this just teaches a child that animals are disposable and that the Resces are there to mop up.
A child cannot be responsible , they cannot buy a pet
The parent is the responsible adult , they step in.
If they don't want to step up , don't get them
Too many guinea-pigs on Gumtree "Kids lost interest"

As I said earlier , my DD had days when she had homework or was at a friends or unwell.
Out of our group of 5 , three were DDs , two were mine .
They had two groups ( 3+2) so I would be feeding and cleaning mine anway , just as easy to do for 5 as for 2 .

But the rule was "Ok , but you do tomorrow" . We were well organised , !

Many rescues won't allow them to go in a child's bedroom, and bear in mind , they (and their hay) are very allergenic.
DD was fine with most of ours but allergic to the coats of 2 (who happened to be the cuddliest )

AmbushedByCake · 22/08/2022 12:18

Never mind the specifics of guinea pigs, any pets need to be agreed on by the whole family.

But guineas, lovely as they are, need so much room - and if they fall out in adolesence (ours did, its impossible to predict if it will happen, and they have to be kept apart or one will kill the other), so now they're in two separate cages but next to one another so they don't get lonely, it takes up an immense amount of room. They need fed twice a day, daily hay, monthly claw trimming, they can get mites, they're sensitive to temperature - mine get ice blocks to sit on in the heat and heat pads in the cool weather - they need haircuts, daily clean outs of the poo and wet hay, we wash our fleeces every third day so our machine is always bloody on and it's impossible to remove all the hair. Sitting in a room on their own won't suit them, they like company and stimulation. They are absolutely adorable and I bloody love them but they aren't a particularly easy pet.

DisappearingGirl · 22/08/2022 12:16

I’d get an outdoor set up and tell DH that it’s his responsibility

Just to say, the people I know who have outside guinea pigs do bring them inside in the winter, or at least into a garage or outbuilding. I think it's too cold outside in the winter unless you live in a warm place. I also worry about outdoor animals in hutches being forgotten and ending up bored/neglected.

I'm overall pleased to see the realistic portrayal of guinea pig ownership on this thread! We do love ours and are happy to have them, but they are our only pets and we were all on board and realistic about the time and space commitment etc.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 22/08/2022 12:14

By all means let him buy a Guinea pig or two but they stay at his ex wife’s house, not yours.
Hth.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 12:12

The cat brought in a live mouse

Wild mice carry a virus which can kill a guinea-pig , gives them horrendous diarrohea which is not good news for piggies .

I was "Eh" when I found this out , but animals have their own specific illnesses

In the same vein, there's an infection that rabbits carry that can kill a guinea-pig ( apart from the fact rabbis can kill a guinea-pig by kicking or mounting it ) they don't go together

thetemptationofchocolate · 22/08/2022 12:12

I have guinea pigs in my house, they do better indoors than outside tbh. But I clean them out often so they don't smell. One has long hair so needs bathing quite often, and a haircut. They need a good diet of unlimited hay and fresh foods, but too much of some foods can cause expensive health issues.
One of mine had to have a surgery last year and that was more than £500.They live on average 5 years but some can go on much longer than that so it's quite a long commitment.
I would recommend anyone thinking of getting guinea pigs to seek out a reputable rescue. Guinea pigs from there will have seen the vet so you know they are reasonably healthy. They will be the sex that the rescue says they are. You will get ongoing support in the way of advice, from the rescue. This will not necessarily be the case with pet shop piggies.

Mulhollandmagoo · 22/08/2022 12:10

No, pets are a huge commitment, and everyone needs to be on board! the fact you say he is a Disney dad I assume means he wont be encouraging DSC to clean/feed/care for the guinea pig either?

00100001 · 22/08/2022 12:09

Just say "yes" on the understanding that DH and DSC do everything, you won't remind them or help or buy anything for it and the moment they don't clean it out the day it's needed/forget to feed it. You're getting rid of it that day.. No chances. No "oh but I was going to..."

Find the local animal rescue and be prepared to take the pig there.

RedHelenB · 22/08/2022 12:07

I think given that you've got pets already you could say it lives in dsc room and your dh and dsc are responsible for it. However, the default is that there should be full agreement before getting pets.

SunnyD44 · 22/08/2022 12:06

Also, like all small pets, guinea pigs always die tragic, heart-wrenching deaths and guess who will have to console the weeping children when they find their pathetic little corpses.

This is one of the reasons why I chose to get my DD some rabbits.

It’s so awful when they die and I cried more than my DD when they died 😂

Family members will die, it’s a part of life.
If a child has never experienced death then it can be much more painful and hard to deal with than if they’ve been around death before.

Having a pet can teach a child about death and how it’s sad but you can make a grave and celebrate their life etc and teach them that death is a part of life.

pastaandpesto · 22/08/2022 12:05

Guinea pigs would be a terrible choice for the setup you've described.

If you did want a compromise, then in my experience gerbils are the easiest small animal to keep. As long as you house them properly (massive tank with an appropriate substrate that enables then to build tunnels) they are very low maintenance - as desert animals they hardly produce any urine at all.

They aren't the easiest to handle but they are super entertaining to watch. Also they have much shorter lifespans than guinea pigs, so practically speaking it is less of a commitment.

Their cage would need to be 100% cat proof though.

SunnyD44 · 22/08/2022 11:59

I personally wouldn’t have a Guinea pig in the bedroom.

I’d get an outdoor set up and tell DH that it’s his responsibility - if SDS doesn’t clean or feed it then DH is going to have to do it.

If DH agrees then I’d be happy with this.
I do think pets are very good for children to teach them responsibilities and to share a bond with.
And Guinea pigs seem to make much better pets than many of the other pets you have have.

ZandathePanda · 22/08/2022 11:57

(Obviously didn’t know they were pregnant when we got them)

ThisIsAddiction · 22/08/2022 11:56

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 11:32

And (while I'm on my soapbox) there's an advert on TV ( NatWest) that shows a girl on the laptop with a talking guinea-pig
They get hurled through a cartooony swirl then the piggie thumps back onto the bed ( they are such fragile animals this could harm them) and in the background you see the plastic cage that even a hamster would struggle in.
Its in the girs' bedroom. OK its an advert but people see this and think , "ooh nice idea"

I emailed to complain about this advert .

Can I add the Halifax advert into the cruelty pile as well? That shows a very small fishbowl on the side with two enormous fancy goldfish in it that are far far too small for it.
I know it's not real, I know it's only an advert. But it does create some very unrealistic expectations for pet ownership.

ZandathePanda · 22/08/2022 11:55

We had 2 female guinea pigs. Ended up with 7. Poor things were only a couple of months old and pregnant when we got them. We had them inside as soon as they looked like dinner plates and their insides were moving. They are noisy at night and the cat brought in a live mouse which then was very happy to live around the guinea pigs. The whole house stank of hay/wee. We had to sex the males at 3 weeks in case the whole cycle ended up again.
They were sweet but don’t do anything other than wheek and wee and poo a lot. And the mess gets everywhere.

Connie2468 · 22/08/2022 11:55

They will destroy your lawn too! You basically need to move the run on to a fresh patch of grass every couple of days.

hedgehogger1 · 22/08/2022 11:38

You'd need two minimum and they take up a lot of room. I just had an illness in one of mine that cost me a fortune in vets bills and they still died. They aren't easy animals. He should know better

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 11:32

And (while I'm on my soapbox) there's an advert on TV ( NatWest) that shows a girl on the laptop with a talking guinea-pig
They get hurled through a cartooony swirl then the piggie thumps back onto the bed ( they are such fragile animals this could harm them) and in the background you see the plastic cage that even a hamster would struggle in.
Its in the girs' bedroom. OK its an advert but people see this and think , "ooh nice idea"

I emailed to complain about this advert .

Lancelottie · 22/08/2022 11:29

I like guinea pigs. But...

Where is he planning to put a 5-foot cage (minimum)? Will it be easy to reach there for frequent cleaning? Will the cat sit on top and stick its claws through? Do you have storage for unfeasibly huge amounts of hay (and in our case, shredded loo-paper style bedding)?

Do you have a lawn with room for a much larger pen than that? How will he cat-proof it, supervise it and shade it?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 11:27

Another one agreeing that guinea-pigs need company ( it's illegal to keep a singleton in Switzerland )
They need a huge enclosure
They are very untidy
They need a load of hay which gets everywhere .

I kept pigggies from the age of 9-22 then my DD wanted A Pet at 9yo , we got guinea-pigs so we had eight years of pigggies ( including The Guinea-Pig Spiral whee one dies , you get another cagemate and so on) .

I will bet any money that your DC will get fed up -even my DD who was 100% for her pigs had days when she said "Mum can you feed/clean them" which I did because some were mine anyway but she was back on board the next day ..

We have cats now ( guieas have all gone to The Bridge ) they are much easier .
You have to keep piggies protected from everything
Heat, cold, damp (its a killer) predators , draughts , changes of temperature .
They have specific food needs and cannot vomit .

They are lovely but hard work.
Your husband needs to do his homework , and don't let an innocent defenceless little rodent suffer just so He can look good .

FlowerArranger · 22/08/2022 11:24

I just don’t agree to animals in small cages.

So many reasons why your husband's idea is unacceptable, but this alone is sufficient reason not to get guinea pigs.

JulesCobb · 22/08/2022 11:19

Absolutely no. Firstly, you cannot just have one guinea pig. Secondly, no.

keep firm, op. This will end badly for those guinea pigs.

Catfordthefifth · 22/08/2022 11:18

Midlifemusings · 22/08/2022 11:13

How and when did the cats come to be part of the household?

What has that got to do with anything?

forrestgreen · 22/08/2022 11:18

I'd write out a care sheet in minutia.

Size of cage
Initial costs
Weekly shopping lists
Daily cleans
Weekly full cleans
Time in garden
Cat proofing areas

Etc etc
In the end column, write down who's doing each thing each day (sc or dh) and how long it takes!!

Transfer all ownership over, I understand you won't mistreat them but he doesn't know that! He needs to think that they'll be sat waiting for him to do each daily clean and hoover!

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 22/08/2022 11:17

Print off lots of info so YOU look supportive. When dh sees the level of work involved HE can be the baddie and tell the dc he has changed his mind.