Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH can't just buy a pet for his child without me agreeing?!

89 replies

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 09:56

H is a bit of a Disney parent to DSC.

I get on really well with my step children but his inability to say no sometimes really winds me up. He carries a lot of guilt about them being from a split family and going on to have more DC with me. That's another thread.

But anyway, the issue...

One of my step children has been asking for a guinea pig for a while. H is now waining and looking to give in.

I am absolutely against the idea for a number of reasons:

  1. There's no way DSC will actually stick to being the one to care for it (like all kids promise to do I imagine), they are 11.
  1. I'm the one at home all day so likely will fall to me to do cleaning out, feeding and so on.
  1. We have other animals including 2 cats (not a good mix, one in particular is a hunter).
  1. DHs solution to this is they can keep it in their room where the cats never go (DSC very keen on this idea) but the smell, the mess!!! Ugh.

Anyway, I've said no way and H is now thinking I'm awful and mean and 'id get one if our child wanted one'. No I wouldn't, any pet we got in the future would be thought about at the time and whether it worked at that point in time (for example perhaps one day when the cats are no longer with us and both of us are around more to care for one) and everyone was in agreement etc.. but right now it doesn't work for us (or me anyway).

AIBU to put my foot down about this, I feel on edge like he's just going to get one for him for his birthday (in a few weeks) and "promise" he'll do everything. I'll be so mad if he does.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cantstandbullshit · 22/08/2022 16:21

@BloodyPets I agree with PP about not getting the Guinea out if the whole family is anti in agreement, but aside that you need to have a serious conversation with your husband about making statements such as if it was your child you would do this or not do this. That is very disrespectful and wrong unless there are truly situations where you treat your step children unfairly.

I haven’t gotten that from your post (and I know we’re only seeing one side) so if you truly care for the kids and there has not been situations wheee you clearly treat then j fairly because they are step children then statement is very very wrong and should be addressed asap.

oviraptor21 · 22/08/2022 14:54

BackInBlackAgain · 22/08/2022 10:20

DP did this but for our DD, she wanted a rabbit, he got her one whilst i said it wasnt a good idea. As much as i like the bunny and she really is cute and gorgeous, its me who feeds her everyday, me who cleans her hutch out every week, me who makes sure she is let out for a run, me who covers her up every night (outdoor hutch) and me who has to do a slug check every night when its wet.

Everyone says to leave it to DP as he wanted to get it, but i know what would happen, and like OP i cant leave an animal to live in filth, water not checked, and not fed very day. It boils my piss but i wouldnt let her be mistreated.

Ultimatum and then take to bunny rescue place?

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/08/2022 14:01

I can see it’s a no. But just giving my experience and what I agreed to as I didn’t want another pet. In the end I compromised with a dwarf hamster. Really cute but dd got scared as it bit (nibbled) her so it isn’t tame. They last 2/2.5 years and I have been cleaning the cage for over a year now. Idk how old your younger dc are but that would be my limit. Dwarf hamsters can be trained to be sociable but do not need interaction and live alone.

diddl · 22/08/2022 13:57

GPs stuck in a bedroom!

The bedroom of a kid that's only there part time?

hangrylady · 22/08/2022 13:55

YANBU but if you do decide to compromise then guinea pigs are definitely not the best option. Firstly they must be kept in pairs so you'd have 2, they shit more than any animal I've ever had and they can live up to 7 years. We have GPs and they are lovely little things but a lot more high maintenance than I thought. We look after then very well but I am the one who cleans them out, which needs doing at least once a week and I'm pretty sure I'll still be looking after them once the kids are teens. A cat is the most low maintenance pet IME.

Quartz2208 · 22/08/2022 13:46

Completely the right and fair decision.

Pets should never be bought just for children, neither IMO should they be entrusted with 100% care - Guinea Pigs and Rabbits are much harder work than you would think and need a lot of care and attention. Most children spend a large proportion of time at school and therefore just arent there.

DD wanted a rabbit for years it was only when I was ready that we did it. And she does feed them and play with them but they are in our lounge roaming around from 9-6 - a lot of which she is at school so I am responsible in that time.

Doing everything is a hell of a lot more than feeding and cleaning out (and that is still time consuming)

Soubriquet · 22/08/2022 13:44

I would say no too. No pets should be bought for children unless there is a parent on board to take over, when the children inevitably get bored.

My dd wants Guinea pigs. I’ve compromised with mice. I like mice and they are a lot easier than piggies.

ds wants a chameleon. I’m going to compromise with either a bearded dragon or a leopard gecko.

In both cases, I’m prepared to take over care

alwayscheery · 22/08/2022 13:31

Can he not offer to buy one to keep at their Mum's house?
Or would it only be polite to check she is on board with the idea first!

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 13:28

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 22/08/2022 12:59

That is no substitute for a companion and you shouldn't be encouraging a new owner to get just one. They should always have a companion.

I wasn't encouraging her, just mentioning it.

BloodyPets · 22/08/2022 13:20

Thanks I'll definitely be saying no. I'm just not interested in getting anymore pets right now. The ones we have are enough (2 cats and a dog). I honestly would say no to a fish at this point because I couldn't be doing with cleaning a tank!

Life's too hectic right now as it is without adding another life to the mix to care for ha.

OP posts:
halfsiesonapotnoodle · 22/08/2022 12:59

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 10:39

I had a solitary guinea pig. Never seemed to suffer just being the only one. Was always out in the run or being fussed.

That is no substitute for a companion and you shouldn't be encouraging a new owner to get just one. They should always have a companion.

MintJulia · 22/08/2022 12:55

Good for you. Why would anyone want a rodent living in their bedroom? And no creature should ever be cooped up on its own. That's plain cruel.

Allyouneedislunch · 22/08/2022 12:53

You are definitely NBU. Guinea Pigs are fabulous little animals who need a lot of care and attention. They get scared very easily and no matter how careful everyone is, the cats will (or at least the hunter will) make it their mission to get to them. I say ‘them’ as a few posters have said, they are social animals and are much happier in groups.

I firmly believe it’s fantastic for children to grow up with animals. They teach them so much BUT everybody in the household has to be on board, everyone has to lookout for them, the house and garden must be safe, and in the case of GPs, gerbils etc there are no predators.

category12 · 22/08/2022 12:47

I love guinea pigs as pets, but everyone has to be on board, and if you're not then it's a no-go.

I've never had any bother with cats with them - my cat ignores them completely. She once broke into their hutch and had a nice sleep in the hay 😂This despite being known to catch wild rabbits.

But yeah lot of work, they need tons of room, they need to be multiple, and their novelty value to kids may well wear off.

Afterfire · 22/08/2022 12:42

Please, please don’t get a Guinea pig. In lots of countries it’s actually illegal to keep one on their own as they need company (another pig, not a rabbit). And they really shouldn’t be kept outside despite what everyone thinks. They prefer to be indoors where there are no extremes of temperature. And they need a HUGE cage - google kavee cage. Google c and c cage.

We have 4 indoor pigs in a cage which takes up a lot of our 30ft kitchen diner. We love them but it’s a huge commitment and if they need vet treatment they’re classed as exotic pets and cost a lot - we recently had one that had an eye injury and the eye was removed - £600.

Preg19 · 22/08/2022 12:37

Sprogonthetyne · 22/08/2022 10:05

A few more negatives for the list.

You can't keep a single guinea pig, they're a social animal so you need two, so it's twice the responsibility.

They need a massive enclosure (70x140cm minimum for 2), so unless your DSC had a very big bedroom, it's not going to fit.

Not that you should need to justify beyond you don't want them, but it might stop DH wavering if he looks at the practicallies, without being able to paint you as the bad guy.

Exactly what I was going to say! Whatever the petshops try to sell you accommodation wise they arnt usually big enough to house 2 guinea pigs, they need lots of space, I use c and c grids for mine and it takes up a fair amount of space.
People seem to think guinea pigs are an easy pet to get children but they are more complex than you think.
definitely put your foot down with this one!

MissGlitterSparkles · 22/08/2022 12:34

Guinea pigs are very time consuming to look after and surprisingly expensive (have just had a £250 vets bill, last year had a vets bill of close to £1000). You should never have just one - they must have a friend as they are very sociable animals and need company.

They are gorgeous pets and I love ours to bits, but they are not the ‘easy’ pet I expected for DD, and either you or DDs dad needs to take responsibility for making sure the guineas are cared for properly. If you don’t want one, then for the sake of the guinea pigs - put your foot down and say no!

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 12:34

And for some of us solitary confinement might be nice. Not all humans are social when though I am constantly hearing we are.

cloudygreyskies · 22/08/2022 12:32

Connie2468 · 22/08/2022 11:14

They do suffer, it's cruel to keep social animals in solitary confinement. Just because it can't tell you it has a miserable life doesn't mean it isn't suffering.
It would be like putting a human in solitary confinement with just another species to fuss over.

Guinea pigs aren't an easy animal to keep well, they need lots of space. We have indoor and outdoor cages (5ft long) and a run, they need a varied diet of fresh vegetables and hay, they poo constantly and need a lot of cleaning out and daily attention.
You can't keep them in the bedroom of children who aren't even living there full time.

Well you're entitled to your opinion, but there was none of this you must have two guinea pigs when she was bought many years ago. Even the book I got at the time didn't tell you you had to buy 2.

The guinea pig lived a long life, she had none of the signs associated with being lonely, and spending so much time with her I'm satisfied that she led a happy life. If I was getting one now I'd get at least two. I'm sure advice changes, or perhaps it's because people aren't properly informed at the time of purchase.

FrizzledFrazzle · 22/08/2022 12:29

Definitely not unreasonable. Any pet is a huge commitment. Not a whimsical purchase to make someone smile on their birthday.

I thought about getting a small animal pet a few years ago. There are various "Guinea pig owners" or "Rabbit care and advice" groups on Facebook, which are great at showing the reality and difficult bits of their care. Endless bunny posts about GI stasis emergencies, bonding failures, chewing and pooping everywhere, destroyed jumpers and floors etc. Guinea pig posts about "boar glue" (ewww), mess and smell, unexplained deaths, noise, the list goes on ...

If you think your DH is serious about getting a pet, get him and your DSC to join some of these - should put them right off.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 22/08/2022 12:28

The only time the guinea-pigs stayd in DD room was when we had a bereaved piggie waiting (about a week) for a new cagemate

Or over Guy Fawkes we put them in their big cage , they woke DD at 3am to demand food !

In winter , they had the small bedroom ( it was empty with no door and radiator off) we had C&C cages and our big indoor cage

We had to put a cover on them like a parrot to tell them "Its bedtime , stop yapping "
They are crepuscular (active at dawn and dusk) but noisy little buggers as they drink , and hope if they hear a noise it means Food !

Fe345fleur · 22/08/2022 12:25

YANBU. Small animals are not good pets for children, despite what pet shops would have us believe. And you will 100% end up being the one cleaning it out all the time.

Frazzled2207 · 22/08/2022 12:21

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 22/08/2022 12:14

By all means let him buy a Guinea pig or two but they stay at his ex wife’s house, not yours.
Hth.

Not really fair on her is it? Unless she is onboard of course

Frazzled2207 · 22/08/2022 12:20

yadnbu.

IMO the cat thing is what makes it not doable.

I like GPs and have looked after a friend’s but they need each other (there are two), have a large enclosure (and another in the garden for nice days) and need surprisingly more work than I thought.

keeping them in the bedroom, unless it is enormous, is a non-starter.

I would only contemplate this if dh was genuinely able to take on the work of sorting them out and we def had the space and there was no cat complications.