Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s time for a general strike

210 replies

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 08:25

I am old enough to remember the poll tax riots which did eventually bring about a shift in policy.

The country is on its knees - I read yesterday that energy bills could hit 6k a year in the spring and put 45 million into fuel poverty.

it’s completely nuts and the current government are wholly to blame after 12 years in power. I have just been in France where bills have risen 4% because the energy companies are nationalised.

I think it’s genuinely time for some collective action.

OP posts:
Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 10:07

@AlexandriasWindmill The people shouting "nationalise stuff!" as a magic bullet haven't spend 30 minutes thinking about it either and have limited knowledge of politics, history and economics.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 10:06

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:02

@Iamthewombat honestly you just seem to want to patronise posters with your apparent superior views

Here we go. You’re losing the argument and your response is crying about being ‘patronised’.

If you’re going to lead the general strike, you’ll need to work on your debating technique.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 10:04

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 09:58

If thats the case, how can you be so dismissive of ideas that you have only considered for 30mins?

That’s right. I’d never thought about general strikes before the OP enlightened me this morning. Didn’t even know what one was.

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:03

A strike isn't a revolution. It isn't anti-capitalist.
It definitely seems as though some posters have spent less than 30 minutes thinking about these issues. And have spent no time at all studying economics, politics or history.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:02

@Iamthewombat honestly you just seem to want to patronise posters with your apparent superior views

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 10:01

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 09:57

We are a country that believes in collective responsibility. People who weren't at the poll tax protests or the bedroom tax demos, won't understand the purpose of collective action.

And there are not enough words or posts to explain it to them because they are wilfully ignoring the history of protest in this country. They're wilfully ignoring the history of workers' rights. They're wilfully ignoring that the general working population is the bedrock on which everyone else's wealth rests.

They foolishly believe that waving excessive consumption in people's faces is a real economic strategy. They hope their smoke and mirrors will blind people to where the real power rests in any country - in its people - not in global companies with no loyalty and no stakes.

So everyone who wasn’t at the poll tax protests or ‘bedroom tax’ protests - a good 95% of the population, I suspect - is guilty of all of the sins you list in your post?

They are all ‘foolish’ and ‘wilfully ignorant’. All waving their excessive consumption in the faces of…er….all the other people doing the same waving?

BashfulClam · 22/08/2022 10:00

I can’t strike and tbh I can’t afford to do it either. My employers have been really good so I won’t go on strike against them.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:00

@Flapjacker48 eventually a general election will have to happen. And I believe that is where collective action now can start to influence and encourage people to vote in a different government - I would prefer a progressive alliance of some kind as it goes and a move away from a one party state

OP posts:
bluelavender · 22/08/2022 09:59

Sorry, was trying to write admitably

Society at the moment is not admirable at all - too many families struggle and our children's outcomes are too dependant on family income and parental education- I want society to be better and fairer, I just don't think that revolutions generally end well- poor people still end up poor, with someone else in control giving the orders

amicissimma · 22/08/2022 09:58

Personally I don't think this is a good time to make life more expensive and difficult. It's always those who can least afford it who bear the brunt of costs and difficulties.

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 09:58

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 09:56

You have no idea how I think. I’ve challenged some lazy statements on this thread.

Nor do I need to offer an alternative solution. Yours won’t work. I know that you don’t want to hear that. Others are allowed to challenge you without producing a fully costed blueprint that they have worked up in the half hour since reading your OP.

If thats the case, how can you be so dismissive of ideas that you have only considered for 30mins?

Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 09:58

@Mountainatmygates I'm afraid there are no (short term, even medium term) answers, the UK is about to get a lot poorer with a serious decline in living standards.

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 09:57

We are a country that believes in collective responsibility. People who weren't at the poll tax protests or the bedroom tax demos, won't understand the purpose of collective action.

And there are not enough words or posts to explain it to them because they are wilfully ignoring the history of protest in this country. They're wilfully ignoring the history of workers' rights. They're wilfully ignoring that the general working population is the bedrock on which everyone else's wealth rests.

They foolishly believe that waving excessive consumption in people's faces is a real economic strategy. They hope their smoke and mirrors will blind people to where the real power rests in any country - in its people - not in global companies with no loyalty and no stakes.

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 09:57

@Flapjacker48 Nationalising billing does little, its the generation and production that needs to be taken into public ownership, which is what France has done with EDF.

Part nationalisation, as was done with the banks to prevent economic melt down.

NS gas is extracted under licence, Shell/BP don't own those fields.

Innovative ways have to be at least considered, gas prices my stay very high for a number of years, costing the govt 100s of billions.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 09:56

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:51

@Iamthewombat you are assuming everyone thinks like you. You are not offering any solutions to the fact that 45 million people are facing food poverty this winter. 18 million households. That is a fundamental change in society happening right now. We are offering one way to stand up and challenge that fact.

You have no idea how I think. I’ve challenged some lazy statements on this thread.

Nor do I need to offer an alternative solution. Yours won’t work. I know that you don’t want to hear that. Others are allowed to challenge you without producing a fully costed blueprint that they have worked up in the half hour since reading your OP.

bluelavender · 22/08/2022 09:55

Ah, perhaps slightly clearer now what the overall objective of the strike might be? Andrew Fisher is an established political writer and activist. He was also suspended from the Labour party for backing a very left wing organisation, Class War at a previous general election

We are in a free society where people can campaign for different political ideas. But if the main purpose of a general strike is perhaps more of a 'workers of the world unite and destroy capitalism', then just wondering, but would it not be better to be more open about this and the sort of society that you'd like in future instead of this (admirably flawed, but probably than many of the alternatives) society that we have right now?

Pyewhacket · 22/08/2022 09:55

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/08/2022 09:16

But that is a policy which could be reversed if we abandoned ‘net zero’, as the Germans have done as soon as it inconvenienced them.

Open a coal-fired power station in the UK and see what happens. That's the problem. And where are the £billions coming from to nationalise E companies because you cannot just size or take over commercial organisations, and does that include Shell and BP ?. And a general strike is just about the most regressive and nihilistic thing ever. The source of supply is the key so I'm sure that will have a great impact in Qatar or Norway.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:54

@Iamthewombat give is your solutions then instead of ripping apart every idea that is proposed on here.

OP posts:
Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:53

@Flapjacker48 well give us some alternative solutions then!

there are posters coming on here and being scathing about striking or re- nationalisation.

offer us some ideas then that deal with the social catastrofuck that is about to hit this country.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 09:53

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:43

She asked how it would be paid for, which is a reasonable question. I read your link. It suggested that the big five energy companies could be renationalised - by the government buying all of their shares - for £2.8 billion.

It took me two minutes to establish that British Gas alone has a market capitalisation of almost £5 Bn. So I might take the numbers in the report you linked to with a pinch of salt.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:51

@Iamthewombat you are assuming everyone thinks like you. You are not offering any solutions to the fact that 45 million people are facing food poverty this winter. 18 million households. That is a fundamental change in society happening right now. We are offering one way to stand up and challenge that fact.

OP posts:
Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 09:51

@Mountainatmygates And nationalising energy suppliers achieves what exactly? Like it or not energy bill mainly reflect a.) the wholesale cost of oil and gas and b.) the governments tax regime for energy

So how does this nationalisation reduce the cost of gas and electricity?

There has indeed been a failure of energy policy for 50 or more years and yes, privatisation was a bad idea, but I think that people who say that "nationalisation" is a magic bullet have not really thought about the issue.

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 09:51

Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 09:37

@Mountainatmygates

So where do you propose the money comes from to nationalise such companies? Based on the water companies profits it would cost about 300 billion to nationalise water. Or do you think the government should just appropriate these companies?

It would be based on their share price not profits.

On costs, the Govt may end up paying 100s of billions over the next 2 or 3 years to stop people freezing to death, money that will go straight to the the privatised utilities, which we will never see again.

France produces around 80% of its own electricity requirements, the UK approx 50% of its energy, why can't we control the price of that 50%, whilst still meeting our obligations to sell gas to Europe when we have a surplus (summer)

This is what (part) nationalisation of energy would do.

I notice it is being talked about by members of all the political parties now.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 09:47

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:39

How would a general strike make those things happen?

Strikes & protest are the main way that the proles get their voices heard and how change happens in the workplace. How else can workers protect themselves from unscrupulous employers/governments that fail to act in their best interests. We are heading back to Victorian Britain without those things (maternity rights, paid holidays, minimum wages etc)

it’s no coincidence that the tories want to ‘rip up’ the EU protections and laws. The new charter cities/ Freeport’s are exactly what they aspire to.

So all those posters being scathing about what a general strike would achieve. It’s a way of standing up to a government that is elected to protect its citizens but is currently failing to do that.

I don’t think that you have understood the question. I’ll rephrase it, very bluntly.

How will a general strike fundamentally change human nature?

Because that’s what the PP was proposing. By next week, before our general strike, every human being in Britain (and presumably the world) has to fundamentally change such that they don’t value wealth and have everybody’s interests at heart, not just their own. And “consider basic human rights a national interest rather than profit driven”, although I’m still trying to work out what that actually means. I’m sure that the PP thought that it sounded good, though.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:46

@AlexandriasWindmill spot on!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread