Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s time for a general strike

210 replies

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 08:25

I am old enough to remember the poll tax riots which did eventually bring about a shift in policy.

The country is on its knees - I read yesterday that energy bills could hit 6k a year in the spring and put 45 million into fuel poverty.

it’s completely nuts and the current government are wholly to blame after 12 years in power. I have just been in France where bills have risen 4% because the energy companies are nationalised.

I think it’s genuinely time for some collective action.

OP posts:
Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 11:00

There won't be a "general strike" or mass protests/riots - even people harking back to the poll tax forget that, percentage wise it was small amounts who didn't pay and even smaller amounts who went to the London protest in march 1990. For all that supposed "anger" who was elected in 1992? The conservatives.

The "replacement" for the poll tax (Council tax) had/has issues too.

Will there be moaning on social media and places like MN - yes, people "taking to the streets"? No.

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:59

The posters defending the utility companies should take the time to research the utility companies' share dividends programmes and benefits given to their boards and their top-level staff.

Posters who are in unions and posters who are activists and campaigners are simply raising awareness on this thread. It would be foolish to list more details when certain other posters have made their loyalties and priorities clear (over very many threads on here).

This isn't where the real organising takes place. It happens in RL, in communities, through networks - the way it always has done.

The anti-strike posters aren't helping their parties. Perhaps they should consider a little Road to Wigan Pier exercise to reacquaint themselves with the priorities and values of all the electorate. Or a quick read of Marx or John Stuart Mill to remind them of the means of production and the role of the government.

Hopefornothing · 22/08/2022 10:55

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:32

Lots of self-employed people are in unions.

That may well be. But my dental practice can still just turn round and tell me not to come back. I have no rights. I'm not like a plumber or builder who takes jobs from the public and can keep working. I work in a practice (2 actually on different days). They can tell me not to bother coming back if I go on strike and there's nothing I can do about it.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 10:55

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:48

@RoseAndRose i think we have been quite clear on here about the purpose of a general strike. The current government don’t care or acknowledge the severity of the current economic crisis for working people and collective action is one way to make them listen. Nationalisation is one option to reduce bills and reduce corporate piss take profits and reinvest. But generally taking a stand against the most corrupt lazy useless government in living memory.

You haven’t defined who you want to nationalise.

We’ve already established that British Gas - who sell gas extracted by other businesses - has a market capitalisation of £5 Bn.

BP’s market capitalisation is £85 Bn. Shell’s is £164 Bn.

Where’s that coming from? Are we printing more money? That will help inflation, eh?

How will the government compel the shareholders to sell their shares?

How will acquiring these businesses help to reduce the wholesale price of gas?

The majority of the shares in FTSE 100 businesses are held by pension funds. Are they ‘pisstaking’? How do you think that those pension funds should be compensated for losing a big chunk of their assets under management?

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:54

@Suetwo yea cos the energy crisis has nothing to do with the tories does it?

OP posts:
VoiceaFromUranus · 22/08/2022 10:53

Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 10:07

@AlexandriasWindmill The people shouting "nationalise stuff!" as a magic bullet haven't spend 30 minutes thinking about it either and have limited knowledge of politics, history and economics.

Amazing really how many on here think that the same "shit show" of a government will suddenly run all of the newly renationalised industries perfectly.

I also dread to think just how much renationalisation would cost in both the short and longer term as suddenly the UK becomes a far less attractive proposition for investors.

Suetwo · 22/08/2022 10:52

Great idea. That's just what our fragile economy needs! Stop people being able to get to work! Yeah...and reduce their capacity to earn and produce. Brilliant. Maybe we could drop a few bombs on ourselves as well.

How is a general strike going to solve the energy crisis, the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Britain's poor productivity, and the long-term aftershocks of the Covid lockdown?

FunsizedandFabulous · 22/08/2022 10:49

I'm a member of the RMT. My husband is a member of the CWU. I'm in the public sector, just, TfL. DH is in Royal Mail, a postal worker. We both have disputes with our employers.

It really is a race to the bottom out there. I stand to lose 600 colleagues. So if you need help, either with your travel costs, with finding a step-free route, with needing an arm to take you to the platform...you will be out of luck in the future. In the outlying stations, there's rumours of putting one member of staff mobile between 2-3 stations. If you are disabled, or a victim of crime, how are you going to get the help you need?

DH has had a 2% pay offer imposed on him. If the union agree to a whole load of unpalatable conditions he might get 5.5%. But inflation is running at 9-11% so even though my wage has increased with RPI, his hasn't, so overall our income combined will reduce in real terms, regardless. Meanwhile Royal Mail paid its CEO £140k in bonuses and handed out the majority of it profits to its shareholders.

It's not just our jobs. It's everywhere. Telecommunications, Courier services, Amazon, education, cleaning services, barristers, Deliveroo, council services, shipping...people are losing money, they can't pay the bills, the burden on food banks grow, the companies make redundancies to cut costs...yet the corporations are taking it in, to the tune of billions. Look at British Gas's recent profits. It's obscene.

There are general unions out there...try the GMB as a start. But yes, go to the link OP posted at the TUC site, and join a union. Also, look up the Enough is Enough campaign on Twitter led by the unions to try and change things for the better. It won't solve all the problems but it's a start.

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:48

@RoseAndRose i think we have been quite clear on here about the purpose of a general strike. The current government don’t care or acknowledge the severity of the current economic crisis for working people and collective action is one way to make them listen. Nationalisation is one option to reduce bills and reduce corporate piss take profits and reinvest. But generally taking a stand against the most corrupt lazy useless government in living memory.

OP posts:
Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:45

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen i disagree. It’s the same principle. I am sure that many more people would resign their roles if they could afford to. MPs had the luxury and security of keeping their well paid constituency positions which most normal working people don’t.

OP posts:
Siezethefish · 22/08/2022 10:44

Pyewhacket · 22/08/2022 08:58

The French invested heavily in nuclear power so they, mostly, produce their own energy. We rely on imported gas despite having our own shale gas reserves and there are gas fields in the north sea, albeit requiring substantial investment. The Germans are opening up coal-fired power stations.

the price of gas is the problem, more gas won’t solve it as it will just be sold at the marginal gas price plus opening up more north sea oil fields / exploiting shale gas will take years. We need to move away from fossil fuelled generation not towards it.

Some GB coal fired power stations that were due to close for good are being paid to stay operating this winter to reduce reliance on gas /
improve security of supply.

some of the French nuclear fleet can’t operate as rivers are very low as they have had too little rainfall to provide cooling water. So GB produced energy is being exported to France through undersea cables to make up some of the shortfall . This and the high price of gas are driving high uk prices.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 10:43

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:23

@Iamthewombat its not about losing an argument. It’s about you coming on threads and aggressively dismissing what anyone had to say without offering a single alternative.

i believe in collective action and have been unionised my entire working life. I see few other alternatives at the moment to empower people to believe that they can create societal change.

Are facts ‘aggressive’? I can see why you would think so.

What about the insults that you and others have thrown at posters who disagree with your general strike rhetoric? Is that OK? Not aggressive at all?

And, I’ve already explained to you why posters are allowed to disagree with your general strike rhetoric without delivering a fully costed plan for an alternative. That’s because well thought out plans generally take time to research and prepare.

Here’s a crumb of comfort: it’s good to feel passionately about making the world a better place. It’s an admirable quality. It’s much better than apathy or selfishly protecting your own privilege. However, it’s better if that desire is properly channelled. Kier Starmer is a fairly divisive figure but he’s got it. So does Rachel Reeves. So did Kier Hardie and Alan Johnson and John Smith and Ed Milliband and many other political figures. That’s how real change happens. That, and people voting for positive change rather than for low taxation.

Walkden · 22/08/2022 10:43

"They hope to be paid whilst not working."

I think people are aware they will not be paid whilst on strike. Joining a union can protect you from being summarily dismissed for striking but does mean you are paid whilst on strike.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/08/2022 10:35

Paid , not laid hah ha ha , I think the autocorrect gremlin voted Labour

RoseAndRose · 22/08/2022 10:35

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 09:44

@RoseAndRose feel free to suggest alternatives then

What is the desired outcome or outcomes are you aiming for though?

Increasing disruption in the hope that something gives, rather than deciding what you want and then how best to reach it seems the wrong way round.

So no I can't suggest alternatives, because it's far from clear what is actually wanted.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/08/2022 10:35

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 08:30

@fufflecake join a union before they get banned as Truss has indicated she would like to.

Its funny how when MPs wanted to remove Boris, they withdrew their Labour

This is completely untrue. Several Cabinet Ministers resigned their posts. They di what everyone does when they resign, they cleared their desks, turned in their cars and stopped being laid for the job they had resigned from. They actually still continued as constituency MP’s.

Strikers withdraw their labour. They expect to return to their job or position, hopefully with increased benefits. They hope to be paid whilst not working.

I m afraid if this comparison is typical of the Left ‘s yearning arguments for a General Strike, it doesn’t say much for their political or economic literacy.

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:32

Lots of self-employed people are in unions.

bluelavender · 22/08/2022 10:32

And, I do support people being able to strike, just have a clear purpose of what you are trying to change. I fully support the junior barristers; but they have clear objectives- they aren't paid fairly, they work very long hours and they have specific concerns about people not having access to justice

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:23

@Iamthewombat its not about losing an argument. It’s about you coming on threads and aggressively dismissing what anyone had to say without offering a single alternative.

i believe in collective action and have been unionised my entire working life. I see few other alternatives at the moment to empower people to believe that they can create societal change.

OP posts:
Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:21

@torquewench www.tuc.org.uk/join-a-union

OP posts:
torquewench · 22/08/2022 10:19

What union could, say, an office junior in a solicitors firm join?
What would the union subs be?
How would striking get their employer to pay them a higher wage and not just dismiss them for not turning up to work?

Hopefornothing · 22/08/2022 10:19

I'm a self employed dental hygienist. If I don't work I don't get paid. So i can't strike. I'm not even self employed through choice. If I want to be employed I'd need to change careers. No one seems to think about self employed people when strikes are mentioned.

superplumb · 22/08/2022 10:18

My husband is a postman and they are going on strike. I'm really worried about the lack of income

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:14

Engaging with sealions isn't productive.

What is apparent is that the government relies upon people not understanding business, shareholdings, profits, economics and politics.

And obviously lots of people don't understand those topics. But people do understand that it's obscene to be a country with one of the largest wealth disparities in the world. They understand that it's appalling that child poverty and food bank usage are growing. They understand that it's ridiculous to give friends contracts worth millions of pounds when essential services are struggling. And they understand that people in full-time employment should be able to afford to heat their homes and feed their families.

It's frankly embarrassing that our politicians seem to have forgotten those basic facts.

Flapjacker48 · 22/08/2022 10:09

All those posters who think I general strike is the way forward, better start trying to organise it then hadn't they? Of course it's easy to call for one on a forum.

Swipe left for the next trending thread