Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s time for a general strike

210 replies

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 08:25

I am old enough to remember the poll tax riots which did eventually bring about a shift in policy.

The country is on its knees - I read yesterday that energy bills could hit 6k a year in the spring and put 45 million into fuel poverty.

it’s completely nuts and the current government are wholly to blame after 12 years in power. I have just been in France where bills have risen 4% because the energy companies are nationalised.

I think it’s genuinely time for some collective action.

OP posts:
Quveas · 22/08/2022 13:05

OnlyEverAutumn · 22/08/2022 08:53

I am old enough to have been AT the poll tax demo! 1990. It was an amazing example of people power bringing an end to a wholly unjust policy.

I don’t know what changed.

whenever they have those vox pops with people who are clearly struggling still saying “Ooh Boris is doing his best” I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.

This government is the most corrupt, cruel and incompetent government I’ve lived through - it’s desperate.

But it wasn't really the demo's that brought about change - a massive contributory factors was the widescale rioting. Civil unrest and anarchy are far better at motivating governments and their powerful friends to take a different approach - at least in the short term. The Council Tax might have seemed like a climbdown, but it only partially redressed the major shift towards a much costlier local taxation system. Loss of control is what the ruling classes fear. Not general strikes or demonstrations. Even on the rare occasions when the latter may give pause for thought, the medium and long term outcomes are always that the workers lose.

BTW, whilst being a life-long trade unionist, and would support a general strike because that is what one does - there are no scabs in our family - I should perhaps point out that (a) the General Strike was a massive failure and (b) at least the TUC supported workers in 1921, but now you should expect both the TUC and the Labour Party (who were opposed to the General Strike) to fall into line with the government and shaft the workers. I also recall the Poll Tax demo's - and the Miners Strikes.

SaintHelena · 22/08/2022 13:01

Isn't the nhs a nationalised company

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 13:01

Missed a zero. I meant £350 million! That’s all right, isn’t it? Ciao!

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 13:01

CanDo92 · 22/08/2022 12:54

But most of the production companies are not British, so it’s not a sensible solution.

The answer is for people to use less gas and electricity. Families should consider sharing homes, people need to get used to heating their homes to lower temperatures, not heating every room, and of dressing differently.

Finding ways to allow everyone to keep burning fossil fuels, as the planet heats up, is not the right thing to do practically or morally.

Yip - exactly. And even British production companies are extracting primarily outside the uk. A longer term energy strategy needs to move away from fossil fuels (this is happening to some degree) but it will take time.

SaintHelena · 22/08/2022 13:00

The French have nuclear power - at the last count the majority were v much against that - where would you store the waste etc

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 13:00

A 1% wealth tax on the UK 171 billionaires would raise almost 60 billion.... now thats simplistic

Hello, is that Mr Abramovich? Can I call you Roman? Hi, we’d like you to give us £35 million please. No reason, just a wealth tax based on how rich we think you are. In cash, by the end of the month. Thanks, byeeee! Whilst you’re on the phone, do you have a mobile number for Mr Deripaska? Or Mr Blavatnik?

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 12:58

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 12:52

So how does this nationalisation reduce the cost of gas and electricity?

I’d have thought that was self evident. It removes the profit element, eliminates dividends to shareholders and means salaries of the people running the companies can be regulated. It’s becoming an increasingly attractive idea, particularly since the UK is an outlier, most countries’ utilities are publicly owned.

Energy suppliers already don’t make any profit or very little. We control the prices they can sell energy at already- it’s so low that many have already gone bust.

global prices of gas and oil are outwith our control.

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 12:54

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 12:49

On the contrary. Mrs Pincher has read the thread correctly. The OP has linked to two separate articles speculating on the cost of nationalising the energy vendors, not the gas extractors. Two entirely separate groups.

I posted the market capitalisations of two oil and gas extraction businesses, BP (> £80 Bn) and Shell (> £160 Bn) upthread and asked (1) where the money to acquire the shares was coming from, (2) how the shareholders would be compelled to sell and (3) how nationalising those businesses would reduce the wholesale price of gas.

No answer. Another poster smartly asked how the government that the OP and others describe as incompetent could be expected to run these multi billion pound businesses. No reply to that either. Funny that.

Thanks @Iamthewombat of course you’re right- nationalizing energy suppliers or producers will not reduce global price of energy.

CanDo92 · 22/08/2022 12:54

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:32

@MsPincher Read the thread, not talking about Octopus etc but the production companies.

But most of the production companies are not British, so it’s not a sensible solution.

The answer is for people to use less gas and electricity. Families should consider sharing homes, people need to get used to heating their homes to lower temperatures, not heating every room, and of dressing differently.

Finding ways to allow everyone to keep burning fossil fuels, as the planet heats up, is not the right thing to do practically or morally.

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 12:52

So how does this nationalisation reduce the cost of gas and electricity?

I’d have thought that was self evident. It removes the profit element, eliminates dividends to shareholders and means salaries of the people running the companies can be regulated. It’s becoming an increasingly attractive idea, particularly since the UK is an outlier, most countries’ utilities are publicly owned.

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 12:52

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:31

If the Uk isn’t attractive to investors (domestic and foreign) the economy will get much much worse and we will all be poorer. Don’t know what you are suggesting re inequality but unfortunately there are not easy answers

A lot of foreign investment is buy outs of UK PLC.

The economy is sunk unless people can afford to go out for the day and shop etc.

In the past, when folk were v poor, we had a very large manufacturing sector, thats gone, replaced with consumerism and services.

A 1% wealth tax on the UK 171 billionaires would raise almost 60 billion.... now thats simplistic but the point is, very small increases in tax on the extremely rich wont effect them but would have a huge positive impact on the rest of us.

If they already pay all this tax people say they do, how come they keep getting wealthier and wealthier?

Don't say "They'll leave" that has been totally debunked & and where too? most countries taxes are higher than the UK's.

This is just silliness. It’s like a student communist society debate (of the usual mc luvvies there to upset their wealthy parents).

As someone who has worked in development I can tell you that there are many countries in the world which are not attractive to investors (foreign and local). They are all desperately poor.

where do you get the “wealth tax” figures from? I thought we were talking about a general strike anyway?

Anyway striking because of inflation will not help- just make the economy even worse.

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 12:49

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:32

@MsPincher Read the thread, not talking about Octopus etc but the production companies.

On the contrary. Mrs Pincher has read the thread correctly. The OP has linked to two separate articles speculating on the cost of nationalising the energy vendors, not the gas extractors. Two entirely separate groups.

I posted the market capitalisations of two oil and gas extraction businesses, BP (> £80 Bn) and Shell (> £160 Bn) upthread and asked (1) where the money to acquire the shares was coming from, (2) how the shareholders would be compelled to sell and (3) how nationalising those businesses would reduce the wholesale price of gas.

No answer. Another poster smartly asked how the government that the OP and others describe as incompetent could be expected to run these multi billion pound businesses. No reply to that either. Funny that.

ScootyAlan · 22/08/2022 12:44

I'm absolutely behind it. Money is what the rich investors treasure over everything. Withdraw labour, no profits.
Nobody, whatever their job, should ever work for less than a living wage. Food and heat is not negotiable.

CanDo92 · 22/08/2022 12:42

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 11:18

@Iamthewombat i think the TUC predicted it would cost 2.5 billion to renationalise the energy companies

And when they did that, you presumably looked at their actual market capitalisation, realised they were completely wrong, and let them know?

Or did you just believe them?

Iamthewombat · 22/08/2022 12:42

MotherOfRatios · 22/08/2022 11:55

The middle-class on here ought to spend a day volunteering in a food bank to see reality

I’m sure that this sounded very good in your head but where is your evidence that posters on this thread don’t know what ‘reality’ is?

That not everybody is on board with the general strike idea, because it makes no logical sense, doesn’t mean that the same people can’t see the impact of high energy costs. They just don’t agree with your solution.

This is where you go, “yes, but what alternative are YOU suggesting?”.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 22/08/2022 12:41

I've seen a general strike on the horizon for some time now.

Scratching my head a bit over the barristers rejecting 15%. The rest, I wholeheartedly support.

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 12:41

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:54

@Suetwo yea cos the energy crisis has nothing to do with the tories does it?

To be honest it doesn’t really no. I am not a bojo fan or Tory voter but I don’t think there’s any evidence that they caused the increase in energy prices. It’s a global phenomenon.

maddiemookins16mum · 22/08/2022 12:40

What and lose my job and not get paid? Nah, I’ll sit this one out thanks.

CanDo92 · 22/08/2022 12:38

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 10:23

@Iamthewombat its not about losing an argument. It’s about you coming on threads and aggressively dismissing what anyone had to say without offering a single alternative.

i believe in collective action and have been unionised my entire working life. I see few other alternatives at the moment to empower people to believe that they can create societal change.

OK, so what are you doing about it? It’s easy for you to post on here, but are you willing to actually go out and do the organising, make yourself the figurehead, find funding to pay the bills of those striking, draw up the manifestos and so on?

I suspect not, but if you are then this seems like a good place to let others know, and ask them to join you.

sst1234 · 22/08/2022 12:33

A general strike won’t undo the damage done by lockdowns (unprint the £450b of money), it won’t add nuclear power stations into grid overnight, it won’t undo the damage done by welfare subsidized wages.

You are venting, but general strikes cannot undo the damage done by 25 years of bad policy.

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:32

@MsPincher Read the thread, not talking about Octopus etc but the production companies.

BearBibble · 22/08/2022 12:32

There are huge swathes of employees that can't strike. I'm in the NHS. My union voted to 'strike' in 2014, for the first time in its >100 year history - what it meant in practice was that if you were rostered to work you still had to turn up for your regular shift (but we were encouraged to 'try and take your full breaks and leave on time' lol) and if you were on a day off or a sleep day having worked the previous night you could go to the picket lines instead. For many workers, not turning up to work has no impact on the government; it only harms the general public who are already on their knees. Our strike (if you can call it that, it was business as usual in the hospital) was almost totally ineffectual as a result. What can we do?

CanDo92 · 22/08/2022 12:31

Mountainatmygates · 22/08/2022 08:30

@fufflecake join a union before they get banned as Truss has indicated she would like to.

Its funny how when MPs wanted to remove Boris, they withdrew their Labour

They resigned from their jobs. That’s very different from stopping working and saying that you expect to have your job kept open for you.

Everyone should have the right to withdraw their labour. Every employer should have the right to find someone else to do the job instead if they do so.

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:31

If the Uk isn’t attractive to investors (domestic and foreign) the economy will get much much worse and we will all be poorer. Don’t know what you are suggesting re inequality but unfortunately there are not easy answers

A lot of foreign investment is buy outs of UK PLC.

The economy is sunk unless people can afford to go out for the day and shop etc.

In the past, when folk were v poor, we had a very large manufacturing sector, thats gone, replaced with consumerism and services.

A 1% wealth tax on the UK 171 billionaires would raise almost 60 billion.... now thats simplistic but the point is, very small increases in tax on the extremely rich wont effect them but would have a huge positive impact on the rest of us.

If they already pay all this tax people say they do, how come they keep getting wealthier and wealthier?

Don't say "They'll leave" that has been totally debunked & and where too? most countries taxes are higher than the UK's.

MsPincher · 22/08/2022 12:28

AndreaC74 · 22/08/2022 12:24

Don't need to nationalise the whole company, just as investment banking wasn't bailed out during the GFC, only the retail part.

Around 4% of of the total value of UK pension funds is in energy.

But the point you are not addressing is that unless radical ideas are considered, then the Govt will just carry on handing £100s of billions to consumers to prevent starvation and death, not too mention economic collapse.

Govt help so far, according to their figures is approx £40 billion and that is based on fuel cap of £2000 and is just for a few months.

what happens if/when price cap stays at £5k for the foreseeable future? No one is going to be trading with Russia for many years to come unless the Ukraine war stops and Putin is no longer in power, two very big uncertainties.

Energy suppliers are making losses and going bust. That’s why so many don’t want to take on new customers. They have to buy energy on global market at a higher price than they are allowed to sell it for due to the price cap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread