Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really sad about this? 😥

81 replies

25carrotgold · 22/08/2022 04:05

So I started University in the September before covid started. We had the first semester as normal and then obviously the second semester was cut short because of covid.

Ever since then, lectures have been online. We were lucky that when University started again in September we were able to go in for the occasional practical or lab, unlike other courses, but it’s not the same as being in all the time. We only see a very small number of coursemates who are in our groups, and apart from that we don’t really know the rest of our year as we barely had 2 semesters to get to know everyone before covid started.

I have a nice group of friends and know of most of my coursemates through our course group chat, but it’s not the same really. Part of going to university is meeting lots of new people, nights out, going for lunch after classes, studying in the library and hanging out. It’s the social side that’s completely missing. All the clubs and societies were restricted or stopped if they couldn’t be run. And since they’ve been off for a few years, there’s no new members to take over so a lot of clubs won’t start up again for a while.

its just all the little things like that that add up to the ‘university experience’ and I feel so sad that it hasn’t happened- going in for 2 hours a week for a class just isn’t the same.

in some ways it has been better having lectures online- it’s easier to take notes, more time to work and do sports, less money and time commuting to Uni, but it would be nice to have a normal year now before we finish. We are going into our last year and my friends have apparently been told that lectures will remain online again this year- we will have more in-person tutorials and practical classes so it’s not terrible, but I was really hoping for a year of normal university experiences.

I know that the University are trying their best and it’s not their fault, and with covid spreading again it will be trickier still, but I just feel so sad about it all. Just needed to get this off my chest, sorry not really an AIBU.

OP posts:
Sswhinesthebest · 22/08/2022 09:35

DD’s have been f2f this year but tbh hardly any students bother to turn up. It’s quite shocking really.

whoamI00 · 22/08/2022 09:23

YANBU OP, that's super sad.

Change123today · 22/08/2022 09:21

I do feel for you. My daughter said she paying for an experience that she could have just done an open university course. She had an awful group in halls - 2 went home at Christmas never returned as they didn’t see the point. The others where international students who stuck to their own groups so she was very lonely and isolated - she used to sit in the kitchen to try and speak to them and they weren’t interested. Her course being the one thing she hoped to meet people - 1 hour f2f didn’t really help with that. She has autism so really struggles in social situation of groups. When she was brave the social group didnt quite work out so ended up alone :(

Online doesn’t work for everyone and a decent mix - and HONEST approach of how the course is being run is needed by university . When we asked at the university we where told one thing only for it to change the first week and they won’t even tell her what the mix will be for year 2. Thankfully she did make some friends and she is moving in with them - all of them have said they hoping year 2 is much more f2f.

poetryandwine · 22/08/2022 09:21

OP,

I think people are not disbelieving you; they are just shocked. Some might like to know how their DCs could avoid applying to units of admission still doing online lectures.

Many unis, including mine, started recording lectures at students’ request some time before COVID. Whilst there are valid reasons for doing this, using the recording of a live lecture as a replacement for attendance on a regular basis is not one of them. Nevertheless lecture attendance plummeted. We can track each student’s access of the recorded lectures and most were not viewing them in a remotely timely fashion. You
can imagine the knock on effect for tutorials, seminars and labs.

With COVID many unis required the development of extremely high quality prepared lectures for recorded delivery together with auxiliary materials. People went into overdrive to meet this brief. Research was interrupted and careers were set back. Now (a) a number of people hired on short term contracts throughout the U.K. to meet this brief are coming to the end of their jobs creating teaching shortages, and (b) there is a reluctance to suppress these very high quality outputs when, in spite of what your peers will tell you, attendance in the time of Lecture Capture is dismal anyway.

I’m with you, OP.

ladymactíre · 22/08/2022 09:18

This shouldn't have happened. My daughter was online 2020-2021 and it was a struggle after 2 years of normal uni. Her results dropped and she absolutely hated it. 2021-2022 they went back to normal and she was flying. I don't think your university does their best for you. You should be allowed to go to school and have a life. The other one did a plc in the "online year" and started first year in 20-21 when thongs got back to normal. All her friends that started uni in that year were unhappy about the online studying. uni is about studying, but it should be the best social experience. Online doesn't do that

OneInEight · 22/08/2022 09:07

I don't think your university is trying its best. ds1 has had a pretty normal university experience this past year. I think the only exception was doing the first half of the year exams at home but otherwise everything as it would have been done pre-covid.

maiafawnly · 22/08/2022 09:01

Im an 0920 student, i started during the pandemic and everything was understandably online, now, two years later, and despite no lockdowns or closures in over a year, we are still all online. Its so hard to stay motivated sat at a computer alone, you also need the support of students in the cohort. Thankfully I've made a small number of friends, but its nothing like the real student experience before covid. We have complained till we are blue in the face, but they're saying this is how its going to stay. I feel ripped of paying £9.5k a year to effectively teach my self from PowerPoints. But we cant change it.

Hazjack · 22/08/2022 08:57

I feel really bad for everyone that missed that proper "uni experience" that most get. I'm doing a 2nd degree (15 years after my first!) and I'm just commuting to a small college this time, don't care about the partying/hook ups anymore! Fresher year didn't live up to the hype anyway tbh and I wish I could take back some of the decisions I made! 😳

I'm also not great with "screen lectures", I need a classroom environment (or outdoors in my case, as it's an outdoorsy subject) and a proper present teacher who I can ask questions to sometimes, but if it was my only choice I'd try my best to adapt. My college and even my kids school don't have any rules anymore - but guessing this winter shit will hit the fan again 🙄

Littlemissprosecco · 22/08/2022 08:43

My daughters going into third year at Cardiff. Mostly still on line, goes in once or twice a week for labs

KarenOLantern · 22/08/2022 08:40

YANBU in the slightest OP. I know a couple of uni-aged people and I just feel devastated for them. When the first lockdown started I thought "meh, it'll just be a couple of weeks, no biggie", but now it's gone past the 2 year mark, and that is a LOT of time in the life of a young person.

The social aspect of it is so important at your age. It's meant to be your introduction to adult life. I'm another one who struggled socially at school and university was such a defining experience. And I don't see why they need to be doing everything online still. You're being robbed. Like someone else said, if you felt like learning from home was something that suited you, you could have signed up to the OU!

I just wonder what knock-on effects all these lockdowns will have on your generation and the ones who are children now, in years to come. I really feel for you all.

WhereAreMyAirpods · 22/08/2022 08:37

Why are people disbelieving the OP? Just because the Uni you teach in, or where your children go has been offering in-person?

Crinkle77 · 22/08/2022 08:26

ChloeKellyIsAnIcon · 22/08/2022 05:02

I'm surprised to hear this OP. I work at a university and all lectures, tutorials etc have been face-to-face since January of this year, and will be in September too. I think your university is being far too cautious.

I'd be interested to know this too as the uni I work at has been delivering fully face to face since last September.

mumonthehill · 22/08/2022 08:20

Ds has done 2 years of uni through covid and it has been awful. He has not enjoyed his course as so much of it online, knows hardly anyone on his course as they hardly ever get to meet and is now just counting the months until he finishes next year. He has made friends, joined clubs but it has not been the same and he suffered in his first year from the isolation.

Cakecakecheese · 22/08/2022 08:19

Oh this is rubbish. Contact the NUS see what they say?

WhereAreMyAirpods · 22/08/2022 08:17

Oh and as to the "why is nobody asking questions" - in Scotland it's slightly different as students aren't paying fees.

And the National Union of Students up here very much supported the cautious, careful, eliminate covid approach of the Scottish government. It really has been a disgrace.

SwordBilledHummingbird · 22/08/2022 08:15

justfiveminutes · 22/08/2022 06:37

So everything will be back to normal except for lectures? I think many universities have decided to keep lectures online for all of the positive reasons you cite, so it sounds as if your third year will be as normal as things are ever going to be.

I have two dc at uni and their lectures have been online this year, but with f2f seminars and tutorials. I would say they have had a normal uni experience this year. They live with friends, have friends on their course that they see in seminars, all clubs and societies running as normal.

I hope you have a great third year. I don't think it will be as bad as you think.

This is what we've done. The lectures are still online but that contact time has been replaced by labs, workshops, seminars, Q&A sessions etc. It means that the students are actually getting access to a lot more teaching and the face to face teaching is more interactive, both with the staff and with each other. Lots of universities have opted for this, it's because it's a better way of teaching and learning, not as a means of avoiding face to face teaching. They get just as many face to face contact hours as before Covid.

WhereAreMyAirpods · 22/08/2022 08:12

YANBU.

My oldest started his undergraduate science degree in September 2021. His last two years at school were hugely affected by Covid. The course he is on is a large one. We are in Scotland where degrees are 4 years not 3, and the first year has a wide range of classes taken by lots of students - so for example DS is on a biomedical science degree and he had a pharmacology module with everyone studying pharmacy and chemistry, a statistics module with the biololgy students and so on.

This past year - so from September 2021 to May 2022 - he was in uni SIX TIMES. 3 hours a time for labs. So 18 hours in TOTAL. Scotland's approach to Covid has been more batshit mental "cautious" than England's and the Uni's attitude was that classes were too big and they couldn't work out any way of getting them all back on campus. They are "hoping" for a normal second year. He knows nobody from his course, each time he was in for labs it was with a different group. None of the clubs and societies were meeting in person.

I needed to access the uni library in May, well after the mask mandate stopped in Scotland in April. The library had one way systems, capacity limits, every other desk taped off, sanitiser everywhere, messages about social distancing and STAYING SAFE.

His mental health is on the floor and he has struggled enormously with being so isolated and confined to his bedroom for a year. The only mercy is that he's here at home with us while "at uni" so we have been able to keep an eye on him when he has been so low and so unahppy.

It's a total shitshow but the Scottish government have been encouraging this "cautious" approach to education and think the universities are doing a marvellous job. Young people have been completely shafted.

Hidingawaytoday · 22/08/2022 08:09

I hear you OP and do feel for you, a relative of time did most of her course online and it just isn't the same.

But I'm really surprised it's still the case now. I have a few friends and family members who work in universities as either lecturers or support and in all of them they're back to normal with teaching in person.

maranella · 22/08/2022 08:08

I know that the University are trying their best and it’s not their fault

Actually, I think your university, whichever one it is, is completely taking the piss! Why on Earth, when the rest of life in the UK has been largely back to normal for months and most universities are back to full, in person teaching, is yours not? If it were me I'd be kicking up an almighty stink about them charging full fees for 2 hours a week of in person teaching and everything else being in your bedroom since March 2020. That is appalling! And no, you are absolutely not BU to be fed up and sad that your university experience has been so disappointing.

Porcupineintherough · 22/08/2022 08:06

My nephew's uni are fully back in person but students can choose to attend lectures on line (either in real time or by watching the recording later). Most are choosing to attend virtually, so I don't think it's as simple as saying universities are cost cutting. Students are making different choices.

2pinkginsplease · 22/08/2022 08:03

My teens are both at the same uni and are doing a mix of online and classes. Ds”s course seems to be mostly online whereas dd has had more actual classes.

will see what this year brings.

uni certainly hasn’t been the experience that mine were looking for .

Smilingwithfangs · 22/08/2022 08:03

You aren’t in any way being unreasonable- I have often said that of all the groups who suffered from lockdown, uni students esp first years, mums at home with babies and toddlers and the isolated elderly have suffered enormously in the way of loss of experience and company and a time in life that they can’t get back.

However I wonder if you all need to be a bit less passive here. Is anyone asking questions- WHY is your uni not back to all or at eh very least mainly face to face and why are they not going all out to resume the social side of the student experience? Almost everywhere is unrestricted now and for a cohort who are young and much less likely to be at high risk from covid there seems little excuse.

Which uni is this? They are apparently behaving differently to almost all those j have knowledge of or other posters so I think they need to be taken to task about it.

is there a student group who could do this?

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 22/08/2022 07:59

Which Uni are you at OP? sounds weird and a complete outlier.

Both my nieces are doing science degrees (different unis) and both have been back to normal with lectures and labs since Jan 2022.
DD starts in September and is fully F2F for everything. In fact we all had several F2F lecture on the offer holder day-parents included! All clubs/music/orchestra/freshers as normal.

Sunnysideup999 · 22/08/2022 07:59

Why is everything on line still? I would complain to the uni - it’s totally unacceptable especially if they are charging full fees. They should be functioning as usual now

Scurryfunge12 · 22/08/2022 07:58

I see the disappointment. Some people don’t learn as efficiently online and like the human element where they can ask questions and interact to facilitate learning

If they wanted online they could have signed up to the OU for £3,000 a year cheaper!