Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away. AIBU that family should come and see us?

236 replies

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

OP posts:
fiorentina · 21/08/2022 21:11

My MIL moved 6 hours away from us and it means it’s hard for us to visit - we both work full time, it’s a shame we don’t see her more but if she won’t come to us we don’t have lots of time to visit her now. Her choice to move though.

AnnieDav · 21/08/2022 21:08

My ILs moved 3 hours away from us when our children were babies (they used to live about 20 minutes away).

They endlessly pressure us to visit them more but we both work, have two now school age children and not huge amounts of free time whilst they are both retired and have an awful lot of free time.

I 100% support their lifestyle change but their choice to move 3 hours away didn’t coincide with us making a choice to want to drive across the country regularly in our very limited free time.

LuftBalloons · 21/08/2022 21:03

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years.

No it’s not selfish to move for your own reasons. What is selfish - or rather unrealistic - is that you expect your children to visit you.

Why not budget time and resources so that you visit them?

Wafflessyrup · 21/08/2022 20:58

You’re not being unreasonable. We have family who moved and we take turns to travel because that’s what family do lol. Albeit it’s harder to organise with work and kids but you find a way.
my mum even flied solo for the first time to Australia to see me once ( I personally think she just wanted a holiday in a new country 🤔😉-

in my opinion young children aren’t an excuse we’re going on our second uk holiday this year that’s a 4 hour drive each way and we stop for lunch and give our toddler a time watching cartoons or dancing to the radio, he sleeps in the car etc (I’m not suggesting a newborn travel this far in a car of course)

my parents drove us on holidays to Europe across America, so maybe I’m inclined to say kids aren’t an excuse

but the notion that YOU moved so they should never visit you is shitty, it’s give and take like anything in life, why wouldn’t family wanna come visit you, see where you live what your new house is like etcetera, It’s not like you’re asking them to travel to see you every time that’d be different.

makes you wonder doesn’t it, when you move away you tend to lose friends and family because most of the time it’s about convenience and not love, unless of course you had an ultimate genuine reason

Luredbyapomegranate · 21/08/2022 20:56

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 21/08/2022 20:44

If you and hour husband are content with this move then go for it .
Don't expect regular visits from your children but heed well that in a few short years, you won't be able to visit them, either.

Your elderly father has a limited amount of time left ( sorry to be blunt) and one of you will be left alone (again, sorry to be blunt .)

Think on that.

As an aside, this story is vaguely familiar.

Very good points

Also extra points for using the expression Heed Well @wherearebeefandonioncrisps

Luredbyapomegranate · 21/08/2022 20:54

It sounds like a reverse because you are moving away and yet moaning that your son won’t visit, even though you haven’t gone yet. It’s such a moany cliche it doesn’t sound quite real.

However since it is:

Yes you are unreasonable to expect regular visits given the stresses of your son’s family’s life and the fact they - you know - have their own lives. Twice a year tops at that distance.

So yes, if that connection matters to you, don’t move so far.

No you aren’t selfish for moving. It’s your life, do what you want. But don’t moan when you don’t get many visitors.

You cannot have it every which way. Choose and take responsibility for your choice.

Pipsquiggle · 21/08/2022 20:47

I live 4 hours from my parents, I have lived in the South East since uni. I have a 10 and 7 year old. My parents travel to us about 85% of the time.

It's a real ball ache to go up there (slightly easier now they're older), both me and DH work full time, school term times, clubs and sports. Realistically it's Christmas and summer.

I get you want to move for lifestyle etc but this will completely change the dynamics of your family but you know that. In terms of travelling, realistically it will be you that's visiting more often than your family coming to you due to the life stages you're at

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 21/08/2022 20:44

If you and hour husband are content with this move then go for it .
Don't expect regular visits from your children but heed well that in a few short years, you won't be able to visit them, either.

Your elderly father has a limited amount of time left ( sorry to be blunt) and one of you will be left alone (again, sorry to be blunt .)

Think on that.

As an aside, this story is vaguely familiar.

mummabubs · 21/08/2022 20:39

We've always lived 3 hours away from our home town (and therefore both my parents and my in-laws). My parents have recently moved in a different direction, but still 2.5 hours away from where we live. We travel to see both sets every 4-6 weeks, they visit us here maybe once or twice a year. We've continued this pattern even after our children came (now 4 and 1yo).

However, even I think YABU. And you're being unreasonable because you expect it. You have made a choice to move (which obviously you are more than entitled to do and I hope you're very happy in your new location). However you cannot reasonably expect everyone else to then make sacrifices of their own and bear the cost of travel to see you regularly - especially if you know they're having a tough time and have a child who doesn't travel well. Would there be space for them to stay with you if they came to you (sorry if I missed that) or would you also be expecting them to fork out for accommodation every time too? Honestly your best bet here is take the pressure off them, see how it goes and if they want to visit you then great. If not you're also very capable of going to see them.

onlythreenow · 21/08/2022 20:38

It's not selfish of you to move, as you rightly said it is your lives and it's time for you to live them how you want to. However, I agree that YABU to expect a couple with two young children to travel such a distance to visit you, and think that if you want to see them you need to be the ones who travel.

ShoesShoesGloriousShoes · 21/08/2022 20:32

My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place,

You lost me at rural. Why on earth would you choose to retire to somewhere rural and move your 80+ year old dad? What happens when his health starts to fail? How will your DS realistically manage to travel to see him and you when it comes to it? Will you be expecting him to leave his family to it at the weekends to help you out? You cannot expect them to visit you more than once or twice a year. Of course they're being non-committal, they don't want to consign their DC's childhoods to the back seat of a car because you deem your free time more important than theirs.

TheHateIsNotGood · 21/08/2022 20:29

YABVU to expect your ds and his family to visit you. You're retired with time for hobbies, your DF will be in assisted living and your ds and his family are going through difficult times.

Another thought you might not have considered is that who do you think will provide any future care for you and your already health-compromised DH? The rural areas look pretty nice so many people move there, so not only are the people who provide care at pitiful wages in short supply (been priced out) but the ratio of demand for elderly care becomes excessively top-heavy.

huuskymam · 21/08/2022 20:29

Ybvu. I hate doing a long drive with my 12 year old who can occupy himself. It can be the 7th circle of hell doing 4 hours with a toddler and baby.

You're retired with free time and no dependent kids, you're the ones moving, you should do the travelling.

3ShotsOfEspresso · 21/08/2022 20:27

You move = you travel.

PersonaNonGarter · 21/08/2022 20:17

They will rarely visit. Right now they need you but they will have to learn to live without you. Once they do, you will become somewhere they go maybe as much as every six months.

Life, hobbies, not much annual leave etc will just mean that they’ll come less and less.

Kite22 · 21/08/2022 20:14

We are making big sacrifices for this move. Moving away from our son, grandchildren, my brother, friends, etc. And it will mean that my husband is even further away from his family. We've explained to everyone our reasons for moving.

If you are looking on it as "making big sacrifices" and haven't posted anything positive about why you are moving to where you are moving, I think that is strange.
I absolutely do NOT think parents of adult dc should arrange their whole lives around their dc, and I completely think slightly older adults should choose to live where it suits them to live but you sound as if everything about this move is negative. That is what is odd about it.

YABVU to expect them to visit more than once a year - it's just not practical.

Goldbar · 21/08/2022 20:14

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 19:19

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years. My husband had a major heart operation a few years ago and it made us re-evaluate our lives. We didn't have our parents around when we were working and our children were little and we all survived. It was never going to be easy but hopefully we'll make it work.

As pp have said, you're perfectly entitled to prioritise yourselves and your son and family are perfectly entitled to prioritise themselves. What is unreasonable is prioritising yourselves and then complaining when other people do the same and don't prioritise you.

I'm sure your son and DIL will manage without your help, but one thing which will make it easier for them is not having the guilt piled on them frequently to drag two very small children on a very long and unpleasant car journey. Why would you want that for your grandchildren anyway?

Christmasfun2022 · 21/08/2022 20:13

Just wanted to say we are in the exact same position with our in laws. And this thread has made me feel better than we don’t/can’t visit then loads 🤷‍♀️

LastWordsOfALiar · 21/08/2022 20:13

I think you're being very unrealistic about what this move will offer you.

It will offer you hobbies and nicer scenery.

But you need to be prepared that it WILL cost you in your relationships with the children and grandchildren. The grandchildren won't know you all that well. They'll love you, and see you periodically, but it'll be different to what you have at the moment.

I'm not saying you shouldn't move, but do it with the realisation that it will distance your relationships and that's on YOU, not them.

I also think it's pretty shitty to acknowledge their stressors and add to it. Adding the expectation that they'll visit you and leave their children with you, when they have so much going on, is a bit egocentric.

ElBandito · 21/08/2022 20:12

I think you are a bit bonkers to move away from your local support network. I think within 10 years you could be regretting this move big time. If one of you falls ill etc how will your son be able to help you?

SausageDogEnvy · 21/08/2022 20:11

You could be my parent but for a few details….moved 5.5 hours away to new-ish partners place of birth. Both left adult children and multiple grandchildren.
moved for a bigger house in a rural location.

if this is real, they moved 18m ago and we’ve visited twice (currently here).
Next visit Easter 2023 at the very earliest, but could well be next summer.

we just don’t want to use all our leave on travelling with small children. And the cost of diesel these days.

my parent also suggested sending the children to them for the holidays. I laughed, they’re early primary aged, and because of the distance don’t have a close relationship and probably won’t. So won’t want/feel comfortable staying without parents so far from home.

YANBU to move, but YABU to expect regular visits.

WinterDeWinter · 21/08/2022 20:10

I think people are suggesting you are really the DIL pretending to be the Mil in order to get unbiased responses- and they perhaps think that because you seem quite detached and unsympathetic, Op. if you're being a bit 'well too bad, we need to put ourselves first' then you can't in truth be surprised when they do the same?

Stretchandsnap · 21/08/2022 20:09

I think you aren’t unreasonable to
do what you want to do at 60 when you are retirees, but you are very unreasonable to expect that your child and family traipse to see you on a regular basis.

You are also moving away from family who could support you as you grow older - you are fine now but in the future if you do need help in a regular basis, you are going to be on your own In a rural location and will be very unreasonable indeed to expect any practical support

Outlyingtrout · 21/08/2022 20:07

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years. My husband had a major heart operation a few years ago and it made us re-evaluate our lives. We didn't have our parents around when we were working and our children were little and we all survived. It was never going to be easy but hopefully we'll make it work.

Well yes, it is selfish. I can't really understand how anyone could argue otherwise. It's the very definition of selfish I.e. to be chiefly concerned with one's own pleasure or profit without regard for anyone else's. In this case you and your husband are primarily concerned with living in a particular location because you like it and because you can do your hobbies there, and you aren't dissuaded by your son and his family needing your support or by the fact that it will undoubtedly have a profound impact on your relationships with him and your grandchildren. You "re-evaluated your lives" and realised that your children and grandchildren aren't your priority.

It is your choice, of course, but I don't know why you need to pretend it's anything other than what it is.

whatthejuice · 21/08/2022 20:03

Yes, it's a massive pain in the a$$ for them to visit you!
Having two young children is extremely challenging at the best of times - then throw in a long journey and staying in a strange place with none of the kid stuff you have at home to make things easier...nightmare!
I have some experience of this as a family member has recently moved.
Why don't you think about...

Is it fair for me to ask my child, who already works and looks after two young children, to travel 3-4 hours regularly to see me?

Presumably they work Monday to Friday...is it fair for me to ask them to come up on Saturday morning and stay 24 hours to then do the return leg of the journey back?

Or perhaps you think they should use some of their precious annual leave to come and visit you?

By all means move to an area you love, indulge in the hobbies you want, but don't be surprised if you see little of your family. They are at a stage of life where they don't have a spare second - and it is exhausting when family don't respect that.