Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away. AIBU that family should come and see us?

236 replies

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

OP posts:
Adversity · 21/08/2022 22:49

I have done that trip with small dc many times but I moved away from my home town. My family rarely visited.

glassdarker · 21/08/2022 22:44

Wow.

Of course it's not unreasonable to want a different life. But it is definitely unreasonable to expect your DS and family to either be happy about that in the short term or to visit.

My DPs live 4 hours away in a beautiful part of the country, with me choosing (post uni) not to live there (no jobs!). We see each other on average every 2-3 months, with us choosing to holiday there 2-3 times a year and them visiting us 1-2 times. Taking the emotion out of it there are some really practical things you need to think of:

  • weekend visits will not happen - we have done this once for a very special occasion. This will not change much as they get older, it's too much travel for everyone.
  • it will change your relationship - having to visit and spend a concentrated period of time together is very different to much more regular but small visits.
  • even if you make the effort to visit you need to bear in mind it won't be the same. If you stay with them that's frankly a whole lot of extra stress and work for them. If you don't you may find it difficult to have access to a suitable base for them to visit, and you won't have the ready stash of stuff which GPS usually have to make visits with young kids easier, nor will it be a familiar environment for them.
Pipsquiggle · 21/08/2022 22:41

@warriorathena yes that does sound rubbish and blatant favouritism

whiteroseredrose · 21/08/2022 22:41

Oh God, your update makes it worse.

DH's parents live 3 hours from us. They are now v elderly with a number of illnesses and we think MIL is starting with dementia.

Unfortunately we cannot help. We did ask them to move closer to us 10 and 5 years ago but they wouldn't. Now they are really too frail to do much themselves and it is awful.

A colleague's DP moved to Wales for the sea air when they retired. She is in the same situation. Her DM is v ill but she is stuck. And COVID was even more of a nightmare.

There is a lot to be said for having family around as you get older.

JenniferBarkley · 21/08/2022 22:38

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 21/08/2022 22:37

Yes, a reverse of a thread I’ve seen a couple of months ago - with the OP complaining that her in laws/parents (I can’t remember exactly) are ‘abandoning’ her.

I posted the link above a couple of hours ago.

Rowen32 · 21/08/2022 22:37

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 19:19

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years. My husband had a major heart operation a few years ago and it made us re-evaluate our lives. We didn't have our parents around when we were working and our children were little and we all survived. It was never going to be easy but hopefully we'll make it work.

Is there a reason you've to move so far away? Even 2 hours would be more manageable. I wouldn't be doing trips like that until the kids are much older, able to read books, play board games etc to entertain themselves..

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 21/08/2022 22:37

PatriciaHolm · 21/08/2022 16:49

I'm calling reverse on this one....

Yes, a reverse of a thread I’ve seen a couple of months ago - with the OP complaining that her in laws/parents (I can’t remember exactly) are ‘abandoning’ her.

JenniferBarkley · 21/08/2022 22:37

Butchyrestingface · 21/08/2022 22:36

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

If you don't know what a "reverse" is, then you can't have an opinion either way on why people would think it is one, Mrs Reverse McReverseFace.

Oh that did make me snort.

Butchyrestingface · 21/08/2022 22:36

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

If you don't know what a "reverse" is, then you can't have an opinion either way on why people would think it is one, Mrs Reverse McReverseFace.

Rowen32 · 21/08/2022 22:34

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

Gosh, I'm sorry but I couldn't fathom doing that road trip with kids that age.. I just couldn't do it - maybe broken up into three trips of an hour with stops but that's a whole day travelling and then back, its a lot of work..

warriorathena · 21/08/2022 22:31

@Pipsquiggle

Yes it certainly is 'crap' for us. I feel they literally choose them over us due to favouritism. They also moved away from their elderly parents and their business too such was their preference for BILs family. We felt completely ditched. Plus we've endured years of them paying for BILs expensive holidays (this years alone was around £15k), £30k wedding, business loans etc which by my estimate has exceeded > £150k! Little help for us in comparison. Maybe you can see why they did it, but it doesn't feel nice from the other side. But I digress.....

expat101 · 21/08/2022 22:31

My Parents did the same when our children were young (and had pets). They had huge expectations we would be able to drive the 5 hours to get to their new location and return home 48 hours later for the new week...

There was no consideration that as the DC grew, they had sporting/hobby commitments and us being self employed usually meant work spilt over into the weekends.

I was happy they had moved to a nice area and along the lines of what had been talked about pre-retirement, albeit in the opposite direction, thats all well and good, but the trade off was they moved away from family by choice.

it depends on what you want out of life priority wise. Surely if you are keen to keep regular contact with your family, you can find something equally suitable in a better location, nearby?

BlueWhat · 21/08/2022 22:12

I'm a similar age to you, although not retired. And have to admit am shocked at your lack of understanding.

You expect them to take annual leave and drive 3/4 hours to come visit you with their kids?

Unbelievable! You're retired and much more flexible, you're the ones that decided to move away!

You will have to be the one to go visit them, if they even have the space? Do they even want you to stay with them for a couple of days?

I absolutely get wanting to move away, I'll be moving abroad once I retire, but I'll be the one coming over to visit my kids. I'll be the one fitting in with them.

Pipsquiggle · 21/08/2022 22:06

warriorathena · 21/08/2022 21:51

My ILs moved 4 1/2 hours away from us to be by the seaside and be near their other son and his family. It's caused no end of resentment our end as we feel second best to BIL's family. They don't understand why we don't visit more often when DH works full time. BIL + family never visit us when they head back home either. Awful, selfish family- I'm now glad they've moved so far away. Of course it's their life, they can do as they want but the consequence is not seeing our DC as often and the relationship reducing as a result.

@warriorathena

I can kind of understand this though. Crap for you but at least the ILs are helping your BIL's family out by the seaside - I am guessing it's a nice place to retire. There would be no point moving half way between you.

This happened to my friend's in laws. One family lived in Cornwall, one family lived near London. They were going to live 'in the middle' but realised they wouldn't see either family that often so they picked a location. They obviously see one of the families much more than the other.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 21/08/2022 22:01

Oh... now I remember... your THAT poster.

Ok, well let them go. It's their decision. You can't stop them.

Newgirls · 21/08/2022 21:52

Find an air B and B you like near your son and go and visit every month or two. I’m sure you gave mates to visit in your old area too?

they won’t be able to visit outside of school holidays really so you will need to make plans to visit them

warriorathena · 21/08/2022 21:51

My ILs moved 4 1/2 hours away from us to be by the seaside and be near their other son and his family. It's caused no end of resentment our end as we feel second best to BIL's family. They don't understand why we don't visit more often when DH works full time. BIL + family never visit us when they head back home either. Awful, selfish family- I'm now glad they've moved so far away. Of course it's their life, they can do as they want but the consequence is not seeing our DC as often and the relationship reducing as a result.

Jalepenojello · 21/08/2022 21:49

They’re unlikely to visit more than twice a year. Life with a young family just gets so busy, especially when working full time. You’ve moved away when they’ve never had more on their plate. And that’s okay but no, you can’t expect them to visit often.

MaggieFS · 21/08/2022 21:45

YABU to expect that they come and see you but YANBU for making the move.

Just wait and see how it goes, plus be prepared that YOU might have to be the one ones who go and do the visiting.

SarahProblem · 21/08/2022 21:40

If this isn't a reverse:

Do what makes you happy but understand from their point of view is you're opting to see less of them regardless of the reason. Also you need to accept that you're going to have to travel more and see them much less.

whumpthereitis · 21/08/2022 21:30

Also calling reverse, and suspect it’s the poster that’s made at least two previous threads about her in laws moving away.

Blondeshavemorefun · 21/08/2022 21:30

You say you made sacrifices to move

but are you willing to sacrifice your family

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 21/08/2022 21:27

YAB completely U. You are choosing to move a fair distance away and expect people to juggle work and kids and visit you. You should definitely visit them. My parents live a similar distance from us (where I grew up) and we go down about once a year. My in laws also have this obsession that we should visit them - they’re retired, we both work full time, kids are tired from school and we have more space. It baffles me to be honest.

badbaduncle · 21/08/2022 21:24

You get one life, do what you want with it, but you have to understand that your son also has his own life, and his own family. DM moved to Florida and as a result sees the 2 DC that like hols in Florida for 3-4 weeks a year and me hardly at all. She complains like hell but tbh I just smile and say "we can't make it this year". It's my life, and I am spending it elsewhere! That is her dream and I wish her every happiness

Oysterbabe · 21/08/2022 21:23

My family live 3.5 hours away. We see them twice a year and my children have no relationship with them. Surely there must have been a closer option?