Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away. AIBU that family should come and see us?

236 replies

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

OP posts:
PuddingBear · 22/08/2022 07:50

YABU. You shouldn’t be expecting them to visit you. You’re the ones moving away and if you have to justify it to all and sundry maybe you shouldn’t be.

MagsR2356 · 22/08/2022 07:46

This does scream reverse
but if not yes your within your rights to move
of course you are

but no it’s totally reasonable to expect them to visit you at all
I think once a year might be more realistic

it’s you that decides to move, so you that has to accept you may see them very little in the year as it’s not fair to expect them to do it

if personally resent the travel with my small children it would be torture and not to mention the upset of routines

TooHotToTangoToo · 22/08/2022 07:37

Your family are not being U, to not want to commit to times/ dates to see you.

My dp retired 5 hours away, which means that I can't just 'visit for a weekend' as it's just not feasible with 2 children. We either leave and drive through the night on Friday after work and school, then everyone is tired on Saturday and we have to leave Sunday, after breakfast at latest. We can't visit during term time as the dc are at school and we only have x number of weeks leave from work. So I maybe see them once a year, maybe twice if we forgo a family holiday. As you can see it's not as easy as saying they will come visit.

I think you're being a bit short sighted, I know you'll miss your family, but ultimately it's your decision, and you have to accept that, that decision will impact others, which will impact their decisions. Luckily my dp appreciate that we can't see them frequently, and there have been years when we've not seen them at all, you will find other ways of interacting

Wilkolampshade · 22/08/2022 07:31

OP you talk of making 'sacrifices' to do this move, but these are not sacrifices, these are absolutely free choices.
My mum and dad did similar. And expected similar. We spent 20 years trying to see them regularly (pils were also 3 hrs away) and I really REALLY wish we hadn't - and I would counsel your dd' not to. It used up masses of time, days and days of driving and made me feel resentful and exhausted. ( with hindsight I was trying desperately to make everything OK, to be a good daughter) 🙄.)
You moved. You make the effort.

Ragwort · 22/08/2022 07:21

I don't know if this thread is a reverse or not but of course the OP should move if she wants to ... my DPs moved four hours away when they retired, I was just delighted for them that they had the opportunity to do something exciting in their retirement years. As it happens we then moved two hours in the opposite direction. We made it work for occasional visits, of course we didn't have the close 'popping in for a cup of tea' relationship but ever since I left home for Uni I've never lived that close to any of my family.

I am approaching retirement myself now and hope to move and to be honest proximity to my adult DC won't be top of my priority - I hope I have raised DC to be independent and not need mum and dad 'round the corner'.

Plenty of adult DC don't hesitate before moving abroad or long distances for their career etc so why should DPs be any different?

Too many women (& some men) end up as unappreciated child minders for their DGC and just taken for granted. FWIW my DC have an excellent relationship with their DGPs even though we never lived close when they were growing up.

Pinklady245612 · 22/08/2022 07:07

4 hours is very far to travel with young children, including one with SN. Especially as they are not the ones creating the distance.
I think it's ok to move away and live your life how you want to, but don't expect regular visits. I think you'll be lucky to see them once or twice a year at yours.

templesit · 22/08/2022 06:59

Yabu.

Decision is, do you want your new location more or the family?

I wouldn't be bringing my young children all that way for a few hours visit its too much.
Have you got space to offer them a holiday stay? That might help.

Of course they won't leave the children to stay with you! You'll be waiting 3+ years for that, if not more.

Your relationship with the baby won't be like it is with the 3 year old
I'm surprised you want to move if you really want to see the kids as much as you say.

Bottom line is you won't see them much now but if that's the sacrifice you choose to make to move area don't complain THEY won't visit.

Flatandhappy · 22/08/2022 06:52

It is not unreasonable to hope they will visit, but tbh from what you have written I think visits will be few and far between. I would plan to see them in the expectation that you will be doing the travelling. You are completely reasonable to make whatever plans you think are best for yourself, your DH and your dad but other people may not react in the way you would like. It sounds like you moving will mean that they have less help than before, some people understand that they are not entitled to help and are grateful for what they get but if you have been on here for any length of time you will have seen how many others think that grandparents should continue to prioritise their kids and grandchildren for the rest of their lives and never put themselves first.

Thegrassaintgreener · 22/08/2022 06:41

No, you aren't selfish, but you have to expect that people won't want to travel.
It's a very long way with small children.

We have 3 sets of family 2 hours from us in completely different directions, we get to all of them once or twice a year, but it's not enjoyable. The journey, having to stay away from home with kids that don't settle, routine disruption, having to share a room with the kids, coming home being more tired than when you set off, only to have to go to work the next day. Even packing is a complete pain and takes a good few hours.

So sadly I see these trips as more of a burden than anything else.

NewtoHolland · 22/08/2022 06:33

They probably feel abandoned and I don't blame them.
You are choosing not to have really anything much to do with your grandchildren, you won't really know them and I doubt they will feel confident stay with you. You've shown how little they mean to you by choosing this. Why should they spend their limited annual leave on you? An 8 hour round trip isn't doable in a weekend with very small children so it'll be a rare trip.

HappyHappyHermit · 22/08/2022 05:27

We have family 3 or 4 hours away. I would say we visit 2 or 3 times a year. It's doable in a weekend, even with young children, but I don't think you can expect it to be any more regular than that. In not all that long the children will have clubs or activities or birthdays to go to at the weekend and won't be happy to miss too many of them either. Nothing wrong with living further away but visits will be less regular.

Funkyblues101 · 22/08/2022 02:56

My parents in law were around 3 hours drive from us. We would go around twice a year for a weekend, other times we'd meet midway at a national trust, twice a year maybe. They would take the children on holiday for a week every summer, but apart from that we didn't see them. We were all very busy and time flies. If you want to regularly see busy people you have to live nearby.

Booklover3 · 22/08/2022 01:48

I think you’ll have to drive back personally. You moved.

lastminutedotcom22 · 21/08/2022 23:27

gogogadgetgo · 21/08/2022 22:57

Fuck me. If it's not a reverse you're just one of the most obtuse 50 somethings I've met.

As everyone has said. You can move wherever the hell you like. But if you move far away you have to accept that distance will make it harder to see people.

You're moving 3/4 hours away and are pissed your family are non committal about coming over.

Your DIL has Pnd, a 10 month old that doesn't travel well and a 3 year old being assessed for additional needs.

But they're not prepared to do a 8 hour round trip to see you?

You don't mention anywhere about you making the trip to see them.

You can't see how unreasonable you're being?

Life is busy for them. And it will get busier when the kids start school. I'd prepare yourself for not seeing much of the grandkids at all.

You also didn't answer my question about the day of child care you vaguely offered. Was that an actual offer they were relying on you've now rescinded?

Excellent post

You also don't say that your in your 60's whether once FIL goes as you age yourselves whether you'll feel cut off and isolated and wish you'd stayed nearer for support yourself?

Your choosing to move
Not your young family

I'd be saying If you want to see your grandkids you come to us which is fine if your young and fit enough to drive/travel but when you aren't, this will be difficult

Zonder · 21/08/2022 23:18

You don't mention anywhere about you making the trip to see them.

To be fair she does. 3rd paragraph of the opening post.

timtam23 · 21/08/2022 23:16

I'm currently visiting my DPs who moved 6 hours' drive away a few years ago and deliberately bought a house with enough bedrooms for us all to stay. My children are now pre-teens but it is still very hard to fit any visits in because of school, homework, work and sports commitments etc. Even in the school holidays we can only manage a few days down here and it is a very long tiring trip, I was exhausted yesterday and the traffic wasn't even too bad. My parents are getting more elderly now and my dad in particular likes his routines and finds even older children a bit too lively, it is quite stressful trying to balance everyone's needs and wants. Yet they say they want us to visit as they want to see their grandchildren, it feels very hard to please everyone. A weekend visit is out of the question I think as we could barely get settled before turning round and driving home. I don't think it was quite what my mum imagined when moving here, I think she thought we'd all be staying for holidays (touristy area). But being a good guest is not always very relaxing and not what I would choose for our summer family holiday. They have said they could not now cope with the journey to see us (they used to drive up but it's too much for them now) so I think they will have to settle for us visiting twice a year at most. It's sad but as they moved further away I think they will have to accept that they hardly see the children.

Zonder · 21/08/2022 23:16

We are making big sacrifices for this move. Moving away from our son, grandchildren, my brother, friends, etc.

You said it. You're sacrificing being close to all these people. That's your choice and your right but you can't expect people to do an 8 hour round trip very often. Especially when they have small children and one seems to have SEN. It sounds like your son and DIL are pretty snowed under and can't think about committing to this journey regularly at the moment.

whumpthereitis · 21/08/2022 23:02

It’s the DIL from the multiple previous threads.

the in laws purposefully didn’t tell you at the same time as everyone else because they knew this would be the result (well, maybe not the mumsnet threads). They have significant caring responsibilities already, and they’re moving to a house they already own if I recall correctly. They also weren’t particularly pressuring you to visit, just letting them know they could.

OP - what do you want, exactly? The pile on of your Inlaws that straight posting didn’t get you? They’re perfectly entitled to move, and clearly they’re going to. Your expectations be damned 🤷🏻‍♀️

Longleggedgiraffe · 21/08/2022 22:59

My Dh and I moved countries and left our grown kids behind. It's what we wanted to do. Sure, I miss them and only see them about twice a year, but it's the price we pay for living where we want to live, not where others want us to.

YANBU for wanting to see them but it seems as if yours really do have their hands full, so you probably will have to accept they might not be able to come. YABU if you put the onus on them. It was your choice to move,, not theirs.

Adversity · 21/08/2022 22:58

I’m back in my home town, it is lovely it’s tempting to retire back here especially as my two best mates have moved back to retire and my sister and her children all still live here . I just bumped in to a lad I went to school with not a close friend but someone in my year, we are meeting up for lunch before I go back, I could have an entire community immediately. There is no way I’m only seeing my adult DS a couple of times a year. The journey is 4 hours each way.

gogogadgetgo · 21/08/2022 22:57

Fuck me. If it's not a reverse you're just one of the most obtuse 50 somethings I've met.

As everyone has said. You can move wherever the hell you like. But if you move far away you have to accept that distance will make it harder to see people.

You're moving 3/4 hours away and are pissed your family are non committal about coming over.

Your DIL has Pnd, a 10 month old that doesn't travel well and a 3 year old being assessed for additional needs.

But they're not prepared to do a 8 hour round trip to see you?

You don't mention anywhere about you making the trip to see them.

You can't see how unreasonable you're being?

Life is busy for them. And it will get busier when the kids start school. I'd prepare yourself for not seeing much of the grandkids at all.

You also didn't answer my question about the day of child care you vaguely offered. Was that an actual offer they were relying on you've now rescinded?

Daisy03 · 21/08/2022 22:56

Reverse

Tee20x · 21/08/2022 22:54

You are being so massively unreasonable. There is no issue with moving away, living your dreams and passions etc. The issue is moving away and expecting your family to just roll with it and visit frequently despite YOU being the one moving.

You've literally listed several reasons that complicate matters but seem to have an issue with them being non-committal about visiting you?

Strange.

user1583920194858592910103848559201 · 21/08/2022 22:51

It's not selfish to move and it's not selfish that your kids don't want to drive 4 hours to visit you.

You'll more than likely need to travel to them because a 4 hour drive for you will more likely be 5.5 with young kids.

You need to accept that you'll be a Christmas and birthday grandparent

toooldtocarewhoknows · 21/08/2022 22:50

It's absolutely not unreasonable to want to retire to a more rural area.

But I would not be expecting a visit from your son more than once a year, maybe every other year if you are visiting them regularly. It's a long way with little children and requires planning and staying.

As you are retired and have free time you should probably expect to be doing the majority of visiting. Can they accommodate you when you visit?

Is your home in a tourist area maybe by the coast so you could offer them a holiday break during school holidays when the children reach that age?
That might be a nice way to see them too.

I know I'd always struggle being in a different county to my children. My husbands family are all quite a drive away too and we see them once a year.

Swipe left for the next trending thread