Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away. AIBU that family should come and see us?

236 replies

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 29/08/2022 12:11

SnowWhite13 · 29/08/2022 11:57

Also, they have done A LOT to help them out by assisting with childcare every single week, even for just one day, through the present! So why, after everything they've done to help them, all the effort OP and DH have put in, including making compromises, is the onus completely on OP??? That's just completely unreasonable to expect that any travel for visiting will only take place if OP comes back to visit them! DIL and son are the ones being unreasonable here. I wish I had only lived 4 hours from my grandparents! For 3 years I was about a days drive away. So we got to see them more often between the time I was 3 and 6 years old! That included staying with them without my parents. They would keep me and my baby brother for a while. But when I was 6, I ended up having to move even further, putting us 3,000 miles away from all of our grandparents and great grandparents! It. Was. Devastating! I was heartsick from being separated from my great grandma. She couldn't travel to us at all due to her health, so I only got to see her when we made the drive back to our hometown. After moving 3,000 miles away, my paternal grandparents came to visit as often as they could. My parents were only able to take us home twice. Once for my great grandma's death. Had they only been 4 hours away, we would have been able to go see them all of the time! Especially over holidays and school breaks! I mourn that I did not get to have time to learn from them, just spent time with them. From the viewpoint of the child, the parents are being unreasonable here, not OP.

Because they may not want to? If they aren't bothered about seeing her then why would they put themselves out that much? Life is stressful and down time is short. I wouldn't waste it doing something I didn't want to.

JustLyra · 29/08/2022 12:10

SnowWhite13 · 29/08/2022 11:40

4 hours in a car ride would be easily doable for a weekend, particularly a long weekend. That's not that long, even with small children. I know because I have firsthand experience. Even with sick kids.

Their child is being assessed for special needs and isn’t a good travel.

Given you have no idea what the child’s needs are, or the OP’s DS’s health issues are, how can you possibly have “first hand experience”.

you know what your situation was and how doable it was, that doesn’t make it remotely the same for anyone else.

SnowWhite13 · 29/08/2022 11:57

Also, they have done A LOT to help them out by assisting with childcare every single week, even for just one day, through the present! So why, after everything they've done to help them, all the effort OP and DH have put in, including making compromises, is the onus completely on OP??? That's just completely unreasonable to expect that any travel for visiting will only take place if OP comes back to visit them! DIL and son are the ones being unreasonable here. I wish I had only lived 4 hours from my grandparents! For 3 years I was about a days drive away. So we got to see them more often between the time I was 3 and 6 years old! That included staying with them without my parents. They would keep me and my baby brother for a while. But when I was 6, I ended up having to move even further, putting us 3,000 miles away from all of our grandparents and great grandparents! It. Was. Devastating! I was heartsick from being separated from my great grandma. She couldn't travel to us at all due to her health, so I only got to see her when we made the drive back to our hometown. After moving 3,000 miles away, my paternal grandparents came to visit as often as they could. My parents were only able to take us home twice. Once for my great grandma's death. Had they only been 4 hours away, we would have been able to go see them all of the time! Especially over holidays and school breaks! I mourn that I did not get to have time to learn from them, just spent time with them. From the viewpoint of the child, the parents are being unreasonable here, not OP.

SnowWhite13 · 29/08/2022 11:40

4 hours in a car ride would be easily doable for a weekend, particularly a long weekend. That's not that long, even with small children. I know because I have firsthand experience. Even with sick kids.

theemmadilemma · 22/08/2022 15:34

I agree with what everyone else has said. Life is busy and goes fast. I'm sure faster with young children.

You have to get over the onus being on them to find the time to visit you.

Zonder · 22/08/2022 15:18

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 22/08/2022 12:12

I don't think OP ( who is the DIL) will be back.
This appears to be the third thread .

Third? So one was DIL, this is MIL, who was the other? Don't tell me it was the toddler?

JenniferBarkley · 22/08/2022 13:45

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 22/08/2022 12:12

I don't think OP ( who is the DIL) will be back.
This appears to be the third thread .

Telling people it's the third thread and that the OP is the DIL doesn't seem to matter. Have been banging my head off a wall since last night.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 22/08/2022 12:12

I don't think OP ( who is the DIL) will be back.
This appears to be the third thread .

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 22/08/2022 11:54

It depends what you expect TBH
my parents moved away, 3 hours from one set of GCs and 5 hours from the other. We all visits 4 times a year including Christmas and they visit a couple of times a year also. That's ok for us but might not be ok for all families - that's what you are likely to get though!

HoppingKangaroo · 22/08/2022 11:51

Since the OP seems to have disappeared since the consensus is they are being unreasonable to expect full time working parents with 2 young children to travel 3 hours on a regular basis to see them (while the OP spends all her free time on her important hobbies) I doubt it is a reverse. OP probably still thinks they are in the right.

KarmaStar · 22/08/2022 11:49

Stop fretting about the future.
Nobody can foresee entirely what's to come,so carrying negative energy around is doing what exactly?attracting more negativity and bringing you down.
You've made your decision and you're looking forward to a new start.Leave it there.
Give your family time to get into a new routine and then discuss a visit but don't expect too much,too soon.
Enjoy your new start.🌻

JustLyra · 22/08/2022 11:15

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 19:19

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years. My husband had a major heart operation a few years ago and it made us re-evaluate our lives. We didn't have our parents around when we were working and our children were little and we all survived. It was never going to be easy but hopefully we'll make it work.

It’s not selfish to go.

it is selfish to expect your son and DIL, who are already struggling, to travel 3-4 hours regularly.
it’s selfish to expect your “not good traveller” grandson to do that regularly.

It’s massively unreasonable to expect to make a move like that and it not have a massive impact on your relationships.

DemelzaandRoss · 22/08/2022 11:11

Of course you are perfectly entitled to follow your dreams before old age & death. We only have one life, so we’re told.
I personally find it sad that you should choose to move so far away from your family. What goes around comes around & of course when you & your DH are maybe struggling a bit with immobility etc in your older years, then your family, who may have been inclined to help a bit, won’t be able to! Similarly any help you could give to lessen the load for childcare won’t be available. As for Dad… well, removing him from his family & friends isn’t awfully caring but probably helps you to get rid of guilt feelings about leaving him behind.
We all have different perspectives about family responsibilities & ultimately this lies with your own beliefs.
Regarding the original question, I think it is completely unreasonable to expect your family to travel to you with young children. Therefore YABU.
At least you’ll be able to video call.

PimlicoUK · 22/08/2022 10:48

You remind me of my in laws who did the same thing. They’re retired, cashed up, and living the sea-change life.
We work full time, have two under 5, virtually no social life but are expected to travel 2 hours to see them.
Sorry OP but you decided to leave. The onus is on you to maintain connection. You have the time on your hands, so use it.Don’t expect people to accomodate for your life choices.

Goldbar · 22/08/2022 10:31

To be quite blunt, you also need to think about what the visits are going to be like for them when they stay with you. My DC has grandparents a similar drive away and actually we do visit quite regularly (every 2-3 months and they come to see us sometimes as well). But my DC has no additional needs and I throw my DC at them the minute we get through the door and largely forget about DC for large chunks of the visit. And DC's grandparents don't mind - they are still physically very active and can easily keep up with DC and are happy to do most of the legwork and potter about with DC when we visit. Their house is relatively safe and has toys and baby stuff (we have a new baby on the way) so visiting isn't a huge hassle apart from the distance. If you are expecting your DS and DIL to do a long journey with their children, bring everything and then still be very much active parents and help with the housework, only away from home and in someone else's house, then it's going to be too tiring for them to want to come and see you frequently.

bridgetreilly · 22/08/2022 10:22

Yes, it’s selfish, because its all about what’s best for you, not your family. You aren’t making sacrifices because you’re expecting everyone else to compensate. If you choose to go ahead with this move, you are the ones who need to commit to regular visits to the rest of your family, not the other way around.

hewouldwouldnthe · 22/08/2022 09:59

Reasonable to visit you once or twice a year and stay a few days. Maybe alternate Christmas but more than that YABU. You could also visit them and stay in a hotel for a few days if they don't have much room.

babyjellyfish · 22/08/2022 09:45

It's difficult, OP.

I can't help feeling that you want to have your cake and eat it.

First of all, your dad. One assisted living facility is much like another, in terms of where it is located. What really makes a difference is the quality of any care they need, and regularity of visits from friends and family. Your dad might have a couple of years left, or he might have 10 or 15 years left. Either way, the likelihood is that he will reach the end of his life at a time when his great grandchildren are still at school. When someone is dying, you need to visit them now or not at all. That means that your son, DIL and grandchildren will need to get in the car and make a four hour trip to see him, regardless of what is going on with them at school. And it means that for however long he's got, he just won't get regular visits from his grandson and great grandchildren, and he won't get to see them grow up. Even if they visit several times a year, that won't be a lot compared to living close by.

Then there's you and your husband. You're moving a long way from home which means you'll need to create a whole new social life for yourselves, as well as making sure that your dad is properly taken care of and not lonely in his own environment. Maybe you're up for that now and confident you can make it work. Maybe you can. Or maybe it'll be more difficult and lonely than you anticipate, or maybe one of you will receive a life changing medical diagnosis in a year's time. Either way, your son just won't be able to be present for you in the way that he is now.

This decision doesn't seem very future proof if you ask me. What happens if you or your husband ends up needing more support in the short to medium term than you anticipate? Are you expecting your son to drive to see you every two weeks? Every month? Or will the three of you uproot and move back to where you came from to be closer to family?

You have the right to live your own life and make whatever decisions you choose. But this is not a decision I personally would make at your stage of life.

I have to travel for about 6 hours to see my parents, and cross an international border. Never thought that part would be a problem, but then Covid happened and the borders were closed on and off for the best part of a year, when I was having my first baby. Thanks to Brexit, if one or both of my parents needed to go into a home, I could not bring them to live near me, because they now need a visa to live where I do, and they wouldn't get one. So I would have to either leave the bulk of the responsibility to my brother and just do what I could, or uproot my entire family and move back to the UK. And again, thanks to Brexit, my husband would now need a visa to live in the UK. My parents are a similar age to you, and my dad was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease not long before I moved. I felt terrible about leaving the UK, but it was that or break up with my long term partner, who was not realistically able to leave the UK. We travel to the UK to see my parents about three times a year, and they currently travel to see us a couple of times a year. When their health no longer allows them to do that, we will have to travel to see them more often. It is hugely time consuming and expensive. But I was the one who made the decision to move, and so it is just part of the price I will have to pay for my own decision.

If it were the other way around, and my parents had moved far away at their stage of life so that they could pursue hobbies, I would be really upset. Especially at the implication that the hobbies were more important than close and regular contact with their grandchildren.

Walkingalot · 22/08/2022 09:19

I think you'll come to regret it. You've decided your desire to live somewhere rural/peaceful is more important than family. You can maybe expect a duty visit once or twice a year and that might tail off when the children are older and have busier lives. I'm guessing you don't have a close relationship with your children and this will get worse over time.
You'll also have to consider that even if you are prepared to do all the travelling, you'll have to factor in their own family plans. It's not like you can pop in for half and hour anymore.

Rowen32 · 22/08/2022 09:02

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 19:19

I don't understand why people think this is a reverse. I don't even know what you mean by that.

Is it selfish to want somewhere peaceful to live, away from the rat run we've been in for years. My husband had a major heart operation a few years ago and it made us re-evaluate our lives. We didn't have our parents around when we were working and our children were little and we all survived. It was never going to be easy but hopefully we'll make it work.

Of course not but there's peaceful places everywhere..

OP, I'm also wondering why you would move your Dad away from his family? Surely he would like to be closer to see them more.. Has he had a choice in this? It seems very sad, in his last years, he won't get to see his family..

HoppingKangaroo · 22/08/2022 08:59

It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route. And they work full time and you are retired. You are the one that moved away.

And you expect them to visit - YABU, very entitled and cheeky.

teawamutu · 22/08/2022 08:46

I have a sibling that moved countries. Spoke glowingly of the lovely holidays we'd have with them.

Misses the points that I already take quite a lot of leave to see them when they come back - which to be fair, is often - and I have plenty of places I'd like to visit and limited resources, so don't need another destination I didn't choose imposed on me.

But not to visit means we don't care about them. It's tough.

Bayleaf25 · 22/08/2022 08:35

As everyone else has said it would be unlikely/genuinely difficult for them to visit often. In a couple of years the kids could have weekend hobbies/clubs - then sports commitments like football, rugby, hockey whatever (and if you want to be part of a team you need to be available). Not to mention friends parties etc.

The older kids get they may have weekend jobs/want to hang out with friends.

So frequent travel is not ideal. I must admit I think it’s unusual to move away from family during retirement and a rural location could be difficult if you ever need to give up driving etc. However of course you are perfectly entitled to move wherever you want. Although if you are retired and have plenty of free time it is easier for you to travel for visiting rather than a busy young family who only have weekends free to cram in a million and one things (our weekends are always so busy doing essential house jobs - cleaning, DIY, gardening, shopping, sorting things for kids etc).

Dreamingcats · 22/08/2022 08:33

I don't think it's unreasonable to move wherever you like.

I think it's unreasonable to expect son and dil to visit often. My grandparents, when growing up, were two hours away and only we visited twice a year. A four hour drive is miserable with small children. If you want to see them more than once a year, you should expect to visit them.

There's zero chance I would leave a 10 month old with anyone else for more than a few hours. I was still breastfeeding them to sleep!

Festoonlights · 22/08/2022 07:58

You may not know it yet, but the chances are you are making a grave mistake.

Moving away from your support network and family into old age is a risk on many, many levels. You are unlikely to bond as well with your grandchildren, and relations with your dc will become distant by default. You are expecting to be healthy but and in reality you may not be, one of you could die and the other one is left alone. You have no one just around the corner to help, no friends or family. You are effectively starting again, which is fine if it goes well but real life is rarely that simple.

How can any hobby regardless of how much you like it possibly replace your own family and friends??

I say this gently, if I was your dc I would assume you were moving away to avoid supporting the grand children with special needs as I find the hobby excuse hard to believe. I would also prepare not to see very much of you going forward as there is no way on earth I would be doing that drive in their position.

It sounds like you haven’t truly factored in what you stand to lose with your relocation. It’s not going to be regular lovely big family holidays and long weekends, granny sleepovers and happy days. I say that from experience.

You will age and struggle with the distance soon, and things won’t get any easier for your dc until their children are young adults, as once the children start school it becomes even harder to travel freely. I wish you luck, and hope it works out for you and is worth the upheaval and heartbreak.

Swipe left for the next trending thread